Best series of the season?

Oct 26, 1:19 PM

#2

Merve2Love

Online

Apr 2020

2880

How would we know?

Yeah. It's good. Let's enjoy it without bashing the other stuff, that is airing^^

Oct 26, 1:30 PM

#3

DayRivia

Offline

Aug 2022

473

Yes. Best so far for sure from what I've watched. I'm not caught up to blue lock but it's best for new series.

Oct 26, 1:34 PM

#4

18927

Offline

Apr 2024

254

Yes, it is the best if we exclude sequels. Otherwise, no. Bleach is way ahead of the competition this season.

Oct 26, 1:37 PM

#5

MyllerPhiem

Offline

Apr 2012

713

I mean, that's why I made this thread, tsk:

https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=2182718

If you haven't watched "Fantastic Children", don't talk about "best anime". Thank you.

Oct 26, 1:43 PM

#6

Sherry221B

Offline

Mar 2024

28

it's maybe not the best cause some others are also pretty good but it's by far the most underrated

My Candies :

Oct 26, 1:50 PM

#7

ImFranciele

Offline

Jul 2013

32

yes, in my opinion it is

Oct 26, 2:09 PM

#8

Memowynekromanta

Offline

Jan 2023

43

Merve2Love said:
How would we know?

Yeah. It's good. Let's enjoy it without bashing the other stuff, that is airing^^

Yes, of course everything could change. For example, after I saw first episode of Uzumaki. I thought, probably it will be one of the best shows in this season. How it ends, everyone knows.

Oct 26, 2:21 PM

#9

Cersil

Offline

Nov 2016

189

It's just Poland Saga, meh

Oct 26, 2:36 PM

#10

Cielord

Offline

Jan 2021

1604

It's way too soon to determine, but so far, then yeah. It's the best new series this season. Blue Box is a close second.

But if we also include sequels, then I don't think it's even top 5.

Oct 26, 2:39 PM

#11

UberBat

Offline

Jan 2008

2989

It's definitely up there.

Oct 26, 2:39 PM

#12

Memowynekromanta

Offline

Jan 2023

43

@Cersil Maybe has kinda similar vibe, and I'll recommend this for those who liked Viland Saga. But still, thinking that all anime with action in medieval europe is just Viland Saga with a twist, is silly.

MemowynekromantaOct 26, 3:00 PM

Oct 26, 2:41 PM

#13

Merve2Love

Online

Apr 2020

2880

Reply to Memowynekromanta

Merve2Love said:
How would we know?

Yeah. It's good. Let's enjoy it without bashing the other stuff, that is airing^^

Yes, of course everything could change. For example, after I saw first episode of Uzumaki. I thought, probably it will be one of the best shows in this season. How it ends, everyone knows.

@Memowynekromanta

That's not -Enjoying it, without bashing other stuff- . since you mentioned Uzumaki....

But I take your point...xD

Oct 26, 3:08 PM

#14

Ash_li

Offline

Feb 2017

23

It's tiring to constantly compare things but it's the show that has my attention the most this season.

Oct 26, 3:13 PM

#15

Cersil

Offline

Nov 2016

189

Reply to Memowynekromanta

@Cersil Maybe has kinda similar vibe, and I'll recommend this for those who liked Viland Saga. But still, thinking that all anime with action in medieval europe is just Viland Saga with a twist, is silly.

@Memowynekromanta Vinland Saga looks less internally contradicting than this, this looks like distorted anime about medieval era. Vinland Saga shows its era more correctly

Oct 26, 3:22 PM

#16

logopolis

Offline

Apr 2012

3289

Way too soon to say. But it's definitely in contention.

Oct 26, 3:45 PM

#17

Dan_ALves

Offline

May 2022

913

So far it´s my top 3 airing, behind Bleach and Dandadan and tied with Blue Box.

Oct 26, 3:55 PM

#18

GiIiLDartZ

Offline

Mar 2016

38

This one is a hidden gem!! But it is getting slowly exposed to lightning and getting what it deserves
MASTERPIECE !!!

Oct 26, 3:59 PM

#19

Piromysl

Offline

Jul 2015

12284

Out of premieres it's either this or Dandandan.

