Kinda nerdy high school student with nothing better (or worse) to do than curate a MAL account.
Iskandar the GOAT
Rating System:
10/10: Masterpiece. Little to no discernable flaws. Excels in every aspect of storytelling and is not only consistently excellent but also has multiple breathtaking peaks. Profoundly challenging intellectually and/or touching emotionally.
9/10: Masterful, Genius. Thematically powerful and well-executed. Series that I rate a 9 have at least one aspect that I consider to be brilliant. They are held back from being a 10/10 by not being consistently gripping, not having high enough peaks, or having too many flaws. Every one of these is a personal favorite.
8/10: Great, Tremendous. Either a simple concept with fantastic execution or an ambitious series with a notable amount of flaws (also everything in between). I thoroughly enjoyed all of these series.
7/10: Good, Quality. These are enjoyable and well thought out but don’t do much outside of that. The lowest score that I would willingly rewatch.
6/10: Decent, Solid. Didn’t leave much of an impression. Usually wildly inconsistent and/or unambitious. However, the good outweighs the bad, and I still enjoyed it.
5/10: Ok, Middling. Neither good nor bad. I will not think about these at all unless someone reminds me of them.
4/10: Bad, Poor. Fails in at least one aspect of storytelling. Not completely horrible, but it still actively sucks.
3/10: Horrible, Trash. Poorly done throughout. A few good moments are scattered here and there, but it is still not worth watching at all.
2/10: Abhorrent, Failure. Inexcusably atrocious with little to no redeeming qualities.
1/10: The Abyss. An affront to the very concept of art. I would like to forget about the existence of these series.
I use decimals in my tags to distinguish between the quality of series in a numerical tier. For example, The Promised Neverland S1 is (in my opinion) better than MHA S2, but not as good as Haikyuu! S2.
All Comments (3) Comments