That Time I got Reincarnated as a Slime
Available on Manga Store
New
Mar 16, 2021 10:17 AM
#1
I'm somewhat conflicted on how I view eating 10000 soldiers. I really like that the show took humanity off a pedestal earlier this season when Rimuru made it home after the attack. But then that escalates quickly to into its OK to eat 10000 humans, genocide style. If this was a darker show like Berserk or Code Gaess, I don't think I'd be conflicted, those shows are gritty enough to handle this kind of gritty theme. This is a rather light-hearted happy go lucky show. The reason Rimuru is even eating the army in the first place is to offer a happy go lucky resurrection to another character. I find myself wishing that it had progressed in a way that got to a place between "we don't need to revere humans" and "its ok to eat hordes of them to save our friend." Stop eating the lvl1 defenseless soldiers. Go eat the generals and royalty and other high-level opponents then I would be fine with it. I don't think "humanity" is the critical thing here either. I think it'd be just as uncomfortable if he was systematically eating goblins or orcs or dragonewts in the way presented. Maybe this tension is intentional and will be addressed at some point in the future, idk. |
Mar 16, 2021 11:29 AM
#2
I think Rimuru's anger was not given justice in the anime. He really quickly got over it and he was shown to be cool headed when he decided to kill the 10000 soldiers. This decision is part anger and part a solution to reviving the fallen. So I think anger is the trigger and the chance to revive the fallen is the justification. At least this is how I view it. |
Mar 16, 2021 11:35 AM
#3
Mar 16, 2021 11:42 AM
#4
Losing your loved ones will push some people over the edge, especially if they feel responsible for their deaths. Rimuru needs to become a Demon Lord in order to revive his fallen companions and he's loves them so much he's willing to go to such lengths as to killing an army of 20k and using their souls to become one. Plus this army is planning to invade his nation, kill his people, and rape the women, they were going to be taken care of one way or another its just very likely they would of have been beaten down and sent packing instead of being outright massacred if they didn't spill the blood of his beloved family. Also slime isn't just a happy go lucky series, we got dark stuff before such as with the orc disaster arc. |
-MahesvaraMar 16, 2021 11:47 AM
My Queens |
Mar 16, 2021 11:43 AM
#5
Also this is war. Peaceful resolution is hard especially if at the start the enemy is winning the battles. If you want a quick win you need to deal huge damage to the enemy so they don't even think about trying to attack you again. |
Mar 16, 2021 11:43 AM
#6
Bfun2468 said: If Rimuru doesnt eat them, they will just die and their soles will just dissapear. Rimuru's kingsom still needs to be defended so either way the enemy needs to die. "Every enemy soldier must die" isn't normal warfare though. Battles happen, some soldiers die, others are wounded, others escape both fates. While "all enemy combatants need to be slain" does happen, it is not the only mode of combat, nor is it even the default. |
Mar 16, 2021 11:58 AM
#7
edgefigaro said: Playing god huh...weighing lives and stuf- nvm just a thought of mine lolI find myself wishing that it had progressed in a way that got to a place between "we don't need to revere humans" and "its ok to eat hordes of them to save our friend." Stop eating the lvl1 defenseless soldiers. Go eat the generals and royalty and other high-level opponents then I would be fine with it. Well, to be fair slime has always had some dark elements since the beginning...remember how Rimuru decapitated the wolf leader or how the Orcs slaughtered and ate other monsters...we prob just think this is more cruel since these are humans and not "mere" animals/furries🥴 Also, I remember hearing that his revenge will even be far worse than that |
asapabriMar 16, 2021 12:04 PM
Mar 16, 2021 12:08 PM
#8
asapabri said: Tbh he just destroys their sole in an instant. There isn't much cruelty going and who likes humans anyway if they are so stubborn and annoying. I would've done the same as Rimuru.edgefigaro said: Playing god huh...weighing lives and stuf- nvm just a thought of mine lolI find myself wishing that it had progressed in a way that got to a place between "we don't need to revere humans" and "its ok to eat hordes of them to save our friend." Stop eating the lvl1 defenseless soldiers. Go eat the generals and royalty and other high-level opponents then I would be fine with it. Well, to be fair slime has always had some dark elements since the beginning...remember how Rimuru decapitated the wolf leader or how the Orcs slaughtered and ate other monsters...we prob just think this is more cruel since these are humans and not "mere" animals/furries🥴 Also, I remember hearing that his revenge will even be far worse than that |
Mar 16, 2021 12:11 PM
#9
Bfun2468 said: asapabri said: Tbh he just destroys their sole in an instant. There isn't much cruelty going and who likes humans anyway if they are so stubborn and annoying. I would've done the same as Rimuru.edgefigaro said: I find myself wishing that it had progressed in a way that got to a place between "we don't need to revere humans" and "its ok to eat hordes of them to save our friend." Stop eating the lvl1 defenseless soldiers. Go eat the generals and royalty and other high-level opponents then I would be fine with it. Well, to be fair slime has always had some dark elements since the beginning...remember how Rimuru decapitated the wolf leader or how the Orcs slaughtered and ate other monsters...we prob just think this is more cruel since these are humans and not "mere" animals/furries🥴 Also, I remember hearing that his revenge will even be far worse than that This man just admitted to mass genocide, agent |
