| So your problem is why top review isn't 10/10?? |
 |
leomike47 said: OttoLannister550 said: yeah thats true, but is alsto true fact that the top reviews donesn't describe the anime and the most of people liked itNah, MT got 8.46 when I wrote this reply while Re:Zero got 8.69 when the first season ended in 2016 before slowly dropped to 8.28 years after that. This is because people tend to overhype a show when it's released and the hype will slowly go down as time passes. The same thing will happen to MT years after the first season ended Source: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1495663 Well neither does the positive reviews. But of course nobody complains if those were at the top. For instance, here is the current top rated positive review 2021 is definitely a year that will be monopolized by Fantasy animes, and honestly, if most of them are like "Mushoku Tensei" I really don't mind. Competing with "Tensura S02" and "So I'm a Spider, So What?" Mushoku Tensei easily (in my opinion) outstands them with better character development and amazing art. They actually make you feel bad about the main character with his past life being so fucked up and seeing him in this new life overwhelming his fears gets you closer to the story. Something we can say other "Reincarnation" type animes definitely fail at. Definitely, this is the anime you should watch if you are into the Fantasy Genre! That's it. Super short and says nothing about the anime. And we can take another example. Here's the top rated positive review back when the show was still airing: According to many light novel readers, Mushoku Tensei: Isekai Ittara Honki Dasu will be one of the best isekai anime. I never read novels but i have high hopes for this anime. Btw there is 24 light novels so that is a lot of content for next seasons. Anime is produced by a new studio called "Studio Bind" and they have done an amazing job for now hope it stays this way (art 10/10). I like this anime cuz main character start from 0 (birth) and he is proggresing in every episode. Another isekai anime with Truck-kun xd Rly love this anime so far overall 9/10 Once again. Extremely short and says absolutely nothing about the anime. This was at the top of the reviews. And do you imagine someone complained then? |
| Subarashii |
| After looking through a bunch of shows and looking at the reviews, I've figured out it's mostly the same people writing all the reviews. Many of them try to act like professional reviewers and their reviews are full of trite phrases and platitudes, and many of the others are just trolls. For some reason the trolls seem to get the most upvotes. It wouldn't surprise me if many of those upvotes are for less than legitimate accounts. The top reviews for this show are without a doubt written by trolls. |
HOOfan_1Mar 26, 2021 6:23 AM
Avicebrons said: Those are marked "preliminary" for a reason.leomike47 said: yeah thats true, but is alsto true fact that the top reviews donesn't describe the anime and the most of people liked it Well neither does the positive reviews. But of course nobody complains if those were at the top. For instance, here is the current top rated positive review 2021 is definitely a year that will be monopolized by Fantasy animes, and honestly, if most of them are like "Mushoku Tensei" I really don't mind. Competing with "Tensura S02" and "So I'm a Spider, So What?" Mushoku Tensei easily (in my opinion) outstands them with better character development and amazing art. They actually make you feel bad about the main character with his past life being so fucked up and seeing him in this new life overwhelming his fears gets you closer to the story. Something we can say other "Reincarnation" type animes definitely fail at. Definitely, this is the anime you should watch if you are into the Fantasy Genre! That's it. Super short and says nothing about the anime. And we can take another example. Here's the top rated positive review back when the show was still airing: According to many light novel readers, Mushoku Tensei: Isekai Ittara Honki Dasu will be one of the best isekai anime. I never read novels but i have high hopes for this anime. Btw there is 24 light novels so that is a lot of content for next seasons. Anime is produced by a new studio called "Studio Bind" and they have done an amazing job for now hope it stays this way (art 10/10). I like this anime cuz main character start from 0 (birth) and he is proggresing in every episode. Another isekai anime with Truck-kun xd Rly love this anime so far overall 9/10 Once again. Extremely short and says absolutely nothing about the anime. This was at the top of the reviews. And do you imagine someone complained then? The ACTUAL top rated reviews, except the current first and another removed (all negative), did in fact offer more complete reviews that can't be summarized in 3 words and that's why nobody complained. But then botting/brigading happened as described in https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1908767, those reviews were replaced by the current 4 |
