All You Need Is Kill

Oct 12, 2014

BlokeTokes

Mixed Feelings

After the release of the live-action movie "Edge of Tomorrow", it was interesting to find that it was actually based on a Japanese light-novel. It came even more as a surprise to see that a manga version had been released, likely coming after the acclaim of the live-action film. The film had some good characters, writing, and some interesting use of the plot's lore. It shouldn't have been a stretch to expect even more from the actual source material, not being held back by the hour and a half length of the movie. However, the biggest surprise came when it became clear that the movie ... didn't cut content, but actually beef it all up.

The "All You Need Is Kill" manga was taken up by the mangaka behind the art of manga like "Death Note", so it should be expected that the artwork would be top-notch. The characters and designs for the mechanisms and creatures are all well done, and there are plenty of well-realized actions shots to go along with it. Even with such great detail in the artwork though, there isn't enough world-building in place to truly make a lot of interesting locations or situations be shown. The action moments get slightly repetitive and the reader might begin focusing on the dialogue to move onwards. Even though that kind of direction would fit with the story at hand, it's still a less interesting way to present things when you take into account that this manga is only seventeen chapters long.

The length of "All You Need Is Kill" brings rise to the next, and biggest, problem with the manga which is that it's too rushed and forced. The basic plot of "All You Need Is Kill" is that a soldier on a futuristic earth is sent out to fight an army of alien invaders that are seemingly impossible to defeat, but he has been trapped in a time loop that makes him face defeat and death over and over again. That's a potentially great plot element that could be used to make some really interesting situations. However, the story is rarely ever imaginative with that element, making the details behind it very basic and simple to conclude. The movie, "Edge of Tomorrow", put in-place more depth and reason behind what goes on, and made everything that happens interaction-wise more intelligent and complex.

The lore of the manga is just used as a gimmick from what it develops into and what events it creates in the process. Besides the most basic of effects from adding the time-loop element in the story, the manga doesn't go into detail about how the main character can better be successful in his next attempts or what might be going on elsewhere in the world at the time. The whole situation with the alien invaders, known as "mimics", is presented as if they're destroying the entire human race across the globe. However, the entire manga takes place on a small battle on an isolated island. The world is never delved into and it's just assumptions to what happens elsewhere, even though characters in the story end up being involved.

The characters in the story aren't bad, but they aren't too unique either. The main character is generally smart and acts reasonable for what situation he's gotten into, but most of the other characters never feel as focused on as him, making them all feel like side characters. A romance also forms a bit into the story, but this romance still suffers from that same problem of other characters besides the main not being treated well enough. The story ends up trying to force content from the love-interest of the main in a chapter or two, focusing on what's going through her mind. Being so forceful in her character development, when moving to a lovey-dovey scene right after, just makes the entire relationship feel contrived. During the build-up of their feelings for one-another, which takes up a very short period, their characters also change slightly in ways that don't seem natural for what is going on for them. They change in slight ways to make their relationship feel more justified and more powerful, but in the end it just makes it feel even more artificial.

That romance leads to the ending, which is mainly where the plot felt rushed and where the focus changed for the worse. The main situation at hand noticeably took the back-seat as the drama of the romance clearly became the main plot of the manga. Barely receiving any development in the details of what is causing the time-loop and what will happen due to it, a quick bow is tied around that entire plot element along with the relationship, making it feel as though the producers of the manga just wanted to end the story and move on. I haven't read the novel, so I couldn't say whether or not it went through everything in the exact same way, but I would imagine that might be what happened when looking at the short length of the novel as well.

The main flaw with this story was the length as the beginning of "All You Need Is Kill" was actually well-paced and had generally good characters. However, wanting to fit everything in just a few chapters later made everything very unsatisfying and feel extremely rushed. The characters take a hit during this time. The lack of length makes the ending less detailed and complex from what it could, and should, have been. The story becomes basic and simple, wasting the potential of the manga's gimmick. The manga had a good budget in the art and design, but the lack of those other details makes for some repetitive scenes and some lack of presenting the world beyond the front-focused battle. "All You Need is Kill" is enjoyable and still worthy of being read, but it would be much more enjoyable to watch the live-action movie first then move on to the manga for some interesting comparisons.

Open

Gift

Jul 3, 2022

ZangBang

Mixed Feelings

All You Need is Kill tries to experiment with the idea of time loop, which is already a pretty overdone idea in the si-fi genre, and sadly not even this manga succeeds in using it in a fresh and original way. The story doesn't focus on the concept of time loop itself but rather the psychological burden that the victims of the time loop have to bear, and its mental consequences. It is a captivating idea on paper, but in practice that is an internal turmoil that we only hear about from the narrator in a very cold and plain way, rather than seeing it ...

