Attack on Titan
What would you like to see in the rumbling arc?
| Where's the option to leave it as it is? Rumbling arc has seen some of the best characterization of this series. People will love it once the series ends and they go back and reread it. |
 |
| Wait Hange’s dead isn’t she? Also Pixis is basically dead? I think Historia is already playing a major role. She’s giving birth right? I’d want Armin to come up with a plan. It seems he’s gonna do that as of 136... As for the writing quality, I guess it’s not as good as previous arcs after 131 but it’s still goddamn incredible. Did you read 136? There are some pretty epic moments in that chapter and the Rumbling arc as well. AOT is simply epic. |
 |
chiearlymorning said: So in my opinion the quality of writing decreased since chapter 124 (with the exception of chapter 131), with the alliance chapters just feeling very forcedand the plot not feeling as interesting. If you were to write the rumbling arc, how would you improve it? Yeah, the characters were forced to team up as Eren was already making his move to genocide the entire world, so yes they were forced to throw their differences aside to save the world. Isayama did a decent job for them to let out their frustration and their difference aside, but with limited time they didn't have a choice but to work together. That is why it felt forced to you, but in a real world situation where the entire world may be destroy, China, Russia, North Korea, US etc and all nation will join forces without hesitation despite their hatred against each other. So you need to be realistic here that the author doesn't need 20+ chapters or how many you think it needs for them to join forces when a pending doom is already happening in real time. the plot not feeling as interesting Yeah its not as interesting as the previous arc because its a simple scenario we are in, the alliance vs Eren that's it, most of the plot twist the interesting dialogue between Reiner and Eren etc are not going to be present in this final plot line as it is simple to stop Eren, the interesting thing is how it will end. Give Historia a bigger role to play She has a very big role in the finale and the final chapter panel is the biggest clue to that, also she is queen she wont be in any battle, what did you expect? And obviously Isayama is hiding her point of view as it has something to with Eren, I feel I know what it is, but we will see. Make Connie have an actual motivation to "save the world" Connie motivation is the same as everyone motivation is to stop Eren from doing mass genocide, you don't need any motivation to save the world, wtf? lol Have Levi confront Annie for killing his squad Lame, what will that do? They all know the situation the warriors are in, no need for that at all. Make Yelena and Kiyomi actual characters in the story I actually like Yelena and many will agree with me, so I can't relate to this comment, Kiyomi is pure plot device and I'm ok with that, she is from a different Country and she is really not someone that the viewers need to like at all. She is in it for business and that's all. Make Armin come up with a plan But he did come up with a plan, remember he drew Eren titan and told them how they will attack him. Make the flying titan less of an asspull Yes, this is one I kinda agree with you, though his name being Falco and one of the Marley Soldier asking if their is any titans with wings? was a hint in retrospect of we seeing a flying titan, honestly though, its not a big deal for me tbh. Make Pixis and Nile play an important role instead of killing them off Nah, I don't see what more can they do? the battle is out side of Paradise, meaning we wont be seeing paradise island point of view anymore and these characters can't fight so what would they do if they were still alive? So its either kill them or let them live, that's all. Make Hange give alternative solutions to the rumbling Can you think of an alternate solution to the rumbling, that hanji can realistically come up with? I don't think so as none of us can really come up with a solution either, and Hanji even admitted that she doesn't have a solution which makes sense because none of us too can't find a solution that will stop this, but again genocide is bad and she wont be able to sleep at night knowing billions of innocent people dying and she didn't even try to stop it, you guys are not even looking at it in that perspective, you guys are making it sound like killing 99% of the population is a no brainer for Hanji and company, but it is not. You can make your own fanfic of the rumbling arc, where the scouting join Eren and help him destroy all of humanity since that makes more sense to you. That would be bad writing and against those characters, but to you its only bad writing if you don't like it, and Isayama would definitely look like a facist if the development was like that pure black and white, it would just seem like Isayama is forcing it down our throat if the viewers didn't get to choose which side they are on, this debate is interesting because it split the fanbase and hows the morality in all of us, it this is a more interesting scenario than whatever you are thinking of. I'm tired of you readers that can't see the big picture here. |
