TheMightyMushi said: Just wanted to make sure, i read [url=https://myanimelist.net/manga/104538]Kimi no Suizou wo Tabetai[url] for one of my entries, and it's TECHNICALLY finished it's run, but it's only translated up to the 6th chapter. Will this still count as being finished for the challenge now that i've caught up to it's most recent translated chapter? I think i had read on the FAQ that it had, but im being a lazy boi. You have to be caught up when you finish your challenge. |
HeNrYTG50 said: TheMightyMushi said: Just wanted to make sure, i read [url=https://myanimelist.net/manga/104538]Kimi no Suizou wo Tabetai[url] for one of my entries, and it's TECHNICALLY finished it's run, but it's only translated up to the 6th chapter. Will this still count as being finished for the challenge now that i've caught up to it's most recent translated chapter? I think i had read on the FAQ that it had, but im being a lazy boi. You have to be caught up when you finish your challenge. .... Still a bit confused. Caught up as in, whole series read? or caught up as in read all that is available? Since my problem is that it's an already finished manga. Wanna make sure it's not "Caught Up" to the whole manga, since i can't do that as it stands right now, i can only read up to a certain point until it gets scanlated or i somehow learn japanese xD Sorry if i come off condescending. |
KasietheMightyMar 16, 2018 1:32 AM
"Make sure to remember, every person and place has a right to exist. It's true for you too, the entire world, as a whole, is your home." - Ginko |
| Hi~ For the item: (23) Read a manga by an author/artist you don't know. it's supposed that I need to read something of an author that I have not read before of this challenge? and someone knows if this counts like a short stories manga? https://myanimelist.net/manga/104723/Dame_na_Yatsu_Hodo_Kawaii |
OnodeathMar 16, 2018 12:32 PM
 |
TheMightyMushi said: .... Still a bit confused. Caught up as in, whole series read? or caught up as in read all that is available? Since my problem is that it's an already finished manga. Wanna make sure it's not "Caught Up" to the whole manga, since i can't do that as it stands right now, i can only read up to a certain point until it gets scanlated or i somehow learn japanese xD Sorry if i come off condescending. Caught up to what is available. What I meant is that being caught up now doesn't matter much, unless you're already done with your challenge. Since you have to be caught up the moment you want to turn-in your challenge, you have to continue reading the chapters that come out until then. FireLight85 said: For the (29) Read a manga that started serialization before 2005, does this mean when it first started in Japan or when it was first translated. I wanted to read Bartender for this one challenge, it started in Japan in 2004 but it didn't start being translated until 2006/2007. In Japan. Onodera_Riku said: Hi~ For the item: (23) Read a manga by an author/artist you don't know. it's supposed that I need to read something of an author that I have not read before of this challenge? and someone knows if this counts like a short stories manga? https://myanimelist.net/manga/104723/Dame_na_Yatsu_Hodo_Kawaii Yes, and yes. |
HeNrYTG50 said: Onodera_Riku said: Hi~ For the item: (23) Read a manga by an author/artist you don't know. it's supposed that I need to read something of an author that I have not read before of this challenge? and someone knows if this counts like a short stories manga? https://myanimelist.net/manga/104723/Dame_na_Yatsu_Hodo_Kawaii Yes, and yes. Thank you and thank you! xD |
|
| (84) Read a manga with a number in the title Will Real girl count because the Japanese an Synonyms title have a number in the title And I will like to have some help with finding manga for the following challenges: (41) Read a manga that takes place outside of Japan, but in the real world: (51) Read a gekiga manga (53) Read a manga written by someone from the Year 24 Group (63) Read a manga that has been adapted to CD drama (72) Read a manga that has a main character that is a professional in his field (76) Read a manga that takes place in Japan |
_Ataku_ said: (84) Read a manga with a number in the title Will Real girl count because the Japanese an Synonyms title have a number in the title And I will like to have some help with finding manga for the following challenges: (41) Read a manga that takes place outside of Japan, but in the real world: (51) Read a gekiga manga (53) Read a manga written by someone from the Year 24 Group (63) Read a manga that has been adapted to CD drama (72) Read a manga that has a main character that is a professional in his field (76) Read a manga that takes place in Japan 84) ehhh sure why not, i see the number 3 on the vol cover 41) emma 63) prunus girl, magico 72) bakuman, black jack, |
