| @CaptainYossarian Only got about five that are rated 10, so this is gonaa be short. Cowboy Bebop is beyond excellent, definitley deserves a ten...and not just because I also rated it 10. The movie on the other hand deserves a 9 in my opinion. I felt that the movie couldn't top the anime, mostly because I think that the movie drags on more then it should have. Don't get me wrong it was a great movie, but the anime just gave more to offer. as for Honey and Clover, Millennium Actress, and Planetes, I haven't watched them so I have nothing to say about them. |
 |
| Renagade -Cowboy Bebop, great series, just not a 10 for me, but I see how it can be for most people -DBZ....nostalgically, yes, logically no -another TTGL 10! hooray! -Haruhi...I didn't like this show. I didn't hate it either, although I did hate Haruhi herself, I found it average, I still don't get all the hype for it -I'm currently watching GITS, but apparently haven't hit any Complex episodes where it gets good. I didn't like the first 3 eps, apparently they were all Stand Alones |
| Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann- i reckon its pretty awesome but not a masterpiece Interstella5555 - The 5tory of The 5ecret 5tar 5ystem- i forget what i rated it but it was pretty amazing |
 |
| Since you seem to be cursed with only getting evaluations from people who haven't seen most of your 10's, I, having seen all of them, will participate in this thread. Interstella: Yuck NO. Maybe I just don't like techno, maybe I just don't care for the 'music changes/obsesses the world/galaxy' mindset, maybe I was just disturbed by how inferior it was to Matsumoto's other works, but I did not like it. Guitar-ship man was the only interesting character, and they killed him off. I only watched to the end because I was hoping they'd pull one of those back-from-the-dead plot twists and give him a happy end, but it was boring either way. LOGH-If I was to form a top 10 list, it would be there, but it certainly wasn't THAT great for me. This might sound strange for a series of such a huge scale, but I wish they'd spent more time on the setting. Like the economies and societies and resources of individual planets. As someone who enjoys IRL history, it felt like various factors were left out or inadequately explained. I suppose there wasn't time for more than what we got, or maybe I'll be contented when I watch the gaidens. At least it's already awesome. Metropolis-amazing animation, cool style, but I didn't like most of the characters. They killed off Wakamoto-bot halfway through and kept giving Rock the short end of the stick when he was a million times more interesting than the protagonist. The plot was interesting and more unique than most distopia stuff, and I laughed when the robot girl(who I did like, but could've been better) was beating up the main guy. Decent movie, but I don't see what was amazing about it. Princess Tutu-yes agree love we're pals now kthnx. GL-again lacking in depth, not enough done for minor characters, but fun for the over-the-top yelling from mechs that it is. Post-timeskip was shallower than the earlier stuff(riding around in a spaceship shooting at stuff to save the girl was pretty bland next to the earlier battles). A hell of a lot cooler and better thought out than most hot-blood and/or scifi/mech action tends to be. Pretty darn cool and respectable. |
| Hmmm, I only know TTGL, I think thats a bit overrated. It was a funny show, but some of the characters were really annoying. I dont get why it is rated so high on MAL. |
| There Is A Light That Never Goes Out |
| lol, 3 people replying on the same list ;P |
| There Is A Light That Never Goes Out |
| ^ Merridian--- Ah... Quite a few I am not aware of. But of the ones I have watched: Neon Genesis Evangelion: Regardless of how amazing it was from a psychological standpoint, in my opinion, I felt the story wasn't particularly outstanding nor were the characters particularly likeable (though that might have been the point). And frankly, the ending annoyed me to no end. I haven't seen the End of Evangelion, though, so my opinion may not be entirely justified. Castle in the Sky: I saw it quite a long while ago so I don't remember entirely, but I remember liking it so I'll agree with you. Cowboy Bebop: Entirely, yes. Just yes. TTGL: Ah, I am nearly done watching this one myself. I'd probably give it an 8 or 9 so far. Personally, I find most of the characters rather shallow and annoying, though that could easily change in the next few episodes. But I admit, it is entirely epic. |
| OF the 10s you have, I know... Death Note Very good anime, but it lacked something to top it up for me Cowboy Bebop One of my favorites but not 10 imo.... 9.5 from me, 9 in the list :D |
| No sig :( |
| Merridian There were a few 10's in you're list that I haven't seen but those that I have seen: Cowboy Bebop is a great series and I think it deserves every 10 it gets so very big thumbs up for that. Then there were those classic movies (Akira, Ghost in the Shell) though which I wouldn't give 10's but I understand I someone would give because they are excllent movies. But then there was Berserk. 10 for the anime? It was okay series in my mind or so I thought it was untill I started reading the manga. Though even before I even started reading it, I thought it had a few major problems. I definetly disagree with you there. Overall the series/movies that you gave 10 were fairly good (atleast the ones I have seen) and the list is pretty good. |