PKXMar 27, 2021 10:06 AM
| Humans are suspicious and jealous creatures. When they see something perfect, they wanna find a flaw. Ratohnhaketon said: You have much to learn if you have not joined the witch hunt to down vote every anime that rises above our underrated favorites. I am currently on a campaign to get Training with Hinako into the top 12. Shit taste is hard to fight though, it's like trying to talk sense to an army of hallucinating loonies. Ty-Ki said: It's hilarious to see morons wasting more time with the series they hate so much than the fans of it. |
PKX said: Those are marked "preliminary" for a reason. The ACTUAL top rated reviews, except the current first and another removed (all negative), did in fact offer more complete reviews that can't be summarized in 3 words and that's why nobody complained. But then botting/brigading happened as described in https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1495663, those reviews were replaced by the current 4 Preliminary or not is completely besides the point. The point is that people complain about negative reviews not talking about the anime itself. But then keep silent when the positive reviews do the exact same thing. Like I even mentioned. You didn't see any thread like this back when the show was still airing, where people voiced concern for how the top rated review didn't touch on the anime's content. And despite it being besides the point, I can add that the current top rated positive review, while marked as "preliminary", he has indeed finished the show as a whole. With the added comment: UPDATE 03/21/2021 8/10 The Show was Super good, definitely had my point that is the best fantasy anime (that is not a sequel) from this fall season, mal wants me to delete this old review so I can post a new one because yea we cant update episodes watched on reviews on mal, but I kinda don't want too. Which again. Does not go into the show at all. |
| Subarashii |
| Isn't it the equivalent of Twitter cancel culture thingy? You get offended hence you and your friends rally and spam 1 star review. In any case, I base my enjoyment... on myself, not what some random salty guy says. Truth to be told, I never read a review before watching a show, only after, to see if it's true or not. Don't worry too much about it. 2nd season will be coming. |
  |
| all 4 top reviews are extremely low scores, each whining about 'muh pedophilia' before the 'read more' line. if you think this shit is organic and not full on botted by some loser(s) I don't know what to tell you. The review side of this site is a joke. As for the individual reviewers, they're retards. The new wave of moralfag compulsive hate watchers is a blight on anime discourse. Hopefully they all realize the anime industry doesn't give even the slightest fuck about them, is almost entirely composed of 'degenerates' or sympathizers and find another medium to moral crusade over. Hilarious seeing faggots with shows containing overt lolicon pandering rated highly clutch pearls over this one because it's harder for their cognitive dissonance to filter out. Also lmao astralbread is self hating lolicon who thinks kvetching about the stuff absolves him of his sins. Hilarious seeing people get behind him without realizing he's the exact pervert they're afraid of. his shoujo ramune avatar is an act of self flagellation. pathetic. |
MaiBudichesMar 28, 2021 6:00 AM
L0sMichal0s said: I just finished last ep of season one and was really happy i watched this anime because it was amazing in my opinion and i rated it 9/10 so i pressed completed and then looked at "mOsT hElPfUl" reviews and i dont think this amazing anime doesnt deserve such a bad reviews. Some people might get scared away because of those trolls. Like seriously im kinda sad this is the first thing you see when you open this anime and scroll down. And why so many people voted for it as helpful review ? What a shame. Anyways thanks for the ride  as i read ppl see issue with MC remembering hes past life in hes original world that this makes him Pedo cause hes mentally 34, some ppl are short sided can't se past that can't see the art and plot they are 2obsessed with reality and bring reality in to fiction can't admit that this is fiction and fictional ppl but good question (if ppl want to bring reality in to this) is can he be mentally 34 if he has kids brain, maybe ur brain still limits ur mental lvl EDIT: watched all new 7/10 loosing 1point cause this relies 2much on getting second season otherwise it would be 8 |
Sugram22Mar 29, 2021 7:45 AM
| Update: it's being investigated by the staff: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1908767#msg62503290 |
