Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
New
What did you think of this episode?
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
Pages (20) « First ... « 4 5 [6] 7 8 » ... Last »
Jan 1, 2011 11:27 PM

Offline
Aug 2009
9
I think I just accidentally got too hooked on the fact that Tatsumi said "four" and they ended up showing Sunako's picture too. Overall it makes the most sense that Sunako is not actually a werewolf. I guess I somehow assumed that she was just "special" because she was so old, the whole time. The fourth werewolf Tatsumi is speaking of *might* be the guy who actually bit Sunako in the first place, but I don't want to dig myself further into giving out the wrong info now =_=

@Iilia: I just watched that scene too, makes sense as well.
Jan 1, 2011 11:41 PM

Offline
Jul 2010
718
@tensainobaka - Yeah, we've definitely established the Yoshie being a werewolf bit. As for Muroi, it's assumed that he became a werewolf at the end as he seemed to die, then instantly rise up, heal, kill Ookawa, and rescue Sunako which led to their escape. To avoid confusion, seeing as he had just rose up then, he was not the fourth Jinrou Tatsumi referred to.

@Ellix - The guy who bit Sunako would be older than she, so I doubt Tatsumi would've ever even met him. It's amazing how simply the mentioning of a fourth Jinrou we haven't seen sparked everyone's attention. For the longest time I thought it was Seishirou, so don't feel bad you thought it was Sunako. XD
Jan 2, 2011 12:33 AM

Offline
Jun 2010
8
Does any one know if a second season is coming out?? I really want to know whats really going to happen.
Signature has been deleted because it exceeded the size limits. Refer to the rules for more info.
Jan 2, 2011 12:48 AM

Offline
Oct 2008
107
Loved the series and thought this episode was really good too. I was sad to see Megumi die, and Tatsumi was too cool to die so he didn't. Those last few episodes I was sad a lot of the time when they were killing the vampires (the worst being when Ozaki was experimenting on his wife, just think waking up and having that done to you, made me sad). Overall it was a pretty good ending and wrapped up some stuff, except when they investigate the town and find all those bodies with steaks in them.

There does need to be some kind of follow up, but overall the series itself was great and the ending was pretty well done.
Jan 2, 2011 1:09 AM

Offline
Jul 2008
4186
Iilia said:

@Ellix - The guy who bit Sunako would be older than she, so I doubt Tatsumi would've ever even met him. It's amazing how simply the mentioning of a fourth Jinrou we haven't seen sparked everyone's attention. For the longest time I thought it was Seishirou, so don't feel bad you thought it was Sunako. XD


I always assumed since he said he had only met four including himself, the fourth one was just not a member of the Kirishiki clan. Like maybe he encountered one in the past but they were not traveling together.

Zensational said:
Loved the series and thought this episode was really good too. I was sad to see Megumi die, and Tatsumi was too cool to die so he didn't.

There does need to be some kind of follow up, but overall the series itself was great and the ending was pretty well done.


Did Tatsumi live? Or did the dynamite kill both Natsuno and Tatsumi? I wasn't sure about that part.

And I thought the ending was wrapped up pretty nicely. There are not that many loose ends as far as I could see.
Jan 2, 2011 1:10 AM

Offline
Nov 2007
403
Great series! Almost dropped it since the pacing was so slow in the beginning, glad I've finished this.
Surprisingly, I was said to to see Megumi die, even though I always hated her :P
Jan 2, 2011 1:11 AM

Offline
Oct 2008
107
GarLogan78 said:
Did Tatsumi live? Or did the dynamite kill both Natsuno and Tatsumi?


I know in my heart that he lived!
Jan 2, 2011 2:15 AM

Offline
Jul 2010
27
Nearly the whole time I was watching this series I wished for the villagers to discover the Shiki so that they could save themselves and destroy the menace. Because for most of the series that is how I thought of the Shiki as monsters and unabsolvable sinners. The humans were the victims and the Shiki the villains. As everyone knows this is reversed later and I got exactly what I hoped for. Shiki getting murdered in droves the villagers walking around covered in blood. Who ever thought that would be more horrifying than the deeds of the Shiki themselves? Now I saw them for what they were terrified human beings labeled evil for a natural reaction to an unnatural situation. And the villagers killed them for it.
Jan 2, 2011 5:35 AM

Offline
Jan 2008
1068
It ends rather well...kinda expected the ending. Even the little annoyance over the successful escape of Muroi and Sunako was included in it.
Jan 2, 2011 6:42 AM

Offline
Aug 2007
3763
I really like the end of the anime. I thought that Sunako will die at the end, but she survived with Muroi.
Jan 2, 2011 6:42 AM
Offline
Nov 2008
49
too bad only characters I hate survived (Ozaki aside)
Jan 2, 2011 6:52 AM
Offline
Dec 2010
11
Could someone explain me the novel from Muroi again? I watched everything two times, but I don't get everything >___<'

Btw I apologized for my triple post, but I don't know if my reply came up! The forum was really buggy before two days, so excuse me again ^____^'
Jan 2, 2011 6:58 AM

Offline
Jun 2009
641
I'm speechless........10/10



Jan 2, 2011 8:06 AM
Offline
Jan 2011
14
ShikiLover said:
Could someone explain me the novel from Muroi again? I watched everything two times, but I don't get everything >___<'


There are 2 characters with an elder bro and a younger bro in this novel. The elder bro left his holly village because he killed his younger bro, who has been always good and loved by everyone. After that, the younger bro was revived as Shiki and followed elder bro. But then this elder bro realized that he didn't have any brother and his brother was himself (he was just confused).

