Kazzeon said: I didn't know alot of those started off as one-shots, I think I'll read Elfen Lied, thank you!Gythia said: Hey, I need some help with #26 (Read a manga that is not ranked), #106 (Read a manga with a vehicle on the cover), and #126 (Read a manga based on a one-shot that got serialized), something completed, fully translated, and under 20 volumes would be great thank you Koe no Katachi, Tokyo Ghoul, Death Note? :) FMA, Shaman King Flowers (apparently), Furou Kyoudai, Medaka Box, Rosario + Vampire, Elfen Lied.. |
 |
Matshews said: Yo, can I get a recommendation for number 95? Yo! Let's see.. 👀 You might like Tsurebito if you liked Mushishi. Homunculus Aku no Hana Jumyou wo Kaitotte Moratta. Ichinen ni Tsuki, Ichimanen de. Onanie Master Kurosawa Sundome Ningen Shikkaku The Horizon :D |
Gythia said: Miss__Manga__ said: 27:Hi all! Any suggestions for the following? 27 - manga that has scored higher than its anime adaption 24 - a manga that has not been adapted in any way 68 - Read a manga featuring a deity. - Suggestions: Gods | Goddess/es --> Saint Young Men counts, right? 83 - Read a manga with a main character that is a professional in their field. - The MC needs to earn a living with it. 96 - rec me something please! 102 - Read a manga that started publishing in the month you joined MAL (any year). --> I follow the google instructions but I only get three results? I joined in April. 125. Read a manga with a franchise/series associated mobile/gacha game. --> something about idols would be great Thank you all so much~ 24: 68 - Saint Young Men counts yeah 83: 96: 102: 125 - I haven't read any, sorry Thanks so much for all your help :) |
  |
kawaii1324 said: I need a recommendation for #95: Read a manga recommended by any MRC staff. (Pretty much free range for rec's just no horror please~) ∀・) Voynich Hotel, Shigeshoushi, Tamashii no Futago, About Death, Fujimi Lovers. Going with a bit of a theme here. |
kawaii1324 said: I need a recommendation for #95: Read a manga recommended by any MRC staff. (Pretty much free range for rec's just no horror please~) (・∀ Going with a different theme Power!! Nijiiro Days Machida-kun no Sekai Manga de Yomu Jinsei ga Tokimeku Katazuke no Mahou Hana to Sakazuki |
| Is there a sign up form for all of the 127 challenges for this challenge? I was planning on trying to go for all of them just like in the anime one, but I wasn't sure if I had to just fill those in myself, which wouldn't be the end of the world. Thanks. |
Kyou85Kirino96 said: Is there a sign up form for all of the 127 challenges for this challenge? I was planning on trying to go for all of them just like in the anime one, but I wasn't sure if I had to just fill those in myself, which wouldn't be the end of the world. Thanks. There is not, unfortunately. |
Kazzeon said: Kyou85Kirino96 said: Is there a sign up form for all of the 127 challenges for this challenge? I was planning on trying to go for all of them just like in the anime one, but I wasn't sure if I had to just fill those in myself, which wouldn't be the end of the world. Thanks. There is not, unfortunately. Ah okay. No worries then! I'll just come up with my own later this month. I don't really know if that's something anyone else is interested in but I can put it somewhere, I suppose. |
| Must i read the mangas according to the items order? or i can go randomally? Also, can i use mangas i haven't finished yet but started before the challange? or i can only use those i started since the challange sign up? |
Reef7 said: Must i read the mangas according to the items order? or i can go randomally? Also, can i use mangas i haven't finished yet but started before the challange? or i can only use those i started since the challange sign up? Any order you want. You can use manga you started before the challenge as long as you have 5 or more volumes left. |
| Hiyo team, can I get some recommendations? 96) Read a manga recommended to you by another participant in the discussion thread. I'm into lighter comedy kinda stuff, but can work with pretty much anything except battle shounen. |
