Why are people praising this show so much?

Hussin said:


read the topic again to know what show we are talking about.

the mc is realy realy stupid, but that is not flaw, the flaws is he can be smart sometimes and can be stupid other times, just for plot convenience. that is not consistent. the author just wrote the story for fun i think. i couldn't take the show no matter how i try to shut off my brain. most characters are 1 dimensional. few characters i liked. i enjoyed few parts of the show, but compared to the shit i have seen, it is nothing. dropped the show after ep 19. couldn't handle. i was thinking maybe something will change.

Hussin said:


you didnt think the mc was inconsistent? well then no need to discuss anything beyond this.

Jagd84 said:


I have no idea who you talking about but doesn't sound like Subaru. Oh love how you call Subaru's love for Emilia obsession and stalker but praise Rem for acting the same way because she is cute girl who must sacrifice themselves for the MC and be rewarded for it but never the other way around. Nevrmind that Subaru his put his life on the line to save Emilia too. Then go around calling Subaru whining crybaby despite fact he's been through more shit than most MC's still mange to overcome his problems (grasp but growing up in a real sense) instead of getting by with generic superpowers by using his witts. If you want the standard masculine MC who incapable of being being anything but being a badass, soulless dolt look elsewhere.

Jagd84 said:


This makes nonsense. She was in love him and pursed her feelings after he had helped. No different with him and Emilia. Whether you liked any of them isn't relevant to me or the facts.

Yes because he has feelings for somebody else. He no obligation to forcibly return her feelings. Just as Emilia was no obligation return Subaru because he helped her out


This is dumb. The only time he caused trouble for her was one episode and even then he had his heart right but wrong approach.

Yes, because incompetent people are totally capable of strategy, negation and putting together coalition armies. But he's "incompetent" because eh made some mistakes along the way acted emotionally like a normal person. No dude he succeed because he used his head. He's no genius but he's dumb because he doesn't do what you say.

You can look at most shounen see what I mean by dolt, but I doubt care about something since you judge a person shallowly on how powerful they are not what they do have. So I couldn't careless about arguing this as will go nowhere.

Nobidexx said:


Watch carefully, it isn't the same alleyway every time. The alley is different in the first, second and third loops. In the fourth one it might be the same one as in the second loop, but I'm not sure. He's definitely not going to the same alleyway every single time, and he only goes through them as a shortcut to get to the loothouse faster (or in the third loop's case because he's chasing Emilia).

He does learn from each loop. In the first loop he was defeated by the thugs because the one in the middle had a knife. So in the second loop he targeted him down first. In the third loop he learned they were afraid of the guards, so instead of risking his life again he simply called them. Likewise, he memorized Elsa's attack patterns after being killed by her twice and managed to dodge some of her strikes in his third fight against her.

Obviously, he doesn't understand everything straight away and sometimes does make dumb decisions (especially when he's blinded by rage and despair, like in arc 3). Like every human being. Nobody is consistently a genius or consistently an idiot.



You're saying he's incompetent because he couldn't form an army without Crusch's help? Not being able to summon an army out of thin air makes him incompetent?

What he did here was using the knowledge he gained from his previous loops. He understood what Crusch wanted (defeating the white whale) and offered her a reasonable deal (mining rights and the white whale's location) in exchange for her help against the witch cult. If that's being incompetent, then I assume someone as competent as you could come up with a better solution to save both Emilia and the village?

Jagd84 said:


If that's you definition of "incompetence" than it's extremely childish. Basically because he doesn't have biggest dick on block, has get people cooperate with him by manulplating things in his favor instead of streaming rolling over everybody like some flat hero he's idiot *rolleyes*. And not you are literally wrong about his competence because he and nobody would survive those conflicts without him actually using his head which Subaru does. Your examples how you are grasping for straws and ignoring anything contradicts it as well as inaccurate to force you view. This so incredible shallow it is laughable moreso because you bring up Eiji of all people.




Unfortunately this seems to be a hard concept for decorators like this guy to understand seem to want one note characters who always right and amazing. Being fallible is seen as sin instead of being human.

Jagd84 said:


1) That has literally nothing to do what we talking about

Jagd84 said:


Your defense actually doesn't defend Eiji and only brings up a random subject (stakes) that has nothing to do with competence (the discussion). You clearly don't know what your talking abut and just arguing for sake of it. So we are done here.

Jagd84 said:


Another reason why he can't train by abusing RBD is because it completely resets Subaru to his initial status. Meaning he lose any physical prowess or mana pool increase to use those so-called powerful spells. The author reconfirmed that in the Q&A. He also little talent in magic and can only ever being a mediocre mage at best. So this train to summon a this army is not only unfeasible for him, but no such convenient spell exists. Might as well say he should be able make rain by blowing his nose by that dumb logic.