Mar 16, 2021 12:42 PM
#10
asapabri said: What would you do if you were in Rimuru's position, be honest. Bfun2468 said: asapabri said: edgefigaro said: Playing god huh...weighing lives and stuf- nvm just a thought of mine lolI find myself wishing that it had progressed in a way that got to a place between "we don't need to revere humans" and "its ok to eat hordes of them to save our friend." Stop eating the lvl1 defenseless soldiers. Go eat the generals and royalty and other high-level opponents then I would be fine with it. Well, to be fair slime has always had some dark elements since the beginning...remember how Rimuru decapitated the wolf leader or how the Orcs slaughtered and ate other monsters...we prob just think this is more cruel since these are humans and not "mere" animals/furries🥴 Also, I remember hearing that his revenge will even be far worse than that This man just admitted to mass genocide, agent Also Rimuru didn't start the war, it's not his fault if they die. |
Bfun2468Mar 16, 2021 1:07 PM
Mar 16, 2021 12:48 PM
#11
Watched the episode. The fun and bright anime went directly to genocide. Like, oh, let's kill these 10k soldiers, who have families and are only doing their job. Wtf. I really hate how the anime took such a sharp turn from really good, to genocide of humans. Agree with everything the OP wrote. Anyway, changed my rating of this anime after this episode. The revenge fights were great, but the genocide part is terrible. |
Mar 16, 2021 1:10 PM
#12
O Bfun2468 said: I'm just jk lmaooasapabri said: What would you do if you were in Rimuru's position, be honest. Bfun2468 said: asapabri said: Tbh he just destroys their sole in an instant. There isn't much cruelty going and who likes humans anyway if they are so stubborn and annoying. I would've done the same as Rimuru.edgefigaro said: Playing god huh...weighing lives and stuf- nvm just a thought of mine lolI find myself wishing that it had progressed in a way that got to a place between "we don't need to revere humans" and "its ok to eat hordes of them to save our friend." Stop eating the lvl1 defenseless soldiers. Go eat the generals and royalty and other high-level opponents then I would be fine with it. Well, to be fair slime has always had some dark elements since the beginning...remember how Rimuru decapitated the wolf leader or how the Orcs slaughtered and ate other monsters...we prob just think this is more cruel since these are humans and not "mere" animals/furries🥴 Also, I remember hearing that his revenge will even be far worse than that This man just admitted to mass genocide, agent Also Rimuru didn't start the war, it's not his fault if they die. |
Mar 16, 2021 1:25 PM
#13
I mean it’s either he eats 20,000 people or the 20,000 people eat him |
Mar 16, 2021 1:31 PM
#14
This is not relevant. It is at a lower level than what I am talking about. Asapbri has it right: asapabri said: Playing god huh...weighing lives and stuf- nvm just a thought of mine lol While my choice wouldn't be to use the term "god" this is the level I'm talking about. The author chose to structure the story where eating 10000 people is the solution to a problem. Thus far, this has been presented to us in a rather nonchalant way. These two things put together cause enough of a disconnect for me to post a thread on the forum about it. The author could have chosen to present a different scenario. For example, resolve the situation by eating a big bad evil dude. The author could have chosen to keep the same plotline, but not been so nonchalant about it. For example, if a supporting character was mortified about eating 10000 but Rimuru, in anger, decides to press on. This would be plausible, but as previously mentioned, I don't really feel this show is gritty enough to support that theme. The show thus far hasn't really tried to fit into a space where Rimuru is an anti-hero. |
edgefigaroMar 16, 2021 1:34 PM
Mar 16, 2021 1:46 PM
#15
edgefigaro said: I haven't read any source material tho but I think it could have also just been the anime that lacked to portray it rightly properlyThis is not relevant. It is at a lower level than what I am talking about. Asapbri has it right: asapabri said: Playing god huh...weighing lives and stuf- nvm just a thought of mine lol While my choice wouldn't be to use the term "god" this is the level I'm talking about. The author chose to structure the story where eating 10000 people is the solution to a problem. Thus far, this has been presented to us in a rather nonchalant way. These two things put together cause enough of a disconnect for me to post a thread on the forum about it. The author could have chosen to present a different scenario. For example, resolve the situation by eating a big bad evil dude. The author could have chosen to keep the same plotline, but not been so nonchalant about it. For example, if a supporting character was mortified about eating 10000 but Rimuru, in anger, decides to press on. This would be plausible, but as previously mentioned, I don't really feel this show is gritty enough to support that theme. The show thus far hasn't really tried to fit into a space where Rimuru is an anti-hero. |
Mar 16, 2021 1:50 PM
#16