CureEtude said: Hiyo team, can I get some recommendations? 96) Read a manga recommended to you by another participant in the discussion thread. I'm into lighter comedy kinda stuff, but can work with pretty much anything except battle shounen. Here you have a few personal recs my dude: Kakukaku Shikajika Yugami-kun ni wa Tomodachi ga Inai Machida-kun no Sekai Spirit Circle |
| Hello! I'm doing KuraikoDesu's card and had a question regarding the Stats section, specifically 31-36. For example: Read a manga that is 2-5/6-12/13-20 volumes in length. Does this mean reading a manga that is 2-20 volumes? |
  |
TambalaiAri said: Hello! I'm doing KuraikoDesu's card and had a question regarding the Stats section, specifically 31-36. For example: Read a manga that is 2-5/6-12/13-20 volumes in length. Does this mean reading a manga that is 2-20 volumes? Yes, exactly that. |
TambalaiAri said: Hello! I'm doing KuraikoDesu's card and had a question regarding the Stats section, specifically 31-36. For example: Read a manga that is 2-5/6-12/13-20 volumes in length. Does this mean reading a manga that is 2-20 volumes? Idk why, but I was under the impression that the different categories given in this challenge were for different difficulties. |
 |
Crossark said: TambalaiAri said: Hello! I'm doing KuraikoDesu's card and had a question regarding the Stats section, specifically 31-36. For example: Read a manga that is 2-5/6-12/13-20 volumes in length. Does this mean reading a manga that is 2-20 volumes? Idk why, but I was under the impression that the different categories given in this challenge were for different difficulties. That's how it used to be, when the items were different based on the difficulty. |
| Can someone answer my question? This is the first time I'm doing this challenge. Is there a limit to number of volumes of a manga which I can use for this challenge? Like for example, can I read a manga which has only 4 volumes (or less)? (Sorry if my question doesn't make sense to you :p) |
 "FALL OFF YOUR HORSE!" - Gyro Zeppeli |
_rao_ said: Can someone answer my question? This is the first time I'm doing this challenge. Is there a limit to number of volumes of a manga which I can use for this challenge? Like for example, can I read a manga which has only 4 volumes (or less)? (Sorry if my question doesn't make sense to you :p) Unless the item specifies a number of volumes (e.g. Read a manga that is 2-5/6-12/13-20 volumes, which means between 2 and 20, or Read a One-shot), you are free to read manga with as many volumes as you want as long as you started it this year. In case you are using a manga you've started before 2022, you must read at least the last 5 volumes. I hope I was clear enough, and welcome to the challenge! |
Armandoriel said: _rao_ said: Can someone answer my question? This is the first time I'm doing this challenge. Is there a limit to number of volumes of a manga which I can use for this challenge? Like for example, can I read a manga which has only 4 volumes (or less)? (Sorry if my question doesn't make sense to you :p) Unless the item specifies a number of volumes (e.g. Read a manga that is 2-5/6-12/13-20 volumes, which means between 2 and 20, or Read a One-shot), you are free to read manga with as many volumes as you want as long as you started it this year. In case you are using a manga you've started before 2022, you must read at least the last 5 volumes. I hope I was clear enough, and welcome to the challenge! Thank you so much! :D |
"FALL OFF YOUR HORSE!" - Gyro Zeppeli |
| hello mrc staff, i need recs for #95 please :D i'm alright with anything not super heavy (like berserk) and i'd also prefer if the chapter count is less than 100, thanks! |
 |
iirayuki said: hello mrc staff, i need recs for #95 please :D i'm alright with anything not super heavy (like berserk) and i'd also prefer if the chapter count is less than 100, thanks! Hello iirayuki. :D Something not super heavy with less than 100 chapters, got it. Nazo no Kanojo X. 😏 Prunus Girl, Fujimi Lovers, Sankarea, Game Over, Seishun Forget!, Isshuukan Friends., Futari no Renai Shoka, Kanojo wa Rokurokubi, Kimi no Suizou wo Tabetai. Not romance: Kamisama no Iutoori, Transfer Student Storm Bringer, Gunnm. |
