Personal top 5:
1. Sora no Woto
2. Legend of the Galactic Heroes
3. 3-gatsu no Lion
4. Sora Yori mo Tooi Basho
5. Chihayafuru
Hall of infamy:
Pupa - worst show ever, fails at every level, no redeeming value whatsoever
Conception - worst full length show
Mayoiga - worst full length show I've ever completed
Clockwork Planet - the show I regret completing the most
Tenshi no Drop - no comment
Character bottom list:
2. Asuka Langley Souryu, Neon Genesis Evangelion
1. Ioq Qujan, Mobile Suit Gundam: Iron-Blooded Orphans, 2nd season
Dishonorable mentions - many, many main characters (mostly male, usually derivative) that are way too pathetic to be taken seriously, such as (in no particular order) Qwenthur Barbotage from Heavy Object, Lefiya Viridis from Danmachi Sword Oratoria, Naoto Miura from Clockwork Planet.
Standards for ratings:
10 - generally excellent, true art, great personal significance or enjoyment, or simply a work that explores a theme of interest better than anything else around (except maybe compared to novels)
9 - as above, but slightly lower on the art/quality/uniqueness/significance and interest scale
8 - overall, a show I found good or fun, but not amazingly so
7 - shows that have something lacking that I found significant
6 - failures with some redeeming value
5 - Sword Art Online, Pingu in the City, Berserk
4 - bad, but, strictly speaking, better than an anime about a talking fart
3 - as bad as an anime about a talking fart, or the actual anime about a talking fart
2 - worse than an anime about a talking fart
1 - Pupa, Conception
Note: The list has been accumulated over the years, and many stuff that may be highly rated were so because I liked them at the time. Many of which I would not watch any more. Cross Ange, though, gets a 10 for being so good at being trash that it deserves a 10 for it.
|
All Comments (3) Comments
I just invited you to the Anime Guild, a mostly seasonal club with lots of interesting features. Feel free to check us out! We're a fairly big and active club, and we have a Discord too!
*You should find the invite as a (1) under your Clubs tab on your profile. If it didn't go through, message me and I'll just re-invite you.*
I noticed you're watching Koisuru Asteroid. What are your thoughts on the show so far ?
Oh, and I was kind of on the fence of whether or not to actually write that pointlessly long rant about your misuse of the word "overrated" until I saw the rating explanation on your profile. Dude! Your use of an "anime about a talking fart" for ratings 4 through 2 reminded me of the second episode of the second season of Rick and Morty! If you haven't seen the show, then you have no idea how awesome an anime about a talking fart can actually be! Anyway, have a great weekend!