| Humans are suspicious and jealous creatures. When they see something perfect, they wanna find a flaw. Ratohnhaketon said: You have much to learn if you have not joined the witch hunt to down vote every anime that rises above our underrated favorites. I am currently on a campaign to get Training with Hinako into the top 12. Shit taste is hard to fight though, it's like trying to talk sense to an army of hallucinating loonies. Ty-Ki said: It's hilarious to see morons wasting more time with the series they hate so much than the fans of it. |
| It's currently sitting at a 8.46/10 which is quite impressive so i wouldn't really be worrying. I personally gave it a 7/10 |
 |
PKX said: Update: it's being investigated by the staff: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1908767#msg62503290 whats being investigated? how legit the reviews are? |
L0sMichal0s said: I just finished last ep of season one and was really happy i watched this anime because it was amazing in my opinion and i rated it 9/10 so i pressed completed and then looked at "mOsT hElPfUl" reviews and i dont think this amazing anime doesnt deserve such a bad reviews. Some people might get scared away because of those trolls. Like seriously im kinda sad this is the first thing you see when you open this anime and scroll down. And why so many people voted for it as helpful review ? What a shame. Anyways thanks for the ride The only good thing that happened because of tis anime is daughter NTR due to his father known to force himself on women. The Roxin one was just hit so at right spots with rud watching it from through door as roxin got drilled hard I will say also check out the koikatsu made NTR of mushoku on pixiv basically premium made animated hentai 👌 |
Destined_OneMar 29, 2021 1:25 PM
Destined_One said: L0sMichal0s said: I just finished last ep of season one and was really happy i watched this anime because it was amazing in my opinion and i rated it 9/10 so i pressed completed and then looked at "mOsT hElPfUl" reviews and i dont think this amazing anime doesnt deserve such a bad reviews. Some people might get scared away because of those trolls. Like seriously im kinda sad this is the first thing you see when you open this anime and scroll down. And why so many people voted for it as helpful review ? What a shame. Anyways thanks for the ride The only good thing that happened because of tis anime is daughter NTR due to his father known to force himself on women. The Roxin one was just hit so at right spots with rud watching it from through door as roxin got drilled hard I will say also check out the koikatsu made NTR of mushoku on pixiv basically premium made animated hentai 👌 What ? I didn't understand a single word you said. Check out who ? |
Just because you are doing something for someone else doesn't make it right. Kindness and beauty can sometimes become cruel.  |
| A lot of people are discussing about the botting of reviews when it can be boiled down due to this series ending. Users flocked here to update their list and give it a rating, so there's a high chance that they are also looking at the reviews. Many people could've pressed helpful due to the review being a good representation of what they feel towards the show while others are just memeing. That does beg the question: Where are the helpful votes of the fans of the series? I'm sure that there are a lot of fans of this anime out there will push upvotes to those more accurate reviews especially when this has a 8.46 score as of the writing of this post. Again, there is a chance botting actually happened but without solid evidence, that goes kaput. |
Sore wa chigau yo! - Junko Enoshima, probably |
| Losers. That's all it is. Remember the people that hated on Re:Zero for no good reason back then? These are those same people. Absolutely. |
 |
| Average score of most helpful reviews is 2,25 while the overall score of the anime is 8,46 so yeah i feel like there is huge gap between those review elitists and actual fans |
Just because you are doing something for someone else doesn't make it right. Kindness and beauty can sometimes become cruel. |