So he realized that he had always pretended as a nice and good person in his village but he didn't liked himself who had behaved like that. Because he knew that it was not his nature. However that village is a holy place and everyone expected him as a person who is nice and gives holy power to them, so he should be good all the time otherwise he cannot stay there. So what he decided was to give up being as a good person and ran away from this village. But outside of this village is a place for Shiki, so he needed to live with Shiki.

As you can see, this story is a metaphor of the whole story of "Shiki" and this person clearly represents Murai (Seishin) himself.

Younger bro
Muroi as a Monk and the person who was hated by himself(Actually Muroi tried to suicide once)

Elder bro
Muroi as a person who hated his given role & villagers who gave it, wanted to be free, and then betrayed human

His holly village
Sotoba village surrounded by death (Shiki) and protected by religion

In my opinion, this metaphorical novel also suggests what would be the sin of villagers in Sotoba and the reason why Sotoba was destroyed. Because they has just been expecting other's kindness irresponsibly but they never wanted to give their efforts to others. When some trouble happened in this village, they always expected someone would solve it but never had "I will solve it" mind (this was also suggested by Ozaki, Akira and Megumi). Though Muroi was forsaken by this village, in other point of view, this means Sotoba village was forsaken by Muroi and his temple that used to protected this village for a long time.

But still some of them could survive because finally they decided to take an action by themselves and showed their efforts, I think.
PenPenGrassJan 2, 2011 8:32 AM
Jan 2, 2011 8:12 AM

Offline
Aug 2009
286
Sunako... why you don't get killed.
good eps not amazing.
the ending didn't match with my hope lol
Jan 2, 2011 8:24 AM

Offline
Nov 2008
253
This episode basically gave me everything I wanted in a Vampire/Psychological thriller. The bonus 2 episodes should help fill in a little more of nitty gritty details about some events that were not explained all the way.
Jan 2, 2011 8:25 AM

Offline
May 2008
1084
Didn't fell sorry for any of the Shiki deaths and I can't believe they didn't manage to kill Sunaki, damn angsty priest.
Jan 2, 2011 8:36 AM
Offline
Dec 2010
11
PenPenGrass said:
<---Spoler because it's a loooong text! ^-^


Ahhh!!! Now it makes soo much more sense! That his younger brother, could be his "nice" side, came in my mind too, as they said that they were the same person! But everything didn't fit for me! But now it does :) Thank you really much ^.^
Jan 2, 2011 9:47 AM
Offline
Dec 2010
142
almost everyone i wanted to live or die did so (happy natsuno was not a hypocrite)

but will say this on the whose better humans and shiki argument

i draw the line on those who say humans are worse and that this a prejudice story

to absolve shiki of what they do is absolving child-killing among other things
shadowiiJan 2, 2011 10:03 AM
Jan 2, 2011 10:46 AM
Offline
Jan 2011
14
shadowii said:
almost everyone i wanted to live or die did so (happy natsuno was not a hypocrite)

but will say this on the whose better humans and shiki argument

i draw the line on those who say humans are worse and that this a prejudice story

to absolve shiki of what they do is absolving child-killing among other things


This animation erased some important parts unfortunately. That's why some people are confused about the meaning of this story.

Originally, Muroi said to Sunako in the end part "Shiki is already a being out of divine providence". So they cannot be absolved anymore. They are no more possible to be judged by the man-made law or religion. Muroi even said "We even don't have any right to be judged". However, as he continued, having life and providence are not related each other. So Shiki is going to be alive as they want anyway. That is the reason why the author wanted Sunako to survive.

Of course we can judge Shiki as an enemy because we are human, we can only judge everything from our human's point of view. But this world will allow them to keep alive anyway without our intention.

So I think good or bad discussion is completely meaningless for this story (and often this author's other stories). It's something like "Which is worse, Lion or Shark?" question.
Jan 2, 2011 11:07 AM
Offline
Dec 2010
142
PenPenGrass said:
shadowii said:
almost everyone i wanted to live or die did so (happy natsuno was not a hypocrite)

but will say this on the whose better humans and shiki argument

i draw the line on those who say humans are worse and that this a prejudice story

to absolve shiki of what they do is absolving child-killing among other things


This animation erased some important parts unfortunately. That's why some people are confused about the meaning of this story.

Originally, Muroi said to Sunako in the end part "Shiki is already a being out of divine providence". So they cannot be absolved anymore. They are no more possible to be judged by the man-made law or religion. Muroi even said "We even don't have any right to be judged". However, as he continued, having life and providence are not related each other. So Shiki is going to be alive as they want anyway. That is the reason why the author wanted Sunako to survive.