| One of my favorite anituberisms was when people were saying Re:Zero was this intense deconstruction on anime tropes when it came out, and then years later when I got around to reading it it was just lolicon chuunige. |
| Does Drifters count as '(40) Read a manga about something related to Japanese culture'? |
⛥Something wicked this way comes.⛥  |
_Ataku_ said: (84) Read a manga with a number in the title Will Real girl count because the Japanese an Synonyms title have a number in the title And I will like to have some help with finding manga for the following challenges: (41) Read a manga that takes place outside of Japan, but in the real world: (51) Read a gekiga manga (53) Read a manga written by someone from the Year 24 Group (63) Read a manga that has been adapted to CD drama (72) Read a manga that has a main character that is a professional in his field (76) Read a manga that takes place in Japan (41) Green Blood, Benkei in New York (51) Samurai Executioner (53) Thomas no Shinzou (76) Yome ga Kore na mon de |
| Because we're stupid that we love to have fun |
| @Scarlett_ryuken, @podetus, Thanks for the help |
Cindy-Uchiha said: Does Drifters count as '(40) Read a manga about something related to Japanese culture'? Sure. :) |
HeNrYTG50 said: Nice! Thank you.Cindy-Uchiha said: Does Drifters count as '(40) Read a manga about something related to Japanese culture'? Sure. :) |
⛥Something wicked this way comes.⛥ |
| So I just posted my turn in form and got a little curious over how many people actually go over them and how long it normally takes to verify one. Seems like it would be a royal pain in the ass, so sorry, I guess? Thanks for all the recs along the way though, these are always fun. |
Ironclad_Cobra said: So I just posted my turn in form and got a little curious over how many people actually go over them and how long it normally takes to verify one. Seems like it would be a royal pain in the ass, so sorry, I guess? Thanks for all the recs along the way though, these are always fun. Usually only one person goes over each form, and it's not that bad, unless the user doesn't follow the rules. xD Perhaps half an hour? Thanks for the heads-up, by the way. :) |
How about Akumetsu, Shigeshoushi, Homunculus, Tetsugaku Letra, Udon no Hito. :) |
| May I have recs for... (42) Read a manga with a child MC (43) Read a manga with a cast mostly of one gender I'm reading a lot of shoujo so maybe shonen for these would be a nice change of pace? Thanks in advance! |
 |
Netbug said: May I have recs for... (42) Read a manga with a child MC (43) Read a manga with a cast mostly of one gender I'm reading a lot of shoujo so maybe shonen for these would be a nice change of pace? Thanks in advance! 42) https://myanimelist.net/manga/1215/Doumu https://myanimelist.net/manga/1257/Higurashi_no_Naku_Koro_ni__Onikakushi-hen https://myanimelist.net/manga/670/Bokurano 43) just try any of the jojos beside part 2and part 8 |
| One of my favorite anituberisms was when people were saying Re:Zero was this intense deconstruction on anime tropes when it came out, and then years later when I got around to reading it it was just lolicon chuunige. |
EagleBlaze said: I hope that this hasn't already been answered but I quickly skimmed through half of the discussion thread but no one has answered this one yet but I need help for number 6. (06) Read a manga from a magazine with less than 250 titles listed in the database. Also for titles, does that refer to the number of chapters the manga has? Sorry, just a little confused. Thanks in advance! ... it's basically the magazine the manga is published in https://myanimelist.net/manga/magazine/98/Dragon_Age like this use a magazine with less than 250 manga |
| One of my favorite anituberisms was when people were saying Re:Zero was this intense deconstruction on anime tropes when it came out, and then years later when I got around to reading it it was just lolicon chuunige. |
EagleBlaze said: Scarlett_ryuken said: yes ... it's basically the magazine the manga is published in https://myanimelist.net/manga/magazine/98/Dragon_Age like this use a magazine with less than 250 manga So would manga like Ouran Koukou Host Club or Vampire Knight work? Thanks! |
| One of my favorite anituberisms was when people were saying Re:Zero was this intense deconstruction on anime tropes when it came out, and then years later when I got around to reading it it was just lolicon chuunige. |
EagleBlaze said: I hope that this hasn't already been answered but I quickly skimmed through half of the discussion thread but no one has answered this one yet but I need help for number 6. (06) Read a manga from a magazine with less than 250 titles listed in the database. Also for titles, does that refer to the number of chapters the manga has? Sorry, just a little confused. Thanks in advance! It refers to any magazine with less than 250 manga in it. :) So, Ouran Koukou Host Club and Vampire Knight are on LaLa, which has 193 manga. As such, they do count. |
