What don't you like about AoT?

deg said:


Attack on Titan is clearly a Plot Driven Story though instead of a Character Driven Story

deg said:
@Watchanime324

meh youre too triggered by this so this is my last reply to you

anyway Occams Razor says the most simple explanation is likely the correct one in most cases so thats how me and those Eren fans think of the second part as for the first part again its just the rule of cool

ktg said:
After S4 the story turned into a pretty illogical mess. Even the new episode was a joke compared to the first 3 season.

LucisCael said:
I don't really understand those who say that AOT justifies genocide... when Eren not only doesn't succeed in the end, but the main cast is literally opposing the genocide. It's the Jaegerists (both in the anime, and in the fanbase) who justify it, thinking it's the only solution for "peace".

coshkunz said:
Mappa is shıt at choosing battle soundtracks.
Reiner is interesting but I'm not a fan of the other characters so I watch it for the plot. It's still a good story, not denying that. 
Still find SOME of the CGI scenes hideous to look at, ofc there are tolerable ones. 

Bhaskar_Singh said:
@moptop2 don't bother with this @ktg guy. If he is being a pusssy, ask him how does spinal fluid works in human body according to his above 99% IQ.Lol. 

jacoblays said:
Wow, it's amazing how someone can be so ignorant and unappreciative of quality art and sound design. It's clear that you have absolutely no idea what you're talking about when it comes to Mappa's battle soundtracks. You're just another uneducated and unsophisticated viewer who lacks the ability to appreciate the nuance and intricacy of the music. And let's not even get started on your shallow understanding of the characters. Reiner may be interesting, but you clearly have no appreciation for the depth and complexity of the other characters. It's no wonder you're only watching for the plot, because that's all your limited mind can handle. And don't even get me started on your critique of the CGI scenes. Clearly, you lack the artistic eye to appreciate the beauty and innovation of the animation techniques used. But what can we expect from someone with such a narrow-minded and unrefined taste in anime? Maybe one day you'll be able to rise above your shallow opinions and truly appreciate the masterpieces that Mappa has created.

Ki11grave said:
I feel like the main problem with Attack on Titan is that it cares about its great plot way too much over characters. Most of them are one-dimentional and passive. Look at Sasha, for example. Her last word was 'meat'. This moment will always be both tragic and ridiculous for me. Is this the only thing Sasha could think about?

Catalano said:
I'll be very brief, I love the show like no other but there's a big thing on my mind since I first saw it in 2013
We never get to see Mikasa or any other chick naked and that is horrible
How come violence is permitted but not nipslips? I just want a scene where Mikasa is having a shower and we see her tits or a scene where Historia is changing clothes and we see her butt naked just before putting on a bra
So yeah, I hate the fact that I don't know how pink are Historia's nipples

_weyhxx said:
Annies character. more like inconsistency between the reaction of the main squad to reiner and to annie. reiner says many times he is sorry for what he did, he even blames himself that he is the reason the rumbling started. and none of the main squad says something against it. jean hit him in the face for killing so many people and so on.
annie on the other side gets no punishment for what she did... yeah she dont wanted it, but cmon she played with the soldiers like with a yoyo. she said she didnt wanted this, but still kills them brutally. also after jean snapped and hits reiner she blames the others for being nothing diffrent, bc they killed too. she never apologized for what she did.
reiner gets punished the whole time and no one likes him, for obvious reasons, but with annie everything is okay, even armin fell in love with her... wtf man...

another thing is the brutality mikasa killed her comrades on the harbour fight. like she had to do it, but she def didn't needed to explode them and showering in the blood rain.

but overall thos are some major issues I have with AoT, but it's still my favourite show of all time, bc those are just small things which are don't damage the quality of the show too much.

MAXproARYAN said:
Tbf, even though i would say AOT makes my top 10, i think it could have done Better
in character writing, i dont really like many characters in the show , and no one besdies eren have any depth. So despite all the deaths, none feel that tragic simply bcuz we never got to know more about them

Shioreru said:
Most of the characters are one-dimensional. For example, Misaka only cares about Eren and basically nothing else, though she at least stopped being annoying in the final season. Most of the side characters get tossed away for example Historia who became queen in season 3 is barely in the final season. Overall Aot is a good anime with weak characters IMO, Isasyama cares too much for the plot rather than the characters. 

moptop2 said:
Plenty of the characters have depth, maybe not as well as Eren but his actions are driving the plot. Hange, Armin, Jean, Reiner, Gabi, Mikasa, Galliard, Zeke, Grisha, Keith, Magath, Connie, Bertolt, Levi, Floch, Erwin are some. AoT does a great job of cutting the fat, they don't have long, drawn out episodes where we learn about the side characters just to induce a tear when they die. If the relationship doesn't move the plot forward it probably isn't going to get a focused episode on it, which is good because I don't want a few episodes about Marco or Moblit just to make me cry more when their current screen time is sufficient for viewers to understand their importance to the main cast

MAXproARYAN said:

Well , they dont have to use an entire ep to flesh out the characters. Erwin was pretty well written, i really like Levi but thats mostly cuz he is cool, other than that rest are meh imo.
There are plenty of anime with way more well written characters in way less episodes than AOT , but the again, AOT has a  better story, so ig it kinda makes sense .
Tho my point still stands imo, but you are free to have your own opinion

moptop2 said:
Well if your point is that you simply don't like them, you're entitled to that. If your point is that they have no depth or are poorly written, well that's just not true. Half the characters I named are as well written or have more depth than Erwin, and they have greater relevance to the overall themes of the show (For example Hange, Zeke, Grisha, Gabi, Reiner, Jean, Armin). 

Which anime has more well written characters in less episodes for example? 

MAXproARYAN said:

Well i would say anime like bungou stray dogs ,made in abyss and  a place further than universe did an insanely good job at writing and developing characters.
When you take someone like Hange for example, what does she have going for her, she is interested in titans? A great leader? Yea but thats about it even tho she was in the show from pratically the start, so even tho
it personally didn't have much effect on me and i doubt many dropped a tear for that.
Same with sasha's death , because she was even less of an important character than Hange imo. But like i said AOT still makes my top 10 and for solid reasons, i think its really good and im not hating on it, just my personal biased opinion