New
This topic has been locked and is no longer available for discussion.
Apr 13, 2020 5:02 AM
#251
Apr 13, 2020 5:03 AM
#252
Part of me regrets making this thread, since it has been constant back and forth between both sides of the argument, which I thought would stop sometime soon but I don't think it will anytime soon. It's like two unmovable rocks trying to push the other one over, it's never going to end. |
Apr 13, 2020 5:04 AM
#253
flowstate said: I've had friend's girlfriends come crying to me because their boyfriends want anime characters that look nothing like their mates and don't give them attention. Wait, what? What does this even mean? Who wants who? I'm so confused by this statement |
Apr 13, 2020 5:05 AM
#254
This character development has been amazing, by the way, for those of you who haven't kept up. We went from attempting to sound knowledgeable and considerate, as if he's fighting for the greater good, for the healthy development of society as a whole: flowstate said: S_Smnt said: flowstate said: Ecchi ruins the industry. It pollutes otherwise often life-changing, inspiring, emotional stories that can impact a more broad range of people in the world if only it didn't go so deep down this tasteless hole. Because of this and this only, watching anime often communicates undertones of pervy, misunderstanding to outsiders and only further perpetuates the NEET stereotype. Otherwise, people would just think "oh, there's another person who appreciates 2d artwork and the story telling that goes along with it". However, you and I know that that's not the case. Instead, people who watch anime from the scope of the outside observer are riddled with a myriad of disheartening stereotypes, ruining the chance of a widespread appeal of such a fascinating, important and impactful medium that has the power to change lives. ...and don't get me started with hentai. Ecchi does not ruin the industry. Let's say an anime has ecchi elements and "life-changing, inspiring, emotional stories" as its components. Since people can have a huge variety of opinions in regards to those two components and in regards to their correlation you will have people who disliked both elements in various degrees (and either thought one element had impacted the other in various degrees or not), people who liked both elements in various degrees (and either thought one element had impacted the other in various degrees or not), people who liked one element and disliked the other in various degrees along with their opinion on the relative impact of the elements on each other and so on. Then there are people who became interested in the anime for either of the elements or both, also people who didn't get into the show due to either or both elements. Now why, for the sake of providing convenience to some of these groups, should the anime have discarded one of the elements when some other groups would have been affected by the decision? If you think it would affect the show economically, then you have to provide appropriate statistics to back that up and even if it does, it's solely the decision of the creators to more cater towards a specific group regardless of what would happen to the widespread appeal. If widespread appeal was the sole reason for a show to achieve, the I suppose "Tatami Galaxy", "Ping Pong the Animation" etc would have chosen widely accessible aesthetics. Now as for your second point, do the outsiders not get that an average person has sexual attraction as a basic biological feature? And where are they getting the "NEET" stereotype from? Since anime is now spread worldwide, you have to have a widespread statistical study to show what proportion of the anime fans or rather "ecchi consumers" are NEET. If someone bases an assumption without any of these, then why would anyone have to respect their opinion? And apparently people with normal sexual function can't appreciate 2d artwork and story-telling? If someone watches one or two movies, dislikes some tropes in them and thinks they won't find anything more suitable to their taste, I think they have no business in trying to find "life changing, impactful" stuff in that medium, especially if they think those also have to have nothing that they don't relate to. Same with anime or manga. If you want something that personally impacts you, you have to search for it, not expect it would be easy or that it wouldn't have anything to your disliking. If you find something and don't like some parts of it, search harder until you find what you want without begrudging others just because they appreciate different things. I'm sorry to break it to you, but I'll just ease you into this one. Let's use an example for you. Let's take an insanely popular and influential film. Let's say... Disney's Frozen. This deals with themes of self acceptance and is admired by millions of people. Now imagine this film with random panty shots. Imagine when she's singing and isolated, that it cuts to a pair of bouncing tits just because the director felt like it was a good look. Now, no matter what your opinion is, the actual fact of the matter is that after the first showing of that film, it would be labeled as tasteless garbage, it would have made the news, and Disney+ subscriptions everywhere would be dropped because people wouldn't want to support such vile trash that their families were subjected to. These decisions have the power to shape an industry into something else entirely, regardless of who found it interesting or enjoyable in the long run. It's important to inspire the youth of the world, because the youth of the world will become the next generation to run the world. You know this. Now, the youth becomes confused. The youth just coming into their sexuality at 13, 14, 15 and so on watches the film and their raging hormones cause them to focus on the first pair of panties they've ever seen in their lives, albeit digital, and not only do they miss the entire main themes of the film, they go on a fap fest to screenshots of their first exposure to what is deemed appealing to their animalistic brain. Of course you're welcome to your opinion in your own little world, and of course what you do in your life affects no one else's lives (plot twist, it does), but people need to care about this. This is what I mean when I say it ruins an industry and the impact that it can have on it's viewers. It's simple math. Take an impactful story and spread it out to as many people as possible for maximum impact. Any creator dreams of this. What on earth does expression of a different aesthetic or art style (e.g. Ping Pong the Animation) have to do with this conversation at all? That's like discrediting someone who chose acrylic over graphite. It's expression. You're missing the point. If you really think a study is necessary to help determine what type of people get off to ecchi, you don't understand the power of marketing psychology. I mean, the most popular version of anime that incorporates this is harems, and look at the dynamic that is based around. It is mostly for dudes with low self esteem who wish they could muster up the courage to put one syllable together in the direction of a female, but would rather up caving to their fears, never taking a risk and living it all from behind a screen in some fantasy where 9 different women all want them. If that doesn't tell you SOMETHING about the type of person who is into this, based solely on who it's marketed to, then you need some more critical thinking in your life. How many self proclaimed NEETs have you seen on MAL? I've seen too many. Posted in their profiles like some badge of honor. First of all, you're a detriment to