PoDak said: You Have To Remember Any Publicity Is Good Publicity. This Anime Is Great And We All Know It's Great. When The Worst Thing Someone Can Say About Mushoku Is Basically. -"You Eat Subway?" "Jarrod Is A Pedophile And He Ate Subway!" "So That Obviously Means You Are Too."- Than I Tend Not To Care About Their Opinions However I Do Share The Concern Of How Those Being The Top Reviews May Affect Potential Fans. Whatever You Do Don't Tell These People About Usagi Drop They May Just Loose Their Minds... Also I See A Lot Of People Call This A Generic Power Fantasy. Did You Even Watch The Show? I Really Don't Feel Like You Did. If people use reviews and opinions to decide whether to watch a show or not, that's on them. Many people call it one as the MC is born with a ton of perks that was absolutely advantageous for him in the beginning: noble Blood, a massive affinity for magic, parents from the two types of fighters in this world to train him, handsome looks, a very mature mind that knows how the RPG-like fantasy world works from the very start (It's basically like knowing all the mechanics of a game at launch which makes you the most OP character at start due to that knowledge.) and most importantly, a world that does not punish things he was supposed to redeem himself and encourages his own desires which was not possible in his previous life. |
Junko_Simp04Mar 30, 2021 4:38 AM
| Sore wa chigau yo! - Junko Enoshima, probably |
Junko_Simp04 said: PoDak said: You Have To Remember Any Publicity Is Good Publicity. This Anime Is Great And We All Know It's Great. When The Worst Thing Someone Can Say About Mushoku Is Basically. -"You Eat Subway?" "Jarrod Is A Pedophile And He Ate Subway!" "So That Obviously Means You Are Too."- Than I Tend Not To Care About Their Opinions However I Do Share The Concern Of How Those Being The Top Reviews May Affect Potential Fans. Whatever You Do Don't Tell These People About Usagi Drop They May Just Loose Their Minds... Also I See A Lot Of People Call This A Generic Power Fantasy. Did You Even Watch The Show? I Really Don't Feel Like You Did. If people use reviews and opinions to decide whether to watch a show or not, that's on them. Many people call it one as the MC is born with a ton of perks that was absolutely advantageous for him in the beginning: noble Blood, a massive affinity for magic, parents from the two types of fighters in this world to train him, handsome looks, a very mature mind that knows how the RPG-like fantasy world works from the very start (It's basically like knowing all the mechanics of a game at launch which makes you the most OP character at start due to that knowledge.) and most importantly, a world that does not punish things he was supposed to redeem himself and encourages his own desires which was not possible in his previous life. It does punish him. In light novel he had a lot of inner guilty thoughts and also when that kid from other group died. That was his mistake. He may know the basics of RPG etc. but experiencing it for real is different and it feels different because its real. And death in "real" life and in game is not the same experience. |
Just because you are doing something for someone else doesn't make it right. Kindness and beauty can sometimes become cruel. |
L0sMichal0s said: Junko_Simp04 said: If people use reviews and opinions to decide whether to watch a show or not, that's on them. Many people call it one as the MC is born with a ton of perks that was absolutely advantageous for him in the beginning: noble Blood, a massive affinity for magic, parents from the two types of fighters in this world to train him, handsome looks, a very mature mind that knows how the RPG-like fantasy world works from the very start (It's basically like knowing all the mechanics of a game at launch which makes you the most OP character at start due to that knowledge.) and most importantly, a world that does not punish things he was supposed to redeem himself and encourages his own desires which was not possible in his previous life. It does punish him. In light novel he had a lot of inner guilty thoughts and also when that kid from other group died. That was his mistake. He may know the basics of RPG etc. but experiencing it for real is different and it feels different because its real. And death in "real" life and in game is not the same experience. Sir, we are discussing about the show or the anime itself not LNs. There's no reprecussions to be had with the MC in the anime, there was one with Sylphy but that went nowhere. Doesn't matter if it's real life or not since the guy most likely played a ton of RPGs in the time he was a recluse. Since RPG-like elements are like the backbone of this world's anime so people can understand it better, Rudy already had a massive boost in knowledge on what to do and what to train whether it is real life or not. |
| Sore wa chigau yo! - Junko Enoshima, probably |
