@TomDay
TomDay said: this is getting quite off topic You are the one who has made this whole thread off topic by only talking abut hair , clothes and not facial features.
TomDay said: ah, i see. you didn't see my edited post. after i typed that first time i decided to scrap it and make another point. reread it, you'll see it's there. Yeah I didn't notice because you edited it in later.
TomDay said: you posted 4 examples of young justice, and that was only in the lips and nose department. again, that's DC and i have already said that DC/Marvel and basically any superhero show does that. that's why i said cartoons nowadays that DON'T have DC/Marvel or superheroes barely have that. i wasn't dismissing. i was trying to make a point. Miss Martian was in the clothes department as well with lips. So why are you limiting cartoons but not anime? Slice and life anime and romcoms do that so why not restrict them? You also haven't proved that considering I have shown a lot of different clothes from other cartoons.
TomDay said: you showed 8 examples of regular show, in the fashion department. a very fair example but it's still only one show, and it's not common in most shows. I have shown Roger from American Dad which dwarfs anything you've posted. You have shown zero proof that it's not common and have ignored the fact that a lot of anime characters where the same clothes over and over.
TomDay said: you only showed two examples of hair in that show. Here are more and these go for both clothes and hair.
TomDay said: you only showed 4 examples of that show. 4 is good enough but here is one more anyway
Tomday said: and you only showed one example of these for fashion. all together that tolls as 4 shows and 11 examples, 90% of that going to regular. Those were specifically for hair not clothes although for Archer there were 3 examples of different clothes. Both Regular show and Roger for American Dad completely dwarfed all your examples.
TomDay said: in my example posts, there was least 2 examples per show, and most commonly 5+ per show. altogether those are ten shows chosen on a whim.
again, i'm not dismissing. i'm simply saying that they're not enough when compared to anime. you seem to have me confused when i say this. i'm not saying fashion doesn't exist in cartoons. i'm saying the majority do not have them. Here are more examples.
Far more anime is released on a yearly basis than western cartoons and you have curtailed the amount of examples for cartoons by restricting an entire genre of cartoons (superhero cartoons). You have demonstrated in no way that fashion doesn't exist in cartoons and I have proven you wrong.
[quote=TomDay]and even for those fashion changes, they are still missing a realmism point that anime provides (ON THE NORM. MAYBE CARTOONS DOES THIS BUT NOT A LOT OF THEM).[/quote[ It seems like you are nitpicking here because I proved you wrong.
TomDay said: you can still see the differences of how the clothes are worn. in cartoons the clothes are skin tight, as if the people drew the clothes literally on the characters, as if the the clothes themselves are part of their skin. in anime clothes are drawn with the characters. there are ruffles, actual space for the clothes to breath. it's not just glued and slapped on their bodies. you can actually picture them picking out their clothes and putting them on.
with cartoons they look like they've been tattooed on lol. In my pics there are clear examples of space between clothes and the clothes in your example look tight. By the way I having been showing examples from the actual shows while with your example it seems like promo art since that anime hasn't even been released yet. Clothes in promo art aren't always an accurate depiction of what will be worn in the actual show.
TomDay said: >steven universe does not have lips as prominent as DC/Marvel. Amethyst, Rose Quartz and Garnet have prominent lips.
TomDay said: >again, not going on the CGI track again. both have their fair shares of facial features. You only provided one anime CGI female character with lips and a nose while I showed you multiple examples where those features are missing.
Tomday said: >monster high has girls with tons of makup therefore making lipstick therefore making their lips prominent. anime does that as well so that point isn't so good. same for ever after high. As I told you before a character must have lips in the first place in order to have lipstick on said lips. Anime generally does that sparsely from anime to anime. You might only see like one or two female characters once in a while with lipstick from show to show. In both Monster High and Ever After High ALL the female characters have it. In the anime Gate you have a few that have it and even then sometimes it's just a bottom lip and there are a lot that don't have them.
TomDay said:
...why on earth did you pick a genre dedicated to the sex drive? of course there would be anything like that in there. but with CHILDREN CARTOONS you get half-nude girls. that's the real problem there. DC animated movies are generally for teens and young adults not children and superhero cartoons are generally for all audiences.Only a superhero cartoon like Teen Titans Go would be to mainly targeted to kids. The female characters in all of them are not as exposed as ecchi female anime character.
Tomday said: i said nothing about her and her boobs. You implied by that choosing that figurine as one of your examples.
Tomday said: there is still absolutely 100% no reason to put a boobcrack on a woman who doesn't need it. Tell that to anime where an adult female character who isn't a loli tends to have big boobs and even some young teens in highschool. Hell in Eiken even lolis have huge boobs. DC girls (in the cartoons) never have boobs as ridiculously big as what you get in anime. The boobs in DC cartoons are generally nicely proportionate and perfect. Not too big and not too small.
Tomday said: moreover, you say she doesn't look slutty with boobs showing, but you included this gif which shows no skin at all but you still used that as an example. Powergirl's boobs aren't bouncing up and down, left to right and even though they have some good size aren't as super huge as that anime girl's boobs.
Tomday said: i was joking. exaggerating and joking. My joke detector must be broken. |