Open

Gift

Nov 15, 2023

hexashadow13

Mixed Feelings

tl;dr: A manga carried by having a really interesting core concept, but that overall feels like a waste of potential.

This manga is an adaptation of a novel that was also adapted into a Hollywood film, though the film is quite a bit different from the novel and manga. The central premise is that humanity is in a war against a mysterious alien force dubbed Mimics, and in the midst of that a soldier named Keiji learns that he loops back 30 or so hours upon death. It’s a very interesting concept and the first volume uses it really well. It fleshes out Keiji’s panic and ...

Open

Gift

Nov 12, 2021

BakaBoysClub

Mixed Feelings

A 5 may seem harsh but hear me out. This is good if you are now getting into manga. This is good if you don't think about it after you are done (which I have done many times, it's not a bad thing). But if you have a bit of reading experience behind you and if you reflect on the 17 chapters... you will be in the exact same spot as me.

I have done a whole video review on this. If you feel like it, you can see that from my profile.

Now to elaborate on my earlier point.

Story - 6
If you haven't experienced ... the concept of time loops in media before you will have a good time, it's a genuinely fun shtick and the manga even improves a bit on that. Our main guy has to do a bunch of mini-quests (get better equipment etc.) to help him escape for the time loop and in that it kinda feels like a roguelike. But apart from that neat idea, everything is pretty standard and generic with a few plotholes for spice.

Art - 8
Now, this is tricky since there are some GORGEOUS pages in here but at the same time, most of this looks very plain and uninspired. By that, I don't mean it's not good it is always presented in a very professional way... which sadly is very generic on its own (r u seeing the pattern?). Still gets an 8 for those amazing spreads tho.

Characters - 7
Even if the time was very limited the 2 main characters were very well presented and really had something... that didn't last long and wasn't properly expanded upon. But again since they were able to make them so personable in 17 chapters this is a pretty big achievement if you ask me. Side characters don't really feel like characters they feel like checkpoints but that's pretty understandable and I don't hold it against the manga. But the broad with the glasses was annoying and that I hold against the manga.

Enjoyment - 7
While I was reading this it was very engaging for what it was. And even after I started thinking and realized this was very very shallow I still didn't feel like I was robbed of my time or anything. I am glad I read this.

Overall - 5
However, after I reflected on this whole thing I can't be honest and give it anything more than a 6 and that's on a good day the rest of the time this is perfect "Mediocre". I believe that is because this is an adaptation of a novel and most things simply weren't properly adapted.

If you are bored have free 30 minutes you can read this and who knows maybe you will like it more than I did (but if you got this far into the review you probably won't... sorry about that).

Open

Gift

May 4, 2018

CrystalAnimeTear

Mixed Feelings

Note: I also wrote this review on Goodreads under the name Animelove24 but it is my review.

All You Need Is Kill is a manga drawn by Takeshi Obata(the same guy who did Death Note and Bakuman) based on the light novel by the same name written by Hiroshi Sakurazaka. In it the main character Keiji is in the army trying to defeat a group of aliens called Mimics who have come to take over Earth. During his first battle, Keiji is seemingly killed by a Mimic but somehow wakes up the next day. This is repeated a few times before he realizes in order to ... get out of the loop he must defeat the Mimics and the story is basically him running around training and trying to go through the same day over and over without dying. It's like Groundhog Day but with aliens.

I found the story over all to be a fun little adventure story. It was funny at parts like with the sour plum eating contest, and heartwarming in others, such as wheb Rita and Keiji find, what I'll call their "common ground" without giving away spoliers. We also see the main character, whose very relatable in his quest to just live, grow as a person and push himself to his physical limits. It's also fun to watch him go through all the same things everyday. While it does exhaust him a lot after a while it's pretty funny to see him know everything that's going to happen, especially when he uses that knowledge to sneak past a bunch of guards. Keiji is also strong willed and I like the even after over 50 loops he still hasn't given up and doesn't even go off of his mission for a second even though he very well ould and it'd be understandable. I liked Rita as well. She definitely a badass as the only one whose known to been able to take down the Mimics in combat and she walks around carrying a giants axe that ways a couple tons so she's pretty tough. But she also has a softer side as we get to see in her backstory. Rita loves her family and her friends and is shown to be just a regular girl at heart. She's stubborn, she cries, loves jewellery likes to have fun as shown in the cafeteria scene and that's what I really enjoyed about her character. I like it when writers create female characters who have all kinds of different facets to their personalities and aren't just the stoic, unfeeling, bitchy type characters we usually get; she is called The Full Metal Bitch but she's also called The Valkyrie so it evens out. That all being said, I hated what became of her after she and Keiji have their "bonding moment". She just becomes the love interest after that and has no real character besides at the end which I won't spoil, but it's a bunch of crap.

