Fullmetal Alchemist
What did you think of this episode?
5Loved it!
51.7%
545
4Liked it!
28.7%
303
3It was OK
9.0%
95
2Disliked it
1.8%
19
1Hated it
8.7%
92
Average 4.1
1,054 votes
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| THIS IS AN ANIME ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS THE MANGA BEYOND THIS EPISODE. ---------------------------------------- Pre-OP= Joliot Vs Scar awesomeness. Joliot's design is always something ultra duper super awesome. OP: FUCKING AWESOME Scenes :3 Episode: Mei's introduction = Shit Rentanjutsu/Alkahestry introduction = OK. Xiao Mei and SCAR = LOL Mei's daydream = 100% faithful to manga LOL. :3 Riza's and Barry's scene = epic :3 Barry's Love = LOL And here they cut Riza's call to Mustang. Thankfully they did not cut "Did you kill Hughes?" line :3 Cut thar and thar and thar and thar and fracking thar. Ling's introduction = Great. Fight = EPIC :3 Fu = Solid Snake :3 Rabbit trap for Ran Fan = LOL They skipped the "beach scene".... T_T ED: calm. Overall episode was better paced than previous ones and I liked that they did not cut many important scenes. It felt good and it had some great animations for fight. Next episode seemingly deals with Overall 4/5, since they DID NOT INCLUDE THE "THE FLAMES WILL BE EXTRA HOT" SENTENCE T_T Where's mah Royai ship >_> |
AhenshihaelJul 12, 2009 1:37 AM
 |
| The new opening is awesome. I love seeing the new cast members in it. :DDD Ling's voice is PERFECT. A+ I loved his quick escapes (especially the one where he sort of dances away from all the angry citizens of Rush Valley) and random popping in. Ling is my hero. Riza shooting Barry was epic. ♥ I love how stoic she can be. I'm sad they cut Riza's call to Mustang. :( They seem to be cutting all the Royai scenes. I was especially sad to see this little exchange cut out. But I loved just seeing Roy and Riza in civilian clothes. ♥♥♥ |
 ジリティック♡BEGINNER |
| Yes, episode was really good (besides Mei's introduction) BUT when you look at it as a royai fangirl whom I happen to be, it was disappointing -.- I mean they cut chess scene earlier and now they cut most of the royaish Barry part, tsk, they cut most of the Barry part even not royaish moments, why oh why they included this fight at the beginning but cut Barry part, darn it -.- |
| deiboom, I'm not sure about Fai but probably, just as me, he watched it online-streamed by KeyHoleTV, TVAnts or something like this... |
| I was quite disappointed with the lack of Royai too! But overall the episode was great, the new OP sounds good and animation is great, ED had mediocre music and animation but I suppose it'll grow on me. Ling and Miyano Mamoru were EPIC! |
 |
| yea, better pacing than the previous because its actual new manga stuff instead of review of previous. ling is awesome as ever, his VA is nice too. the beginning fight was a great intro for us saying 'its new stuff!' the comedy is presented more than before since the previous were used in fma1 already, so seeing all the comedy again is nice. liked and didnt like the new opening at the same time. nothing too special aside from the fight scenes. |
| Great episode. Ling's voice makes him more likable (I honestly hated him when I first read the manga) and Ran Fan seems more feminine than I remember. Also loved the comedy scenes with Ling and Winry XD & I miss the old opening :< |
 |
| ...Must...see....Ling....must...see.....*dies from not seeing 15 yet* Damn I'm pathetic to want to see this guy so badly. xD Still, from what you guys have said, it looks like another good episode. Saw the new opening and I'm meh about it. I think the first one was better, but the animation quality is still superb. *Nod* I really love how good the animation is in all of Brotherhood; it just makes me go wow, lol. Edit// Okies, finally saw it. Pretty good; May's opening was bad though, even if a person hadn't read the manga. It's like she's so..randomly entered. I mean, she was pretty random in the manga with her introduction, but at least it made more sense to how she got to Scar and Yoki. Still, Ling's introduction made up for it. xD Poor poor Ed, he wasn't expecting that. Ling's voice actor is really good too. 0-0 Fits him well. |
PosskJul 12, 2009 2:05 PM