Of course we can judge Shiki as an enemy because we are human, we can only judge everything from our human's point of view. But this world will allow them to keep alive anyway without our intention.

So I think good or bad discussion is completely meaningless for this story (and often this author's other stories). It's something like "Which is worse, Lion or Shark?" question.


but all shiki started as human and to me that is important
Jan 2, 2011 11:07 AM
Offline
Dec 2008
35
what happened to seishirou?
Jan 2, 2011 11:43 AM
Offline
Jan 2011
14
shadowii said:
but all shiki started as human and to me that is important


Yes, but this human was dead once as human.
So when they were dead, they were released as human life once, then become Shiki which is a different creature but with human's body and memory. It's same as zombie snail controlled by some parasite (Shiki is controlled by blood btw). We cannot say zombie snail as snail anymore.

If I met Shiki, I'm perfectly sure that I would hunt them without any excuse. But it doesn't mean Shiki is bad. They are just dangerous for mankind like other man-eater animals for me. But if I have such thoughts in my mind, this means I'm also dangerous for Shiki.
Jan 2, 2011 12:00 PM
Offline
Dec 2010
142
PenPenGrass said:
shadowii said:
but all shiki started as human and to me that is important


Yes, but this human was dead once as human.
So when they were dead, they were released as human life once, then become Shiki which is a different creature but with human's body and memory. It's same as zombie snail controlled by some parasite (Shiki is controlled by blood btw). We cannot say zombie snail as snail anymore.

If I met Shiki, I'm perfectly sure that I would hunt them without any excuse. But it doesn't mean Shiki is bad. They are just dangerous for mankind like other man-eater animals for me. But if I have such thoughts in my mind, this means I'm also dangerous for Shiki.


thats your opinion, but i dont agree with it
particularly in the face of interactuion between human villagers and shiki villagers
Jan 2, 2011 12:28 PM
Offline
Jan 2011
14
shadowii said:
thats your opinion, but i dont agree with it
particularly in the face of interactuion between human villagers and shiki villagers


Probably I 'm bit biased. But most of the things I explained are just explained in the original novel. Basically I just tried to fill in the gap between animation and novel (original story is too long to be made as animation in 22 episodes).

I think this story is quite difficult to capture. I read the original novel about 5 times and then I understood the meaning quite well, even though it explained much detail about this story.

But u can interpret this story in a different way of course, and I don't intend to force you to change. Sorry if I annoy you.
Jan 2, 2011 12:30 PM

Offline
Jun 2008
2206
shadowii said:
PenPenGrass said:
shadowii said:
but all shiki started as human and to me that is important


If I met Shiki, I'm perfectly sure that I would hunt them without any excuse. But it doesn't mean Shiki is bad. They are just dangerous for mankind like other man-eater animals for me. But if I have such thoughts in my mind, this means I'm also dangerous for Shiki.



If i met a shiki i would run the fastest i can XD now seriously, i would hunt them too. its a matter of to kill or to be killed...it raises a lot of questions. Choose to die, or choose to fight...
Im a very peaceful person, but i would not want to have a shiki as a neighbor and wake up on the middle of the night with my neck being bitten. Its a matter of survival. I totally understand the shiki, but since im human...i cannot stop thinking as one. Its them or us.(if i was a shiki, ofc i would hunt humans too).
I mean nature its like that, only the stronger ones survive. We humans all love the little bunnies, yet we eat them. We can all swim friendly with a shark...and we can be with him many times on a friendly way...until he feels our blood and tries to eat us.
Ofc, there are always exceptions. There are veggies everywhere XD i wish i could be one too...

ワンダーランド花 ♥

Jan 2, 2011 12:39 PM

Offline
Oct 2008
107
PenPenGrass said:
Yes, but this human was dead once as human.
So when they were dead, they were released as human life once, then become Shiki which is a different creature but with human's body and memory. It's same as zombie snail controlled by some parasite (Shiki is controlled by blood btw). We cannot say zombie snail as snail anymore.

If I met Shiki, I'm perfectly sure that I would hunt them without any excuse. But it doesn't mean Shiki is bad. They are just dangerous for mankind like other man-eater animals for me. But if I have such thoughts in my mind, this means I'm also dangerous for Shiki.


They do retain their memories so they are different from zombies. Shiki are pretty much exactly the same as humans except they sustain themselves with blood (in addition to their weaknesses).

Take for example Midori who starved herself because she didn't want to hurt someone, it's not as if she couldn't control herself she still retained her reason even while starving to death, Or just like Natsuno was able to fight them after he died and ended up killing himself. Zombies are mindless.

Some of the killings were hard to watch, I hated when Toshio experimented on his wife I just think imagine waking up and wondering what's going on only to be tortured for a few hours then killed by the person you loved. Kind of sad to me all those killings, but then I understand what Kaori was going through the paranoia of when is she going to be killed.

I don't think Shiki really have to kill people, but I think in this town they just wanted to make a safe haven for shiki by turning all the residents into one, so it was kill or be killed I guess but I still felt bad. I guess my opinion of them turned around after Toshio was experimenting on his wife, that was sad to me. And even though I never really liked Megumi that much I was still sad to see her die.
Jan 2, 2011 2:07 PM
Offline
Jun 2010
25
Emo priest and annoying little girl didn't die.

