| Like Jesus, the amount of character development he has received in just 30+ episodes are beyond insane. Who else thinks he's a Top-Tier character that deserves more respect? |
| ๐๐ฃ๐ ๐๐๐๐๐ ๐ฅ๐๐๐๐ฃ๐ ๐๐จ ๐ฅ๐๐ง๐๐๐๐ฉ๐ก๐ฎ ๐๐๐ฃ๐. - ๐๐๐๐ |
| to the question in the title no to the poll yes |
keinboesewicht said: _otaku_man00 said: are you joking??? i don't think he is best character in anime,, even in last episode he lied to sylphy that she is all he needs ,but later he is going to get more waifus I know that,, he isn't even honest to his own wife,, how can you say he is best character in anime?? op means „best written“. they dont have to be the most likable maybe I am blind but he didn't mention op here,, he said one of the best character,,, 8 don't think he is ,, even with 20+ character development episodes,, 40+ age is still acts like a kid and blamed eris for living him and lies to sylphy,,, he should be honest with her that he likes roxy atleast,,,  |
_otaku_man00 said: maybe I am blind but he didn't mention op here,, he said one of the best character,,, 8 don't think he is ,, even with 20+ character development episodes,, 40+ age is still acts like a kid and blamed eris for living him and lies to sylphy,,, he should be honest with her that he likes roxy atleast,,, okay he is a bad person but that doesn't mean he's a bad written character or not the best. If we're going by your standards, that means Luffy is the best character |
Yantama said: _otaku_man00 said: maybe I am blind but he didn't mention op here,, he said one of the best character,,, 8 don't think he is ,, even with 20+ character development episodes,, 40+ age is still acts like a kid and blamed eris for living him and lies to sylphy,,, he should be honest with her that he likes roxy atleast,,, okay he is a bad person but that doesn't mean he's a bad written character or not the best. If we're going by your standards, that means Luffy is the best character only honesty doesn't make a person as a best character,,but honesty is also part of it,, you can lie somethings to make your loved once happy,,but don't lie on the thing that you can't control,,,, Rudy knows he loves roxy ,, her panties are god to him,,,, he should be honest at this kind of situation ,, i don't think Luffy is best character but he is not like Rudy,, I can atleast say Luffy is good,, |
_otaku_man00 said: Yantama said: okay he is a bad person but that doesn't mean he's a bad written character or not the best. If we're going by your standards, that means Luffy is the best character only honesty doesn't make a person as a best character,,but honesty is also part of it,, you can lie somethings to make your loved once happy,,but don't lie on the thing that you can't control,,,, Rudy knows he loves roxy ,, her panties are god to him,,,, he should be honest at this kind of situation ,, i don't think Luffy is best character but he is not like Rudy,, I can atleast say Luffy is good,, youre having a completely different discussion. NO ONE said that rudeus is a GOOD PERSON. (which is also debatable, but thats a different discussion as i already said) we‘re saying that he is a REALISTIC CHARACTER with lots of development. and that makes him a WELL WRITTEN character |
keinboesewichtApr 30, 3:47 AM
keinboesewicht said: _otaku_man00 said: only honesty doesn't make a person as a best character,,but honesty is also part of it,, you can lie somethings to make your loved once happy,,but don't lie on the thing that you can't control,,,, Rudy knows he loves roxy ,, her panties are god to him,,,, he should be honest at this kind of situation ,, i don't think Luffy is best character but he is not like Rudy,, I can atleast say Luffy is good,, youre having a completely different discussion. NO ONE said that rudeus is a GOOD PERSON. (which is also debatable, but thats a different discussion as i already said) we‘re saying that he is a REALISTIC CHARACTER with lots of development. and that makes him a WELL WRITTEN character the pole doesn't say what you are saying,,, just read the question,,, he is not one of the best character ,,,, he may be realistic,,,,( 40+ age still a kid) but not best for sure . |
_otaku_man00 said: maybe I am blind but he didn't mention op here,, he said one of the best character,,, 8 don't think he is ,, even with 20+ character development episodes,, 40+ age is still acts like a kid and blamed eris for living him and lies to sylphy,,, he should be honest with her that he likes roxy atleast,,, OP mentioned "character", not "a person", which is used to described quality of the writing, not morality. And since you already spoiled yourself for whatever reason, you should know that Rudy himself didn't liked the idea of polygamy himself, but his three wifes pushed for it. And no, it's not "cheating" because nobody hides anything from anyone and Rudy himself eventually agreed on that, because he just didn't wanted to discriminate between the three and choose only one. And, yes, I do think he is well written because his character development is truly beautiful, but he still has a long way to go. |