Oct 26, 4:10 PM

#20

Nirinbo

Offline

Sep 2018

4456

AOTS and saving grace of one of the worst seasons of the last few years, so far. Beastars Final Season is the only anime that might get close to Chi., but I haven't heard good things about how the manga ended.

Oct 26, 6:04 PM

#21

natewu

Offline

Aug 2019

3

Reply to Piromysl

Out of premieres it's either this or Dandandan.

@Pieromysl Definitely this for seinen!

Oct 26, 6:14 PM

#22

Pablo_Neruda1

Offline

Dec 2022

751

Memowynekromanta said:
As far, Chikyuu is the best new series of fall season for me. Don't get me wrong. Dandadan still is very good, even though I don't like absurd humor as much. Third season of Re:Zero is comparable, and I can't decide which is better. Further, with a progress of plot, it can change though.

dude let's just enjoy the damn shows. its still to early to term it the best series. come on, it's just 5 episodes.

Oct 26, 6:15 PM

#23

Pablo_Neruda1

Offline

Dec 2022

751

Cersil said:
It's just Poland Saga, meh

You're probably too dumb then. cope harder.

Oct 26, 6:51 PM

#24

FutoiOtaku

Offline

Nov 2023

933

Can’t really see the ‘best anime’ label some people put on this. Yes, it’s well made and covers some interesting philosophical and moral issues from angles that anime doesn’t usually bother with, but originality doesn’t make it actually entertaining. It’s definitely good enough that a decent proportion of viewers will see it as best, that’s how individual taste works, but to me it’s not really proper anime anyway. I know it qualifies technically, but the art style and darkness, visually and thematically, make it more of an animated historical drama to me. (Yes it’s subjective and I respect anyone’s opinions, I’m just replying to OP with my own).
Anyhow, there are at least 5 currently running anime that are more entertaining this season to me, so that’s my view on it.

Oct 26, 7:35 PM

#25

FreedomKME

Offline

Feb 2018

366

I am not a fan of the pacing, what they did with 5 episodes could have been done with 2, even 1 if you are smart. Also, everyone being shitty or broken doesn't exactly make them compelling characters.

Oct 26, 9:01 PM

#26

MusashiKarlsefni

Negator

Offline

Mar 2022

767

FreedomKME said:
I am not a fan of the pacing, what they did with 5 episodes could have been done with 2, even 1 if you are smart. Also, everyone being shitty or broken doesn't exactly make them compelling characters.

Fitting the content in these 5 episodes into just 1 or 2 would absolutely make for a far worse product, idk why you would even propose that.

Oct 26, 9:27 PM

#27

Thisas

Offline

Apr 2022

96

As I can see, yeah definitely

Oct 26, 11:14 PM

#28

WatchTillTandava

Offline

Jun 2019

6631

Of everything airing I'm currently watching eight seasonals for sure regularly including this one, a few others which I've sampled and debated whether to continue with or not, at least one I'm probably going to drop, a few I haven't touched yet but am probably going to at least try eventually, and one which I definitely intend to watch but doesn't start until late in the season in mid-November. Oh, and a few series which I had planned/wanted to watch before the season actually started but then found out they were just very short shorts.

So, taking all that into consideration, I can only really judge the ones which I'm actively keeping up with right now and have seen every episode that has been released of.

Of those, for me it's between If My Wife Becomes an Elementary Student, this (Orb), and 365 Days to the Wedding for my favorite. Then additionally there are even some other series which are a lot better than I initially expected them to be, like Maou 2099. But of all I've seen, this one probably has the strongest writing.

Oct 27, 2:25 AM

#29

removed-user

Offline

Jul 2018

564089

Reply to Cersil

It's just Poland Saga, meh

@Cersil Poland saga 😆

Oct 27, 2:33 AM

#30

FreedomKME

Offline

Feb 2018

366

MusashiKarlsefni said:

FreedomKME said:
I am not a fan of the pacing, what they did with 5 episodes could have been done with 2, even 1 if you are smart. Also, everyone being shitty or broken doesn't exactly make them compelling characters.

Fitting the content in these 5 episodes into just 1 or 2 would absolutely make for a far worse product, idk why you would even propose that.

"Fitting the content"? Dude, CUT the content.

Oct 27, 5:03 AM

#31

CheliosX

Offline

Dec 2022

1827

Geez, can you relax? What's with the "best series this season" threads lately?
Personally, that's a bit of a stretch. But one thing I can honestly admit is that ORB is my best new anime of the fall 2024 season. But best anime of the season overall? No. T10 for sure.