-Mahesvara said: Losing your loved ones will push some people over the edge, especially if they feel responsible for their deaths. Rimuru needs to become a Demon Lord in order to revive his fallen companions and he's loves them so much he's willing to go to such lengths as to killing an army of 20k and using their souls to become one. Plus this army is planning to invade his nation, kill his people, and rape the women, they were going to be taken care of one way or another its just very likely they would of have been beaten down and sent packing instead of being outright massacred if they didn't spill the blood of his beloved family. Also slime isn't just a happy go lucky series, we got dark stuff before such as with the orc disaster arc. I wonder if it is the "eating" part that makes me uncomfortable. I get the idea of "we need to defend ourselves against being raped and murdered. We are going to have to kill a whole bunch of them to do so." I feel like "we need to eat all of them" is another threshold beyond "we need to kill a bunch of them to defend ourselves from being raped and murdered." I feel like the show presents them at the same level, but I don't feel like they are the same. This in turn makes me wonder why I am ok with all of the other eating scenes. Hmm. Maybe I'm not surprised that this show makes me examine the acceptable boundaries of vore? |
edgefigaroMar 16, 2021 1:54 PM
Mar 16, 2021 2:07 PM
#17
@edgefigaro did you miss the part when rimuru and the gang have massacred 50k of orcs in season 1? it should be noted that these orcs were on the way to sis lake(lizardmen homeland) and then most likely to blumund kingdom rimuru couldve just left these orcs alone, they wouldnt even visit jura tempest federation at all so, now whats so bad about annihilating 20k of human soldiers who are about to invade jura tempest federation? lol |
Lab_Rat_0978Mar 16, 2021 5:22 PM
Mar 16, 2021 2:08 PM
#18
edgefigaro said: Think your taking the eating part to literally, he's only after their souls, not the actually physical flesh lol.-Mahesvara said: Losing your loved ones will push some people over the edge, especially if they feel responsible for their deaths. Rimuru needs to become a Demon Lord in order to revive his fallen companions and he's loves them so much he's willing to go to such lengths as to killing an army of 20k and using their souls to become one. Plus this army is planning to invade his nation, kill his people, and rape the women, they were going to be taken care of one way or another its just very likely they would of have been beaten down and sent packing instead of being outright massacred if they didn't spill the blood of his beloved family. Also slime isn't just a happy go lucky series, we got dark stuff before such as with the orc disaster arc. I wonder if it is the "eating" part that makes me uncomfortable. I get the idea of "we need to defend ourselves against being raped and murdered. We are going to have to kill a whole bunch of them to do so." I feel like "we need to eat all of them" is another threshold beyond "we need to kill a bunch of them to defend ourselves from being raped and murdered." I feel like the show presents them at the same level, but I don't feel like they are the same. This in turn makes me wonder why I am ok with all of the other eating scenes. Hmm. Maybe I'm not surprised that this show makes me examine the acceptable boundaries of vore? |
My Queens |
Mar 16, 2021 2:16 PM
#19
-Mahesvara said: ]Think your taking the eating part to literally, he's only after their souls, not the actually physical flesh lol. Yah, I've thought about this. It is somewhat difficult to make a meaningful distinction. How different is killing them all for the purposes of consuming their soul different from the same action for consuming their flesh? However, if you are accusing me of using charged language to dramatize my point, color me guilty. It is intentional. |
Mar 16, 2021 2:21 PM
#20
edgefigaro said: The soul leaves the body upon death, remember? The magic barrier Rimuru placed is keep the souls from escaping.-Mahesvara said: ]Think your taking the eating part to literally, he's only after their souls, not the actually physical flesh lol. Yah, I've thought about this. It is somewhat difficult to make a meaningful distinction. How different is killing them all for the purposes of consuming their soul different from the same action for consuming their flesh? However, if you are accusing me of using charged language to dramatize my point, color me guilty. It is intentional. |
My Queens |
Mar 16, 2021 2:39 PM
#21
-Mahesvara said: The soul leaves the body upon death, remember? The magic barrier Rimuru placed is keep the souls from escaping. I feel like that detail makes it somewhat more monstrous. It is more clinical. Anyway, in both form and function, soul eating gluttony is so similar to the flesh-eating gluttony that it is difficult to draw meaningful distinctions between the two actions. |
Mar 16, 2021 2:45 PM
#22
edgefigaro said: The soul eating is a necessary step to becoming a Demon Lord which will give him the power to revive his beloved comrades. Its a necessary evil for him.-Mahesvara said: The soul leaves the body upon death, remember? The magic barrier Rimuru placed is keep the souls from escaping. I feel like that detail makes it somewhat more monstrous. It is more clinical. Anyway, in both form and function, soul eating gluttony is so similar to the flesh-eating gluttony that it is difficult to draw meaningful distinctions between the two actions. |
My Queens |
Mar 16, 2021 2:54 PM
#23