Who didn't see emo priest saving her at the end?

0/10 for not giving a brutal death to the 2 most annoying characters of all time. Unless I see a painful death, 0/10 for the rest of this series' life.
Jan 2, 2011 2:42 PM
Offline
Oct 2010
11
PenPenGrass said:
shadowii said:
almost everyone i wanted to live or die did so (happy natsuno was not a hypocrite)

but will say this on the whose better humans and shiki argument

i draw the line on those who say humans are worse and that this a prejudice story

to absolve shiki of what they do is absolving child-killing among other things


This animation erased some important parts unfortunately. That's why some people are confused about the meaning of this story.

Originally, Muroi said to Sunako in the end part "Shiki is already a being out of divine providence". So they cannot be absolved anymore. They are no more possible to be judged by the man-made law or religion. Muroi even said "We even don't have any right to be judged". However, as he continued, having life and providence are not related each other. So Shiki is going to be alive as they want anyway. That is the reason why the author wanted Sunako to survive.

Of course we can judge Shiki as an enemy because we are human, we can only judge everything from our human's point of view. But this world will allow them to keep alive anyway without our intention.

So I think good or bad discussion is completely meaningless for this story (and often this author's other stories). It's something like "Which is worse, Lion or Shark?" question.


This is why authors like her wouldnt do to well with a western audience, even when it comes to literary writing. Let's face it her reason for allowing Sunako to survive is STUPID. Because they are now a being that exceed judgment? what kind of rubbish is that?
The priest I might understand, he didnt kill anyone, apart from the old guy, he just hated the responsibility passed down on him.
Sunako was an evil little bitch that has killed and killed. She should have paid for her crimes. She's being alive for too long not to find a way to feed on humans without killing them. It's what is called satisfaction factor in fiction. My Japanese isn't so good, but frankly its a mess trying to read through Ono's dense prose so I gave up reading the novels. Why the hell are the books so long anyway?
All in all, Stephen King did a better job with Salem's lot and I know Ono was inspired by it. The anime did a wonderful job with the story because of the creep factor they added. I just wished they hadnt followed Ono's ending. It's a problem were we have almost 200 posts and almost everyone is saying the same thing that they weren't pleased with Sunako surviving.
Jan 2, 2011 2:45 PM
Offline
Oct 2010
11
If the Manga art wasnt so awful, I might have liked it better than the anime. So far I prefer the anime, I just wished it ended on a different note. Still for the awesome characters, its up there in my book.
Jan 2, 2011 3:18 PM
Offline
Dec 2007
5304
What an amazing anime. You rarely get to see a series that develops so much in just 22 episodes, from a rather dull first arc introducing almost a whole village of shallow characters to the mind-blowing savage final arc and all the story and character-building episodes in between, it was simply awesome. The atmosphere was extremely well-detailled and the second part felt really brutal and radical enough to impress even me at times. Most of all, the scenario felt right and credible from beginning to end and all the characters had a part (however small or big it may be) to play somewhere along the series, a bit like the characters from A Song Of Ice And Fire, in a different setting and format. After the first 6 episodes I would probably have rated it 7 but seeing the completedness, scope and huge success of it all, I must say it now deserves a 10. Hands down the best vampire anime ever made.

In every age, in every place, the deeds of men remain the same.
Jan 2, 2011 3:37 PM
Offline
Dec 2010
142
PenPenGrass said:
shadowii said:
thats your opinion, but i dont agree with it
particularly in the face of interactuion between human villagers and shiki villagers


Probably I 'm bit biased. But most of the things I explained are just explained in the original novel. Basically I just tried to fill in the gap between animation and novel (original story is too long to be made as animation in 22 episodes).

I think this story is quite difficult to capture. I read the original novel about 5 times and then I understood the meaning quite well, even though it explained much detail about this story.

But u can interpret this story in a different way of course, and I don't intend to force you to change. Sorry if I annoy you.


not annoyed justg stating my opinion in a discussion
i guess is why so many stories get revised in fiction
I feel i get a different batch o meaning than what ms ono might have intended
Jan 2, 2011 3:51 PM
Offline
Dec 2010
11
Ugh I have another question ^^
Why does Shoujirou shoot the female werewolf?
ShikiLoverJan 2, 2011 4:16 PM
Jan 2, 2011 4:49 PM
Offline
Jan 2011
14
Orulyon said:

Im a very peaceful person, but i would not want to have a shiki as a neighbor and wake up on the middle of the night with my neck being bitten. Its a matter of survival. I totally understand the shiki, but since im human...i cannot stop thinking as one. Its them or us.(if i was a shiki, ofc i would hunt humans too).
I mean nature its like that, only the stronger ones survive. We humans all love the little bunnies, yet we eat them. We can all swim friendly with a shark...and we can be with him many times on a friendly way...until he feels our blood and tries to eat us.
Ofc, there are always exceptions. There are veggies everywhere XD i wish i could be one too...