| For #71 Read a manga about food, music or art, would Kasane count since the MC is in theater? |
TheOrdinaryHuman said: For #71 Read a manga about food, music or art, would Kasane count since the MC is in theater? yes |
| Hey everyone, could I get a rec for #17. Read a manga recommended to you by another participant in the discussion thread? Preferably something completed, psychological, seinen. :) |
HeNrYTG50 said: Hey everyone, could I get a rec for #17. Read a manga recommended to you by another participant in the discussion thread? Preferably something completed, psychological, seinen. :) Shi ga Futari wo Wakatsu made Saikyou Densetsu Kurosawa Holyland |
StrangerZzMar 22, 2018 9:53 AM
| (83) Read a manga that is related to something you have previously read: Is Rave Master (want to read) related to Magi(read) in some sort of way. Want to make 100% sure. |
Moonie said: (78) Read a manga recommended to you by a challenge staff member: I need some help with this one Lucifer and biscuit hammer Gon Kakukaku shikajika |
_Ataku_ said: (83) Read a manga that is related to something you have previously read: Is Rave Master (want to read) related to Magi(read) in some sort of way. Want to make 100% sure. I can't find "Rave Master", can you link to it? |
AudioTsunami said: _Ataku_ said: (83) Read a manga that is related to something you have previously read: Is Rave Master (want to read) related to Magi(read) in some sort of way. Want to make 100% sure. I can't find "Rave Master", can you link to it? https://myanimelist.net/manga/14/Rave?q=Rave%20Master |
It has to be related, as being of the same franchise, a spin-off, sequel, usually the MAL page of one leading to the other, not just being about something similar. :P |
It would seem so, yes. :) |
Thank you, I'll check Holyland then. :) |
Has to be listed under the "related manga bar" so Rave Master would not count as related to Magi because it's not directly related to magi in the related manga tag IDK, it's good enough for me; "There are multiple stories in this, each lasting a few chapters, telling different tales of how couples deal with their pairing." |
AudioTsunami said: Has to be listed under the "related manga bar" so Rave Master would not count as related to Magi because it's not directly related to magi in the related manga tag HeNrYTG50 said: It has to be related, as being of the same franchise, a spin-off, sequel, usually the MAL page of one leading to the other, not just being about something similar. :P Thanks for the info |
| Is it ok if I use ReLIFE for 'Read a manga that has been adapted to anime' ? Because it's categorized as manga but it's written like manhwa. |
Hachi13 said: Is it ok if I use ReLIFE for 'Read a manga that has been adapted to anime' ? Because it's categorized as manga but it's written like manhwa. Yes. Manga, manhua and manhwa (webtoons included) all count as manga for the sake of this challenge. |
密室殺人はなぜ美しいのか。 |
| Great ^^ Thank you :D |
jajaxxarden said: Need a recommendation manga that starts with Letter J? Thank you! any jojo manga https://myanimelist.net/manga/100448/Jumyou_wo_Kaitotte_Moratta_Ichinen_ni_Tsuki_Ichimanen_de https://myanimelist.net/manga/1495/Juuki_Ningen_Jumbor |
| One of my favorite anituberisms was when people were saying Re:Zero was this intense deconstruction on anime tropes when it came out, and then years later when I got around to reading it it was just lolicon chuunige. |
izziiwillkill said: Hey, I also need someone to recommend a manga (or a few more) to me for the 2018 Manga Challenge. it should be a completed series. Genres I don't like: Fantasy, Harem, Sci-Fi, Yaoi Genres I like: basically everything else, but especially Mystery, Shoujo-Ai or Action. https://myanimelist.net/manga/78523/ReLIFE https://myanimelist.net/manga/3102/Girl_Friends https://myanimelist.net/manga/3986/Deadman_Wonderland https://myanimelist.net/manga/30457/Transfer_Student_Storm_Bringer https://myanimelist.net/manga/88991/Skill_of_Lure https://myanimelist.net/manga/56549/Love_Riron |
More topics from this board
» Listening to Music while readingAllAlone8 - Oct 27, 2025 |
29 |
by Ashymations
»»
29 minutes ago |
|
» Personal Reading Goals for 2026.jiv123 - Jan 5 |
9 |
by Ashymations
»»
39 minutes ago |
|
» Recently Bought Manga, Mahnwa, Manhua, or Light Novels. ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Maora - Oct 24, 2008 |
6179 |
by DesuMaiden
»»
Yesterday, 3:26 PM |
|
» most overrated manga?eternalworm2008 - Jan 8 |
9 |
by Ghostfreak2000
»»
Yesterday, 11:26 AM |
|
» Manga Like The Dangers in My Heart?Delleah - Yesterday |
1 |
by ryan77999
»»
Yesterday, 8:36 AM |