edgefigaro said: The manga did it better where most of the solider knew what they where doing was wrong but the liked that, they showed 1 who also knew it was wrong but was doingit anyways for his family & there was also a conversation on rape the monster woman so I'm assuming rimuru heard that which lead to him being totally cold hearted which I likedI'm somewhat conflicted on how I view eating 10000 soldiers. I really like that the show took humanity off a pedestal earlier this season when Rimuru made it home after the attack. But then that escalates quickly to into its OK to eat 10000 humans, genocide style. If this was a darker show like Berserk or Code Gaess, I don't think I'd be conflicted, those shows are gritty enough to handle this kind of gritty theme. This is a rather light-hearted happy go lucky show. The reason Rimuru is even eating the army in the first place is to offer a happy go lucky resurrection to another character. I find myself wishing that it had progressed in a way that got to a place between "we don't need to revere humans" and "its ok to eat hordes of them to save our friend." Stop eating the lvl1 defenseless soldiers. Go eat the generals and royalty and other high-level opponents then I would be fine with it. I don't think "humanity" is the critical thing here either. I think it'd be just as uncomfortable if he was systematically eating goblins or orcs or dragonewts in the way presented. Maybe this tension is intentional and will be addressed at some point in the future, idk. |
Mar 16, 2021 3:07 PM
#24
-Mahesvara said: Its a necessary evil for him. I wish the show was more clear that Rimuru considered it a necessary evil. I wish he was conflicted. I wish the show's nearby characters were somewhat disturbed by what it happening. The idea "we need to go harvest souls to reverse death" is an uncomfortable plotline for the heroes to have. That is traditionally the basis for a villainous destiny, not a heroic one. |
Mar 16, 2021 3:43 PM
#25
edgefigaro said: I wish he was conflicted. You may be forgetting that Rimuru isn't a human anymore after reincarnation and his emotions may not be exactly what you could expect. When he was grieving next to Shion's body: "All these intense emotions are raging in my head, but at the same time, I'm painfully calm. I can't even shed a single tear. Oh, I get it. I've become a monster at heart, too." If you read the source material, you will probably get more satisfying exposure to Rimuru's feelings if that's what you're looking for. The anime has a limited runtime after all. Also, no need to talk about eating/vore to exaggerate. It's not what's being depicted and just weakens your point. |
Mar 16, 2021 3:53 PM
#26
The soldier came to kill all the monsters with a spell making them sort of defenseless. And now ppl complain that he retaliates and kill soldiers with families and such, don't make me laugh it's war, plus they were on their way to exterminate them. If that was the opposite with monster having killed a humain village, you would have no complain about some human heroes avenging them by killing monsters. For 1 episode and a half he's explaining he feels more monster than human. I don't see the issue. I would have disliked the show if he would have say 'no don't attack the army I will negotiate with them'. On the contrary we at last witness a show that goes toward a different direction than your average shounen, let's see how it will turn out. |
Mar 16, 2021 5:09 PM
#27
skysurf said: If you read the source material, you will probably get more satisfying exposure to Rimuru's feelings if that's what you're looking for. The anime has a limited runtime after all. Also, no need to talk about eating/vore to exaggerate. It's not what's being depicted and just weakens your point. Re: source material. I suspected as much, but there is a large enough hole for me to be curious. Also, I'm using charged language because the show is downplaying what is happening. The heros are harvesting a mass quantity of souls to power a resurrection spell. That shouldn't be downplayed. No vore? I spent the entire episode wondering how soul harvesting worked and if it was related to gluttony. I get to the end of this episode and he hasn't started to physically consume them but he is certainly physically killing all of them for the purpose of consuming something. His power has been consuming things in the past. The episode ends and I still don't know how the whole soul-consumption thing is going to go. However, I'd come to the conclusion that the difference between physical consumption and soul consumption is trivial, it certainly is going to have the physical killing part along with the consumption part. That is too late. I'm already uncomfortable. I'm curious as to why I'm uncomfortable. There are a lot of things in the show that I'm100% comfortable with. He has eaten a lot of other characters in the show and I never batted an eye. I'm curious as to where those distinctions lay. If one of the sources of my discomfort is the eating part, I don't have a better term for it than vore. It has everything i'm looking for in a word. It is emotionally charged and kinda messed up term to describe something I am claiming to be more emotionally charged and messed up than presented. ManteR said: The soldier came to kill all the monsters with a spell making them sort of defenseless. And now ppl complain that he retaliates and kill soldiers with families and such, don't make me laugh it's war, plus they were on their way to exterminate them. If that was the opposite with monster having killed a humain village, you would have no complain about some human heroes avenging them by killing monsters. For 1 episode and a half he's explaining he feels more monster than human. I don't see the