Yeah I have a same opinion. It's a survival issue. I just want to survive, so I will kill Shiki as human. But if I became Shiki, I would kill human to survive, although I hate any violence.

Zensational said:

Take for example Midori who starved herself because she didn't want to hurt someone, it's not as if she couldn't control herself she still retained her reason even while starving to death, Or just like Natsuno was able to fight them after he died and ended up killing himself. Zombies are mindless.


Does Midori mean Ritsuko? Ritsuko was actually really patient. But I think not many Shiki can bear such demanding situation. Shiki can only drink human blood otherwise severe hunger, which is way harder than human's one (according to Tohru), would attack their stomach. So most of them tried to resist against sucking human blood first, but then they couldn't bear this great pain and started sucking the blood.

Natsuno was also able to fight but one of the main reason was because he was a warwolf, so he didn't have to suck human blood and no pain for his survival.

Toshio's experiment also made me feel really sad and bad. It was completely madness.
It turned to a sad situation for both sides. I'd rather say it was a war between human and Shiki.

Theduchess said:

Sunako was an evil little bitch that has killed and killed. She should have paid for her crimes.


I just want to mention that Sunako was also a victim of Shiki. And the pain of hunger is unbearable for Shiki. And fear for death is as same strength as we human has.

If We were Sunako's situation, I think most of us would choose exactly the same choice of what Sunako had chosen. Perhaps, as u said, there might be another choice not to kill anybody, but I guess she already tried and gave up. In fact, Kanami was trying to co-exist with her mother who became Shiki, but it looked pretty difficult situation that someone feeds Shiki by just only the realistic amount of him/her blood. Anyway I guess it looks bit like hindsight issue.

In addition, I think Sunako already paid a lot about what she had done. Her most important Shiki and person were killed and her Sotoba family was perfectly destroyed, and she even were not allowed to suicide, she is going to be alive with her pain for long time with desperation. Suicide is a piece of cake and more irresponsible solution compared to life with desperation, at least from my personal experience hahaha. So I think she chose most difficult option.

But anyway, Yes I agree with you. I think for the people in Western culture, Ono's novels wouldn't make sense sometimes. Ono's thoughts are deeply influenced by Buddhism and Asian philosophy (her major was Buddhism when she was in a Buddhism university), and the logic behind looks really different from Western logic and thoughts unless you study the essence of epistemology. Fortunately, globalism hasn't break through the cultural difference yet LOL.
PenPenGrassJan 2, 2011 5:06 PM
Jan 2, 2011 5:10 PM

Offline
Oct 2008
107
PenPenGrass said:
Does Midori mean Ritsuko? Ritsuko was actually really patient. But I think not many Shiki can bear such demanding situation. Shiki can only drink human blood otherwise severe hunger, which is way harder than human's one (according to Tohru), would attack their stomach. So most of them tried to resist against sucking human blood first, but then they couldn't bear this great pain and started sucking the blood.

Natsuno was also able to fight but one of the main reason was because he was a warwolf, so he didn't have to suck human blood and no pain for his survival.

Toshio's experiment also made me feel really sad and bad. It was completely madness.
It turned to a sad situation for both sides. I'd rather say it was a war between human and Shiki.


Yeah, lol in my head I was like "green...her name must be midori", but yeah Ritsuko. The point was that they were able to fight their desire for blood, so they were still able to retain their reason unlike a mindless zombie that's just a host body for something else. They were conscious of what they were doing and it's not something that can't be controlled. Ritsuko in her life as a human was kind and still remained the same when she was transformed into a shiki.

Obviously it would be painful and they still have problems (especially when they are first risen) drinking blood or harming people because of their previous lives, and that they still retain their reason. They still don't want to die and that fear/pain/desire drives them to drink the blood they need to survive. I guess after watching the last few episodes (begining with Toshio's wife) just made me sympathize with the shiki a lot, and like even though I never really liked Megumi her death scene was pretty sad to me.

I still don't understand why they had to kill their victims other than wanting to make that town like the shiki's safe haven.
ZensationalJan 2, 2011 5:14 PM
Jan 2, 2011 5:22 PM
Offline
Jan 2011
14
shadowii said:

not annoyed justg stating my opinion in a discussion
i guess is why so many stories get revised in fiction
I feel i get a different batch o meaning than what ms ono might have intended


OK.
It's quite interesting to me to see different kind of impressions and opinions. :)

ShikiLover said:
Ugh I have another question ^^
Why does Shoujirou shoot the female werewolf?


Because Natsuno bited Shoujirou and he controlled him. You can see the scars on Shoujirou's right arm.
Jan 2, 2011 5:56 PM
Offline
Jan 2011
14
Zensational said:
PenPenGrass said:
Does Midori mean Ritsuko? Ritsuko was actually really patient. But I think not many Shiki can bear such demanding situation. Shiki can only drink human blood otherwise severe hunger, which is way harder than human's one (according to Tohru), would attack their stomach. So most of them tried to resist against sucking human blood first, but then they couldn't bear this great pain and started sucking the blood.

