Is Kurisu Makise a transgender woman?

@Fireine Am I required to provide any "evidence" if all this activity happened at the exact moment you started this thread here? As far as I can tell from the screenshot from reddit, the dialogue in question also happened today. There are too many coincidences with very good timing to assume they were random

@RobertBobert despite this, it isn't something you can succinctly prove; and it's also external to this website. this discussion is directly related to actual content published here; so is absolutely relevant. Google also crawls this data and publishes it near the top of its search results. So if the data is not correct, it should be fixed if the fandom doesn't want a particular character potentially misrepresented.

@Fireine Again, there are too many coincidences whose explanation requires too many assumptions. https://lgbtqia-characters.fandom.com/wiki/Ruka_Urushibara?type=revision&diff=88082&oldid=79056 At the same time, if you look at the original author's contribution to the LGBTQ wiki, you will notice that they previously tried to rewrite the Ruka article into an article about "trans Kurisu" (for which, by the way, they were banned by local administrators). Not only by linking to your thread, but by doing so in a manner similar to your comments here, where you linking transgender terms with links to external sites. https://www.reddit.com/r/Kurisutina/comments/1b9ww40/is_kurisu_makise_a_transgender_woman/ As I expected, the reddit thread was actually created today as well.

So, not only did you create an article to use as an argument in this thread, but you actually looped it around, using the same thread to support the article's take, lmao.

@RobertBobert world-line divergence could easily skew the nature of ones very existence. A string that maps uniquely to Ruka (as you've linked, though unofficial and not endorsed by MAGES) at time and space could have been reassigned to Kurisu given the nature of world-line divergence. But you knew this already (I assume you're mathematically sophisticated enough to reach these same conclusions until proven otherwise). The very wiki you're referencing isn't officially maintained by MAGES. So exactly anything it contains shouldn't be a reliable source unless published otherwise at an official statement by the publishers. Let us know if that data materializes. Until then, this (subtle) canon cannot be succinctly disproven.

@Fireine What exactly can be refuted in my argument by the fact that this is not an official wiki? The fact that you unironically tried to edit the wiki to confirm your take on the forum in 2024? Or were you in that way hoping that copying our dialogue above and reversing the roles in it, would somehow make your position look better? Sorry, this won't work without context.

I also advise you to study the concept of "burden of proof". It is up to you to prove your theory and you cannot claim that your theory cannot be refuted because people have not literally proven the opposite. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russell%27s_teapot At least read about Russell's Teapot. With that logic, we'd have to conclude that all the characters in the title could be said to be trans, since the writers apparently didn't waste time disproving that Okabe and or any of his friends were trans.

@RobertBobert Well, if you truly are this anti-trans, then tis' the season for revisionist history I guess. Feel free to submit a request to edit her bio to relinquish this subtle canon and remove all doubt that Kurisu is a biological female. But until then, this subtle canon cannot, and will not be refuted until proven otherwise by an official source (MAGES).

Kurisu was a women designed to compliment the mcs personality and hobbies. If she was trans, her skeletal frame would be wider like broad shoulders.

Simple, if you need someone to approve of your choices of life, talk to your family, your friend, a counsellor... If you need a fiction to do so, just create one, don't try to force your state of mind on an, already existing, piece of media that has nothing to do with it...

And after all of that, people still are shocked to see the amount of anti-LGBTQIA+...

@Fireine I don't need any "mathematical analysis" to disprove that a theory that requires mental gymnastics, logical fallacies and wiki editing to prove it is not true. Especially when you reach the point of complete absurdity, linking in a thread to a wiki article, which in turn links to a thread, lol.

You tries to hide your insecurity behind your search of logical answers, and everyone already realized that, hence the lot of hate you are getting here. You would have more chance on Twitter, to be honest...

@Fireine I don't need any "mathematical analysis" to disprove that a theory that requires mental gymnastics, logical fallacies and wiki editing to prove it is not true. Especially when you reach the point of complete absurdity, linking in a thread to a wiki article, which in turn links to a thread, lol.

What is dude even waffling about

why is this bait thread still up

mods do your job

A thread was kicked off the Popular New Discussion leaderboard for this

How is this brainrot the longest mal thread I’ve ever seen💀

How is this brainrot the longest mal thread I’ve ever seen💀

top quality bait kek
or maybe some people are just obsessed with making every character in anime trans

I've played the Steins;Gate visual novel and seen all the endings. I can confirm, Makise Kurisu is trans. But only in one of the timelines. There is a secret scene where Okabe gobbles Kuristina's massive 9 inch schlong. Only real Steins;Gate fans like me will know this fact.

13 hours ago is crazy

the bait is so strong i'm choking on it, just like i'm choking on makise kurisu's 12 inch gigacock, OP is right

A thread was kicked off the Popular New Discussion leaderboard for this

@Alexioos95 I want whatever you're smoking. I simply fielded a question given the nature of the bio hosted at this very site. If you could read critically you'd see where where I'm coming from. "as a girl," should absolutely be fixed if Kurisu isn't trans.

@Fireine You already got a logical answer to that, multiple times, and it's "NO", "as a girl" simply means "as a kid"

I usually don't interpret fan written character biographies in a different language into the text of an anime based on a visual novel, but it's a fun little exercise.

Ok so I am too lazy to actually go into depth into this but do you realise that MAL mods (and users indirectly) can change whatever is said on the character bio? Obviously, they won't put random bullshit that is very clearly false, but anything can be written there even slightly misleading information. Case in point (I wrote the entire bio when I submitted it many moons ago).

The reason why I mentioned any need to go into depth about this is because I wanted to check the source but the page is completely fucked so one would have to use the wayback machine or something. For some reason, maybe due to the nature of the text--doesn't seem all that well connected in terms of the flow of writing I guess, I doubt that any serious fandom wiki would have the kind of bio that MAL has for Kurisu.

Maybe you are just overthinking this. But I would recommend going into depth with the original sources and find what you can from there.

@NextUniverse

Unfortunately, only MAL mods have superuser privileges at this context. rando's can only petition to change something. perhaps it's reasonable to expect MODS, if they're going to write a bio that is indexed by Google as a top source to provide credible information about a char based at official sources only. And, if it's inaccurate, to update it. But perhaps my statement is naive.

@Fireine
If there is a legitimate reason to change something objectively, then it can be done by a sole user. Case in point, this thread (I managed to get the Akira image to change).

I don't exactly know what you are getting at here with this comment, but from what I can understand of it I just wouldn't put too much faith in the mods. Idk how good it is these days but whatever. Not the cleanest of track records.