society if you are this type of individual. You're squandering your existence and lessening the impact of your one and only life to cater to an impulsive life filled with a lack of self control, lack of ambition and no positive impact on anyone or anything around you indefinitely if this is a life that you chose. It is EVERYWHERE. I don't even have to explain myself. Look at how many profiles on here watch harems until the cows come home and look at how many of them have like 400/500+ DAYS of anime watching. Society is the sum of its parts. If the parts are diluted and confused, so is the whole. This is why it's ruining the industry. To caps locking and ad homming people after people didn't buy into his "think of the children" rhetoric and him accidentally outing himself as not actually upholding the values he claims to hold: flowstate said: LMAO, WATCHING ANIME DOESN'T MAKE ANYONE A LOSER. How dense do you have to be to not understand my point, here? In VERY SIMPLE TERMS: Anime has a bad rep. The bad rep is perpetuated by what I consider to be the worst parts of the industry, ecchi and hentai. To just spamming shrug emotes: I rest my case. This person can't deal with opposition to his values healthily and isn't credible, even for his own claims. A childish reaction like this should signify mental immaturity more than anything. The irony of the situation shouldn't be lost on anybody. |
ManabanApr 13, 2020 5:09 AM
Apr 13, 2020 5:08 AM
#255
Why would you want anime to become mainstream? That's what making it worse and more sanitized. |
Apr 13, 2020 5:09 AM
#256
Kami_sama_ said: I wouldn't mind if you listed some, I am not one who really likes wholesome anime that has a women demographic. Clannad, Little Busters, Hinamatsuri, Kemono Erin are a few that come to mind. Most everything on my completed list rated 7 or above is wholesome, and probably contains some inspirational messages. That's my preference after all and I've had no trouble finding shows that appeal to it. Then again if you're determined to be narrow minded I am sure you will find something objectionable about them. |
Apr 13, 2020 5:11 AM
#257
Kami_sama_ said: Part of me regrets making this thread, since it has been constant back and forth between both sides of the argument, which I thought would stop sometime soon but I don't think it will anytime soon. It's like two unmovable rocks trying to push the other one over, it's never going to end. You had good intentions. Bringing up your chosen topic on MAL is unfortunately... an uphill battle, due to the numbers. I've only recently decided to take to forums here but am quickly realizing the futility of doing so with highly controversial topics. This futility points to the psychological term "ego-investment", which essentially points to someone internalizing a belief to a point where it is integrated into their personality. Hopefully at least one quiet person had the awareness to consider a couple statements made and can use that to influence the beliefs that guide their decisions. |
Apr 13, 2020 5:15 AM
#258
Kami_sama_ said: epidemia78 said: Kami_sama_ said: I am not saying that Anime should be exactly like Frozen, I don't even think it is a good movie, but it has positive effects on society. Imagine if anime had positive representation like that. I could show it to my younger cousins and they would love it just the same, thereby creating Anime as a source of more good and not only for wish-fullfillment like it is used most of the time. Even though it's part of the same media industry that produced Frozen you're not gonna show Game of Thrones to your 7 year old cousins, are you? There's plenty of wholesome anime without ecchi. If you think otherwise then you're not looking hard enough. I wouldn't mind if you listed some, I am not one who really likes wholesome anime that has a women demographic. The films of Hayao Miyazaki:Spirited away, future boy Conan, porco Rossi, kiki's delivery service, ponyo etc Mamoru Hosoda films:boy and the beast, Mirai of the future, summer wars etc Masaaki Yuasa:eizouken,ride your wave, lu over the wall (avoid devil man crybaby and some of his older works if you dislike nudity) Isao Takahata:only yesterday, maybe Princess kaguya and grave of the fireflies the latter two get into some dark and deep subject matters so avoid them with younger ones Most sports and slice of life shows are okay territory just be vigilante and ask people before watching lest you end up with something like Keijo😅 If you have anything against violence, you should probably skip most action shonen shows or at least ask before hand. While shonen means boys, more often than not, they may show a level of violence you may not be comfortable with e.g Kimetsu no Yaiba shows dead bodies, blood and flying limbs and heads on a regular basis These are just the ones from the top of my head, if you want to know some more wholesome anime there are a lot of recommendation forums around. The key in finding wholesome anime is to ask. Hope this was helpful |
AbrahamOmosunApr 13, 2020 5:25 AM
Apr 13, 2020 5:16 AM
#259
flowstate said: You had good intentions. Bringing up your chosen topic on MAL is unfortunately... an uphill battle, due to the numbers. I've only recently decided to take to forums here but am quickly realizing the futility of doing so with highly controversial topics. I mean, it's just as simple as not making up people's lifestyles for them and trying to tell them they're a parasitic entity because they're not watching entertainment that promotes the healthy development of children. I don't think you really have much perspective on the issues you're trying to make here and how you're presenting yourself in response to them being pointed out. Trying to just blame everybody around you while simultaneously patting yourself on the back as being right about everybody reeks of denial. flowstate said: Hopefully at least one quiet person had the awareness to consider a couple statements made and can use that to influence the beliefs that guide their decisions. Oh right, another cheap appeal, by the way. "I'm right. Hopefully somebody smart enough out there believes me and ignores my general actions and behavior and how I've been conducting myself this whole time!" Riiiight. You're totally not trying to pander people into agreeing with you at all by attempting to present yourself as misunderstood by an unfair social circle, and that only other people capable of comprehending the complexity/reality of what you had to say are smart enough to follow in your footsteps. I am, yeah. Degrading yourselves from attempting to provide dignified responses earlier in the thread to just throwing tantrums is pretty much proving my point. |
Apr 13, 2020 5:23 AM
#260
AbrahamOmosun said: Kami_sama_ said: epidemia78 said: Kami_sama_ said: I am not saying that Anime should be exactly like Frozen, I don't even think it is a good movie, but it has positive effects on society. Imagine if anime had positive representation like that. I could show it to my younger cousins and they would love it just the same, thereby creating Anime as a source of more good and not only for wish-fullfillment like it is used most of the time. Even though it's part of the same media industry that produced Frozen you're not gonna show Game of Thrones to your 7 year old cousins, are you? There's plenty of wholesome anime without ecchi. If you think otherwise then you're not looking hard enough. I wouldn't mind if you listed some, I am not one who really likes wholesome anime that has a women demographic. The films of Hayao Miyazaki:Spirited away, future boy Conan, porco Rossi, kiki's delivery service, ponyo etc Mamoru Hosoda films:boy and the beast, Mirai of the future, summer wars etc Masaaki Yuasa:eizouken,ride your wave, lu over the wall (avoid devil man crybaby and some of his older works if you dislike nudity) Isao Takahata:only yesterday, maybe Princess kaguya and grave of the fireflies the latter two get into some dark and deep subject matters so avoid them with younger ones These are just the ones from the top of my head, if you want to know some more wholesome anime there are a lot of recommendation forums around Spirited Away was the first anime I ever saw, so I absolutely agree with that. I really admire Miyazaki for not incorporating lewd content in his movies. I find everything about Spirited Away to be perfect, I think I even tried recommend it to my cousins before, but their parents didn't allow it because they thought it was a bit too mystical for their children to watch (they are hard C Christians). |
