MikanNatsume5 said: Is a collection of one shots the same as a collection of short stories? For the purpose of the item, sure. :) |
| "Read a manga recommended to you by another participant in the discussion thread" Something Psychological perhaps. |
  |
| Great recommendations. 👀 |
Gythia said: Ryunuosuke said: Helter Skelter"Read a manga recommended to you by another participant in the discussion thread" Something Psychological perhaps. Kizu Arigatou Onanie Master Kurosawa Nijigahara Holograph Ori no Naka no Soloist They look interesting. Thanks! Probably gonna go with Onanie Master Kurosawa as this was recommended by a couple of people till now and I never got into it xD |
| |
| I can just pick anything off the challenge list and read it until I hit my difficulty requirement right? I cant believe that out of all the information on the other page... i had to come to the discussion page to find that most essential piece of information! Sorry, not trying to be negative, but in the spirit of discussion i just had to get that out there. Its not too late, you might wanna make that more clear in the guidelines. |
Lainsbearsuit said: I can just pick anything off the challenge list and read it until I hit my difficulty requirement right?  Remember that the challenge list has more items than required, so you can modify it at any time while completing the challenge. :) |
Lainsbearsuit said: I can just pick anything off the challenge list and read it until I hit my difficulty requirement right? I cant believe that out of all the information on the other page... i had to come to the discussion page to find that most essential piece of information! Sorry, not trying to be negative, but in the spirit of discussion i just had to get that out there. Its not too late, you might wanna make that more clear in the guidelines. What was the most helpful post for that? We are aware of participants having a rough time with the jokers and we are open for any input to better the situation and make things more clear. |
| 22. Read a Psychological or Thriller manga. 28. Read a Psychological or Supernatural manga. Is it a mistake, or can I just read two psychological mangas for these challenges? |
lubryka said: Good question. :) We'll get back to you.22. Read a Psychological or Thriller manga. 28. Read a Psychological or Supernatural manga. Is it a mistake, or can I just read two psychological mangas for these challenges? |
lubryka said: Yes. :)22. Read a Psychological or Thriller manga. 28. Read a Psychological or Supernatural manga. Is it a mistake, or can I just read two psychological mangas for these challenges? Have fun. :P |
| my third attempt for MRC, but i never completed previous due to time, so There are 111 challenge items this year, i will start step by step so if i start beginner, can i choose any 10 from 111 ? or it has to be in order? regards |
 |
Daisy-Sensei said: my third attempt for MRC, but i never completed previous due to time, so There are 111 challenge items this year, i will start step by step so if i start beginner, can i choose any 10 from 111 ? or it has to be in order? regards You can choose any, there's no order you need to stick to! |
    |
| If I start to read an on going manga (like Haikyuu or Mairimashita, Senpai for example). When I do complete one item of the challenge? For example [Started: DATE] [Finished: DATE] #26. Read a Sports or Games manga. Haikyuu. |
 |
UndefinedProfile said: If I start to read an on going manga (like Haikyuu or Mairimashita, Senpai for example). When I do complete one item of the challenge? For example [Started: DATE] [Finished: DATE] #26. Read a Sports or Games manga. Haikyuu. You "complete" the item on the day of your turn in. Until then you have to be up to date with ongoing series. The Finished Date is the day you read the latest chapter available. This can be one week before your turn in or just a day. You can ignore everything that gets published the day after your turn in. |
Schlopsi said: UndefinedProfile said: If I start to read an on going manga (like Haikyuu or Mairimashita, Senpai for example). When I do complete one item of the challenge? For example [Started: DATE] [Finished: DATE] #26. Read a Sports or Games manga. Haikyuu. You "complete" the item on the day of your turn in. Until then you have to be up to date with ongoing series. The Finished Date is the day you read the latest chapter available. This can be one week before your turn in or just a day. You can ignore everything that gets published the day after your turn in. So, if the chapter 380 is the last chapter available, when I reach the chapter 380, then I complete the item? |
