Isaac_ said: what the hell? http://myanimelist.net/anime/21/One_Piece/reviews Most of the One Piece reviews are negative. The second highest ranked one even gave it a 4, how come so many people upvoted it? I thought One Piece was generally liked by the community :'( There are a lot of hipsters that want to hate on the series now because it's popular, nothing new. There's also the occasional legitimate review, with fair valid criticism. Instead of nitpicking and a low score without any substantially good reason. |
FullmetalRaikouJul 15, 2015 5:14 PM
 |
Isterio said: Why is Asura an asspull? Comes out of nowhere, can barely be justified even with One Piece logic and just seems like it exists so Zoro could beat Kaku with a "cool" new move since he used everything else in that fight. It's not even an "illusion" thing since he also used it on a Pacifista during two panels of Sabaody(and it never gets brought up again). Diable Jambe is just exaggerated friction and Hell's Memories is 50% gag @ post skip OP discussion most weekly Shonen readers are fickle as hell and hardly even pay attention while reading the series they -do- like, this is nothing new lmao. People will probably complain and shit on the next arc when it'll likely be adventure focused and not "OMG Luffy vs. Big Mom/Kaidou", especially if the antagonist(s) happens to have a goofy ass design like Moria and his gang |
Kaimon said: @ post skip OP discussion most weekly Shonen readers are fickle as hell and hardly even pay attention while reading the series they -do- like, this is nothing new lmao. People will probably complain and shit on the next arc when it'll likely be adventure focused and not "OMG Luffy vs. Big Mom/Kaidou", especially if the antagonist(s) happens to have a goofy ass design like Moria and his gang I'm just waiting for Oda to do Wano Kuni, I have a feeling that arc will get dark or at least more dramatic like Water 7 was. Then all the so called 'fanboys' will come rushing back for the "grimdark 2edgy4me OnePiss-wank". |
|
| Fun read: Zoro and his bandanna. ;D Isterio said: Please explain how are those DEM/asspull. I haven't check yet, but I think you said kamehameha is also a DEM, why? I think you're stretching the term a bit too far.tsudecimo said: Is gear 2nd a DEM/Asspull? Yes but so is Chidori, the end. Agafin said: Haikyuu was cringefest. One of the worst sports anime I've seen recently, and of course, the most overrated one. I liked KnB more, but mainly just for Aomine and first season. Go watch Baby Steps instead.I've just noticed that Haikyuu is (slightly) more popular than KnB in Japan. Do you guys too like Haikyuu more? Isaac_ said: Don't worry, from what I have seen, newer fans love to hate on things, I've seen many anime where older reviews have very high score, and all the newer ones rate about 5-6 only, or even lower. People used to watch anime / read manga because they love it, it wasn't popular back then. Now, everyone watch them because they can.what the hell? http://myanimelist.net/anime/21/One_Piece/reviews Most of the One Piece reviews are negative. The second highest ranked one even gave it a 4, how come so many people upvoted it? I thought One Piece was generally liked by the community :'( Fullmetal89 said: And a lot of those "valid criticism" I see are directed toward certain arcs, especially the more recently ones, which I don't think is fair, given One Piece's length and how small those arcs look in the grand scheme of things. Those arcs should not represent One Piece as a whole in my opinion. If they are doing that, why don't they just write arcs review then. They can start from Baratie, and how "omfg Luffy survived against Krieg asspull!", you know, with how much blood he lost. People don't seem to notice these things in a marathon. It's also stupid to review Naruto based on just the final arc. I know it's long, but that's not Naruto as a whole.There are a lot of hipsters that want to hate on the series now because it's popular, nothing new. There's also the occasional legitimate review, with fair valid criticism. Instead of nitpicking and a low score without any substantially good reason. Edit: What I mean to say is, it is okay to address those flaws, but weave it into the review of the entirety of One Piece up to that certain point, and not pick it out and review it separately. Isterio said: First, spoiler your.. spoiler on the latest chapter. Some people prefer not to know about anything before they actually watch it. So ya.Fujitora Sabo, Zorro they all got teased so long and barely did anything (on screen). As for Fujitora, I am pretty sure he has made Fullmetal89 said: Chances are, we will probably get the next big arc soon with no breather arc. People speculated that maybe the island Kaimon said: @ post skip OP discussion most weekly Shonen readers are fickle as hell and hardly even pay attention while reading the series they -do- like, this is nothing new lmao. People will probably complain and shit on the next arc when it'll likely be adventure focused and not "OMG Luffy vs. Big Mom/Kaidou", especially if the antagonist(s) happens to have a goofy ass design like Moria and his gang I'm just waiting for Oda to do Wano Kuni, I have a feeling that arc will get dark or at least more dramatic like Water 7 was. Then all the so called 'fanboys' will come rushing back for the "grimdark 2edgy4me OnePiss-wank". |