Apr 13, 2020 5:28 AM
#261
Kami_sama_ said: Part of me regrets making this thread, since it has been constant back and forth between both sides of the argument, which I thought would stop sometime soon but I don't think it will anytime soon. It's like two unmovable rocks trying to push the other one over, it's never going to end. all I've taken from this thread is that people must be suffering from cabin fever. god forbid they're this hostile irl |
Apr 13, 2020 5:31 AM
#262
Kami_sama_ said: Spirited Away was the first anime I ever saw, so I absolutely agree with that. I really admire Miyazaki for not incorporating lewd content in his movies. I find everything about Spirited Away to be perfect, I think I even tried recommend it to my cousins before, but their parents didn't allow it because they thought it was a bit too mystical for their children to watch (they are hard C Christians). Chihiro of spirited away is an isekai self-insert therefore, degenerate. The movie also depicts romantic feelings between her and Hako, therefore it is sexual in nature. |
Apr 13, 2020 5:34 AM
#263
I may not be the biggest ecchi fan, but I will defend the right for it to exist. |
Apr 13, 2020 5:35 AM
#264
epidemia78 said: Kami_sama_ said: Spirited Away was the first anime I ever saw, so I absolutely agree with that. I really admire Miyazaki for not incorporating lewd content in his movies. I find everything about Spirited Away to be perfect, I think I even tried recommend it to my cousins before, but their parents didn't allow it because they thought it was a bit too mystical for their children to watch (they are hard C Christians). Chihiro of spirited away is an iskeai self-insert therefore, degenerate. The movie also depicts romantic feelings between her and Hako, therefore it is sexual in nature. I mean, I don't think you need to try that hard, considering some of the incredible ideas he had earlier in the thread. Kami_sama_ said: NeoAnkara said: I don't get what you are referring to, look at any seasonal list on MAL and you will see that at least half of the shows are sexual in nature, whether it be an isekai, a harem.Kayle_x_Morgana said: NeoAnkara said: Here we go again with the myth that sex=sells. You being serious or trolling?.... MAL didn't track sales again because of the rule on Oricon side but as far as I follow with their coverage on sales thread only handful of series can be considered of hit. And surely that also apply to other genre where every now and then you find a breakout hit. Even look at your signature, that picture in your signature clearly displays a harem show, e.g. there is one person who resembles a guy in a crowd of feminine characters. While you might say that you don't like the show purely based on the harem, you clearly liked the fact that the show has many cute girls. Thinking someone is cute = some kind of attraction to said person/character = an appeal to your sexual desire, even if in a minor way. Therefore, even sexual attraction, essentially sex, plays a huge part in how you watch anime. Pullman summed up the issue with it really nicely: Pullman said: lmao, that's some of the funniest mental gymnastics I've seen in a while. Guy realizes that his claim is bullshit and there are not many ecchi and harem shows per season and most of them don't sell at all so all of a sudden he invents a new definition of sexuality that can include literally anything as soon as it has characters that aren't ugly as fuck. Do you know how many people find AoT characters attractive? Does that mean AoT is part of your 'ecchi culture' and 'essentially sex plays a huge part in why people watch it'? That's how your desperate mental gymnastics trying to sell us any show with cute girls as 'ecchi culture' sounds like. Ecchi is at this point just a niche genre for a relativel small group of hardcore fans in Japan and it will continue to exist like this, without being nearly as popular or dominant as it was 10 years ago. If people are prudes and oversensitive to sexuality to the point where even a cute design is too sexually charged for them, that's their problem. That's not reasonable on their part. ---- Ericonator said: I may not be the biggest ecchi fan, but I will defend the right for it to exist. I mean, it's not even just the content we're talking about here, it's the fandom itself :> These people have not shied away from their desire to purge at all. |
ManabanApr 13, 2020 5:43 AM
Apr 13, 2020 5:40 AM
#265
Manaban said: I mean, I don't think you need to try that hard, considering some of the incredible ideas he had earlier in the thread. If you judge Spirited Away by his standards its practically hardcore porn and should not be allowed by a decent society. |
Apr 13, 2020 5:42 AM
#266
epidemia78 said: Manaban said: I mean, I don't think you need to try that hard, considering some of the incredible ideas he had earlier in the thread. If you judge Spirited Away by his standards its practically hardcore porn and should not be allowed by a decent society. Like Pullman brought up, every anime that doesn't have intentionally ugly characters is. At least according to the arguments he tried making earlier. We have devolved into this point, where we're actually entertaining ideas this ridiculous from two people who are responding to opposition to "not wanting to purge people from the fandom for liking ecchi" via tantrum and spam. |
ManabanApr 13, 2020 5:46 AM
Apr 13, 2020 5:59 AM
#267
epidemia78 said: Kami_sama_ said: Spirited Away was the first anime I ever saw, so I absolutely agree with that. I really admire Miyazaki for not incorporating lewd content in his movies. I find everything about Spirited Away to be perfect, I think I even tried recommend it to my cousins before, but their parents didn't allow it because they thought it was a bit too mystical for their children to watch (they are hard C Christians). Chihiro of spirited away is an isekai self-insert therefore, degenerate. The movie also depicts romantic feelings between her and Hako, therefore it is sexual in nature. There are major differences in intentions between a harem anime, where the creator creates a man to be the object of affection for over four women of which I used as an example before, and Spirited Away, an anime about a character maturing emotionally from an self-absorbed brat. Why it might seem likely from a surface level observation that Spirited Away is an Isekai, normal isekai's place a character in a world distant from reality, where the laws of our world don't apply. While Spirited Away is based on the Shinto religion of Japan, so the place that Chihiro is sent to is their reality, it is the 'Plain of High Heaven'. It is a location within the Shinto mythology where all the Kami live. Chihiro passes into