Ranking

CyborgSaber said:

Can ask why Steins;Gate the fans never do or talk about downvoting they are one of the more chill fanbases in the top. If anything FMAB, HxH and AoT are the fanbases you should be calling out.

"64 episodes is better than 1 movie".

InspectorLunge said:


I have neither seen FMAB nor Gintama but this is factually correct; Gintama's final season has solely been rated by individuals who liked all the previous movies and 300+ episodes enough to sit through each one of them.. Pretty sure the "Sequel effect" is the correct term for it as defined by another MAL user in another post.

TecHeDD said:
Nah tbh It deserves top 20 at most the movie wasn’t good ending was trash AND HOW DARE IT TOOK OUT STEINS GATE FROM TOP 3

xZabuzax said:
I haven't watched a single episode of Gintama so I don't know how good this is but if this surpass FMAB then yeah, expect to see some massive downvoting on this because the FMAB fanboys won't have any of it.

And yeah, the Steins;Gate fanbase is the most chill fanbase at the top but as a Steins;Gate fan myself I'm quite jelly seeing Steins;Gate going down but then again, the ratings doesn't mean shit in MAL, I personally won't place FMAB in my top 100, FMAB is the most overrated garbage I've seen so far.

SKKintheHouse7 said:
Every fandom has a number of idiots lurking for attention(just like the steins gate fan above).

xZabuzax said:

Every fandom also has idiots giving other idiots attention (just like the idiot above me).

SKKintheHouse7 said:
I'm just trying to get you out of your "steins gate is the chillest fandom" bubble and people like this need to get called out for their stupidity.

Fruscio said:
Would you stop it? FMAB fandom has never downvoted anything.

Fruscio said:
It wasn't, FMAB fandom has yet to downvote anything but because it's the best-rated anime, it takes all the blame for something it didn't do - no-proof accusations.

Fruscio said:
What there is to explain? I see a normal ratio distribution of scores for top anime and that someone has taken a screenshot of Fruits Basket and FMAB displaying the difference in score. Yet this proves little to nothing that FMAB fandom is the one behind this. That other person's tweet proves nothing either given how easy it is to impersonate someone of a particular group to make said group look bad.

What you should explain is how its score went from 9.18 to 9.8 in about 2 days. Given how everyone was liking Fruits Basket, I can't imagine it would fall down that much if... and this may seem a crazy conspiracy - people were upvoting it and MAL's scoring system boosting recalculations kept it from staying up there any longer.

Fruscio said:
I didn't state he was impersonating the FMAB fandom, I meant it as a probability and that we shouldn't be judging people by a mere tweet. Unlike you, however, that by giving me the link of the thread clearly intended him as one of "many" dethroning everything that comes near FMAB. The proofs may never be found but if ever given, you'd be the one to present it to me before I do it to you as you were that started it off the contention first. Don't claim, prove it.

Yes it does. The dev team made it possible to make the rankings as accurate as possible and Fruits Basket didn't deserve the 9.18.

I haven't been given any proofs so the "FMAB fandom has never downvoted anything" stands still.

Fruscio said:
You keep alluding to the idea a tweet of Fruits Basket stats make an actual statement and good case to affirm the FMAB fandom is the one behind this because it got dethroned for one day. How many 1s has gotten before and after the event is irrelevant if nothing connects back to FMAB fandom you keep claiming to be responsible. I can't accept something it's not true and you refuse to give me irrefutable proof because you have none. If you did then you wouldn't have given me a screenshot of a guy who had just learned where to see the stats of anime on MAL.

>You can literally see increase in 1s after it dethroned FMAB

It jumped from 9.18 to 9.8 in an instant because its score was recalculated as a bunch of illegitimate votes were given. It didn't go down slowly one by one to finally end up at the score it is now because that would've only happened if your stance on "its score dropped the moment it dethroned FMAB" was remotely correct.

Like I said in a previous post, ya'll act like this because FMAB takes the first place. Were it to be another anime, it'd be the exact scenery we are witnessing like now where you and company slander the fandom for no reason other than is the easiest fandom to cherry-pick at.

Fruscio said:
You've shown that before, saw it, and debunked why doesn't prove anything in the long run. You dismiss the obvious with nothing to back up your claims but it's there and happily like always has been. You should re-read my previous replies than posting the same thing in an attempt to encounter my belief. You didn't. One person's random tweet about something you can never be sure was meant to be taken for granted cannot be irrefutable proof and with that in mind generalizing the entire fandom off of that alone. The same can be said of that "FMAB user" you mentioned about the thread, which not only makes it pointless to even mention him here since you can't "prove" what he did or was going to do but he also falls in the same category as the other guy - that you have to first prove to me they were the biggest FMAB fan and they were indeed willing to downvote anything that even dares to come closer to FMAB and then I'll admit that two FMAB fans indeed downvote Fruits Basket and perhaps other series as well. Until then, I'm in the clear.

It didn't play any massive role because the score change was done instantly. Because of 10s mass inflation, it was nearly impossible to get a sudden change looking at how in comparison of 1s and 10s was a huge difference in favor of the 10s. The point is, more people were giving high scores than low scores and therefore if were to had been a change, it would've been by 1 or 2 points and not by 10 as it occurred.

Interesting you didn't mention Gintama in your name-dropping of fandoms you think do these virulent things. Don't be afraid of facing out the truth, if there's something left, my dude.

xZabuzax said:

Well I hardly see the Steins;Gate fandom making a big fuss about losing its ranking unlike FMAB or AOT which always make a big fuss about it.

So yeah every fandom does have some people here and there that are jelly about it like me, I've just stated that in my first comment but you just needed to be a big dumbass and insult me about it when I stated the obvious already but that doesn't change the fact that the Steins;Gate fandom is still one of the chillest fandom out there you stupid moron.

SKKintheHouse7 said:


How did I insult you lmao? I just showed you an example of a fan that rated the final movie a 1 without watching any of the prequels. If you thought I was calling you an idiot you misunderstood, it was the person above that I was referring to.

UaEfAlCoN83 said:
Does not even deserve +8.5 in my opinion. Animation was bad compared to previous seasons (excluding the last 2) and the story became bad at the end in my opinion. The whole Utsuro thing ruined Gintama. In my opinion the second movie is superior and way better. For me, this movie deserves 7/10 at max.

Theo1899 said:
I don't think it's good enough to rank this high tbqh. It's the worst gintama imo.

abpg said:
I don’t think it’s highly likely that it will rank to 1 and if it did the FMAB fandom will put 1/10 on it. Did you see what they did to fruits basket…

Nurguburu said:


FMAB score went from 9.17 to 9.16 now.

Okeanix said:
Stop comparing ratings with 10K votes.

Gintama Final have 10K Votes which most of them fans completed every season not dropped halfway through it.

Fullmetal Alchemist doesn't have sequel or prequel and have 1.5 Million Votes

I'm sorry Gintama fans but if Gintama had 1.5 Million Votes like FMAB actual score probably would be below 8 because Gintama is not for everyone but FMAB is a classic.

Anime Discussion rules said:

2.　Please refrain from creating threads that do not encourage meaningful and/or civil discussion. Examples include:
[...]
e.　MAL community data
e.g.　Questioning the score/ranking/character favorite counts
e.g.　Saying that series X should have a higher/lower score/count