issue. I would have disliked the show if he would have say 'no don't attack the army I will negotiate with them'. On the contrary we at last witness a show that goes toward a different direction than your average shounen, let's see how it will turn out. This isn't uncharted territory. This kind of a plotline typically runs through anti-heros. Rimuru certainly could be an anti-hero, but that would be a departure from how he is presented thus far. I'm not complaining that he is killing soliders. I'm complaining that what he is doing seems to be pretty kinda genocideish. Maybe just a little bit genocideish. I'd be happy if it was just your traditional kill the enemy troops, minus the genocide parts.Which gets me wondering, where are the distinctions between the kill the enemy troops parts and the genocide parts? I'm lazy though and I don't want to read the history of the geneva convention. So I made this thread instead. This distinction is a long way away from me advocating "no don't attack the army I will negotiate with them." |
Mar 16, 2021 5:14 PM
#28
Thank you everyone for your insights! I understand why i feel conflicted about this much more now that when I initially posted. |
Mar 16, 2021 5:46 PM
#29
edgefigaro said: Re: source material Just FYI the monologue I quoted is from the anime. And it's ok if you felt uncomfortable with the scenes. A ruthless war is being portrayed so there aren't easy "good and bad" actions. I'll quote myself from another post: skysurf said: (...) the context is war, no clear lines of good and bad. Tempest city is under siege, got attacked already with dead bodies piled up in the streets and they were being held captive with a barrier that also made them defenseless and were scheduled to being completely destroyed after a few days. To the survivors, it doesn't matter if the soldiers have families or were forced to serve in the army or whatever, all those soldiers were marching to kill them all later on. That's why they're forced to fight back with all their might to ensure their survival. (...) So with all the background context and the insights we get into Rimuru's non-human emotions, I wouldn't say it's being downplayed, but I understand how you can see it that way. Last thing, about genocide, a quick definition is: Genocide, the deliberate and systematic destruction of a group of people because of their ethnicity, nationality, religion, or race. So if anything, it was the Falmuth empire the ones who were in the process of committing genocide against the monster race with the excuse of them being "enemies of God" (as usual, the real reason is about power and money, which gives a good touch of credibility to the story). Tempest citizens killing invading soldiers doesn't seem to fit that description since they're not killing the soldiers because they're humans, but because the soldiers are about to kill them otherwise. |
skysurfMar 16, 2021 5:52 PM
Mar 17, 2021 2:53 AM
#30
GatsuLTU said: Watched the episode. The fun and bright anime went directly to genocide. Like, oh, let's kill these 10k soldiers, who have families and are only doing their job. Wtf. I really hate how the anime took such a sharp turn from really good, to genocide of humans. Agree with everything the OP wrote. Anyway, changed my rating of this anime after this episode. The revenge fights were great, but the genocide part is terrible. I understand your perspective I feel the same way watching season 2 makes me nervous watching an episode before in season 1 I could watch it no problem but the soldiers weren't only going to kill the citizens of Tempest because it's their job they also seem to enjoy participating as one of the soldiers said "some of the women are beautiful" followed up by "first come first serve" implying that they were gonna rape the women although the genocide is bad Rimuru has to do it to save his people/family and save them from being wiped out and he has to "fall from grace" as Rimuru's been told before to evolve into a Demon Lord and he needs 10K human souls to become a True Demon Lord |
Mar 17, 2021 5:36 AM
#31
I see it as rimiru realised he's a monster and while we're all conflicted about genocide on humanity . We're not really seeing that isn't what the soldiers done just as wrong. Monsters are being discriminated under no basis. And for the sharp turn, most op MC animes are happy go lucky, so if we don't see that MC put his powers to use like this in a different way where he is still a hero if you look at it in perspective of his own people, then I'd say it wouldn't be as enjoyable. |
Mar 17, 2021 5:39 AM
#32
”GENOCIDE!" Pfff, stop being this cringe guys. Watch GATE Anime, where the pacifist Japanese Defense Forces had to deal with an agression by low-technology equiped armies from the fantasy world, killed +100.000 enemy soldiers in a blink of an eye, had to deal with all the bureaucracy of Japanese Government, in a Democracy under State of Law and Human Rights, in order to get authorization to that and when facing its aftermath, and never, never was acused of genocide. That's war! And more yet, Self-Defense. And none civilian was kilked. ---------- "Youm, be the New King of Falmuth and make good relations with us" - But Rimuru, i think i will have issues with the seek for revenge by the families of the +10k guys you've killed. "I never said that would be a Democracy, Youm (Build a Memorial and start a Holiday, whatever) " |
Rob7Mar 17, 2021 5:44 AM
Mar 17, 2021 5:55 AM
#33
