Report MetalRain's Profile

My outstandingly overwrought rating criteria:

10 - Near perfect and, crucially, important to me on a personal level. These shows feel like they fundamentally changed the way I think about things and/or had a noticeable impact on the way I live my life.

9 - Near perfect. I have no major complaints about anything in the show, and its good qualities are exceptionally well-executed. In quality these are on par with a 10, but lack the same level of personal impact.

8 - An exceptionally good show, which may have negative elements, but they are so greatly outweighed by the positive that they don't detract from my overall appreciation for the product.

7 - Consistently entertaining or engaging, though with some major flaws or some elements that fell flat in critical ways so as to impair my overall appreciation for the product. Very good, but not extraordinary.

6 - A mixed bag, where significant flaws regularly detract from my enjoyment or there is a lack of major highs to appreciate, but I still at least am happily engaged for the majority of the time that I spend watching it.

5 - Has some good moments or strong conceptual aspects, but poor execution consistently distracts from its positive qualities and balances out the overall impression to one of mediocrity.

4 - May still have some positive qualities or moments, but the bad significantly outweighs the good and, aside from a few short moments, prevents me from enjoying or appreciating the experience of watching it.

3 - Has little to no positive qualities, but the negatives are not so egregious as to be outright offensive to my sensibilities.

2 - Consistently bad to the point that it actively upsets my sensibilities to watch. Irredeemable on any level.

1 - Aho Girl. The only 1 I've ever given, and god willing I'll never watch anything else that requires me to flesh out the way I feel about this level more.