Natsuno was also able to fight but one of the main reason was because he was a warwolf, so he didn't have to suck human blood and no pain for his survival.

Toshio's experiment also made me feel really sad and bad. It was completely madness.
It turned to a sad situation for both sides. I'd rather say it was a war between human and Shiki.


Yeah, lol in my head I was like "green...her name must be midori", but yeah Ritsuko. The point was that they were able to fight their desire for blood, so they were still able to retain their reason unlike a mindless zombie that's just a host body for something else. They were conscious of what they were doing and it's not something that can't be controlled. Ritsuko in her life as a human was kind and still remained the same when she was transformed into a shiki.

Obviously it would be painful and they still have problems (especially when they are first risen) drinking blood or harming people because of their previous lives, and that they still retain their reason. They still don't want to die and that fear/pain/desire drives them to drink the blood they need to survive. I guess after watching the last few episodes (begining with Toshio's wife) just made me sympathize with the shiki a lot, and like even though I never really liked Megumi her death scene was pretty sad to me.

I still don't understand why they had to kill their victims other than wanting to make that town like the shiki's safe haven.


Do you know Midori is Ritsuko's sister lol? So I was also confused.

Yeah...I also felt sympathy to them. And Megumi in final episode made me feel sad though I dont like her so much like you.

I think the reason why they killed all victims were because 1. They needed to exclude human from Sotoba village anyway to make Shiki's village 2. Sunako wanted to have as many Shiki as she can in this village not to feel loneliness.
Second reason was actually told by Tatsumi in a novel with the word of "childish dream". One of Sunako's problem was that she was too childish and lonely as Shiki.
PenPenGrassJan 2, 2011 6:13 PM
Jan 2, 2011 7:01 PM

Offline
Apr 2009
141
PenPenGrass said:
If I met Shiki, I'm perfectly sure that I would hunt them without any excuse.

I however, in a setting that was presented in this show, would most likely ask them to bite me.

Also, to those people whining about how much they hate Sunako/Sesishin surviving...
You should stick to shonen - this anime was probably not meant for you.
You missed the fact there where no good or bad guys in this story to begin with.
Brother killing brother was the theme here.
Shiki where clearly shown to be just as much human as the villagers.
Or are you saying what makes someone 'human' is simply the way their bodies function?
Pff.

I suppose you can indeed choose to put blame on Sunako for setting things in motion, personally tho, I can sympathise with her reasons for doing so.
Saying however, that the villagers had some right to murder rest of the Shiki, aka - people who lived in that village just as long as them and had every right to continue doing so...
That's just utter bigotry.
(And no - 'to protect themselves from Shiki' is not a good enough reason in my eyes.)
XayozJan 3, 2011 5:19 AM
Whenever you correct someone's grammar just remember that nobody likes you.
Jan 2, 2011 7:34 PM

Offline
Aug 2010
21
at the end, it's mr muroi in the car but whats in the box? and also when did Akira get away? i can't remember anything being mentiond about him escaping that okiagari
Jan 2, 2011 7:48 PM

Offline
May 2010
241
My impressions are here http://wp.me/p12uiW-1QC
Jan 2, 2011 8:09 PM

Offline
Jul 2008
1281
Xayoz said:
I suppose you can indeed choose to put blame on Sunako for setting things in motion, personally tho, I can sympathise with her reasons for doing so.
Saying however, that the villagers had some right to murder rest of the Shiki, aka - people who lived in that village just as long as them and had every right to continue doing so...
That's just utter bigotry.
(And no - 'to protect themselves from Shiki' is not a good enough reason in my eyes.)


What bigotry? There's no bigotry in wanting to destroy something who's only source of food is humans, i.e. human-exclusive, that even their own population comes from humans. Those facts already separates them from, let's say, sharks, because obviously if humans were the only prey of sharks most should have died by now because if there are 10,000 sharks in the world and only 1,000 shark attacks, what happens to the sharks that didn't attack any humans? Obviously they preyed on other animals.

I however, in a setting that was presented in this show, would most likely ask them to bite me.

Also, to those people whining about how much they hate Sunako/Sesishin surviving...
You should stick to shonen - this anime was probably not meant for you.
You missed the fact there where no good or bad guys in this story to begin with.
Brother killing brother was the theme here.
Shiki where clearly shown to be just as much human as the villagers.
Or are you saying what makes someone 'human' is simply the way their bodies function?
Pff.


They can never be "just as much human" as the villagers because they already died! There's no need to delved on biological functions; that's one of the things that differentiates the shiki from the humans, they died but can still exist with an animated body, a consciousness and cognitive thinking (but presumably without a soul/lifeforce/spirit/whatever).

You consider the shiki as "human" yet then agreeing in the assessment that the shiki follow different standards from humans? LOLWUT
Jan 2, 2011 9:06 PM

Offline
Jul 2008
64
MASTERPIECE!!
After this.. How can I bring myself to watch vampire series again?!
Jan 2, 2011 9:08 PM
Offline
Oct 2010
11
PenPenGrass said:
Orulyon said:

Im a very peaceful person, but i would not want to have a shiki as a neighbor and wake up on the middle of the night with my neck being bitten. Its a matter of survival. I totally understand the shiki, but since im human...i cannot stop thinking as one. Its them or us.(if i was a shiki, ofc i would hunt humans too).
I mean nature its like that, only the stronger ones survive. We humans all love the little bunnies, yet we eat them. We can all swim friendly with a shark...and we can be with him many times on a friendly way...until he feels our blood and tries to eat us.
Ofc, there are always exceptions. There are veggies everywhere XD i wish i could be one too...