PiromyslApr 30, 4:07 AM
 |
_otaku_man00 said: keinboesewicht said: youre having a completely different discussion. NO ONE said that rudeus is a GOOD PERSON. (which is also debatable, but thats a different discussion as i already said) we‘re saying that he is a REALISTIC CHARACTER with lots of development. and that makes him a WELL WRITTEN character the pole doesn't say what you are saying,,, just read the question,,, he is not one of the best character ,,,, he may be realistic,,,,( 40+ age still a kid) but not best for sure . omfg its like talking to a wall.. you must be trolling at this point. theres multiple people telling you that you misunderstood. but please, keep thinking you’re the only one who is right |
| No. Saying that while I really enjoy MT. |
 |
| The poll and ur title isn't the same thing. He is a good character, but not one of the best |
 |
_otaku_man00 said: keinboesewicht said: youre having a completely different discussion. NO ONE said that rudeus is a GOOD PERSON. (which is also debatable, but thats a different discussion as i already said) we‘re saying that he is a REALISTIC CHARACTER with lots of development. and that makes him a WELL WRITTEN character the pole doesn't say what you are saying,,, just read the question,,, he is not one of the best character ,,,, he may be realistic,,,,( 40+ age still a kid) but not best for sure . Realistically bad personality IS good character. Bad personality -> this guy sucks Good character -> make the story interesting |
| Why the fuck would he be? He's more or less a functioning human being at this point, but that's about the extent of it. |
| If you reply back to me and I never respond, I lost interest and don't care. Sorry about that. |
| he's written as a pos with some growth, I like it. |
| Rudy is surprisingly well-written. Mushoku Tensei features great character writing in general (and it is despite the language of the visual novels is worse than of a grade schooler) and Rudy is just one example. I wish there were more stories with this level of character writing. Watching this thread is hilarious. There are really people out there who can't understand how well-written characters and well-behaved people are different things (like @_otaku_man00). But what is more hilarious, there are people who try to argue with such media illiterate viewers as if they were intellectually equal to them (like @Piromysl). Like, really, can't you see how their whining makes little to no sense? They keep embarrassing themselves before the whole forum and yet some people think as if something may appeal to their ignorance, incompetence and lack of shame. Nothing can. Don't waste your time on counter-productive discussions, watch Madoka Magica and Black Rock Shooter TV instead, it is a way better use for your time. |
PostMahouShoujoMay 1, 12:57 AM
Blackโ
Rock Shooter (TV) is beyond its time arthouse fantasy/psychological drama/psychological horror/action. Should you watch it? See my review.  โบ  โบ  โผ  |
| I believe rudeus is one of the worst character in the history of anime. He is one of the main reason that I hate MT. |
If you enjoyed the time you wasted, then its not a waste of time.  |
Reply to _otaku_man00
PostMahouShoujo said:
Rudy is surprisingly well-written. Mushoku Tensei features great character writing in general (and it is despite the language of the visual novels is worse than of a grade schooler) and Rudy is just one example. I wish there were more stories with this level of character writing.
Watching this thread is hilarious. There are really people out there who can't understand how well-written characters and well-behaved people are different things (like @_otaku_man00). But what is more hilarious, there are people who try to argue with such media illiterate viewers as if they were intellectually equal to them (like @Piromysl). Like, really, can't you see how their whining makes little to no sense? They keep embarrassing themselves before the whole forum and yet some people think as if something may appeal to their ignorance, incompetence and lack of shame. Nothing can. Don't waste your time on counter-productive discussions, watch Madoka Magica and Black Rock Shooter TV instead, it is a way better use for your time.
Rudy is surprisingly well-written. Mushoku Tensei features great character writing in general (and it is despite the language of the visual novels is worse than of a grade schooler) and Rudy is just one example. I wish there were more stories with this level of character writing.