| I'm surprised about Ling's voice actor, Miyano Mamoru... But liked his voice... fits him very well... For me, the new opening wasn't so bad... and the ending is more or less... Loved the fight scenes... the animation was very good. The only bad part was May's introduction... Possk said: Okies, finally saw it. Pretty good; May's opening was bad though, even if a person hadn't read the manga. It's like she's so..randomly entered. I mean, she was pretty random in the manga with her introduction, but at least it made more sense to how she got to Scar and Yoki. Still, Ling's introduction made up for it. xD Poor poor Ed, he wasn't expecting that. Ling's voice actor is really good too. 0-0 Fits him well. Agree... |
| Where i can download the episode!?!? i want to watch! |
| Changing for the Sake of the future |
luigi21 said: I can only speak for my self, but I usually watch it live on KeyHoleTV but you find raws for it, too.Where i can download the episode!?!? i want to watch! |
ジリティック♡BEGINNER |
| I liked the ED, but the OP the former was much better, the episode was very funny o// |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Are they gonna fucking sub it or what? |
| nice: Scar vs Mei-chan Scar vs Xiao-Mei Ling pace not so nice: OP song overall: nice ^_^ PS I've just noticed that Ran Fan looks like Ogiue from Genshiken manga... |
 |
brettchalupa said: Swiftblade said: Are they gonna fucking sub it or what? Give it time buddy. :) Kinda hard to give them time when they've been releasing it on Sunday every week. |
| You'll get over it. =P You could always ask for your money back!!!! -.- |
Swiftblade said: brettchalupa said: Swiftblade said: Are they gonna fucking sub it or what? Give it time buddy. :) Kinda hard to give them time when they've been releasing it on Sunday every week. I know Eclipse's original parent server was shut down by Funi for distributing FMA:Brotherhood. Maybe they finally caved in even though they are running on a new server? I hope not.... I just peeked on their site and they have nothing listed for episode 15 yet. |
 |
Swiftblade said: brettchalupa said: Swiftblade said: Are they gonna fucking sub it or what? Give it time buddy. :) Kinda hard to give them time when they've been releasing it on Sunday every week. New OP and ED means more time. |
brettchalupa said: Omegaoveride said: Swiftblade said: brettchalupa said: Swiftblade said: Are they gonna fucking sub it or what? Give it time buddy. :) Kinda hard to give them time when they've been releasing it on Sunday every week. I know Eclipse's original parent server was shut down by Funi for distributing FMA:Brotherhood. Maybe they finally caved in even though they are running on a new server? I hope not.... I just peeked on their site and they have nothing listed for episode 15 yet. I was afraid of this too, but I would like to know if it is confirmed or speculation. SF or Darksoul subs should be out relatively soon I hope. I was on Eclipse's IRC tonight. No "official" dropping of the series stated. The one in charge of subs probably took the night off or something its not like these guys are getting paid to do this so I will wait patiently for Eclipse to deliver. |
| |
| cant wait to watch this episode :) i love ling.......he's my all time fav character from FMA lol |
| man, how i want eclipse and mkv right now D': |
  |
| Some new group translated ep 15, KG subs. I prefer eclipse thou. |
| LIIIIIIIIIIIIIING <3 RANFAN >3 MEI<3 and even that old ninja geezer! Episode was great, tought i was little disappointed because they cut Risa's phone call to Mustang, but oh well it was okey because there is ling vs Wrath battle scene at opening :D. |
Possk said: ...Must...see....Ling....must...see.....*dies from not seeing 15 yet* Damn I'm pathetic to want to see this guy so badly. BUT I TOTALLY FEEL FOR YOU. I've only seen the opening so far, I'm gonna watch the episode when I find a better translation xP But seeing Ling in the op alone made me go like SPAZZOMFG. I can't help it, I love this guy to no end and what happens later in the manga is just the cherry on top of the cake that is Ling. I've been waiting for his appearance in the anime since I've first seen him in the manga. And then I found out his seiyuu is Miyano. SO FUCKING AWESOME x3 I love Miyano. Ok, I'm literally jumping on my chair here. God, I never expected being a fangirl. Dx So sad. But I can't believe they cut out Roy's Glowing Eyes of Doom and the 'extra hot flame' line Dx I have no idea how to deal with torrents BUT I'M GONNA FIND OUT. For the sake of the link few posts above. |