MetukkeliJan 10, 2010 2:12 PM
| MetalGearShake I definitely agree that Ruorouni Kenshin Tsuiokuhen is a masterpiece. Everything was perfect in it. Cowboy Bebop got a 10 from me just after I completed it, but later on, I downgraded it to 9. Something's missing in it to call it a masterpiece :) Same thing goes for the movie. Havent seen the other ones. |
| No sig :( |
| Algirdyz Ok...i'm impressed. Cool anime list style. Code Geass - Yes. Defnitely. Glad to see you rated the second season lower. TTGL - No surprise there. Texhnolyze - I've been coming across this name too frequently now. And i'v been hearing good things about it. But I don't like depressing anime. It's still ther in my PtW. |
 |
| Boony -man, your list is kinda hard to read, that white font just kinda disappears into Spike if you ask me -Cowboy Bebop, good stuff, not quite a 10 for me, but good stuff nontheless -Gankutsuou....I'm debating dropping this one on a visuals basis, but I was enjoying it. Either way if I had finished it, those visuals would keep it from ever being a 10 for me. -Kino's Journey is a great series, I've been meaning to rewatch it, I'm fairly certain my score would go up at least one. -LoGH, 10 here too :P -Monster...I find it rather overrated and with little rewatch value personally, I liked it the first time, but never truly loved it. |
| @classicalzawa out of your 10s I have only seen TTGL and Metropolis TTGL is too epic not to get a 10 :D no comments Metropolis was a little above average. Nothing special I think. And definitely not 10 |
| No sig :( |
| @Algirdyz I haven't seen any of your 10's but I can say a few things. The Aoi Bungaku Series I just looked up sounds fantastic and has great artists behind it, so you may have peaked my interest in viewing this series. I've been meaning to watch the Kara No Kyoukai's and Code Geass so its good to hear more praise from those awaiting my attention. Lastly there is the Rurouni Kenshin OVA's this series gets a lot of positive attention but I've never been bothered to watch it yet, so another positive review of the series and apparently excellent OVA's may help me get to watching them. |
| @Zutrax Black Lagoon: The Second Barrage - I watched this one without knowing it was second season and then searched unfortunately for this supposed second season. I don’t think this is worth ten. There is many good shows and this one is one of them but not 10. Eureka Seven - I couldn’t get into Eureka. First 15 episodes were pain to watch. But the ideas behind the show were nice. Full Metal Panic? Fumoffu . I laughed to this one. It was fun. Easy going show for long evenings. Higurashi no Naku Koro ni - But there were so many plot holes, which never got explanation. I am sure that they were explained in game, but not here. Point down. Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann - I once rated it 10 before I watched Law of Ueki and found it superior. I like strategy based battles better than power based ones. |
| @ monkatx Baccano!: very awesome show with lovely music and characters. I rated this 9 because it was rather short. Terra e... : pretty underrated sci-fi anime with a pretty deep story. Isn't as good as the seikai series though. Haibane Renmei: Show I still have to watch because I am scared that it will be too dramatic Bokurano: Haven't watched but it's on my too watch list Princess Tutu: ^ Kemono no Souja Erin: One of the best shows of last season. People call this a kids show but it turned out to be one of my fav shows of last year... Erin is <3 Aoi Bangaku Series: dropped after 2 episodes because of lack of subs... might check it out later |
| lifeaspect -Cowboy Bebop, while good for me, just wasn't a 10 for me. -I find Monster massively overrated, having little rewatch/reread value doesn't help this figure for me. -Girl Who Leapt Through Time's ending was just awful and felt rushed to me, even if I liked the rest of the movie well enough -I need to check out Aria because Junichi Sato is amazing -I saw most of Nausicaa on TV ages ago, I really dislike Miyazaki and the heroine of the story is one of my main reasons why, I just don't think she's as right as she and Miyazaki both think she is, I really dislike his story and characters, but that's just me. |
| @classicalzawa You only got one 10 on your list that you and I share, and thats Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann. What can I say, Gurren Lagann is probably the best anime ever (in my opinion). the characters are great, the animation is as awesome as the voice acting, the story is freaking epic beyond proportions, and oh god I can just do this all day. Anyway you get the picture, TTGL is just awesome! |
|
| Full metal alchemist- totally deserves a 10 When they Cry- still watching it though i don't know what score ill settle on in the end, though its one of the most...interesting moe/ harem anime Ive seen Haruhi- An excellent anime, though i dont think it deserves a 10 Cowboy Bebop- 100% agree, a classic Needless- never seen it Dragon Ball Z (U.S.)- interesting Trigun- never seen the anime but Ive read abit of the manga and it seems quite good. Tenjou Tenge- never seen it. |
| Renagade07 Out fo your 10s I have seen only CG, CG R2, TTGL, Needless, Cowboy Bebop. I would agree on almost all of them, that they are really good and are worth a 10. Except Needless :P. Lol wtf? that is definitely not a masterpiece... It was a mediocre.... |