Junko_Simp04 said: L0sMichal0s said: It does punish him. In light novel he had a lot of inner guilty thoughts and also when that kid from other group died. That was his mistake. He may know the basics of RPG etc. but experiencing it for real is different and it feels different because its real. And death in "real" life and in game is not the same experience. Sir, we are discussing about the show or the anime itself not LNs. There's no reprecussions to be had with the MC in the anime, there was one with Sylphy but that went nowhere. Doesn't matter if it's real life or not since the guy most likely played a ton of RPGs in the time he was a recluse. Since RPG-like elements are like the backbone of this world's anime so people can understand it better, Rudy already had a massive boost in knowledge on what to do and what to train whether it is real life or not. Have you seen his reaction when he for the first time saw someone die/be killed ? And then again at the end of the season when that kid died because of him ? This is not RPG. If he dies he is dead its not some forgiving fairy world. And its impossible to judge such a big show based on one short season. It would be stupid and too generic if he redeemed himself in span of few episodes and compeltely changed his behaviour. |
Just because you are doing something for someone else doesn't make it right. Kindness and beauty can sometimes become cruel. |
L0sMichal0s said: Junko_Simp04 said: Sir, we are discussing about the show or the anime itself not LNs. There's no reprecussions to be had with the MC in the anime, there was one with Sylphy but that went nowhere. Doesn't matter if it's real life or not since the guy most likely played a ton of RPGs in the time he was a recluse. Since RPG-like elements are like the backbone of this world's anime so people can understand it better, Rudy already had a massive boost in knowledge on what to do and what to train whether it is real life or not. Have you seen his reaction when he for the first time saw someone die/be killed ? And then again at the end of the season when that kid died because of him ? This is not RPG. If he dies he is dead its not some forgiving fairy world. And its impossible to judge such a big show based on one short season. It would be stupid and too generic if he redeemed himself in span of few episodes and compeltely changed his behaviour. I know, but we were talking about how this anime is a generic wish fulfillment. Yes of course, you die when you are killed in this world but both you and I probably will already know that the MC won't die while the show is running. Shit you're right, it's definitely stupid and generic to fix the MC's fear of the outside world in a few episodes. I didn't know you can fix agrophobia, that the MC's prolly been having for 2 decades now, by just having a friend horseride you in town. I was just really looking for something or anything really to kickstart development, it could happen while the show is running. Remember, this is advertised as a "Redemption" show so one would expect something to be done with his "desires". 11 eps later and yeah. |
| Sore wa chigau yo! - Junko Enoshima, probably |
Junko_Simp04 said: L0sMichal0s said: Have you seen his reaction when he for the first time saw someone die/be killed ? And then again at the end of the season when that kid died because of him ? This is not RPG. If he dies he is dead its not some forgiving fairy world. And its impossible to judge such a big show based on one short season. It would be stupid and too generic if he redeemed himself in span of few episodes and compeltely changed his behaviour. I know, but we were talking about how this anime is a generic wish fulfillment. Yes of course, you die when you are killed in this world but both you and I probably will already know that the MC won't die while the show is running. Shit you're right, it's definitely stupid and generic to fix the MC's fear of the outside world in a few episodes. I didn't know you can fix agrophobia, that the MC's prolly been having for 2 decades now, by just having a friend horseride you in town. I was just really looking for something or anything really to kickstart development, it could happen while the show is running. Remember, this is advertised as a "Redemption" show so one would expect something to be done with his "desires". 11 eps later and yeah. Its gonna be a long series and they plan to animate whole LN so we have a lot of eps till the end. He still had that fear even as Rudy for ages until Roxy "forced" him to ride with her out of his comfort zone. He didnt want to. Sometimes your friends have to force you to overcome your fears because you alone would be too scared to make that one step. And here is your "development" and redemption you have been asking for. Its might seem like a small thing but for his character its a big step. Thats why he think of Roxy as his goddess and savior because she saved him at that moment. |
Just because you are doing something for someone else doesn't make it right. Kindness and beauty can sometimes become cruel. |