- If you believe this place holds you, it is a prison. If you do not wish to leave, it will become a fortress. Current icon: Kusuriuri from Mononoke by pana (LJ username) |
| ep full with win! new characters! lol moments! fights! and omg plot is so different and that is also very great, well i just love this anime so far! 8} have to get used to new op though, i liked 1st one very much so it's a bit sad.. btw ppl, what's with wrath? the one from fma 1, was he kinda like filler character? here wrath is supposed to be fuhrer? ..confusion here =/ |
| |
| i like the new op.! :) i like the song of the ending. |
Shadoww said: btw ppl, what's with wrath? the one from fma 1, was he kinda like filler character? here wrath is supposed to be fuhrer? ..confusion here =/ Oh, no, you should separate the 1st and the 2nd anime, they're completely different. I haven't watched the 1st one but if Wrath wasn't Bradley, then it WAS filler. Manga Wrath is Bradley. Think of this anime as of a completely different story. If not, you're gonna be confused. |
- If you believe this place holds you, it is a prison. If you do not wish to leave, it will become a fortress. Current icon: Kusuriuri from Mononoke by pana (LJ username) |
| Ling!!! Oh what a great episode Can't wait for the 'boot' scene lol |
 |
| Cool Ep. but the subs i watched sucked ass. |
| I like Xiao Mei, she's cute. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Cenedess said: Shadoww said: btw ppl, what's with wrath? the one from fma 1, was he kinda like filler character? here wrath is supposed to be fuhrer? ..confusion here =/ Oh, no, you should separate the 1st and the 2nd anime, they're completely different. I haven't watched the 1st one but if Wrath wasn't Bradley, then it WAS filler. Manga Wrath is Bradley. Think of this anime as of a completely different story. If not, you're gonna be confused. yes it was filler....in the frist one bradley was pride and wrath was ed/al's master's kid |
suigetsu00 said: Cenedess said: Shadoww said: btw ppl, what's with wrath? the one from fma 1, was he kinda like filler character? here wrath is supposed to be fuhrer? ..confusion here =/ Oh, no, you should separate the 1st and the 2nd anime, they're completely different. I haven't watched the 1st one but if Wrath wasn't Bradley, then it WAS filler. Manga Wrath is Bradley. Think of this anime as of a completely different story. If not, you're gonna be confused. yes it was filler....in the frist one bradley was pride and wrath was ed/al's master's kid Haha no way xD I hope none of the FMA1 fans will be offended when I say BULLCRAP. Lol. I need to watch that episode but I want the good quality subs x_X Ehh, be patient, be patient. |
- If you believe this place holds you, it is a prison. If you do not wish to leave, it will become a fortress. Current icon: Kusuriuri from Mononoke by pana (LJ username) |
| SWEET The Xing guys finally appear!!!! aww the part with Barry was cut short only with the massive pistoling and short questioning |
 True or False Anime + Manga = Chuck Norris / Chuck Norris |
Cenedess said: suigetsu00 said: Cenedess said: Shadoww said: btw ppl, what's with wrath? the one from fma 1, was he kinda like filler character? here wrath is supposed to be fuhrer? ..confusion here =/ Oh, no, you should separate the 1st and the 2nd anime, they're completely different. I haven't watched the 1st one but if Wrath wasn't Bradley, then it WAS filler. Manga Wrath is Bradley. Think of this anime as of a completely different story. If not, you're gonna be confused. yes it was filler....in the frist one bradley was pride and wrath was ed/al's master's kid Haha no way xD I hope none of the FMA1 fans will be offended when I say BULLCRAP. Lol. I need to watch that episode but I want the good quality subs x_X Ehh, be patient, be patient. Not to mention that FMA1 kept Tucker alive as Rabbit Chimera, with upside down head. Oh and Sloth was Ed's mother thar As for quality. There are no quality subs for now. The ones that exist well...are almost impossible to understand Quoting the current subs: "Not bad but scratch, I get high!" "Scratch? I blow scratch high" "What this is?" |
|