Huh? What is wrong with eating 10000 hostile soldiers who are about to destroy your hometown? It's war, not some friendly mock battles :) If eating 10000 hostile soldiers is required to resurrect my fallen friends then I would be totally happy to do so, nothing illegal~ edgefigaro said: Stop eating the lvl1 defenseless soldiers. Go eat the generals and royalty and other high-level opponents then I would be fine with it. defenseless or not, generals or footmen, in the end they are still hostile humans to Rimuru and his friends. I dont see any points why Rimuru should make some exception to defenseless soldiers. |
(っ◔◡◔)っ 𝓘 𝔀𝓲𝓼𝓱 𝔂𝓸𝓾 𝓪𝓵𝓵 𝓱𝓪𝓿𝓮 𝓪 𝔀𝓸𝓷𝓭𝓮𝓻𝓯𝓾𝓵 𝓭𝓪𝔂 ♥ |
Mar 17, 2021 8:53 AM
#34
Mar 18, 2021 11:58 PM
#35
edgefigaro said: I find myself wishing that it had progressed in a way that got to a place between "we don't need to revere humans" and "its ok to eat hordes of them to save our friend." Stop eating the lvl1 defenseless soldiers. Go eat the generals and royalty and other high-level opponents then I would be fine with it. I don't think "humanity" is the critical thing here either. I think it'd be just as uncomfortable if he was systematically eating goblins or orcs or dragonewts in the way presented. Maybe this tension is intentional and will be addressed at some point in the future, idk. Firstly, Rimuru's kingdom was attacked by Falmuth's forces for the sole purpose of greed and if we're talking about genocide then let's dissect exactly why the Western Saints Church approved this attack on Tempest. Simple, they're monsters making them automatically enemies of humanity, just for that they'll have to be wiped out which is the purest definition of genocide. Secondly, "stop eating the lvl1 defenseless soldiers", are you joking right now? They are literally soldiers who are making their march towards Tempest armed and ready not to mention these same "level 1' soldiers put a barrier over tempest and then proceeded to kill everyone they laid their eyes on including the most innocent, the children and they laughed while they committed to these killings. These "level 1" soldiers are completely aware of what they're doing, it wasn't included in the anime but there was a soldier (I'll assume there were probably others like him as well) that's shown to have "integrity" because while the other soldiers were talking about raping the females of Tempest to relieve themselves, he showed visible contempt towards their conversation and excused himself to prepare his weaponry for their full army invasion to Tempest. During this sequence, he was having an inner monologue thinking about how he doesn't personally have anything against Tempest but "He's gotta what he's gotta do". Sorry buddy, but I can definitely get behind "Let's kill off the enemies that attacked and killed my people to resurrect the lives that have been lost due to them" vs "I gotta do what I gotta do", f*** outta here with that garbage. Furthermore, "Go eat the generals and royalty and other high-level opponents then I would be fine with it." Who do you think is leading this army to wipe out Tempest? The literal King of Falmuth and his closest aides. You're letting your concept of strong be blurred by the incredible outlier of Rimuru and his geneology. The soldiers are not weak in general, they brought thousands of soldiers plus mages. The church sent 4000 troops divided into 3000 professional demon exterminators and made a special exception to deploy 1000 knights who far stronger than the other troops. Moreover, about your perspective of "Humanity isn't the critical thing here" is unfortunately flawed because this is a biological fact that human empathy and compassion towards species decreases with evolutionary divergence which is basically just saying humans have a significant bias when it comes to such feelings for other species. This is showcased simply by your statement of leave the "level 1 soldiers alone" meanwhile let's ignore the fact that the predicament they're currently in is due to how they literally waltz into a country and killed innocent life including children and their families. It's alright though, you can't really help being influenced by your subconscious but I digress. Lastly. A wise king never seeks out war. But he must always be ready for it. With that in mind and the lesson Rimuru has learned from all this, I am completely in support of his actions. Hell, make it a 100,000 soldiers and it makes zero difference to me except for the benefit derived of having extra souls around for future possible needs and putting every other enemy of Tempest on alert, letting them know that if you ask to see the boss we'll send him. |
HI007Mar 19, 2021 12:01 AM
Mar 19, 2021 1:06 PM
#36
HI007 said: edgefigaro said: I find myself wishing that it had progressed in a way that got to a place between "we don't need to revere humans" and "its ok to eat hordes of them to save our friend." Stop eating the lvl1 defenseless soldiers. Go eat the generals and royalty and other high-level opponents then I would be fine with it. I don't think "humanity" is the critical thing here either. I think it'd be just as uncomfortable if he was systematically eating goblins or orcs or dragonewts in the way presented. Maybe this tension is intentional and will be addressed at some point in the future, idk. Firstly, Rimuru's kingdom was attacked by Falmuth's forces for the sole purpose of greed and if we're talking about genocide then let's dissect exactly why the Western Saints Church approved this attack on Tempest. Simple, they're monsters making them automatically enemies of humanity, just for that they'll have to be wiped out which is the purest definition of genocide. Secondly, "stop eating the lvl1 defenseless soldiers", are you joking right now? They