ToG25thBaamJul 15, 2015 9:22 PM
| Honobono Log - best slice of life short -------------------------------------------- most kawaii loli overlord ---------------------------- Donquixote Doflamingo AMV - Control |
| @Isterio Yeah I've noticed that a lot of the newer fans or people who recently caught up tend to not have the patience to deal with One Piece's pacing. @ Tog25thBaam What I meant is that there are some reviews that are well written and bring up some decent criticism beside the usual. This character sucks because I don't like him, or the art sucks etc. I know I'm probably in the minority here but I'm hoping there is a breather arc. The crew needs some downtime. I know Davy Backfight arc isn't one of the most popular but I enjoyed it. I think it was the right thing to do in between Skypiea and CP9. Dressrosa really started with Punk Hazard so it's been one continuous long fight. I'd like to see the crew chill for a few chapters before jumping into another huge fight. |
|
Fullmetal89 said: I know I'm probably in the minority here but I'm hoping there is a breather arc. The crew needs some downtime. I know Davy Backfight arc isn't one of the most popular but I enjoyed it. I think it was the right thing to do in between Skypiea and CP9. Dressrosa really started with Punk Hazard so it's been one continuous long fight. I'd like to see the crew chill for a few chapters before jumping into another huge fight. Well, but even then PH had a lot of crew chill moments. The underwater journey to the surface, arrving at PH, goofing around with Kinemon and switched bodies etc. I thought the first half of PH was very chill and adventurous. Only when they all arrived in the lab, the arc changed to "fight mode". As for the post-skip quality, I just hope Oda is done with building up the minor stuff and now will mostly focus on top players. Less Rikus, Tontattas and Gladiators, more SH's, supernovas, marines, revos, shichibukais, yonkous(but not too much, the "inside stories" with brand new characters are necessery) I'm not too scared about the future of One Piece. There is shitload of great material to work with, and if Oda really wants to finish OP within next 10 years, then he needs to step on the gas. |
 |
8animet said: No I'm with you we need a cool down arc and some nice SH interaction The non stop action since they entered the NW is getting tiresome DBF was ok, it was short and funny Still the non canon G8 filler arc was better as a fun arc between Skypiea and W7 Speaking of G8 filler, regardless of what Oda does in the manga the anime desperately needs a filler. I would prefer a 10-15 episode filler over the pacing we are currently getting. I know some people disagree but this arc is already draggy as it is in the manga. Dahaka_ said: Well, but even then PH had a lot of crew chill moments. The underwater journey to the surface, arrving at PH, goofing around with Kinemon and switched bodies etc. I thought the first half of PH was very chill and adventurous. Only when they all arrived in the lab, the arc changed to "fight mode". As for the post-skip quality, I just hope Oda is done with building up the minor stuff and now will mostly focus on top players. Less Rikus, Tontattas and Gladiators, more SH's, supernovas, marines, revos, shichibukais, yonkous(but not too much, the "inside stories" with brand new characters are necessery) I'm not too scared about the future of One Piece. There is shitload of great material to work with, and if Oda really wants to finish OP within next 10 years, then he needs to step on the gas. Yeah, that's true but what I mean is something of a proper chill arc like DBF. Where it's several chapters of nonsense and Mario Party like fun. Doesn't have to be exactly like DBF obviously, but something in that vein. |
FullmetalRaikouJul 16, 2015 8:17 AM
|
8animet said: FT level? Unless Oda suddenly stops caring that won't happen There are always silly haters but most people still appreciate quality lol ironic considering fair tail has been better than one piece for the last 2 years or so XD I'd take ft over disappointing fights any day. The new bleach fanbook preview gave out the 5th best gotei fight chosen by readers |
 |
JD2411 said: Yes, let's blame the hipsters that only hate on One Piece to be cool and the stupid shounen fanbase instead of being mature enough to accept that some people don't like Post-Timeskip One Piece. Sasuga One Piece fans. The irony is that most of the negative reviews are from former one piece fans or/and people with popular anime on their favorites lol |