the Plain of High Heaven because she enters through a Torii, which is a Shinto gate that symbolizes the transition of the mundane to the divine. There are many other Shinto references in the film but I just wanted to point out that this is no Isekai, because in Japan it is a religion, therefore based in our current reality. Miyazaki didn't create Chihiro to be a object of the male affection like most Isekai's treat women. For instance, at the start of the movie Chihiro is an ignorant character that only cares about superficial things, so Miyazaki uses her as a self-insert of the viewer as they are only focused on superficial things. This is done because Spirited Away was used by Miyazaki as a hit-piece on industrialized Japan, and how they do not care for anything other than their superficial needs. Now onto her relationship with Haku. Miyazaki uses our self insertion of Chihiro and her relationship with Haku as a metaphor that people need to reconnect with nature and the supernatural, returning to a time of innocence like when we were younger, like she does when she remembers who Haku was from when she was younger and innocent to the superficiality of the world. You see Miyazaki created Spirited Away to be a metaphor for a current society, which was not sexual in nature. It is not a harem anime that was created for no other reason than to intrigue the sexual desire within it's viewers, whether they be male or female. Thank you for listening to my Ted Talk about Spirited Away. |
removed-userApr 13, 2020 6:06 AM
Apr 13, 2020 6:04 AM
#268
Kami_sama_ said: There are major differences in intentions between a harem anime, where the creator creates a man to be the object of affection for over four women of which I used as an example before, and Spirited Away, an anime about a character maturing emotionally from an self-absorbed brat. Remember, though - while harems were relevant to the signature you responding to, your stated logic was this. Thinking someone is cute = some kind of attraction to said person/character = an appeal to your sexual desire, even if in a minor way. Therefore, even sexual attraction, essentially sex, plays a huge part in how you watch anime. This isn't at all inherent to harem anime and can easily be applied to shows like Spirited Away. You didn't even word it as such, it's a matter of whether or not you find the character cute. That's it. |
Apr 13, 2020 6:14 AM
#269
Kami_sama_ said: epidemia78 said: Kami_sama_ said: Spirited Away was the first anime I ever saw, so I absolutely agree with that. I really admire Miyazaki for not incorporating lewd content in his movies. I find everything about Spirited Away to be perfect, I think I even tried recommend it to my cousins before, but their parents didn't allow it because they thought it was a bit too mystical for their children to watch (they are hard C Christians). Chihiro of spirited away is an isekai self-insert therefore, degenerate. The movie also depicts romantic feelings between her and Hako, therefore it is sexual in nature. There are major differences in intentions between a harem anime, where the creator creates a man to be the object of affection for over four women of which I used as an example before, and Spirited Away, an anime about a character maturing emotionally from an self-absorbed brat. Why it might seem likely from a surface level observation that Spirited Away is an Isekai, normal isekai's place a character in a world distant from reality, where the laws of our world don't apply. While Spirited Away is based on the Shinto religion of Japan, so the place that Chihiro is sent to is their reality, it is the 'Plain of High Heaven'. It is a location within the Shinto mythology where all the Kami live. Chihiro passes into the Plain of High Heaven because she enters through a Torii, which is a Shinto gate that symbolizes the transition of the mundane to the divine. There are many other Shinto references in the film but I just wanted to point out that this is no Isekai, because in Japan it is a religion, therefore based in our current reality. Miyazaki didn't create Chihiro to be a object of the male affection like most Isekai's treat women. For instance, at the start of the movie Chihiro is an ignorant character that only cares about superficial things, so Miyazaki uses her as a self-insert of the viewer as they are only focused on superficial things. This is done because Spirited Away was used by Miyazaki as a hit-piece on industrialized Japan, and how they do not care for anything other than their superficial needs. Now onto her relationship with Haku. Miyazaki uses our self insertion of Chihiro and her relationship with Haku as a metaphor that people need to reconnect with nature and the supernatural, returning to a time of innocence like when we were younger, like she does when she remembers who Haku was from when she was younger and innocent to the superficiality of the world. You see Miyazaki created Spirited Away to be a metaphor for a current society, which was not sexual in nature. It is not a harem anime that was created for no other reason than to intrigue the sexual desire within it's viewers, whether they be male or female. Thank you for listening to my Ted Talk about Spirited Away. Many of Miyazaki's films portray an innocent romance between a young boy and girl and that is a huge factor in their appeal. The girl is always more interesting than the boy, and we root for him to win her over. It would be very disappointing if they didnt end up together at the end, wouldn't it? Those harem animes you hate so much play in the same ballpark. A story about a young guy and his first experiences with love. Harems are almost never about sex, even the ones that have ecchi content. They're about love. |
Apr 13, 2020 6:19 AM
#270
Manaban said: Kami_sama_ said: There are major differences in intentions between a harem anime, where the creator creates a man to be the object of affection for over four women of which I used as an example before, and Spirited Away, an anime about a character maturing emotionally from an self-absorbed brat. Remember, though - while harems were relevant to the signature you responding to, your stated logic was this. Thinking someone is cute = some kind of attraction to said person/character = an appeal to your sexual desire, even if in a minor way. Therefore, even sexual attraction, essentially sex, plays a huge part in how you watch anime. This isn't at all inherent to harem anime and can easily be applied to shows like Spirited Away. You didn't even word it as such, it's a matter of whether or not you find the character cute. That's it. Of course you can apply it to anything, but the point of Spirited Away isn't about cute young girls, like the harem of which I was referring to. The whole point of a harem is the self insertion of the main character, so the creator then creates a whole variety of girls of which he assumes you are going to find cute. Miyazaki created Chihiro not with the intention of creating a cute character that we were 'going to find cute' but for a greater meaning. Now onto my controversial statement. Sexual desire is also known as Libido, this libido is influenced by biological, psychological, and social factors. Biologically, the sex hormones and associated neurotransmitters that act upon the nucleus accumbens regulate libido in humans. So when you look at a character that is cute these neurotransmitters go off and the thought process is what I stated before. You think someone is cute = you gain some kind of attraction to said person/character = an appeal to your libido, even if in a minor way. As humans we don't want to admit that this is the case, but down to a neural level our capacity to find something cute is connected to our libido system. So if an animator creates a character specifically to be cute, it is an appeal to our libido system, thereby our sexual desire. |