Kazzeon said: iirayuki said: hello mrc staff, i need recs for #95 please :D i'm alright with anything not super heavy (like berserk) and i'd also prefer if the chapter count is less than 100, thanks! Hello iirayuki. :D Something not super heavy with less than 100 chapters, got it. Nazo no Kanojo X. 😏 Prunus Girl, Fujimi Lovers, Sankarea, Game Over, Seishun Forget!, Isshuukan Friends., Futari no Renai Shoka, Kanojo wa Rokurokubi, Kimi no Suizou wo Tabetai. Not romance: Kamisama no Iutoori, Transfer Student Storm Bringer, Gunnm. those are great recs, i'll read all of them in the future! thank you :) |
|
| I'd like some recommendations for, (96) Read a manga recommended to you by another participant in the discussion thread. I usually tend to like psychological, mystery and action, but I'm fine with anything as long as it's completed. |
"FALL OFF YOUR HORSE!" - Gyro Zeppeli |
_rao_ said: I'd like some recommendations for, (96) Read a manga recommended to you by another participant in the discussion thread. I usually tend to like psychological, mystery and action, but I'm fine with anything as long as it's completed. Here you have a few, hope some catch your interest! Action manga I recommend to everyone - Sengoku Youko Some cool police inspector stuff - Jiraishin A great psychological/mystery - Homunculus A different type of psychological, a manhwa this time! - Bastard And some fun horror - Shigahime |
Armandoriel said: _rao_ said: I'd like some recommendations for, (96) Read a manga recommended to you by another participant in the discussion thread. I usually tend to like psychological, mystery and action, but I'm fine with anything as long as it's completed. Here you have a few, hope some catch your interest! Action manga I recommend to everyone - Sengoku Youko Some cool police inspector stuff - Jiraishin A great psychological/mystery - Homunculus A different type of psychological, a manhwa this time! - Bastard And some fun horror - Shigahime Thanks! I'll definitely check 'em out! :D |
"FALL OFF YOUR HORSE!" - Gyro Zeppeli |
| Can someone reccomend me manga for #4 "Read a web/4-koma manga" is web manga that isn't 4-koma will be concidered? |
Reef7 said: Can someone reccomend me manga for #4 "Read a web/4-koma manga" is web manga that isn't 4-koma will be concidered? I haven't read many, but here you have a couple: You can be one of the first 50 people in the site to read this - Akita Land Gothic Animals and a lot of green - Harinezumi no Harry A classic (quality may vary) - Azumanga Daioh One of (if not) the best, still publishing though - Gekkan Shoujo Nozaki-kun |
Reef7 said: Can someone reccomend me manga for #4 "Read a web/4-koma manga" is web manga that isn't 4-koma will be concidered? Relife, Bastard, Friendly Winter, The Horizon, Something about us, Kuro (Somato), Good day to be a dog, The descending moon at the foot of the mountain. :) Yep! |
Reef7 said: Can someone reccomend me manga for #4 "Read a web/4-koma manga" is web manga that isn't 4-koma will be concidered? If you're looking for 4-koma recommendations, I strongly recommend Gekkan Shoujo Nozaki-kun. This link will take you to Baka Updates' list of every series categorized as a 4-koma, sorted by how highly they've been rated. As for webmanga, I'm much less well-versed. I have a question of my own, though. For one of my challenges, I'm reading Unmagical Girl, which technically has 3 volumes of which only 2 have been officially released in a physical edition in English (with no more releases planned by Seven Seas, according to their website). I want to avoid any issues, so I wanted to verify: Is it okay for me to just read the two physical copies that are available in English, since I started reading it in the physical English editions? Or should I go ahead and read the third volume on a scanlation website just to be safe? |
CrossarkFeb 15, 2022 6:13 PM
|