 |
| Any shounen is still better than the last 2/3 of hunter x hunter 2021 |
| My top anime quotes 1. I AM JUSTICE!- l/light (Death Note) 2. IT'S OVER 9000!!!!- Vegeta (dbz) 3. Almighty Push!/ Shinra Tensei!- Pain (Naruto Shippuden) 4. We stand in awe before that which cannot be seen- Rukia (Bleach) 5. I'll take a potato chip.....AND EAT IT!!!!!- Light (Death Note) 6. Art is an explosion - Deidara (Naruto) 7. Shut the fuck up Kakazu - Hidan (Naruto) 8. Bulma, you've lost your balls- Goku (dragonball) 9. "Don't call me small! I'll break off your feet and stick em on your head!"- Edward Elric (fmab) |
JD2411 said: ToG25thBaam and Ulysse have a point though. Even though I don't like PTS OP, I won't lower my score by more than a point or two since it's just like 25% of OP so far.Yes, let's blame the hipsters that only hate on One Piece to be cool and the stupid shounen fanbase instead of being mature enough to accept that some people don't like Post-Timeskip One Piece. Sasuga One Piece fans. |
Agafin said: JD2411 said: ToG25thBaam and Ulysse have a point though. Even though I don't like PTS OP, I won't lower my score by more than a point or two since it's just like 25% of OP so far.Yes, let's blame the hipsters that only hate on One Piece to be cool and the stupid shounen fanbase instead of being mature enough to accept that some people don't like Post-Timeskip One Piece. Sasuga One Piece fans. That's what I said too. There are a lot of reviews on that page that gave One Piece 1/10 for ridiculous reasons. Let's not act like all the reviews on MAL are legit when it comes to One Piece because it fits 'my anti-one piece rhetoric.' MAL has a lot of troll reviews for every series, there's just more of them for the popular ones. Same thing that we are seeing with One Piece now, we saw with Naruto during the war arc. It's actually pretty hard to find good partial well written reviews on this site. They are either fanboy babble or random nonsense by some troll just hating on a series because it's popular. |
|
| Surprisingly enough, Naruto Shippuden which seems to receive more hate than One Piece has very positive reviews comparatively. http://myanimelist.net/anime/1735/Naruto:_Shippuuden/reviews |
DarkDawn said: Any shounen is still better than the last 2/3 of hunter x hunter 2021 Your HxH review surprisingly doesn't have insane amount of downvotes. |
|
| @JD http://myanimelist.net/reviews.php?id=157411 Lets start with the story. Story. 2/10. The story is about a boy name luffy that wants to go and reach one piece. Him and his crew member will set sail to go anywhere except one piece. Art. 3/10 The art in one piece is ridiculous stupid looking the characters have weird over exaggerating expression. When they are shouting or just opening their mouth it's so huge it could fit 10 ships in it. Ed edd n eddy has way better art than one piece and that cartoon was made from the 90s that's to show you how bad the art is. Sound. 7/10 the sound is the best thing in the series this is what made me watch made me watch so much episode of one piece is because I enjoy the sound. I also like to laugh at how stupid it's and how stupid the characters look. Characters. 1/10 The characters are cut out cardboard boxes they dont change they are exactly the same and I'm talking from a manga reader the series has over 700+ chapters and all the characters are still the same. Oda doesn't know what character development means. Enjoyment. 5/10. My enjoyment comes from how stupid it's, I lol so much time while watching this series. it even tries to take it self seriously but failed miserable, lol and that made me laugh a lot so I had some enjoyment in it because of how stupid it's but the other 50% of the series is Luffy running up and down like a chicken without a head which is boring.... overall this series is mostly full of gag you should not take it seriously if you do you're only going to be disappointed so the series isn't the worst series I've ever watch. So if you want a series to laugh at, I would 100% recommend one piece to you all. Isn't this a troll review? (granted a hilarious one) |
| http://myanimelist.net/profile/RyuujiXmemories/reviews And what about this. People always told me, ''watch 50 episodes or so and it will be good''. 50 episodes so that its interesting? No, thanks. I will make it short: - Plot is practically not existent. - Nearly every Character is Mentally Challenged. - The animations are Awfull. - It looks bad. - The whole anime is like a big filler arc. If you like all those points and if you can switch your brain completely off, watch it. He's not even trying and there's 136 out of 250 that upvote this. |
 |