Watching this thread is hilarious. There are really people out there who can't understand how well-written characters and well-behaved people are different things (like @_otaku_man00). But what is more hilarious, there are people who try to argue with such media illiterate viewers as if they were intellectually equal to them (like @Piromysl). Like, really, can't you see how their whining makes little to no sense? They keep embarrassing themselves before the whole forum and yet some people think as if something may appeal to their ignorance, incompetence and lack of shame. Nothing can. Don't waste your time on counter-productive discussions, watch Madoka Magica and Black Rock Shooter TV instead, it is a way better use for your time.
well written good character,then no ,,, well written shitty character then yess,,, i would consider Eran ,gabi as well written good character,, even if they are wrong at some places they are right at something,,,, they may be wrong from others perspective but from what he is gone through or what he is trying to do is right at some point,,,
but in case of Rudy i don't think I can support him as much as you guys are doing,, except Rudy i would consider others characters of mushoku as well written character,,,, i would consider Lelouch ( from code geass ) as well written good character but not rudy, because lelouch may be wrong and also did many mistakes but he is right too,,,
Rudy is well-written shitty character,,that's what I think,, he is also 40+ years old ,has new life , but didn't change at all ,, last 25+ epds was all about character development,,no story,, i don't even know what's going on ,, i think novel readers should stop talking to anime watchers ( me) ...if you are novel reader then please stop it,, he may be a better person in the future but now he is shit ....
| @_otaku_man00 If you seriously gonna say that "Rudy did not changed at all since reincarnating", then you are objectively wrong. Unless you were watching MT with monitor and speakers turned off, your statement is clear cause of confirmation bias and you're overall not worth even debating with. @PostMahouShoujo is correct on that one and you proved his point 100% I don't see the reason why I'm even wasting time to argue with people, whom clearly won't change their mind no matter how hard proven wrong with objective facts because they will just double down. I honestly thought that once Rudeus became less degenerate over the course of second season, we wouldn't have takes like this one, but I guess I was too naive and had too much faith in this community. |
|
| Rud is def not a good char he has his negative characteristics plot wise. As for whether he is one of the best written chars, I think he is definitely up there - his original character is written very convincingly with his NEET side. The kid Rud definitely has some good writing behind him but not much substance beyond the average reincarnated adventure driven MC. |
ST63LTH said: Rud is def not a good char he has his negative characteristics plot wise. As for whether he is one of the best written chars, I think he is definitely up there - his original character is written very convincingly with his NEET side. The kid Rud definitely has some good writing behind him but not much substance beyond the average reincarnated adventure driven MC. Friendly reminder that good character is not the same as a good person. |
|
| He's definitely in the top 1000 for sure. |
| One of the most pathetic beta MC. Who collects panties like loser even after getting married. |
| yet another delusional MT fan smh. |
| Well Rudeus is a fun guy who has different tastes ofcourse. But I don't see him as a S tier character. |
| I might never be the hands you put your heart in Or the arms that hold you any time you want them But that don't mean that we can't live here in the moment 'Cause I can be the one you love from time to time |
| Im getting sick of Rudeus tbh, there's so many better characters in Mushoku Tensei. I get that him acting like a terrible person makes him more "realistic", but he still feels like a self insert character. The anime does not commit to portraying him realistically because he always has some overpowered ability and everyone just randomly likes him despite his shitty behavior. And the fact this dude is mentally 40 yet still acts like he is a teenager is just really annoying and cringe. |
"Get your tentacles off me or ill make calamari out of your manhood" -Mirai Nikki Dub |
More topics from this board
» How many seasons are left?x3z - May 12 |
35 |
by shaked6540
»»
12 minutes ago |
|
» Would this season stretch out for too long if they covered everything?Blazehot10 - 9 hours ago |
7 |
by ExternalWorld
»»
24 minutes ago |
|
» Why do people defend Rudeus? ( 1 2 )Leon888 - Yesterday |
90 |
by peepmo
»»
57 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » Mushoku Tensei II: Isekai Ittara Honki Dasu Part 2 Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Stark700 - May 12 |
187 |
by justamegamind
»»
2 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Mushoku Tensei II: Isekai Ittara Honki Dasu Part 2 Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Stark700 - Apr 28 |
161 |
by DoisacChopper
»»
7 hours ago |