Crossark said: I have a question of my own, though. For one of my challenges, I'm reading Unmagical Girl, which technically has 3 volumes of which only 2 have been officially released in a physical edition in English (with no more releases planned by Seven Seas, according to their website). I want to avoid any issues, so I wanted to verify: Is it okay for me to just read the two physical copies that are available in English, since I started reading it in the physical English editions? Or should I go ahead and read the third volume on a scanlation website just to be safe? It's ok. :) If you're already planning on reading the last volume anyway, though, it'd be easier if you marked it in the challenge as completed. However you prefer. |
| Hi! I just wanna clarify if the tags in manga-updates are the sole basis for the validity of the items read for some specific niches in the challenge. To elaborate, I was planning to use Geinoujin no Yatsura for challenge 64 seeing as how it has the magical boy tag in manga-updates. Upon reading it however the story ain't as "magical boy" as it seems save for some magical aspects that were otherwise incorporated poorly. Seeing as how manga-updates is used as a basis for most of these genre-and-tag-specific challenges, that got me thinking if the actual content of the stories in our lists will be verified by the staff upon submission and not just base it on what manga-updates says. so yea tldr: am i allowed to use geinoujin no yatsura for challenge 64? also I'm aware that I can always just read another magical girl/boy manga for this challenge like say madoka if i ain't satisfied with the one i just read, but I'm kinda doing another challenge alongside MRC 2022 wherein i only use bl or titles that lean towards bl for this challenge, and finding a bl that's also a magical boy manga was already quite hard lol. |
  |
mehmeh-san said: Hi! I just wanna clarify if the tags in manga-updates are the sole basis for the validity of the items read for some specific niches in the challenge. To elaborate, I was planning to use Geinoujin no Yatsura for challenge 64 seeing as how it has the magical boy tag in manga-updates. Upon reading it however the story ain't as "magical boy" as it seems save for some magical aspects that were otherwise incorporated poorly. Seeing as how manga-updates is used as a basis for most of these genre-and-tag-specific challenges, that got me thinking if the actual content of the stories in our lists will be verified by the staff upon submission and not just base it on what manga-updates says. so yea tldr: am i allowed to use geinoujin no yatsura for challenge 64? also I'm aware that I can always just read another magical girl/boy manga for this challenge like say madoka if i ain't satisfied with the one i just read, but I'm kinda doing another challenge alongside MRC 2022 wherein i only use bl or titles that lean towards bl for this challenge, and finding a bl that's also a magical boy manga was already quite hard lol. Hey there. :) Yes, the tags in mangaupdates work as validation for the items. We can't really read every manga the participants submit, so that's how it has to work. If you asked us beforehand, we could tell you that it's not about what it says it is, but it would be up to you whether you decide to read it or not. Since you already read it, don't worry about it. On the other hand, if you read something that doesn't have the tag, but you say is valid, we can also count it, after we check. |
Kazzeon said: mehmeh-san said: Hi! I just wanna clarify if the tags in manga-updates are the sole basis for the validity of the items read for some specific niches in the challenge. To elaborate, I was planning to use Geinoujin no Yatsura for challenge 64 seeing as how it has the magical boy tag in manga-updates. Upon reading it however the story ain't as "magical boy" as it seems save for some magical aspects that were otherwise incorporated poorly. Seeing as how manga-updates is used as a basis for most of these genre-and-tag-specific challenges, that got me thinking if the actual content of the stories in our lists will be verified by the staff upon submission and not just base it on what manga-updates says. so yea tldr: am i allowed to use