|
UndefinedProfile said: If you turn in your form, and the latest available chapter is chapter 380, then yes.So, if the chapter 380 is the last chapter available, when I reach the chapter 380, then I complete the item? If you reach chapter 380, but there's another chapter available by the time you turn in your form, you also have to read that chapter. |
| hey! i was just wondering about something and figured i'd ask it here. i'm doing manga expert, and i'm close to finishing. however, there are ofcourse more challenges than just 65, and i'd like to do those too. can i send in my completion form if i finished 65 mangas, and still edit my sign in post to do the other challenges? or can you only send in your completion form if you're not going to do any more challenges? sorry if my question is confusing! |
| hi, could one of you help me with this one, please : #87. Read a manga recommended to you by another participant in the discussion thread. thank you in advance. |
Gythia said: aemiliuz said: Azumanga Daiohhi, could one of you help me with this one, please : #87. Read a manga recommended to you by another participant in the discussion thread. thank you in advance. I sold my life for ten thousand yen per year. Solanin All You Need Is Kill Nice suggestions, i'll keep them in mind for the other items and go with I sold my life etc, seems like an interesting one. Thank you. |
xiulaces said: hey! i was just wondering about something and figured i'd ask it here. i'm doing manga expert, and i'm close to finishing. however, there are ofcourse more challenges than just 65, and i'd like to do those too. can i send in my completion form if i finished 65 mangas, and still edit my sign in post to do the other challenges? or can you only send in your completion form if you're not going to do any more challenges? sorry if my question is confusing! You can do more than those 65 items, but we probably won't check any more than those tbh (since it's rather time costly to inspect). So I'd recommend you to either list all the other items you won't include in Manga Expert in a separate spoiler on the bottom section of your form, or do a separate attempt i.e. in a blog post which you can edit safely any time. Once you turn in your form however, you shouldn't edit the 65 items you're using for Expert - about the others below we don't really care. ;) aemiliuz said: hi, could one of you help me with this one, please : #87. Read a manga recommended to you by another participant in the discussion thread. thank you in advance. Kanata no Astra Land Lock G Senjou Heaven's Door Yuureitou Half & Half Afterschool War Activities |
Schlopsi said: You can do more than those 65 items, but we probably won't check any more than those tbh (since it's rather time costly to inspect). So I'd recommend you to either list all the other items you won't include in Manga Expert in a separate spoiler on the bottom section of your form, or do a separate attempt i.e. in a blog post which you can edit safely any time. Once you turn in your form however, you shouldn't edit the 65 items you're using for Expert - about the others below we don't really care. ;) thank you very much for your quick answer! i'll make sure to put them in a separate spoiler then! |
| Help me with #87 Not too long, short is fine but I prefer them not to be a one shot. I'd like a drama, if you wouldn't mind/ |
 |
Hackser_ said: Help me with #87 Not too long, short is fine but I prefer them not to be a one shot. I'd like a drama, if you wouldn't mind/ Annarasumanara Confession Heads Jumyou wo Kaitotte Moratta. Ichinen ni Tsuki, Ichimanen de. Kamisama ga Uso wo Tsuku. Omoide Emanon Solanin (or anything else from Inio Asano) Suiiki Watashitachi no Shiawase na Jikan |
Schlopsi said: Hackser_ said: Help me with #87 Not too long, short is fine but I prefer them not to be a one shot. I'd like a drama, if you wouldn't mind/ Annarasumanara Confession Heads Jumyou wo Kaitotte Moratta. Ichinen ni Tsuki, Ichimanen de. Kamisama ga Uso wo Tsuku. Omoide Emanon Solanin (or anything else from Inio Asano) Suiiki Watashitachi no Shiawase na Jikan Thank you very much. I've read Jumyou wo Kaitotte, while Solanin, Omoide Emanon, and Heads are already in my waiting list, but the rest of them are very interesting. I think I'm gonna go with The Gods Lies. Anyway, once again thank you very much |
|
| #57: Read a manga with a main character that is a professional in their field. I just want to make sure for this: If the series doesn't have any character entries in the DB (making it unclear who is or isn't a MC), is it fine as long as the series synopsis makes the character's profession (and their main...ness, so to speak) obvious? I wanted to use this for this entry, there's no character entries, but I think the ML and his profession are pretty unambiguous. Is this fine, or does the character HAVE to have be officially marked as main? |
Horkus said: #57: Read a manga with a main character that is a professional in their field. I just want to make sure for this: If the series doesn't have any character entries in the DB (making it unclear who is or isn't a MC), is it fine as long as the series synopsis makes the character's profession (and their main...ness, so to speak) obvious? I wanted to use this for this entry, there's no character entries, but I think the ML and his profession are pretty unambiguous. Is this fine, or does the character HAVE to have be officially marked as main? In cases like this, where it's super obvious by just the synopsis, that's fine :) |
|
Horkus said: As long as it's apparent based on cover/description/character description, it's fine. :)#57: Read a manga with a main character that is a professional in their field. I just want to make sure for this: If the series doesn't have any character entries in the DB (making it unclear who is or isn't a MC), is it fine as long as the series synopsis makes the character's profession (and their main...ness, so to speak) obvious? I wanted to use this for this entry, there's no character entries, but I think the ML and his profession are pretty unambiguous. Is this fine, or does the character HAVE to have be officially marked as main? |
Hackser_ said: Help me with #87 Not too long, short is fine but I prefer them not to be a one shot. I'd like a drama, if you wouldn't mind/ Peach Girl is 72 chapters long but I have a soft spot for it and I think maybe you could like it Yuri na Watashi to Akuma na Kanojo(?) is not drama but it's a very nice read (and short too) those are the ones on your ptr list that I read not on your list but you could give a try: Claudine...! is short but is very dramatic, it's one of those manga that I recommend to everyone Kamisama ga Uso wo Tsuku.: short? check. drama? check. since i'm not really into drama i didn't like it, but i can see why people love it! Shimanami Tasogare beautiful art, it focuses on identity and "growing up as a lgbt kid" drama. give it a try. I tried rec'ing what you asked for but drama's not really my forte sahiogdusifu sorry I hope this was still helpful, though!! :) |
   |
| Would the interior of a vehicle count for #84? |
   |
BrainpanSonata said: Sure. Which manga is that? 👀Would the interior of a vehicle count for #84? |
HeNrYTG50 said: BrainpanSonata said: Sure. Which manga is that? 👀Would the interior of a vehicle count for #84? Durarara!! Saika-hen |
|
isahbellah said: Hackser_ said: Help me with #87 Not too long, short is fine but I prefer them not to be a one shot. I'd like a drama, if you wouldn't mind/ Peach Girl is 72 chapters long but I have a soft spot for it and I think maybe you could like it Yuri na Watashi to Akuma na Kanojo(?) is not drama but it's a very nice read (and short too) those are the ones on your ptr list that I read not on your list but you could give a try: Claudine...! is short but is very dramatic, it's one of those manga that I recommend to everyone Kamisama ga Uso wo Tsuku.: short? check. drama? check. since i'm not really into drama i didn't like it, but i can see why people love it! Shimanami Tasogare beautiful art, it focuses on identity and "growing up as a lgbt kid" drama. give it a try. I tried rec'ing what you asked for but drama's not really my forte sahiogdusifu sorry I hope this was still helpful, though!! :) Thank you for you suggestions. Claudine is a very interesting take, especially since I've watched some of the author's (Ikeda, Riyoko) anime adaptations (Versailles no Bara and Oniisama e), and I really love them, so I'll definitely read this one later. Thank you |
|