The artstyle is well done. Takeshi Obata is also very detailed with his work and has his own in dividual style which a lot of sharp lines and hard edges which is different to see inanineor manga. It's part of what made Death Note stand out more than it already did. He also does good with movement especially with hair. It actually moves like real hair and seems silky and smooth. He also didn't great with making Keiji look exhausted from all the hard work he was putting in to defeating the Mimics. He looked exhausted and like he was about to break and just the way the eyes were drawn and the bags under them made me feel tried just looking at him. I also liked the interpretations of the mech suits and the Mimics. The suits looked sufficiently heavy as well as the axes and the Mimics looked like what the Langoliers should have looked like. Terrifying monster balls with teeth that look like they're oozing evil. I will say on downside is all the action scenes. I'm not sure if it's just the style of manga books overall or if it's that Obata doesn't draw action that often but I found it hard to really tell what was going on half the time. The characters would start doing something and then the next panel would be them doing somethibg completely different with no inbetween panels. This was especially prevalent in the final two battles. Overall I do enjoy Obata's art however but perhaps he should stick with doing the more person centric stories.

Other things I didn't like besides the action scenes and the way Rita was treated as a character were...well there's really only two things. #1 The ending. The ending was a load of bullshit. Without saying any spoilers, it makes sure Rita definitely not pass the Mako Mori test, if you catch my drift. She's such a cool character and to be reduced to THAT pisses me off. It also brings my to #2. The whole thing with the Mimic antenna makes no goddamn sense. Here's where it's going to get into spoilers, so if you don't want to read those, skip to the 👍(this includes ending spoilers). Okay so here it's goes. If whomever kills the antenna Mimic in their first loop slowly becomes an antenna over many different loops, made known by a headache one gets when becoming one, Rita should have never been able to leave her loop without the Mimics winning that battle and leaving her alive. Because the way it is explained in the story, is that the only way to get out of a loop is to ultimately kill all the antennas after destroying a bunch of other parts of the Mimic army, and Rita was an antenna during that time then she should have been stuck there forever because killing the antenna ultimately also restarts the loop so she couldn't kill herself. Therefore the only way to win an battle with antenna type Mimics is to let them win because that is the only way the loop stops. That also brings me to the bullshit ending where Keiji and Rita have to fight to the death because they have to kill all of the antenna but they're both antennas because they've both gotten the headaches for this loop and therefore there was no reason for Rita to fucking die because they shouldn't have been able to get out of that loop. What I'm saying really, in shortened terms, is that either the Mimics should have won that battle a longtime ago or Rita should be stuck in her first loop forever. I don't know if it's explained better in the books or not but here that whole thing makes no sense.

👍 Okay spoilers are officially over. Time for the end thoughts. Overall I did enjoy reading this book. Like I've said, I liked the artstyle, the story is an interesting look at what someone might do if the were stuck in the same day forever and the characters are fun to watch. There are a couple nitpicks here and there and two big nitpicks near the end of the book, but in the end if was a fun adventure to go on and makes me want to read the actual book and see the Tom Cruise movie. I probably won't read it again just because it's not really my genre but for anyone whose really unit sci-fi I'd say give it a whirl.

Open

Gift

Feb 26, 2023

Jaitnium

Mixed Feelings

There isn't much so say because there aren't that many chapters. The story doesn't feel that deep.

To me the entire story was built around the climax, but it still manages to come off as contrived. In my opinion, these types of finales only work over much MUCH longer stories. While the conclusion is a bit surprising, I don't think it's that effective.

The art is absolutely gorgeous, but I find the antagonists boring. Only two characters matter so they're the only ones who get development. Once again, the reason development is given is to service the climax. Due to the nature of the story there isn't ...

Open

Gift

All You Need Is Kill
Edit

What would you like to edit?

Alternative Titles

Information

Statistics

Available At

Resources

Write a Review
Reviews

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters

All You Need Is Kill Edit What would you like to edit? SynopsisBackgroundAlternative TitlesPictureChapters/VolumesPublishing DatesRelationsTypeExternal Links

Alternative Titles

Information

Statistics

Available At

Resources

Write a Review Reviews

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters

All You Need Is Kill
Edit

What would you like to edit?

Write a Review
Reviews