Yeah I have a same opinion. It's a survival issue. I just want to survive, so I will kill Shiki as human. But if I became Shiki, I would kill human to survive, although I hate any violence.

Zensational said:

Take for example Midori who starved herself because she didn't want to hurt someone, it's not as if she couldn't control herself she still retained her reason even while starving to death, Or just like Natsuno was able to fight them after he died and ended up killing himself. Zombies are mindless.


Does Midori mean Ritsuko? Ritsuko was actually really patient. But I think not many Shiki can bear such demanding situation. Shiki can only drink human blood otherwise severe hunger, which is way harder than human's one (according to Tohru), would attack their stomach. So most of them tried to resist against sucking human blood first, but then they couldn't bear this great pain and started sucking the blood.

Natsuno was also able to fight but one of the main reason was because he was a warwolf, so he didn't have to suck human blood and no pain for his survival.

Toshio's experiment also made me feel really sad and bad. It was completely madness.
It turned to a sad situation for both sides. I'd rather say it was a war between human and Shiki.

Theduchess said:

Sunako was an evil little bitch that has killed and killed. She should have paid for her crimes.


I just want to mention that Sunako was also a victim of Shiki. And the pain of hunger is unbearable for Shiki. And fear for death is as same strength as we human has.

If We were Sunako's situation, I think most of us would choose exactly the same choice of what Sunako had chosen. Perhaps, as u said, there might be another choice not to kill anybody, but I guess she already tried and gave up. In fact, Kanami was trying to co-exist with her mother who became Shiki, but it looked pretty difficult situation that someone feeds Shiki by just only the realistic amount of him/her blood. Anyway I guess it looks bit like hindsight issue.

In addition, I think Sunako already paid a lot about what she had done. Her most important Shiki and person were killed and her Sotoba family was perfectly destroyed, and she even were not allowed to suicide, she is going to be alive with her pain for long time with desperation. Suicide is a piece of cake and more irresponsible solution compared to life with desperation, at least from my personal experience hahaha. So I think she chose most difficult option.

But anyway, Yes I agree with you. I think for the people in Western culture, Ono's novels wouldn't make sense sometimes. Ono's thoughts are deeply influenced by Buddhism and Asian philosophy (her major was Buddhism when she was in a Buddhism university), and the logic behind looks really different from Western logic and thoughts unless you study the essence of epistemology. Fortunately, globalism hasn't break through the cultural difference yet LOL.


Thanks for replying. I guess Ono's writes in her own way. I understood there were no bad or good guys and that wasnt what bothered me. As much as I didnt like the priest I didnt have a problem with him surviving. I think both human and Shiki became beast and both should have died.
Do you know why she allowed Ozaki to live? what was the philosophy behind that? because frankly I think he crossed the line as well? Sure, he was trying to protect the village, but something about him was very off. If you have the time please tell me more about his character in the book. He seemed very apathetic in the anime.
Jan 2, 2011 9:34 PM

Offline
Jul 2009
338
Megumi suffered a brutal death.

/nothingelsematters
Jan 2, 2011 9:45 PM

Offline
Jun 2008
631
nicoliolipoli said:


Also, can ANYONE please help me understand two things.
1- Who was in the blue car at the end, and what was in the box? Was that Muroi & Sunako? :o (JUST REWATCHED, and I'm confirming that it was Muroi driving. The person had glasses and the same eyes as him.)
2- Who got on the bus during the credits that the two kids (forgot their name) were surprised to see?

Does this mean a sequel? Because although the people in the car might be who I said, I have never seen the two people on the bus..

(Woah, I just realized how much I wrote, sorry).


The car is Muroi and Sunako, that is obvious
From what I could see in the tiny bus scene was Natsuno's Dad and some other lady that I am not even sure who it was.
Jan 2, 2011 10:29 PM
Offline
Dec 2010
142
Xayoz said:
shadowii said:
If I met Shiki, I'm perfectly sure that I would hunt them without any excuse.

I however, in a setting that was presented in this show, would most likely ask them to bite me.

Also, to those people whining about how much they hate Sunako/Sesishin surviving...
You should stick to shonen - this anime was probably not meant for you.
You missed the fact there where no good or bad guys in this story to begin with.
Brother killing brother was the theme here.
Shiki where clearly shown to be just as much human as the villagers.
Or are you saying what makes someone 'human' is simply the way their bodies function?
Pff.