Apr 13, 2020 6:23 AM
#271
Kami_sama_ said: Of course you can apply it to anything, but the point of Spirited Away isn't about cute young girls, like the harem of which I was referring to. Iunno, man. You stopped pretty decisively at "You find it cute, you want to fuck it. Sex is a part of how you want anime." I feel like the protag of SA can be easily interpreted as cute by a lot of people. There's no need for a long-winded bit about how sexual attraction works whenever you're still reaching the ultimate conclusion of "cute = sex appeal = sex is a part of your experience." SA has cute, young girls. It's a part of your boundaries you set up. It can be a part of what you're trying to deride and prevent. Therefore, it is. It falls into the boundaries. Spirited Away contributes to Ecchi Culture. I do think most sane people don't watch SA in a way that's sexually charged, mind you, but you didn't talk about finding a character cute in the way of authorial intent. You were basing it on audience experience, and perceived cuteness by the audience is what mattered to you when you made that statement. Full stop. Your explanation here regarding how it functions reinforces that. Authorial intent be damned, and that's what led to the argument regarding people finding AoT characters cute and you accusing that of contributing to ecchi culture. It's about "Do you find this girl cute?" These are goalposts. You have established the boundaries. Don't move them to suit your needs. |
ManabanApr 13, 2020 6:32 AM
Apr 13, 2020 6:35 AM
#272
Manaban said: Kami_sama_ said: Of course you can apply it to anything, but the point of Spirited Away isn't about cute young girls, like the harem of which I was referring to. Iunno, man. You stopped pretty decisively at "You find it cute, you want to fuck it. Sex is a part of how you want anime." I feel like the protag of SA can be easily interpreted as cute by a lot of people. There's no need for a long-winded bit about how sexual attraction works whenever you're still reaching the ultimate conclusion of "cute = sex appeal = sex is a part of your experience." SA has cute, young girls. It's a part of your boundaries you set up. It can be a part of what you're trying to deride and prevent. Therefore, it is. It falls into the boundaries. Spirited Away contributes to Ecchi Culture. I do think most sane people don't watch SA in a way that's sexually charged, mind you, but you didn't talk about finding a character cute in the way of authorial intent. You were basing it on audience experience, and perceived cuteness by the audience is what mattered to you when you made that statement. Full stop. Your explanation here reinforces that. Authorial intent be damned, and that's what led to the argument regarding people finding AoT characters cute and you accusing that of contributing to ecchi culture. These are goalposts. You have established the boundaries. Don't move them to suit your needs. You seem so adamant to destroy my arguments to fit your opinion. I did set my goalposts, you can see it in the statement here: Thinking someone is cute = some kind of attraction to said person/character = an appeal to your sexual desire, even if in a minor way. Therefore, even sexual attraction, essentially sex, plays a huge part in how you watch anime. You're assuming that I mean't "You find it cute, you want to fuck it. Sex is a part of how you want anime.". But if you read my previous ted talk at all before you collected the parts that fit your agenda you would understand that it is not what I was referring to. But anyway it doesn't matter what we feel we believe, internally and neurally we function differently, e.g. the libido system I just explained. Someone can say that they love the taste of alcohol as much as they want, but the thing that is bringing them back time and time again is how it flows through their bloodstream. |
Apr 13, 2020 6:39 AM
#273
Kami_sama_ said: You seem so adamant to destroy my arguments to fit your opinion. I did set my goalposts, you can see it in the statement here: Of course you can apply it to anything, but the point of Spirited Away isn't about cute young girls, like the harem of which I was referring to. Yeah, no shit, that's why I accused you of doing so. You're trying to shift it from audience perception to authorial intent to suit your needs, and then going on irrelevant ramblings about how it functions to try to distract from that fact. The cute = sex appeal argument you made earlier was entirely centered around audience perception in terms of finding a character cute. Authorial intent is being added to the equation when it suits you, even when a series meets the checklists you're providing of having "cute, young girls." That's why it's moving the goalposts. So, again. Spirited Away contributes to Ecchi Culture. It has girls the audience can find cute, and that makes sex a part of their experience. |
Apr 13, 2020 6:42 AM
#274
Manaban said: Kami_sama_ said: You seem so adamant to destroy my arguments to fit your opinion. I did set my goalposts, you can see it in the statement here: Of course you can apply it to anything, but the point of Spirited Away isn't about cute young girls, like the harem of which I was referring to. Yeah, no shit, that's why I accused you of doing so. You're trying to shift it from audience perception to authorial intent to suit your needs, and then going on irrelevant ramblings about how it functions to try to distract from that fact. The cute = sex appeal argument you made earlier was entirely centered around audience perception in terms of finding a character cute. Authorial intent is being added to the equation when it suits you, even when a series meets the checklists you're providing of having "cute, young girls." That's why it's moving the goalposts. So, again. Spirited Away contributes to Ecchi Culture. You might want to look up, that statement is not the statement I was referring to, I don't know why you did it, but you wanted to edit my argument to fit your opinion. This is what I said: Kami_sama_ said: You seem so adamant to destroy my arguments to fit your opinion. I did set my goalposts, you can see it in the statement here: Thinking someone is cute = some kind of attraction to said person/character = an appeal to your sexual desire, even if in a minor way. Therefore, even sexual attraction, essentially sex, plays a huge part in how you watch anime. |
Apr 13, 2020 6:44 AM
#275
Kami_sama_ said: You might want to look up, that statement is not the statement I was referring to, I don't know why you did it, but you wanted to edit my argument to fit your opinion. That's what you had it as being at first. That's how it appeared to me on the quote and what was there when I quoted it to respond. But either way, yes. You're saying that you find it cute, so that ties into your libido and that makes sex a part of how you watch anime. Now that I look at it again, what's it even change about my point? Especially regarding the shift from audience perception to authorial intent that you're doing to justify that, which is the boundaries that was being referred to in the first place. But still, my point: Thinking someone is cute = some kind of attraction to said person/character = an appeal to your sexual desire, even if in a minor way. Therefore, even sexual attraction, essentially sex, plays a huge part in how you watch anime. People can find what's-her-face cute. It's some kind of attraction to said character. There's an appeal to the audience member's sexual desire, even in a minor way. Therefore, even sexual attraction, essentially sex, can play a part in how you watch Spirited Away. Spirited Away contributes to Ecchi Culture. People can find her cute, meaning people are sexually attracted to her if they do so. It's all in how libido works, you understand. |