| Honestly I have stopped taking seriously the reviews, most are too subjective. However honestly in the last two years I have enjoyed more Fairy Tail despite the many flaws than One Piece. |
tr1ckst3r said: http://myanimelist.net/profile/RyuujiXmemories/reviews And what about this. He's not even trying and there's 136 out of 250 that upvote this. People like upvoting funny reviews, nothing weird about it. |
|
DarkDawn said: Yupp fell off hard after yorknew idk how people say 10/10Any shounen is still better than the last 2/3 of hunter x hunter 2021 |
 |
mochabearbruh said: Because of the ant arc.DarkDawn said: Yupp fell off hard after yorknew idk how people say 10/10Any shounen is still better than the last 2/3 of hunter x hunter 2021 |
| Note that I said He's not even trying? what I'm trying to say is 'some people' will instantly upvote One Piece reviews that rated bad without even reading what is written in it. Isterio said: tr1ckst3r said: He's not even trying and there's 136 out of 250 that upvote this. http://myanimelist.net/profile/holdenn/reviews&p=2 So what this guy gave it a 10/10 and his review is a synopsis of the series and alot of talk Why it´s so great. There is nothing valueable to find here. Well, It's a reviews after all of course he's gonna talk about what's good or bad in a series, and since he rated it 10/10 of course it'll mostly talk about it's good point. |
|
| I've noticed that the best reviews are generally those of unpopular anime. |
| Same goes for the opposite http://myanimelist.net/reviews.php?id=338 You can't tell me that you think this was helpful. |
|
Isterio said: Agafin said: Because of the ant arc. OH Agafin I´d like your opinion on the great conspiracy of Togashi being the hidden writer behind Tokyo Ghoul and how he left a Code for the readers to explain it. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_-EE_ZEWTlc&ab_channel=ChibiReviews He's not serious, he's just making it for the views. Both authors and their works are light years apart. |
Isaac_ said: what the hell? http://myanimelist.net/anime/21/One_Piece/reviews Most of the One Piece reviews are negative. The second highest ranked one even gave it a 4, how come so many people upvoted it? I thought One Piece was generally liked by the community :'( It is certainly weird. Most of the reviews on the following pages are the typical 9/10s and 10/10s. It looks like they just collected pretty much all of the negative reviews for the front page, even those from previous years. Anyway, it's natural that the popularity would bring a fair bit of those who dislike it and haters. There are some that came to watch it while disliking other shounen, some take issue with the nature of the series itself, and there are a few haters pretending to have watched it all the way. Of course I can't say that for sure, but watching 630+ episodes of a series you rate 1/10 is very suspicious. |
| "Let Justice Be Done!" My Theme Fight again, fight again for justice! |
Isterio said: tr1ckst3r said: Well, It's a reviews after all of course he's gonna talk about what's good or bad in a series, and since he rated it 10/10 of course it'll mostly talk about it's good point. Oh the hypocrisy. It´s an evil when someone says anything negative about One Piece and totally unfair, but when someone rates it flawless it´s completely legit, and justfied right? Do you even read your shit before you post it? Do you? since I don't really get what 're you talking about. I never said that bad reviews about One Piece is no-no while the good is always a welcome. What I'm trying to say is whether it's good or bad, at least put some proper thought and reasoning in the reviews and not just "looks bad, I don't like it hence 1/10. done". |
|
tr1ckst3r said: Note that I said He's not even trying? what I'm trying to say is 'some people' will instantly upvote One Piece reviews that rated bad without even reading what is written in it. I suspect there are some of them in this very thread. Seriously though, I've noticed that some otherwise critical people extend a lot of hate when it comes to series that are too popular in their eyes. Vocal minortites aside, it's still doing great. It is still the #4 favourite anime on the site despite all the complaints and #2 favourite manga. Luffy is still 3rd favourite character despite Death Note and Code Geass having many more members (nearly 150% in comparison for CG and 200% for Death Note), and Zoro is also there. And Oda is still the #1 favourite shounen mangaka on the site. Both still have pretty good scores considering the 1/5th rule is not yet in play for them, and they have a high number of people who dropped them and gave very negative scores. I don't think the haters are even enough to prevent it from being in the Top 10 after it finishes airing (being modest with the position there), although some are pretty dedicated. |
RedRoseFringJul 16, 2015 12:29 PM