L0sMichal0s said: Junko_Simp04 said: I know, but we were talking about how this anime is a generic wish fulfillment. Yes of course, you die when you are killed in this world but both you and I probably will already know that the MC won't die while the show is running. Shit you're right, it's definitely stupid and generic to fix the MC's fear of the outside world in a few episodes. I didn't know you can fix agrophobia, that the MC's prolly been having for 2 decades now, by just having a friend horseride you in town. I was just really looking for something or anything really to kickstart development, it could happen while the show is running. Remember, this is advertised as a "Redemption" show so one would expect something to be done with his "desires". 11 eps later and yeah. Its gonna be a long series and they plan to animate whole LN so we have a lot of eps till the end. He still had that fear even as Rudy for ages until Roxy "forced" him to ride with her out of his comfort zone. He didnt want to. Sometimes your friends have to force you to overcome your fears because you alone would be too scared to make that one step. And here is your "development" and redemption you have been asking for. Its might seem like a small thing but for his character its a big step. Thats why he think of Roxy as his goddess and savior because she saved him at that moment. Hmmm... I can see that, I liked that it isn't fully a "Dude, trust me." chacracter development like Paul. I would've liked more scenes about his agrophobia as it is after all one of the major obstacles he has to overcome himself. |
| Sore wa chigau yo! - Junko Enoshima, probably |
Junko_Simp04 said: L0sMichal0s said: Its gonna be a long series and they plan to animate whole LN so we have a lot of eps till the end. He still had that fear even as Rudy for ages until Roxy "forced" him to ride with her out of his comfort zone. He didnt want to. Sometimes your friends have to force you to overcome your fears because you alone would be too scared to make that one step. And here is your "development" and redemption you have been asking for. Its might seem like a small thing but for his character its a big step. Thats why he think of Roxy as his goddess and savior because she saved him at that moment. Hmmm... I can see that, I liked that it isn't fully a "Dude, trust me." chacracter development like Paul. I would've liked more scenes about his agrophobia as it is after all one of the major obstacles he has to overcome himself. its beautiful fantasy anime. in my opinion it deserves rating 8-10 for sure. the world, characters, animation and music all is amazing and beautiful. |
Just because you are doing something for someone else doesn't make it right. Kindness and beauty can sometimes become cruel. |
rdturbo said: Junko_Simp04 said: Hmmm... I can see that, I liked that it isn't fully a "Dude, trust me." chacracter development like Paul. I would've liked more scenes about his agrophobia as it is after all one of the major obstacles he has to overcome himself. Actually, the traumas are not really gone, they come back to bite him in the ass in the really important moments. It's not until really later, does he seem completely free from his traumas. Maybe, but like I said, it would've been better if there were more scenes about it and how he overcomes that obstacle to him getting better |
| Sore wa chigau yo! - Junko Enoshima, probably |
| because this is MAL where they always highly rate generic garbage like Rental Girlfriend but if its something different or has an MC thats kind of interesting they go REEEE wE wAnT bRaIndEaD mCs |
this is too funny omfg |
L0sMichal0s said: Junko_Simp04 said: Hmmm... I can see that, I liked that it isn't fully a "Dude, trust me." chacracter development like Paul. I would've liked more scenes about his agrophobia as it is after all one of the major obstacles he has to overcome himself. its beautiful fantasy anime. in my opinion it deserves rating 8-10 for sure. the world, characters, animation and music all is amazing and beautiful. Minus the controversial scenes, I would've given this show a 7-8. |
| Sore wa chigau yo! - Junko Enoshima, probably |
| Thread locked. Not a discussion about the anime and is encouraging flaming and bashing other users. If there is a troll review please use the report button in the review so that the review mods can handle it. |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Mushoku Tensei: Isekai Ittara Honki Dasu Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Mar 21, 2021 |
495 |
by Empirekiller
»»
Sep 26, 3:11 PM |
|
Poll: » Mushoku Tensei: Isekai Ittara Honki Dasu Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jan 31, 2021 |
393 |
by MartaNara21
»»
Sep 25, 3:31 AM |
|
Poll: » Mushoku Tensei: Isekai Ittara Honki Dasu Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )MegamiRem - Dec 31, 2020 |
431 |
by James-LastOmnic
»»
Sep 5, 9:37 PM |
|
Poll: » Mushoku Tensei: Isekai Ittara Honki Dasu Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )MegamiRem - Dec 31, 2020 |
403 |
by removed-user
»»
Aug 30, 1:01 AM |
|
» Studio Bind........Ren_Nohihara7005 - Jul 9 |
40 |
by animefanftw123
»»
Aug 6, 11:34 AM |