Oct 27, 5:10 AM

#32

Memowynekromanta

Offline

Jan 2023

43

FreedomKME said:

MusashiKarlsefni said:

Fitting the content in these 5 episodes into just 1 or 2 would absolutely make for a far worse product, idk why you would even propose that.

"Fitting the content"? Dude, CUT the content.

I would never expect, that I met this guy. Who thinking is a great idea to adapt whole over a dozen volumes manga, in one season with 12 episodes. Bro, just stop making anime, everyone hates you.

MemowynekromantaOct 27, 5:42 AM

Oct 27, 5:18 AM

#33

Cersil

Offline

Nov 2016

189

Reply to Pablo_Neruda1

Cersil said:
It's just Poland Saga, meh

You're probably too dumb then. cope harder.

@Pablo_Neruda1 dw, I'm smarter than you'll ever be

Oct 27, 5:27 AM

#34

Memowynekromanta

Offline

Jan 2023

43

CheliosX said:
Geez, can you relax? What's with the "best series this season" threads lately?
Personally, that's a bit of a stretch. But one thing I can honestly admit is that ORB is my best new anime of the fall 2024 season. But best anime of the season overall? No. T10 for sure.

Like I said, as far. I know everything can change. In the beginning of fall season, Uzumaki was in my top 5. I never thought, that if some show has good first 5 episodes. Means entire show will certainly be good. It's just predicting.

Oct 27, 5:28 AM

#35

CheliosX

Offline

Dec 2022

1827

Memowynekromanta said:

CheliosX said:
Geez, can you relax? What's with the "best series this season" threads lately?
Personally, that's a bit of a stretch. But one thing I can honestly admit is that ORB is my best new anime of the fall 2024 season. But best anime of the season overall? No. T10 for sure.

Like I said, as far. I know everything can change. In the beginning of fall season, Uzumaki was in my top 5. I never thought, that if some show has good first 5 episodes. Means entire show will certainly be good. It's just predicting.

Alright, I can agree with you on that.

Oct 27, 5:46 AM

#36

Memowynekromanta

Offline

Jan 2023

43

Cersil said:
@Pablo_Neruda1 dw, I'm smarter than you'll ever be

Can you two chill out.

Oct 27, 6:40 AM

#37

ZXEAN

Offline

Sep 2020

5333

Better than anything that came in Summer 2024 but this season competition is high.

Oct 27, 7:28 AM

#38

Ash_li

Offline

Feb 2017

23

Reply to FreedomKME

I am not a fan of the pacing, what they did with 5 episodes could have been done with 2, even 1 if you are smart. Also, everyone being shitty or broken doesn't exactly make them compelling characters.

@FreedomKME This is how we ended up with gems such as Uzumaki and Promised Neverland Season 2. No thanks.

What makes them compelling is that their beliefs, philosophies and worldviews are well thought and fleshed out. They have more dimensions as people that we can understand. Maybe if you ignore the dialogue and cut it out they feel like simple caricatures.

Oct 27, 8:37 AM

#39

FreedomKME

Offline

Feb 2018

366

Ash_li said:
@FreedomKME This is how we ended up with gems such as Uzumaki and Promised Neverland Season 2. No thanks.

What makes them compelling is that their beliefs, philosophies and worldviews are well thought and fleshed out. They have more dimensions as people that we can understand. Maybe if you ignore the dialogue and cut it out they feel like simple caricatures.

Are they "well thought and fleshed out"? Kid spent 3 episodes hammering down how smart he is and how he tricks people into doing what he wants to live a better life, only to abandon everything to a new found dogma/research he WON'T GET TO SEE.

Oct 27, 9:36 AM

#40

wingzero604

Offline

Jul 2022

6

How is it good when whole episode 4 is under funding and only see black for most of the show.

Oct 27, 9:39 AM

#41

Ash_li

Offline

Feb 2017

23

Reply to FreedomKME

Ash_li said:
@FreedomKME This is how we ended up with gems such as Uzumaki and Promised Neverland Season 2. No thanks.

What makes them compelling is that their beliefs, philosophies and worldviews are well thought and fleshed out. They have more dimensions as people that we can understand. Maybe if you ignore the dialogue and cut it out they feel like simple caricatures.