| "Let Justice Be Done!" My Theme Fight again, fight again for justice! |
| Just throwing a glance at some review pages, I'd say it's mostly with FMAB, LOGH and HxH 2011 that positive reviews are insta upvoted. One Piece is a bit weird, unlike all the other anime reviews page, One Piece's has an overabundance of recent reviews. |
| Basically - filler, dbz with swords, no character development or characterization (lol), fillers, music is good but I'll give it bad score anyways, no plot (what does this mean?) fillers http://myanimelist.net/anime/269/Bleach/reviews |
|
| I've tried watching both Bleach and Naruto and gradually lost interest in both of them. I've considered giving Bleach another shot. The only one I haven't attempted to watch yet is One Piece. The only problem I have with these sorts of shows is their length and their potential for too many off-shoots and being dragged out longer than the story necessitates simply because they are hugely popular. Still, One Piece looks like a lot of fun and I'm interested in giving it a go. And the entire concept behind Bleach keeps me intrigued enough that I want to go back and try watching it again. Naruto is meh, in my opinion. |
| "I love a woman who can kick my ass." -Spike Spiegel |
Isterio said: Agafin said: Because of the ant arc. OH Agafin I´d like your opinion on the great conspiracy of Togashi being the hidden writer behind Tokyo Ghoul and how he left a Code for the readers to explain it. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_-EE_ZEWTlc&ab_channel=ChibiReviews TG's author is 29 years old, has like 4 or 5 assistants and was previously a tattoo artist. They're not the same person and besides Togashi never had any assistants. Agafin is correct. He's just doing it for the views. |
a-rootin-tootin said: I've tried watching both Bleach and Naruto and gradually lost interest in both of them. I've considered giving Bleach another shot. The only one I haven't attempted to watch yet is One Piece. The only problem I have with these sorts of shows is their length and their potential for too many off-shoots and being dragged out longer than the story necessitates simply because they are hugely popular. Still, One Piece looks like a lot of fun and I'm interested in giving it a go. And the entire concept behind Bleach keeps me intrigued enough that I want to go back and try watching it again. Naruto is meh, in my opinion. lel I can't even pass the first two episodes of Bleach. Anyway, I see you haven't touched Hunter x Hunter? Wut? Give it a go, you have Brotherhood on your fav.. |
| Well the beginning of Bleach is quite dull, up until soul society is introduced. I think the only battle anime that is good from the start or at least easy to get into from the beginning is Naruto, Nanatsu no Taizai, HxH and Soul eater. |
|
a-rootin-tootin said: I've tried watching both Bleach and Naruto and gradually lost interest in both of them. I've considered giving Bleach another shot. The only one I haven't attempted to watch yet is One Piece. The only problem I have with these sorts of shows is their length and their potential for too many off-shoots and being dragged out longer than the story necessitates simply because they are hugely popular. Still, One Piece looks like a lot of fun and I'm interested in giving it a go. And the entire concept behind Bleach keeps me intrigued enough that I want to go back and try watching it again. Naruto is meh, in my opinion. Definitely give it a go if you are looking for fun and also dem feels. Naruto & Bleach are easy to get into, so if you didn't like them you may not like other shounen. HxH and KHR are especially harder to get into. Both have some of the slowest starts I've seen in anime. |
| "Let Justice Be Done!" My Theme Fight again, fight again for justice! |
tsudecimo said: Well the beginning of Bleach is quite dull, up until soul society is introduced. I think the only battle anime that is good from the start or at least easy to get into from the beginning is Naruto, Nanatsu no Taizai, HxH and Soul eater. Yea unfortunately that particular arc is the only good thing I heard about Bleach, but I'll get to it eventually when I have the motivation. Also I'd add Jojo and probabaly Beelzebub to the list of battle anime that easy to get into. |
More topics from this board
» Anime fans ,how do u feel about slice of life anime???Animystics - Yesterday |
38 |
by Hitotsuhan
»»
2 minutes ago |
|
» Could you survive in the world of your favorite anime?Spunkert - 4 minutes ago |
1 |
by Serafos
»»
3 minutes ago |
|
» Who here has a more Unconventional first ever anime?TheBlockernator - Yesterday |
35 |
by Hitotsuhan
»»
19 minutes ago |
|
» Which is the correct anime consumption posture?SgtBateMan - Yesterday |
16 |
by BigBoyAdvance
»»
49 minutes ago |
|
» Why do you think about Orihime from Bleach?isolated-otaku - Yesterday |
29 |
by BigBoyAdvance
»»
52 minutes ago |