ManabanApr 13, 2020 6:50 AM
Apr 13, 2020 6:48 AM
#276
@Kami_sama_ Cute girls have always been a big fucking deal in anime and it's not always about the libido. Moe characters are designed to appeal to the natural impulse to protect and cherish cute things... But in your world, in normie-land, that feeling is dirty and shameful. That's why it is much more socially acceptable to the "mainstream" to admit to feeling lust for anime characters than feeling protective towards them. I think thats at least part of the reason why the "ecchi culture" you hate can be somewhat obnoxious with their tendency to shove erotic fan art in peoples faces on twitter. |
epidemia78Apr 13, 2020 7:04 AM
Apr 13, 2020 7:03 AM
#277
Also, for what it's worth when we're speaking of authorial intent when it comes to Spirited Away, I'd like to drop this here. If true, Spirited Away contributes to Ecchi Culture. If untrue, Spirited Away contributes to Ecchi Culture. Because cute, young girls. At the end of the day, Spirited Away is just a goddamn great ecchi and I'd recommend it for anybody looking for a fun and sexually charged experience. |
Apr 13, 2020 7:08 AM
#278
Here is an article worth reading that references Miyazaki's view on problems in the industry and otaku in general. It is also difficult to argue with the perspective of an influencer on the industry such as Miyazaki himself. Here is a quote taken from the author of the article: "Understand that I'm not saying all otakudom is a morass of navel-gazing fetishism. But it can sure feel like it, even to other people who want to call themselves fans of one kind or another. When untested against reality and the rest of life, including the rest of creative life, any fandom becomes introverted and sterile. And the more such insularity is unthinkingly supported on both sides, the less we'll see in this field of everything that was truly diverse and original about it in the first place." This statement exemplifies some of the view points made earlier here. Think on this quote applied to the hardcore otakus embracing the aforementioned ecchi culture. To revisit this question now "Is anime better with or without ecchi 'culture'", we need to note a couple things: One, better is subjective and is the root of much disagreement here. Remember, ego-identity is powerful. If you buck someone's views on anime, it's like bucking someone's religion when their ego is strictly tied to one outcome. Let's consider then how the industry is influenced because of ecchi 'culture'. If you go back to the article referenced above, that points to much of the reason why things may be the way they are today. The industry is challenging enough, so creators take the easy way out and cater to the most powerful desire of humans - sex energy. This happens, a lot. Now, if an industry at its inception was something that it is now holistically not anymore, we can say that it has certainly shifted. If one large direction of this influence predominately caters to sexual impulses in humans, we can note massive influence stemming from a very popular niche, ecchi harems. It is also interesting to note that the most popular club on MAL for ecchi harems, with just under 13,000 members at the time of writing, (many of which have participated in this forum discussion), refers to it's community as "degenerates". The introduction to new users of the club is as follows: "Welcome to the Harem&Ecchi Club, MyAnimeList's #1 Hive For Degeneracy... [and goes on to say] ...pop on our active Discord server and chat with other degens." Let dictionary.com clarify that for a moment: degenerate to fall below a normal or desirable level in physical, mental, or moral qualities; deteriorate: The morale of the soldiers degenerated, and they were unable to fight. to diminish in quality, especially from a former state of coherence, balance, integrity, etc.: The debate degenerated into an exchange of insults. to cause degeneration in; bring about a decline, deterioration, or reversion in. adjective having fallen below a normal or desirable level, especially in physical or moral qualities; deteriorated; degraded: a degenerate king. having lost, or become impaired with respect to, the qualities proper to the species or kind Now if we go ahead and apply this term that not myself, but the largest ecchi harem group on MAL uses to label their users, we can then ask ourselves some important questions. Now, why would a community judge their members so harshly to make such statements about its own community? Moreover, why would people actually join a club that refers to them this way? Interesting food for though. If we look at even just this information above, are we better equipped to tackle some important questions like "How does ecchi culture influence not only anime, but society as well?". If we process what a degenerate person's lifestyle may look like, we may be lead in an interesting direction that makes us more well equipped to find an answer. It's worth noting that I personally do not by any means believe that anyone with interest in ecchi and harems is a degenerate, or a "NEET". This behavior alone is not enough to further define an individual. However, when this behavior, combined with a lack of discipline, ambition, motivation, will to create anything of value in society, willfull ignorance of how their actions affect the world around them, constant reliance on systems and people around them, etc... then we see this developing into what some may call a degenerate or a NEET. The difference between medicine and poison is in the dose. |
Apr 13, 2020 7:09 AM
#279
Without echhi 60% of anime fan wouldn't exist, Echhi has been the savior of anime in the middle tier segment. Echhi will always be king. |
Apr 13, 2020 7:10 AM
#280
flowstate said: It is also interesting to note that the most popular club on MAL for ecchi harems, with just under 13,000 members at the time of writing, (many of which have participated in this forum discussion), refers to it's community as "degenerates". The introduction to new users of the club is as follows: "Welcome to the Harem&Ecchi Club, MyAnimeList's #1 Hive For Degeneracy... [and goes on to say] ...pop on our active Discord server and chat with other degens." What's important to note is the context we're using language in, not necessarily the dictionary definition of the term. This is especially prominent in subcultures, where words can have different meanings relative to that group's way of communicating. In this case, we embrace the term "degenerate" as a form of self-reference primarily in defiance to people who try to label us as such as a pejorative. Maybe the actual meaning of the word itself is negative - hell, it is, and that's precisely why it's a common insult hurled our way. People who are there understand this. People who join and stick with us understand this. Because we've all been unfairly labeled stuff like this at points. We also have referred to ourselves as MAL's Island of Misfit Toys before. A lot of our subcultural literacy is defined by this sort of isolation and generally disparaging attitudes towards us from the rest of the anime fandom. It's also why we have such a massive presence on clubs and have three clubs with 10,000+ members. Because most ecchi fans don't want to be around you people, precisely because of the sorts of extremely negative things you attribute to us based on nothing other than we like ecchi. It's a part of the ecchi fandom's literacy, and it's become as such due to our history of being ostracized with terms and labels like that. Trying to chalk it down to treat it like we're using it as a form of self-negativity or that we view ourselves in the same vein that you're treating the term as meaning in this context is missing the point. Context matters. And I don't demand that you grasp the nuances of our literacy, but I will demand you to not project your own interpretations of what we mean onto us. |