keragammingJan 16, 2021 2:08 PM
| @keragamming I think the flying titan is iffy because of the way it was introduced. It's just Falco coming up to Annie and saying ''Oh I got some memories of the clouds and it feels like I can do it too.'' TBH it would have worked better if that scene was skipped and then later explained how Falco can fly. |
|
I_Am_Freeballing said: @keragamming I think the flying titan is iffy because of the way it was introduced. It's just Falco coming up to Annie and saying ''Oh I got some memories of the clouds and it feels like I can do it too.'' TBH it would have worked better if that scene was skipped and then later explained how Falco can fly. That is the one I kinda agree with, and think Isayama may fix it in the anime, but it really isn't a big thing for me personally. The Reiner transfering his conscientiousness will never be top imo, so this is the least. And I bet @chiearlymorning, didn't have any problem when that happen, but you see, when you don't enjoy something, what you do is nitpick it more vs when you enjoy it. |
| The only thing I would fix would be giving better foreshadow to the flying titan, that’s it. Ah, the op is 19 years old, I understand everything now. |
cAbaddonJan 16, 2021 3:18 PM
| I heavily shit on ch 91-96 when they came out. I'm not going to make the same mistake again. |
cAbaddon said: The only thing I would fix would be giving better foreshadow to the flying titan, that’s it. I feel like the anime is foreshadowing it a bit too much. One of my anime-only friends said that he'll become a flying titan based on his lines, ending visuals and what calvi said. |
| about the flying titan im not sure why the founding titan did not create even one flying titan to counter falco flying titan though instead she created an army of War Hammer Titan instead Make Hange give alternative solutions to the rumbling (your vote) i was expecting Hange or any of the adults have the solution to the vicious cycle of hate but i guess there is none and that Eren will kill all of humanity now, the world is cruel its kill or be killed base on chapter 111 too |
| I think it's pretty decent |
| >Make Connie have an actual motivation to "save the world" I guess he has one. About "wanting to be a soldier that protects people". But i don't really buy it. He lost his family, his people and he swore to destroy his enemies. This sudden shift is something i don't buy. >Have Levi confront Annie for killing his squad Yeah this one should have happened. Jean confronted about Marco. And i would expect a comment atleast from Levi when Yelena told how Annie killed many soldiers. >Make Armin come up with a plan Really this. Without a plan, just going against Eren to stop him makes me support Eren. I understand what Eren doing is not a good thing. But there is nothing else he can do. And alliance having no plans, no future solutions makes me just unable to side with them. >Make the flying titan less of an asspull I understand that a plot device like this was needed but it feels a bit too convenient. Something i can ignore tbh The Points i want to add: -Kiyomi and the others on the ship should have died. I don't see the point of "sacrificed her boat for us!" Wow too bad rip her ship. -Remove extremely cringe panels like "ANNIE EATING PIE HAHAHAH" or "Time to save the world" marvel tier hero pose. -Let someone die already. Everything feels too convenient for the Alliance. I don't feel any sense of danger for the last 2 chapters because i know nobody will die. They are cutting through hordes of past shifter titans. Even Onyakapon survived that plane crash. -Too much time wasted on the Warrior Parents. Seriously We didnt need this many panels of them. Especially not at the end of the series where we have limited amount of panels left. |
ShadzzoJan 18, 2021 4:03 AM
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Chapter 138 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )deg - Mar 5, 2021 |
1128 |
by Berry-Vodka
»»
5 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Chapter 139 / Ending Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )NextUniverse - Apr 7, 2021 |
1875 |
by Berry-Vodka
»»
6 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Chapter 4 DiscussionMagEarwhig - Sep 11, 2011 |
25 |
by HenryDanger
»»
Apr 24, 6:34 AM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Chapter 141 Discussionventi_e - Sep 30, 2022 |
32 |
by Berry-Vodka
»»
Apr 20, 1:36 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Chapter 77 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Jan 7, 2016 |
137 |
by Berry-Vodka
»»
Mar 31, 12:03 AM |