geinoujin no yatsura for challenge 64? also I'm aware that I can always just read another magical girl/boy manga for this challenge like say madoka if i ain't satisfied with the one i just read, but I'm kinda doing another challenge alongside MRC 2022 wherein i only use bl or titles that lean towards bl for this challenge, and finding a bl that's also a magical boy manga was already quite hard lol. Hey there. :) Yes, the tags in mangaupdates work as validation for the items. We can't really read every manga the participants submit, so that's how it has to work. If you asked us beforehand, we could tell you that it's not about what it says it is, but it would be up to you whether you decide to read it or not. Since you already read it, don't worry about it. On the other hand, if you read something that doesn't have the tag, but you say is valid, we can also count it, after we check. I see! Thanks for clarifying :DD |
| |
| Hi! I wanted to double check that Gon: A Very, Very Lucky Birth counts for item #105 (Read a manga with an animal on the cover). I'm pretty sure it does since Gon is a dinosaur, but I wanted to make sure just in case. |
    |
CCC47 said: Hi! I wanted to double check that Gon: A Very, Very Lucky Birth counts for item #105 (Read a manga with an animal on the cover). I'm pretty sure it does since Gon is a dinosaur, but I wanted to make sure just in case. He do be a dinosaur. :) |
Kazzeon said: CCC47 said: Hi! I wanted to double check that Gon: A Very, Very Lucky Birth counts for item #105 (Read a manga with an animal on the cover). I'm pretty sure it does since Gon is a dinosaur, but I wanted to make sure just in case. He do be a dinosaur. :) Okay, thank you! :D |
|
Bookworm86 said: I am doing Kazzeon's Card and am tackling number 126: (126) Read a manga based on a one-shot that got serialized. Would Claymore, fulfill this requirement? The one-shot is: Claymore Bangai-hen Senshi Reimei-hen. Thanks. Hello. It seems to be an extra published after chapter 125 of the original series. It also doesn't seem to be based on this, as this is just something that happened chronologically before the original series. A one-shot a series is based on usually shows up as Alternative Version in the Related Manga section, and is published beforehand. Here are some examples: https://myanimelist.net/manga/48621/Koe_no_Katachi https://myanimelist.net/manga/80909/Tokyo_Ghoul https://myanimelist.net/manga/3645/-/moreinfo https://myanimelist.net/manga/15143/Medaka_Box So no, it wouldn't count. :) |
Serrio said: Hi! I need a recommendation for #96(Read a manga recommended to you by another participant in the discussion thread.) and #125(Read a manga with a franchise/series associated mobile/gacha game.) please. Here's my manga list if it helps. Also, just wondering, does Kaguya sama wa Kokurasetai Doujin ban count as a doujinshi for Kagura-sama? Thank you :) I'm going by another site's tags for the qualification, but here's some mobile game sourced options for #125. Completed Options: Ore Alice: Danjo Gyakuten Nami Iro IDOLiSH7 Sengoku Night Blood Kemono Friends: Youkoso Japari Park e! Ongoing Options: Disney Twisted-Wonderland Anthology Comic Azur Lane Comic Anthology Azur Lane: Queen's Orders Magia Record: Mahou Shoujo Madoka☆Magica Gaiden Fate/Grand Order: Dengeki Comic Anthology |
   |
| Hello!! I'm looking for a MRC staff recommendation (#95)! My List Likes: Josei, Shojo with a more mature protagonist, Wholesome Content, Romance, Slice of Life, Older Isekai (my sweet spot seems to be ~1990s/2000s Isekai. Not interested in "In my Next Life, I swore there were slimes, now they turned into witches and are my best friends forever!"), Tradegy, Drama, Supernatural, Psychological, Dire Survival 'Games' (ex. Alice in Borderlands, Battle Royale). I'm okay with any kind of more adult content (gore, nudity, ecchi, etc). Dislikes: Yaoi, Yuri, Harem/Reverse Harem, Sports, Mecha, Shounen/Shojo geared towards very young audiences. Preferred Completed Series with less than 10 vols. Can be found in English. Thank you <3 |