ManabanApr 13, 2020 7:24 AM
Apr 13, 2020 7:16 AM
#281
Kami_sama_ said: On the other hand, I feel that if it wasn't such a massive part of our community we could truly hit the mainstream, like many other 'nerd' based cultures have before. Thereby, allowing more and more quality anime to be created, even if our community becomes diluted with people with so-called 'trash taste'. What's the evidence that hitting mainstream (if anime didn't hit it already) brings you more quality work? If anything other industries show you the opposite. |
Apr 13, 2020 7:19 AM
#282
Mistek98 said: Kami_sama_ said: On the other hand, I feel that if it wasn't such a massive part of our community we could truly hit the mainstream, like many other 'nerd' based cultures have before. Thereby, allowing more and more quality anime to be created, even if our community becomes diluted with people with so-called 'trash taste'. What's the evidence that hitting mainstream (if anime didn't hit it already) brings you more quality work? If anything other industries show you the opposite. LOTR brought high fantasy to the mainstream and what did we get? Fucking Game of Thrones... |
Apr 13, 2020 7:33 AM
#283
Apr 13, 2020 7:40 AM
#284
300 replies in a day, I feel like this thread has a hit a milestone. |
Apr 13, 2020 7:46 AM
#285
Me and Dekn pushed a thread to 1,000 posts over the course of a couple of weeks before, back in our prime. Most threads start off with steam and die out later to just a few posters. This isn't anything special. I am impressed at how long I've lasted, though. Usually he tanked and I'd pop in with something lengthy on the side. I've never been good at these drawn out things, certainly not like he is. |
ManabanApr 13, 2020 7:51 AM
Apr 13, 2020 8:08 AM
#286
Definitely better without ecchi or blue comedy, because comedy is subjective. Comedy is not a very skilled genre to begin with plus a bad influence for revenue. What people really want to spend their money on is action. Can ecchi anime even sell out toys or become a metafranchise? nope! |
Apr 13, 2020 8:10 AM
#287
Apr 13, 2020 8:13 AM
#288
NeoAnkara said: So we are having 7 page talking about the response of what I get on the first page. Not really. That's only recently been brought back into the equation. |
Apr 13, 2020 8:15 AM
#289
Kurt_Irving said: Definitely better without ecchi or blue comedy, because comedy is subjective. Comedy is not a very skilled genre to begin with plus a bad influence for revenue. What people really want to spend their money on is action. Can ecchi anime even sell out toys or become a metafranchise? nope! Except that, you know, there are plenty of figurines of ecchi protag. And don't speak for people saying that all they want is "action". Well, I want ecchi action, so heh. Also, there is an entire franchise built around ecchi figurines, "Sin Nanatsu no Taizai". |
TropischApr 13, 2020 8:23 AM
"Well, she's flatter than a pancake" -Mimi Alpacas |
Apr 13, 2020 8:17 AM
#290
I also like the appeal to profitability. I like it when people act like they're businessmen and need to try to justify their stances based on how well they think something can sell. It really adds a fascinating dimension to the conversation. Also, what are PVC figures, if we're talking about a show's ability to pump out physical merch determining its right to exist. Who do people think tends to buy and collect stuff like that? |
Apr 13, 2020 8:51 AM
#291
Kami_sama_ said: Part of me regrets making this thread, since it has been constant back and forth between both sides of the argument, which I thought would stop sometime soon but I don't think it will anytime soon. It's like two unmovable rocks trying to push the other one over, it's never going to end. No, you got it wrong bud. It's been people ripping apart your intial arguments and stance and you still sticking by it because you never intended to reach a common ground or change yours or anybody elses opinion in the first place. |
The beauty of humans is that they say one thing then do another, but at the same time that can also be their ugliest side. |
Apr 13, 2020 8:54 AM
#292
Yes, it's definitely better, meaning no more code geass like your forum picture lmao NeoAnkara said: Here we go again with the myth that sex=sells. This is not a myth, it has been practiced since like Edward Bernays appropriated Freud's concepts in advertising. It's not that sex itself which sells, but associating people's desires to the product will usually appeal more. |
Apr 13, 2020 9:02 AM
#293
in my opinion, whatever, unless it spoils a serious scene, as in the case of fire force |
Apr 13, 2020 9:08 AM
#294
AstZero said: Kami_sama_ said: Part of me regrets making this thread, since it has been constant back and forth between both sides of the argument, which I thought would stop sometime soon but I don't think it will anytime soon. It's like two unmovable rocks trying to push the other one over, it's never going to end. No, you got it wrong bud. It's been people ripping apart your intial arguments and stance and you still sticking by it because you never intended to reach a common ground or change yours or anybody elses opinion in the first place. Bud, I said I wanted to hear their opinions, I didn't mean I would change my stance because of said opinions. I don't blame them though, these people are passionate about what they love. But it just so happens that what they love is what I dislike. |
Apr 13, 2020 9:15 AM
#295
Kami_sama_ said: I don't blame them though, these people are passionate about what they love. But it just so happens that what they love is what I dislike. Downplaying it by passing it off as an honest dislike. Nice. What you're failing to acknowledge is the amount of people who say they dislike it in this thread and other threads. Nobody cares that you dislike it. If they do, then they can go sit in the same corner with you in terms of being pathetically thin-skinned. Criticism and distastes aren't personal attacks. What makes you bad specifically is the eradicative mentality towards our fandom and the weak-ass justifications you've been trying to hoist up as the reason. You're not living that down by just trying to pass it off as being in the same boat as just disliking the content. You *are* trying to leverage personal attacks. You *are* the aggressor here, and we're just acting in self-defense of our character and our ability to just simply be here. ---- I'll also just point out that my personal favorite part of this thread was when that other guy came in and you got confident again due to external validation. You've maintained that even after he had his temper tantrum and broke that facade of altruism and being dignified and educated, but you wavered there, didn't you? You wanted to back off hard by trying to point out things like that you didn't insult me specifically and kept trying to seek cheap appeasement for agreeing to disagree when I was coming down on you, then you came back and doubled down as soon as somebody else came and made you feel less alone and even kept at it with me for a while. You have a weak conviction to the extremities of your opinion and you needed affirmation to be willing to stick with it to the extent that you have, I'm guessing. |