Fai said: Not to mention that FMA1 kept Tucker alive as Rabbit Chimera, with upside down head. Oh and Sloth was Ed's mother thar As for quality. There are no quality subs for now. The ones that exist well...are almost impossible to understand Quoting the current subs: "Not bad but scratch, I get high!" "Scratch? I blow scratch high" "What this is?" XDD Ok, I'm sorry, but I think they reached new heights of Asspulling there XD As for the subs that are present at the moment - I got through the beginning but I didn't really get the Scar/Silver Alchemist conversation AT ALL. So I turned it off. I'M WAITING FOR HIGH QUALITY LING QUOTES. (Oh, and to be perfectly clear, this is NOT supposed to be jerkass rushing the subbing groups, I'm just stating a fact there :) I figure that if I can't help, I shouldn't at leat complain, yep? xP) ...but actually, I get much more pleasure this way, waiting for Ling to appear on-screen x3 And no, I won't stop talking about him xD I'm sorry. |
- If you believe this place holds you, it is a prison. If you do not wish to leave, it will become a fortress. Current icon: Kusuriuri from Mononoke by pana (LJ username) |
Cenedess said: Shadoww said: btw ppl, what's with wrath? the one from fma 1, was he kinda like filler character? here wrath is supposed to be fuhrer? ..confusion here =/ Oh, no, you should separate the 1st and the 2nd anime, they're completely different. I haven't watched the 1st one but if Wrath wasn't Bradley, then it WAS filler. Manga Wrath is Bradley. Think of this anime as of a completely different story. If not, you're gonna be confused. i know that fma 1 & movie is separated story like it never even happened because it's not after manga, i was wondering because everyone else from homunculis team are the same at this fma too and then there was no wrath, but wrath came out to be fuhrer afterall, so u wont tell me fuhrer will reveal his "true" form or something as this kid..  ..at some moment of story? well i guess not...i'm gonna miss this ^ character a bit however, but luckily this, the real version of Fma has some new cool characters instead, take for instance Ling xD |
ShadowwJul 14, 2009 2:12 PM
| |
Shadoww said: .i'm gonna miss this ^ character a bit however, Sadly I wont. Hated that character, voice and anything surrounding his storyline to the core. Hated how stupid Izumi would act around him, Hated his almost abnormal relationship with Sloth/Ed's_Mother, hated him for Thankfully his VA does a perfect(that is, different from his FMA1 role) job as Ran Fan(Ling's female guard) in FMA:B, so I can forget how annoying that VA sounded in FMA1... |
AhenshihaelJul 14, 2009 2:48 PM
|
Fai said: Shadoww said: .i'm gonna miss this ^ character a bit however, Sadly I wont. Hated that character, voice and anything surrounding his storyline to the core. Hated how stupid Izumi would act around him, Hated his almost abnormal relationship with Sloth/Ed's_Mother, hated him for Agreed. I couldn't stand the little twerp. x___x And that was before I'd even set eyes on the manga. Looking back...FMA1 really made a lot of stupid plot choices compared to the actual manga storyline. Meh. Oh well. If I hadn't watched it, I wouldn't have read the manga, and thus I would not have heard of the epicness that is Ling Yao. LING. *dies* Damn I loved his introduction in this episode. xD That definitely wasn't your average stray. |
| Great to see Ling in his animated glory. His VA is perfect. Looking forward to more. |
| New OP and ED =D and new characters =D XD at Ling when he was saying he didnt understand the country's language forcing them to fix everything XD |
| OP Much better then the first, ED is alright but not as good. |
![http://myanimelist.net/signature/Oxu.png"](http://myanimelist.net/signature/Oxu.png"){kind=link}
| Is it possible to die from FMA2 starvation? >_< need it now! |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )kurotsuki - Apr 12, 2009 |
369 |
by MaryMastersMedia
»»
Oct 4, 8:27 AM |
|
Poll: » Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Veronin - Apr 5, 2009 |
624 |
by MaryMastersMedia
»»
Oct 4, 8:24 AM |
|
Poll: » Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Ahenshihael - Apr 19, 2009 |
325 |
by Denebb
»»
Oct 3, 11:02 PM |
|
Poll: » Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Episode 23 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Ahenshihael - Sep 13, 2009 |
200 |
by fwk2v
»»
Oct 3, 7:15 AM |
|
Poll: » Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Episode 59 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Ahenshihael - May 30, 2010 |
237 |
by grimjaw1513
»»
Oct 2, 4:02 AM |