are literally soldiers who are making their march towards Tempest armed and ready not to mention these same "level 1' soldiers put a barrier over tempest and then proceeded to kill everyone they laid their eyes on including the most innocent, the children and they laughed while they committed to these killings. These "level 1" soldiers are completely aware of what they're doing, it wasn't included in the anime but there was a soldier (I'll assume there were probably others like him as well) that's shown to have "integrity" because while the other soldiers were talking about raping the females of Tempest to relieve themselves, he showed visible contempt towards their conversation and excused himself to prepare his weaponry for their full army invasion to Tempest. During this sequence, he was having an inner monologue thinking about how he doesn't personally have anything against Tempest but "He's gotta what he's gotta do". Sorry buddy, but I can definitely get behind "Let's kill off the enemies that attacked and killed my people to resurrect the lives that have been lost due to them" vs "I gotta do what I gotta do", f*** outta here with that garbage. Furthermore, "Go eat the generals and royalty and other high-level opponents then I would be fine with it." Who do you think is leading this army to wipe out Tempest? The literal King of Falmuth and his closest aides. You're letting your concept of strong be blurred by the incredible outlier of Rimuru and his geneology. The soldiers are not weak in general, they brought thousands of soldiers plus mages. The church sent 4000 troops divided into 3000 professional demon exterminators and made a special exception to deploy 1000 knights who far stronger than the other troops. Moreover, about your perspective of "Humanity isn't the critical thing here" is unfortunately flawed because this is a biological fact that human empathy and compassion towards species decreases with evolutionary divergence which is basically just saying humans have a significant bias when it comes to such feelings for other species. This is showcased simply by your statement of leave the "level 1 soldiers alone" meanwhile let's ignore the fact that the predicament they're currently in is due to how they literally waltz into a country and killed innocent life including children and their families. It's alright though, you can't really help being influenced by your subconscious but I digress. Lastly. A wise king never seeks out war. But he must always be ready for it. With that in mind and the lesson Rimuru has learned from all this, I am completely in support of his actions. Hell, make it a 100,000 soldiers and it makes zero difference to me except for the benefit derived of having extra souls around for future possible needs and putting every other enemy of Tempest on alert, letting them know that if you ask to see the boss we'll send him. You are missing my point. I'm not saying don't kill the solidiers. I'm saying don't write the killing of the soliders in this way into the piece. |
Mar 19, 2021 8:33 PM
#37
I would suggest you to search for Reimei - TRUE lyric, the one play during megido scene. I translate that stuff using google and it clearly depict Rimuru state of mind. Something like " Is this my fault? Someone died but I cant shed tear, I'm a monster huh No matter... I will do anything to protected my loved one If that is "evil" " He blame himself for bring naive He know what he is doing is evil But it his only option for him to bring selfish of bring back his loved one Even if it innocene soul bring mixed along He will do anything to ensure that the revival process have highest change possibld So completely wiped an army is logical option for him or anyone in his shoes. It come to simple questiin How much will you go to ensure that your loved one is return If the expense is the offender soul? It not like Rimuru invade Farmuth directly to harvest the soul. This is not on individual scale since it a full scale invasion from another country so no one gonna interview and judge each of them and decide which to spare |
mickbisMar 19, 2021 8:41 PM
Mar 19, 2021 10:28 PM
#38
@edgefigaro Then 8bit might as well have completely changed this entire adaptation of volume 5 for the anime and just not do the Tempest attack in general because what happened there was significantly worse than killing off soldiers. Mind you soldiers are literally people serving in the army and I assume they would be aware that their occupation puts their life on the line, I personally can't see the issue here. If you wage war against another country, I see no reason to be surprised if they choose to obliterate your army in response. It's not like Rimuru went and killed all the innocent in Falmuth Kingdom, he's attacking the force that the opposition specifically prepared for war against his nation. |
HI007Mar 19, 2021 10:37 PM
Mar 20, 2021 4:19 AM
#39
In that world where other beings have the same intelligence as humans there should be no difference in them slaughtering the orc army to a human one. They both were killing indiscriminately. Humans dont deserve a break just because they are humans. The way they act puts them on the level of brainless monsters. |
Mar 20, 2021 5:37 AM
#40
@Jyoshiro Jyoshiro said: In that world where other beings have the same intelligence as humans there should be no difference in them slaughtering the orc army to a human one. They both were killing indiscriminately. Humans dont deserve a break just because they are humans. The way they act puts them on the level of brainless monsters. Completely agree. |
Mar 21, 2021 6:49 AM