ManabanApr 13, 2020 9:21 AM
Apr 13, 2020 9:18 AM
#296
Kurt_Irving said: Definitely better without ecchi or blue comedy, because comedy is subjective. Comedy is not a very skilled genre to begin with plus a bad influence for revenue. What people really want to spend their money on is action. Can ecchi anime even sell out toys or become a metafranchise? nope! i don't buy figurines because i don't see the point, but saying ecchi can't become a metafranchies is kinda ignoring the fact that we already have metafrachies ecchis To love ru porbably has some of the most figurines and continues to pump them out long after the manga has ended. there are also several video games. senran kaugra has several anime video games. and a bunch of merchendice from figurines to freaking body pillows. just saying. Joms said: Yes, it's definitely better, meaning no more code geass like your forum picture lmao NeoAnkara said: Here we go again with the myth that sex=sells. This is not a myth, it has been practiced since like Edward Bernays appropriated Freud's concepts in advertising. It's not that sex itself which sells, but associating people's desires to the product will usually appeal more. ^ this also if sex didn't sell rule 34 wouldn't exists. |
"among monsters and humans, there are only two types. Those who undergo suffering and spread it to others. And those who undergo suffering and avoid giving it to others." -Alice “Beauty is no quality in things themselves: It exists merely in the mind which contemplates them; and each mind perceives a different beauty.” David Hume “Evil is created when someone gives up on someone else. It appears when everyone gives up on someone as a lost cause and removes their path to salvation. Once they are cut off from everyone else, they become evil.” -Othinus |
Apr 13, 2020 9:20 AM
#297
Manaban said: Kami_sama_ said: I don't blame them though, these people are passionate about what they love. But it just so happens that what they love is what I dislike. Downplaying it by passing it off as an honest dislike. Nice. What you're failing to acknowledge is the amount of people who say they dislike it in this thread and other threads. Nobody cares that you dislike it. If they do, then they can go sit in the same corner with you in terms of being pathetically thin-skinned. Criticism and distastes aren't personal attacks. What makes you bad specifically is the eradicative mentality towards our fandom and the weak-ass justifications you've been trying to hoist up as the reason. You're not living that down by just trying to pass it off as being in the same boat as just disliking the content. You *are* trying to leverage personal attacks. You *are* the aggressor here, and we're just acting in self-defense. I'll also just point out that my personal favorite part of this thread was when that other guy came in and you got confident again due to external validation. You've maintained that even after he had his temper tantrum, but you wavered there, didn't you? You wanted to back off hard by trying to point out things like that you didn't insult me specifically and kept trying to seek cheap appeasement for agreeing to disagree when I was coming down on you, then you came back and doubled down as soon as somebody else came and made you feel less alone and even kept at it with me for a while. You have a weak conviction to this opinion and you needed affirmation to be willing to stick with it to the extent that you have, I'm guessing. I'll be honest, I fell asleep part way through this thread that is why I wasn't active, this epidemic had ruined my sleep schedule. But I will admit that having someone with common beliefs in an angry mob that wants me dead was a relief. |
Apr 13, 2020 9:23 AM
#298
Kami_sama_ said: I'll be honest, I fell asleep part way through this thread that is why I wasn't active, this epidemic had ruined my sleep schedule. But I will admit that having someone with common beliefs in an angry mob that wants me dead was a relief. Well, I wasn't talking about your lack of activity for a while, I'm talking about the gear shift you had when you were trying to seek appeasement with me and then after that other guy came in and you redoubled on your original stance. You went from "Let's agree to disagree" and "I didn't insult you specifically!" to trying to come back even stronger after you felt validated in maintaining your prejudices against us. That didn't happen while you were sleeping, that all happened after you came back. I don't think that's what a person who actually believes in something strongly would do. |
Apr 13, 2020 9:25 AM
#299
Joms said: I'm not talking about that though. We are talking on the context of animanga here where people say that ecchi are selling which in fact not quite true as in proven by number that are available in sales thread that MAL have been posted. It is as profitable as other series maybe even less. There are exception of course but so is other genre.Yes, it's definitely better, meaning no more code geass like your forum picture lmao NeoAnkara said: Here we go again with the myth that sex=sells. This is not a myth, it has been practiced since like Edward Bernays appropriated Freud's concepts in advertising. It's not that sex itself which sells, but associating people's desires to the product will usually appeal more. |
Apr 13, 2020 9:38 AM
#300
Manaban said: I was thinking of taking a backseat on this matter after I had discussed it for a while but one of your responses to him on Pg.5 made want to support his argument. Kami_sama_ said: I'll be honest, I fell asleep part way through this thread that is why I wasn't active, this epidemic had ruined my sleep schedule. But I will admit that having someone with common beliefs in an angry mob that wants me dead was a relief. Well, I wasn't talking about your lack of activity for a while, I'm talking about the gear shift you had when you were trying to seek appeasement with me and then after that other guy came in and you redoubled on your original stance. You went from "Let's agree to disagree" and "I didn't insult you specifically!" to trying to come back even stronger after you felt validated in maintaining your prejudices against us. That didn't happen while you were sleeping, that all happened after you came back. I don't think that's what a person who actually believes in something strongly would do. Additionally, his own stance on the matter with the Frozen female representation example personally got to me. As I stated before with my cousins and how they love Frozen, they are practically like sisters to me, so it gave me some personal stake in this matter thereby driving me to pursue my argument more than before. |
This topic has been locked and is no longer available for discussion.
More topics from this board
» Can't find an anime I watched 3 years ago.niai00 - Oct 1 |
13 |
by niai00
»»
16 minutes ago |
|
» 🍉 Summer 2025: Anime of the Season (AOTS) ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )nirererin - Oct 9 |
255 |
by StyxParadise
»»
21 minutes ago |
|
» What anime only exist inside other anime not real life?AnimeDownUnder - Yesterday |
26 |
by MeguSae38
»»
22 minutes ago |
|
» ☀️ Anime Summer 2025 Male & Female Characters Tournament ( 1 2 3 )ISeeLifePeople - Oct 5 |
122 |
by Zarutaku
»»
25 minutes ago |
|
» From Superheroes To Shōnen: Sony Bets On Anime As The Next Global IP EngineOld_School_Akira - 7 hours ago |
2 |
by Captain-577
»»
28 minutes ago |