Zephyrranth said: Hello!! I'm looking for a MRC staff recommendation (#95)! My List Likes: Josei, Shojo with a more mature protagonist, Wholesome Content, Romance, Slice of Life, Older Isekai (my sweet spot seems to be ~1990s/2000s Isekai. Not interested in "In my Next Life, I swore there were slimes, now they turned into witches and are my best friends forever!"), Tradegy, Drama, Supernatural, Psychological, Dire Survival 'Games' (ex. Alice in Borderlands, Battle Royale). I'm okay with any kind of more adult content (gore, nudity, ecchi, etc). Dislikes: Yaoi, Yuri, Harem/Reverse Harem, Sports, Mecha, Shounen/Shojo geared towards very young audiences. Preferred Completed Series with less than 10 vols. Can be found in English. Thank you <3 By found in English, do you mean physically? (I don't really know about that.) From your list, Game Over. https://myanimelist.net/manga/72007/Bocchi_na_Bokura_no_Renai_Jijou https://myanimelist.net/manga/32201/Boku_wa_Hajikko_ga_Suki https://myanimelist.net/manga/104491/Bokura_no_Shokutaku https://myanimelist.net/manga/99584/Emperor_to_Issho https://myanimelist.net/manga/93695/Ganbare_Nakamura-kun https://myanimelist.net/manga/14115/Prunus_Girl https://myanimelist.net/manga/26404/Seishun_Forget https://myanimelist.net/manga/96573/Something_About_Us https://myanimelist.net/manga/86156/Tonari_no_Robot Hope you enjoy something from here. n_n |
Serrio said: Hi! I need a recommendation for #96(Read a manga recommended to you by another participant in the discussion thread.) and #125(Read a manga with a franchise/series associated mobile/gacha game.) please. Here's my manga list if it helps. Also, just wondering, does Kaguya sama wa Kokurasetai Doujin ban count as a doujinshi for Kagura-sama? Thank you :) This is a tough question, as what a doujin is is pretty vague. This is basically an official spinoff, so let's go with yes for simplicity's sake. |
Kazzeon said: Zephyrranth said: Hello!! I'm looking for a MRC staff recommendation (#95)! My List Likes: Josei, Shojo with a more mature protagonist, Wholesome Content, Romance, Slice of Life, Older Isekai (my sweet spot seems to be ~1990s/2000s Isekai. Not interested in "In my Next Life, I swore there were slimes, now they turned into witches and are my best friends forever!"), Tradegy, Drama, Supernatural, Psychological, Dire Survival 'Games' (ex. Alice in Borderlands, Battle Royale). I'm okay with any kind of more adult content (gore, nudity, ecchi, etc). Dislikes: Yaoi, Yuri, Harem/Reverse Harem, Sports, Mecha, Shounen/Shojo geared towards very young audiences. Preferred Completed Series with less than 10 vols. Can be found in English. Thank you <3 By found in English, do you mean physically? (I don't really know about that.) From your list, Game Over. https://myanimelist.net/manga/72007/Bocchi_na_Bokura_no_Renai_Jijou https://myanimelist.net/manga/32201/Boku_wa_Hajikko_ga_Suki https://myanimelist.net/manga/104491/Bokura_no_Shokutaku https://myanimelist.net/manga/99584/Emperor_to_Issho https://myanimelist.net/manga/93695/Ganbare_Nakamura-kun https://myanimelist.net/manga/14115/Prunus_Girl https://myanimelist.net/manga/26404/Seishun_Forget https://myanimelist.net/manga/96573/Something_About_Us https://myanimelist.net/manga/86156/Tonari_no_Robot Hope you enjoy something from here. n_n 'Can be found in English' - as long as I can find it somewhere online in english (Scans, or On a digital/physical storefront of some kind), I'll be okay :) Oooooh! Some stuff i've never heard of. Thank you <3 |
ZephyrranthFeb 20, 2022 10:26 AM
More topics from this board
Sticky: » 2025 Manga Reading Challenge - Sign-Up ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )MRC_mod - Mar 8 |
356 |
by lemonmon
»»
1 hour ago |
|
» Do you prefer reading Light Novels or Manga?Duado - 4 hours ago |
1 |
by Ymir_The_Viking
»»
4 hours ago |
|
» What are you reading right now? ( 1 2 )nirererin - Jun 24 |
87 |
by Kruszer
»»
9 hours ago |
|
» Manga collection pictures ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )crazekat - Apr 12, 2008 |
266 |
by Kruszer
»»
10 hours ago |
|
» So why do people say manga is better?Zachshock - Oct 8 |
12 |
by deg
»»
10 hours ago |