Are they "well thought and fleshed out"? Kid spent 3 episodes hammering down how smart he is and how he tricks people into doing what he wants to live a better life, only to abandon everything to a new found dogma/research he WON'T GET TO SEE.

@FreedomKME This is an example of what I said. You just stated the beginning of his character arc, skipped everything in the middle and then stated the end of his character arc like he suddenly changed his mind. If it was all condensed in 1 episode, you'd be right. And the fact that you think they can cut everything in between shows that you don't actually care for character building in this way.

It's fine if you don't enjoy this topic or style of storytelling but you're blatantly misrepresenting what actually happened. I'm just glad it exists for people that do enjoy it.

Oct 27, 12:54 PM

#42

upwindspy

Offline

Aug 2015

34

orb is best of the season hands down

Oct 27, 1:13 PM

#43

Zarutaku

Offline

Sep 2016

9889

So far it seems like the best and TsumaSho 2nd.

No, this isn't my signature.

Nov 3, 7:26 AM

#44

Mackyreels

Offline

Jul 2024

147

Reply to wingzero604

How is it good when whole episode 4 is under funding and only see black for most of the show.

@wingzero604 episode 4 has the best animation so far, the only problem with this anime is its too dark but they are slowly improving it in the latest episode.

Nov 3, 7:27 AM

#45

Mackyreels

Offline

Jul 2024

147

Reply to CheliosX

Geez, can you relax? What's with the "best series this season" threads lately?
Personally, that's a bit of a stretch. But one thing I can honestly admit is that ORB is my best new anime of the fall 2024 season. But best anime of the season overall? No. T10 for sure.

@CheliosX its definitely top 5 for sure

Nov 3, 7:29 AM

#46

CheliosX

Offline

Dec 2022

1827

Mackyreels said:
@CheliosX its definitely top 5 for sure

w, I like this......

Nov 3, 9:05 AM

#47

Mackyreels

Offline

Jul 2024

147

Reply to Cielord

It's way too soon to determine, but so far, then yeah. It's the best new series this season. Blue Box is a close second.

But if we also include sequels, then I don't think it's even top 5.

@Cielord nah top 5 easily

Nov 3, 2:05 PM

#48

Cielord

Offline

Jan 2021

1604

Reply to Mackyreels

@Cielord nah top 5 easily

@Mackyreels After more episodes of each series came out and my opinion on each 'solidified', then yeah, it's top 5 for me. But genuinely, how pathetic are you to go to anyone who has a different opinion from you and reply to them?

Nov 13, 11:59 AM

#49

Ilias03x

Offline

Nov 2023

9

I mean re:zero ain't the best of the season Dan Dan is a better candidate if we hear re:zero fan talking about it,it is an undeniable masterpiece for them ,and if you say that it is a great anime but it is not a masterpiece, their fan are worse than inquisition

Nov 13, 5:31 PM

#50

Ambeon

Offline

Nov 2018

217

If it keeps its appeal that it has throughout the series, it will be the AOTS, but a lot can happen in a full cour, the quality for all we know could fall of a cliff on episode 12, we'll just have to wait and see. But so far its looking very promising. Its not as exciting as Dandadan, but the story is way more compelling.

Poll: » Chi. Chikyuu no Undou ni Tsuite Episode 8 Discussion Stark700 - Nov 16	41	by Dripispopis »» 2 hours ago
» Teaser and Fall 2024 Dbagas8 - Jul 24	7	by Mackyreels »» Yesterday, 3:43 AM
» To Everyone Complaining about historical accuracy pls read this Mackyreels - Oct 30	35	by Mackyreels »» Nov 19, 6:17 PM
» Dark scenes nearly unwatchable Malisa90 - Nov 13	36	by Phlaryx »» Nov 19, 4:40 PM
» So season 2 of this anime will be.... RjtheGreat14 - Nov 13	18	by Soulblight »» Nov 19, 10:54 AM

Best series of the season?

More topics from this board

Poll: » Chi. Chikyuu no Undou ni Tsuite Episode 8 Discussion

» Teaser and Fall 2024

» To Everyone Complaining about historical accuracy pls read this

» Dark scenes nearly unwatchable

» So season 2 of this anime will be....

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters