| We should be able to leave comments on the character pages and also relate them to other charcters. Mod Edit: Modified title for clarity and/or easier searching. |
TenshoSep 10, 2019 9:58 AM
 |
| Why would you want to relate them to other characters? |
| The ability to comment on character pages was considered...but dropped due to the potential for people to spoil. |
ScrumYummy said: Just for the fun of it... people might want to watch a show with similar characters.Why would you want to relate them to other characters? Xinil said: I know what you mean... but people could put a spoiler warning or just comment on the looks but meh I guess it really doesn't matter.The ability to comment on character pages was considered...but dropped due to the potential for people to spoil. |
|
| Tons of bitches in the world. I can't tell you how many times I've seen "general" discussion turn in to spoiler crap by jerks wanting to ruin stuff for people. so yeah, there isn't an effective way to combat this. :( |
| Yeah I know I hate when people just spoil the series... I guess this is best for people to avoid spoilers. |
|
| Not sure if this was already mentioned or not, but like how you made possible discussion under each Voice actor profile page, have a similar kind of concept under each anime/manga character profile. Something small, and you may view it as not necessary, but it's convenient for people who simply want to express love/hate for a particular character. |
| thought about this, but decided to not implement it as it could lead to a large amount of spoilers. |
| Ah, makes sense. Sounds good. Thanks. |
| Hey, it would be nice if we could post a comment on a character's page just like the Seyuu's pages. Thanks 4 the attention Ryushi |
| Nice idea, but it's already been mentioned and shot down here. |
| Oh thnaks! Srry for making you waste your time. =P Next time i will use search feature. Sorry, and thanks again xD |
| Hey, there is the spoiler button, i guess that wouldn't be a problem Sorry to be bothering about this, but i would really like to be implemented. (Sorry, im annoying, i know =P) Thanks 4 your time and patience. |
| Should we have a comment area for the characters in a Anime or Manga? Like the way you would comment a voice actor/actress, you could comment the character. Please comment on this. I can't search if this idea has suggested or not. "The search feature is currently offline for maintenance. Sorry for the inconvenience."....is what I see when I click on search. Sorry~ |
| Hello! |
| It has been requested and denied before due to possible abuse and highly probably spoiling. Sorry, not gonna happen. |
 staff.applications ▼ guidelines.faq ▼ report.abuse ▼ thx.skittles ▼ thx.kina ▼ [H+] ³ ▼ |
| I see. Oh well. |
| Hello! |
| I nothiced that we can comment on other people's profiles, clubs, club pictures, people, blogs...etc. But we can't comment on characters. If there was a technical problem with that, it's okay but a character profile can't be different from a user profile can it? Anyway, by that, we can also talk to other people who like that character. Eg. You love Fuji Syusuke but it dosen't fit on your fave list as you moved on from Prince of Tennis. You can always post a comment saying I love fuji Syusuke, have anyone seen the episode when... That way, you don't have to go through all the users' profile to say do you like Fuji. What do you think? |
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the General Forum Guidelines! |
| I see your point. We're able to comment on People but not on Characters even though it's pretty much the same thing: Describing a character whether it's a physical real one or virtual fictional one. Commenting on characters could probably be nice but I'm gonna be honest and say that I have up till now not missed this feature. As for finding other users that like a certain character I see two available options:
I'll vote maybe. |
| ... Even if I took time to write alot of intelligent words of deep thought and meaning in my signature, would you really care to read and comment on it? ... |
CaMaVan said: I see your point. We're able to comment on People but not on Characters even though it's pretty much the same thing: Describing a character whether it's a physical real one or virtual fictional one. Commenting on characters could probably be nice but I'm gonna be honest and say that I have up till now not missed this feature. As for finding other users that like a certain character I see two available options:
I'll vote maybe. but the problem is there are many less popular characters with no fanclub and you must be in the club to post a comment. And sometimes the less popular ones dosen'y make it on the fave list. Anyway, the comments aren't just for fanboy/girling, eg. I might post I HATE HIM!!! |
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the General Forum Guidelines! |
ALL_HAIL_LELOUCH said: , eg. I might post I HATE HIM!!! Why would you do that? Isn't that a reason in itself for why this shouldn't be implemented? :) I mean, what's the point in spreading a negative atmosphere in a social community? Not that I'm against the suggestion. ^^ |
CaMaVanFeb 5, 2009 2:17 AM
| ... Even if I took time to write alot of intelligent words of deep thought and meaning in my signature, would you really care to read and comment on it? ... |
| Won't be implemented. It has been suggested and denied before, use the search function and you'll find the topic. The risk of spoilers etc. is too high. Use the clubs. (: |
staff.applications ▼ guidelines.faq ▼ report.abuse ▼ thx.skittles ▼ thx.kina ▼ [H+] ³ ▼ |
| i liked the idea ^_^ |
ALL_HAIL_LELOUCH said: , eg. I might post I HATE HIM!!! This is exactly why I'm completely against the idea. The last thing we need is for people to start flame wars. |
 Znips: When Shay is born she just crawls back in the womb to shitpost for another year |
ALL_HAIL_LELOUCH said: but the problem is there are many less popular characters with no fanclub and you must be in the club to post a comment. Then make a club, that's what most people do. And ya, you usually have to join a club to post, but you just join, post, and then leave and your comment stays unless someone deletes it. |
   |
Amaya-no-Hime said: same here~ ALL_HAIL_LELOUCH said: , eg. I might post I HATE HIM!!! This is exactly why I'm completely against the idea. The last thing we need is for people to start flame wars. seems pretty pointless when there are already fanclubs dedicated to many characters. |
| This is actually I pretty good idea :3 |
Music is from the soul~ ♥ |
| Are you still going on about this... Xinil said: The ability to comment on character pages was considered...but dropped due to the potential for people to spoil. Xinil said: Tons of bitches in the world. I can't tell you how many times I've seen "general" discussion turn in to spoiler crap by jerks wanting to ruin stuff for people. so yeah, there isn't an effective way to combat this. :( Case closed, sorry. If you can't find these posts, then blame yourself for not using the search function. The topics have the same title even... Someone lock this please. |
cyruzFeb 5, 2009 5:23 PM
staff.applications ▼ guidelines.faq ▼ report.abuse ▼ thx.skittles ▼ thx.kina ▼ [H+] ³ ▼ |
| Plus, if you do not wish to use a club, you can just make a thread for the character in it's anime sub-forum. |
| Sorry if there's already a thread like this.. So People pages have their own comment box right? Then why can't characters have them too? On the other hand, I kind of see the downside as being people fangirling or spamming. Still... |
MAL Book Club join if you like reading  |
| It may seem like a good idea, but due to the fangirls out there, the idea had been disabled. I asked the question as well, a while back. |
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the General Forum Guidelines! |
| Like it is available for people I think comments should be allowed on a characters page. If this is not do-able It'll be fine but it could prove a fun and useful feature.. |
| Not really. Imagine all the trolls and haters this could cause. At least most users on MAL don't care/known about people. Now imagine naruto's page. Filled with comments about how much he sucks etc. Don't think it gonna happen :) |
 |
| D: I guess you're right.. |
| Also imagine the huge amount of Fangirl and Fanboy posts like: "KYAAAAAAA HE IS SO CUUUUTE I LOVE HIM SO MUCH!!!!111111" that wouldn't be really nice to see something like that on your favourite characters profile. XD |
Music is about enjoying sound~
| How about adding a new tab-page for comments? That way, you could keep trolls and haters off the main page but still have a comments section. Crunchyroll used to be like that (don't know if it still does). |
Earth gets angry after a kick in the face. |
teanut said: How about adding a new tab-page for comments? That way, you could keep trolls and haters off the main page but still have a comments section. Crunchyroll used to be like that (don't know if it still does). Good idea. That could work. |
| I think adding comments to your favorites list might be more feasible and useful. In line with the flaming that would go on provided it was on a characters page, users can instead comment on their favorite characters, anime, and manga for other users to view on their profile. This can be a good way to see justifications and rationale for the reason the user had picked that favorite item in question. |
divito said: Those types of things are generally left to the About Me section or your blog.I think adding comments to your favorites list might be more feasible and useful. In line with the flaming that would go on provided it was on a characters page, users can instead comment on their favorite characters, anime, and manga for other users to view on their profile. This can be a good way to see justifications and rationale for the reason the user had picked that favorite item in question. As for this suggestion in general, yes, it has been denied multiple times in the past for reasons Cloud cited. And this: teanut said: I don't think the problem is whether or not the flaming/idiotic comments are immediately accessible. Putting them one click away won't change the fact that the comments might have to be moderated.How about adding a new tab-page for comments? That way, you could keep trolls and haters off the main page but still have a comments section. Crunchyroll used to be like that (don't know if it still does). |
Xjellocross said: Those types of things are generally left to the About Me section or your blog. O_o I think that's a little more fragmented, but whatever floats your boat I guess. :) |
| Well, it'd be interesting to see what other people have to say but of course there'd be those damn fucking fan girls (or fan boys). |
Cloudy-Sky said: Not really. Imagine all the trolls and haters this could cause. At least most users on MAL don't care/known about people. Now imagine naruto's page. Filled with comments about how much he sucks etc. Don't think it gonna happen :) in THAT case we need some 'censore' button... if more than 5 people censores teh comment, it will automatic be deleted or spammed.. like in youtube.. |
Cloudy-Sky said: Not really. Imagine all the trolls and haters this could cause. At least most users on MAL don't care/known about people. Now imagine naruto's page. Filled with comments about how much he sucks etc. Don't think it gonna happen :) Well there can be Troll and haters for the people section as well... but ye most users on mal check characters. and so characters like naruto in which are are lots of haters of him, will surely spam his page area XD If you want to comment on characters that you like join the fan club? |
 |
| please put a comment place 4 everyCharaceters , like u put 4 every Seiyuu [ Voice Actor ] . we want to comment on the character sometime not the voice actor . tanom ლ(╹◡╹ლ) |
 |
| With so many other things in the debate for removal (clubs and/or messages), for being too taxing on the server, it's more unlikely for features to be added, than to be deleted at this time. |
| This has already been shot down and it's not going to happen because of the major amount of "trolling" that would probably ensue on certain characters such as naruto and all of that junk. I'm sure we're all aware of how anime fans feel about their favourite characters.. So it would be nothing more than an unnecessary 'blood bath' in the comment sections most likely |
kinoholicJan 17, 2011 4:25 AM
| I see that you've put a comment box for voice actors and manga creators, so why haven't you put one for the characters? |
 |
| Sounds like those would be filled with spoilers in no time. |
| I definitely have superpowers. I can feel it in my balls. |
| Fans are gonna get bashed by haters and vice versa. |
More topics from this board
» Prevent obscure Donghua from polluting the top rankingsZarutaku - Yesterday |
8 |
by Detalius
»»
3 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » Add list setting to make notes private (on public lists)Shark93 - Nov 12, 2022 |
28 |
by Potimas
»»
1 hour ago |
|
» The "related entries" redesign is atrociousFurMetarArkemist - 5 hours ago |
2 |
by velvetnyan
»»
4 hours ago |
|
» Who thought this was a good idea?Shenhe - May 26 |
7 |
by Zarutaku
»»
Today, 6:51 AM |
|
» please increase the tag character limit 🙏wormwormy - Today |
0 |
by wormwormy
»»
Today, 6:17 AM |