Bookworm86 said: Schlopsi said: There's no such thing as dumb questions. ;) Yes, it's just as you explained. The manga description often varies a bit when it comes to those, so things like this: Love Letter or this Yaneura no Majowould would be valid for it as an example. Would the manga: https://myanimelist.net/manga/3258/Haruka_na_Machi_e Count as a collection of short stories? No, it doesn't count, sorry. The item requires several stories, which are bundled together in a volume or more (like in the examples shown above). Not just episodic chapters. |
Gythia said: For Tags & Demographics, can I use short story collections as long as one of them has the required tag/genre and that tag/genre is listed in the MAL database entry? Going to use Koi no Kamisama for "#21. Read a Super Power or Magic manga." Sure, that works. |
| "#87. Read a manga recommended to you by another participant in the discussion thread." Can someone recommend me an manga about courtesans? (I think I've read every manga that was in the tags in the mangaupdates but could exist something without the correct tag) or an manga about the feudal Japan? Thanks. |
 |
Kamirura said: Saraiya Goyou? :0"#87. Read a manga recommended to you by another participant in the discussion thread." Can someone recommend me an manga about courtesans? (I think I've read every manga that was in the tags in the mangaupdates but could exist something without the correct tag) or an manga about the feudal Japan? Thanks. |
Please read the first 4 posts on this thread: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1818367 If you still have questions after thoroughly reading through everything, don't hesitate to ask here. |
|
| I would like some recommendations for #87. I'm always thirsty for some cute and fluffy slice of life stuff, so I'd prefer something like that thank you~ |
fraideii said: I would like some recommendations for #87. I'm always thirsty for some cute and fluffy slice of life stuff, so I'd prefer something like that thank you~ K-On! Aria Ojojojo Uchi no Maou Kamimasen yo |
|
fraideii said: I would like some recommendations for #87. I'm always thirsty for some cute and fluffy slice of life stuff, so I'd prefer something like that thank you~ I just finished reading Yuru Yuru for the colored manga entry and really enjoyed it. I dunno if I'd call it fluffy, but it was a cute and relaxing slice of life series |
| #09. Read a manga by your favorite author/artist. I was planning to use anything I haven't already read by Syundei - come to find out, Doushite Sensei ni Natta no is a oneshot inside this anthology. Am I able to still use it if I give a link to MU? Or is it considered the anthology in general and to be used with a different challenge #? |
CMYK said: It would count as an anthology, unfortunately, since that's how it is in the database.#09. Read a manga by your favorite author/artist. I was planning to use anything I haven't already read by Syundei - come to find out, Doushite Sensei ni Natta no is a oneshot inside this anthology. Am I able to still use it if I give a link to MU? Or is it considered the anthology in general and to be used with a different challenge #? |
BrainpanSonata said: fraideii said: I would like some recommendations for #87. I'm always thirsty for some cute and fluffy slice of life stuff, so I'd prefer something like that thank you~ K-On! Aria Ojojojo Uchi no Maou Kamimasen yo Horkus said: fraideii said: I would like some recommendations for #87. I'm always thirsty for some cute and fluffy slice of life stuff, so I'd prefer something like that thank you~ I just finished reading Yuru Yuru for the colored manga entry and really enjoyed it. I dunno if I'd call it fluffy, but it was a cute and relaxing slice of life series Thank you both, I'll hopefully be able to use all of them |
More topics from this board
» Good manga to read for people starting outGoblingaming - May 21 |
9 |
by Rissio
»»
1 hour ago |
|
» Have an amazing art in manga but not in animekirA_-_ - Apr 15 |
17 |
by DesuMaiden
»»
Yesterday, 11:23 AM |
|
» Thoughts on long manga?Chuckiemuffin - Feb 29 |
35 |
by DesuMaiden
»»
Yesterday, 11:22 AM |
|
» Completed my first LN.Clannat - Yesterday |
3 |
by DesuMaiden
»»
Yesterday, 11:21 AM |
|
» Im just gonna say it, Tokyo Ghoul has some of the best art and story in all of manga behind BerserkNessieMAL - May 24 |
4 |
by DaoistFR
»»
Yesterday, 8:12 AM |