#41
edgefigaro said: I don't recall them saying it in the anime (if they did, it was really quick) but in the manga Rimiru's "underling"s clearly showed more anger towards Falmuth because they set-up this situation so that Rimiru -whom had just revealed to them that he was a human in his past life- is being pushed/forced to kill "fellow humans". The "visitors" whom are present during this discussion also agreed. (Or at least didn't object.)I wish the show's nearby characters were somewhat disturbed by what it happening. My impression from the manga was that this anger was greater than the anger they had towards having their own killed. So there's that in regards to this point. (aka: it's depicted slightly better in manga than anime) |
IkanoMar 21, 2021 6:54 AM
Mar 23, 2021 12:02 PM
#42
edgefigaro said: Bfun2468 said: If Rimuru doesnt eat them, they will just die and their soles will just dissapear. Rimuru's kingsom still needs to be defended so either way the enemy needs to die. "Every enemy soldier must die" isn't normal warfare though. Battles happen, some soldiers die, others are wounded, others escape both fates. While "all enemy combatants need to be slain" does happen, it is not the only mode of combat, nor is it even the default. Well 2 eps back the elf princess told us the story or rather tragedy of Milim an according to that killing every single one of them is precisely the only way out here . Besides, the act of killing and slaying innocents r justified if they are done by human to other races but when the other races make a move it's inhuman monstrosity how is that justified? |
ScoppyMar 23, 2021 12:06 PM
Mar 23, 2021 3:10 PM
#43
Yeah I think its a bit odd to just kill 10k humans like that in a show like this where even the dead can be revived |
"This emotion is mine alone. It is for Madoka alone." - Homura or how I would descripe Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica. |
Mar 23, 2021 3:50 PM
#44
I think that slime isekai is now showing the world in a less idealistic way. In the end that army was coming to destroy their nation and it had to be eliminated. I was thinking it was crazy but then when you consider how wars are constantly happen ein fun real life it seems a lot more reasonable |
Mar 23, 2021 10:33 PM
#45
Rimuru didn't think it was OK. He think there was literally no other choice as there's no other form of way to being the Dead back to Life except for that one "theory" (which has a credible source, Millim) And the only way to become the Demon Lord was only that one condition of requiring 10,000 dead Humans. Also, in this Fantasy World, War is different than ours, it has a different set of rules. Especially when it's war between 2 entire set of genetic species. "Humans vs Monsters" (tho keep in mind, Monsters also come in loads of different species, but this is just how the Humans in this Fantasy World regards them as one species) The Human Church literally think it's their "god given right" to kill any Monsters. Have you played any RPG games as Human main? yea... think of how many monsters you've killed from beginning to end. Was that alright to do? Same deal here from the "Monsters POV". And Rimuru originally stated he didn't want to hurt any Humans, but did not expect or foresaw the Humans in this Fantasy World are mostly asses as majority of them are under the Church's teachings (which was monsters = bad). |
Nothing Written Here But Us Anime Bunnies *boing boing boing* |
Mar 27, 2021 2:09 PM
#46
i just wished the show would stop acting like rimuru is the good guy with all this happy music, he isnt good at all, the soldiers were literally begging and he was like nah, fuck him |
Mar 29, 8:51 AM
#47
Reply to Rukasumi
i just wished the show would stop acting like rimuru is the good guy with all this happy music, he isnt good at all, the soldiers were literally begging and he was like nah, fuck him
@Rukasumi Late reply but I agree completely. This anime is sadly not any different from any other cheap edgelord isekai when it comes down to scenes like this one. All this discussion about how to justify rimuru's actions is nonsensical. Tensura tries to present itself as a mature and nuanced approach to the isekai genre, but the simple fact that the author cooked a scenario where the comically evil human army consisting of opinionless soldiers who just want to rape and pillage has to be wiped out in this completely unepic and unhonorable way shows how childish this anime is. Someone mentioned GATE as a comparison, but that show is just as stupid as Tensura in its display of power and conflict. It's nothing but a childish power fantasy. You can like it and give it a 9/10, but to claim that Tensura and especially this scene is well written is honestly just embarrassing. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Tensei shitara Slime Datta Ken 2nd Season Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Mar 30, 2021 |
263 |
by Alvie48xi
»»
Dec 1, 10:02 AM |
|
Poll: » Tensei shitara Slime Datta Ken 2nd Season Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Mar 23, 2021 |
352 |
by Alvie48xi
»»
Dec 1, 9:05 AM |
|
Poll: » Tensei shitara Slime Datta Ken 2nd Season Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Mar 16, 2021 |
326 |
by Alvie48xi
»»
Dec 1, 8:26 AM |
|
Poll: » Tensei shitara Slime Datta Ken 2nd Season Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - Mar 2, 2021 |
242 |
by Alvie48xi
»»
Dec 1, 7:26 AM |
|
Poll: » Tensei shitara Slime Datta Ken 2nd Season Episode 7 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Stark700 - Feb 23, 2021 |
187 |
by Alvie48xi
»»
Dec 1, 6:14 AM |