I suppose you can indeed choose to put blame on Sunako for setting things in motion, personally tho, I can sympathise with her reasons for doing so.
Saying however, that the villagers had some right to murder rest of the Shiki, aka - people who lived in that village just as long as them and had every right to continue doing so...
That's just utter bigotry.
(And no - 'to protect themselves from Shiki' is not a good enough reason in my eyes.)


uh thats nice and all but i think you got the quote wrong
i dont remember typing that
and whatever you could call this bigotry is definately not the right word (especially since you cannot deny who started killing first)
shadowiiJan 2, 2011 10:36 PM
Jan 3, 2011 2:29 AM
Offline
Nov 2008
608
Until the end I still can't decide which side i was on.....and in the end both sides faded....very symbolic ending...great anime 10/10.
Jan 3, 2011 3:51 AM
Offline
Oct 2009
29
Poor Megumi D:

Phew! Sunako and Muroi are alive !
Jan 3, 2011 4:11 AM
Offline
Jan 2011
14
Theduchess said:
Thanks for replying. I guess Ono's writes in her own way. I understood there were no bad or good guys and that wasnt what bothered me. As much as I didnt like the priest I didnt have a problem with him surviving. I think both human and Shiki became beast and both should have died.
Do you know why she allowed Ozaki to live? what was the philosophy behind that? because frankly I think he crossed the line as well? Sure, he was trying to protect the village, but something about him was very off. If you have the time please tell me more about his character in the book. He seemed very apathetic in the anime.



Well.. to be honest, I don't know the reason why Ozaki could survive. One of the clue would be Muroi's words when Sunako decided to stay in Sotoba and fight against villagers. Muroi said to Sunako in his mind that "Sunako you should escape from here. You don't really understand about how people in this village can turn to be fearful and cruel, once they set up their mind.".

In another word, Shiki is basically weaker beings than mankind, once human recognizes its existence and define as enemies. There was a description in the novel something like "Shiki's superior position is only secured if nobody believes its existence". In fact, Shiki fought better in the animation than the novel. In the novel, Shiki was just hunted and killed brutally for over 100 page descriptions in the final part without any effective resistance.

So, IMHO, he survived maybe because he was the person who recognized Shiki and succeeded to make people understand it. Maybe he represents the cruel part of humanity (but I'm not so sure).

Ozaki in the novel was even more apathetic than this animation btw. I kinda like and hate him together LOL.
PenPenGrassJan 3, 2011 4:32 AM
Jan 3, 2011 4:21 AM

Offline
Jul 2009
538
Xayoz said:
shadowii said:
If I met Shiki, I'm perfectly sure that I would hunt them without any excuse.

I however, in a setting that was presented in this show, would most likely ask them to bite me.

Also, to those people whining about how much they hate Sunako/Sesishin surviving...
You should stick to shonen - this anime was probably not meant for you.
You missed the fact there where no good or bad guys in this story to begin with.
Brother killing brother was the theme here.
Shiki where clearly shown to be just as much human as the villagers.
Or are you saying what makes someone 'human' is simply the way their bodies function?
Pff.

I suppose you can indeed choose to put blame on Sunako for setting things in motion, personally tho, I can sympathise with her reasons for doing so.
Saying however, that the villagers had some right to murder rest of the Shiki, aka - people who lived in that village just as long as them and had every right to continue doing so...
That's just utter bigotry.
(And no - 'to protect themselves from Shiki' is not a good enough reason in my eyes.)


Shiki weren't shown as being just as human as humans though, do you not remember that terrifying scene where Megumi bit Tohru? The scene that pretty much broke Natsuno?

They were, for the most part, monsters. Even Sunako when she was being kept in that shed, she couldn't hold her urge to bite people and kill them. It isn't about having human emotions although most of the Shiki who enjoyed being Shiki seemed to be completely insane except Tatsumi who was badass.

The villagers are completely right to kill the Shiki. They're undead creatures that kill humans. Not only that, but the fact of the matter is that not everybody rises. Some just die and a life is wasted, while some of the Shiki hate themselves (Tohru, Rit-Chan and to a point Sunako). The point was that Sunako didn't choose the path of suicide (Which you could call the "Easier" route, but looking at Rit-Chan's condition when she refused to eat, I'd say it's the hard route) but instead continued to live if you can call it that. She fought against the fate presented to her but is indeed making thousands suffer. Seishirin is no different now.

Also, I think the one who should stick to shonen is you if you gave in to this sympathetic visage Sunako is putting up. She isn't the hero of this story.
Pages (20) « First ... « 4 5 [6] 7 8 » ... Last »

More topics from this board

Poll: » Shiki Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )

starrysky - Jul 15, 2010

202 by ANONYMOUS_YUKINO »»
Nov 22, 2:46 AM

» Muroi is one of the worst characters in anime ( 1 2 3 )

masaba - Mar 30, 2011

102 by L01MK »»
Nov 10, 3:09 PM

Poll: » Shiki Episode 15 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )

tsubasalover - Nov 11, 2010

216 by L01MK »»
Nov 7, 11:28 AM

Poll: » Shiki Episode 21 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

tsubasalover - Dec 23, 2010

317 by emivenus »»
Nov 5, 3:59 AM

Poll: » Shiki Episode 20 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Oosran - Dec 16, 2010

282 by TheColonel76 »»
Oct 28, 5:27 PM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login