| No sig :( |
| Code geass (both) well when first i watched the series i rated it highly too, but after rewatching it i changed my mind. though first season is better than second i still don't think they deserve 10. 10 to FMA? weird i think brotherhood is much more better. i guess that i shouldn't say anything about Haruhi, cause i really disliked the series from the beginning higurashi...ummm the show is good but not of a masterpiece i guess and in the end TTGL :3 when it goes with this show i'm totally partial. |
| Kaltsu on your two 10s... FLCL is one unique anime for me by standards, thus this means a unique preference from you for making it rated as masterpiece...never fully previewed it yet though... TTGL in the first blush is an overrated yet epic anime...popularity and artistic plotline/animation could be the factor of such deserving rating by preference... |
| I like Clannad~After story, but i dont know the others. |
| I havent seen any of them, but I am planning to watch clannad. |
| No sig :( |
| @Algirdyz Rurouni Kenshin: Tsuiokuhen - Definitely a masterpiece Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann - a very good show indeed, but super robots and yelling, can't give a ten. Kara no Kyoukai 5: and 7 - Are these movies really good? haven't watched them. But seems I should watch them. |
We are the United. Even in defeat we stand united. |
-Freedom_Gunboy- said: @Algirdyz Rurouni Kenshin: Tsuiokuhen - Definitely a masterpiece Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann - a very good show indeed, but super robots and yelling, can't give a ten. Kara no Kyoukai 5: and 7 - Are these movies really good? haven't watched them. But seems I should watch them. Most of them I don't know, but I agree with you about NANA. ^^ |
 |
| The only one I know is Monster. I have started watching it recently, and I really love it. Out of the first few eps I would have give it 10 for sure. But later on they put a few crappy eps in, which had nothing to do with the main story. I was annoyed. But I will definitely finish it and judge it then :) |
| No sig :( |
Algirdyz said: The only one I know is Monster. I have started watching it recently, and I really love it. Out of the first few eps I would have give it 10 for sure. But later on they put a few crappy eps in, which had nothing to do with the main story. I was annoyed. But I will definitely finish it and judge it then :) Oh no, in the end, it will all make sense. Maybe rightnow you think it's got nothing to do with the main plot, but it does, really. By the way, I don't know anyof your 10's. |
|
| @Kaltsu TTGL and FLCL? You have fantastic taste my friend. Gainax's best. |
| My first novel, Kardia has been published! Click here to read! |
| Splitter Ive only seen TTGL out of your 10s and I totally agree on it. Its too epic for a 9. |
| No sig :( |
| @Merridian All the anime you have given 10 are indeed class acts and i can see why you would want to give them a perfect score. I am in totally agreement about Cowboy Beebop as its one of my all time favourites series of anything! The ony thing i would say is maybe wrong is "Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann"... I agree that the characther design and artstyle and animation is amazing... even the overall story is quite good... but i think the way the show is paced and how the storyline is developed is abit gamey almost!! The show just kinda explodes into these upgrade in power and you end up feeling like its just a case of rinise and repeat and that no matter the odds the humans will win. |
| I'm just an immortal kind of guy... |
| ricosaur I've yet to watch Princess Mononoke and Cowboy Bebop. But it's good to see that you are selective when it comes to rating anime a 10. |
| no 10s :D I win the thread!!! |
| No sig :( |
| ^ Okay i agree with all your tens that I've seen besides Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann 10 is waaaaaay too high. I gave it a 7 but thinking about it now I think i should have rated it a 5. |
| Yukari -If I don't comment, haven't seen it -Mmmm, Baccano! Also similar, we rated the side OVA 1 lower than the main series. -I must disagree with Death Note, the first half was getting damn close to 10 for me, but the 2nd half? No, not at all, killed 10 potential for me. -10 for Howl's? Strange, most Miyazaki fans seem to rate that movie low. I hate Miyazaki, so I'll just leave it at that and I hated Princess Mononoke too. -I've started watching the Kara no Kyoukai series, I've only seen the first one, but I seem to see a lot of 10s for at least 1 of the movies. The first movie has only convinced me to keep watching for now. -Mushi-shi is always a "hell yes!", just wish they would give us more! -I'm not a big fan of Girl Who Leapt Through Time's somewhat awkward and rushed ending made me rather not like it a ton. |
Yukari said: ^ Okay i agree with all your tens that I've seen besides Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann 10 is waaaaaay too high. I gave it a 7 but thinking about it now I think i should have rated it a 5. @ Yukari Never watched 5 CPS, so I can't say much on that. However just about anything made by His Majesty The King of Anime Hayao Miyazaki I believe deserves a 10 so I agree with you on those animes. Death Note however good and addicting, I don't think deserved a 10. Just seemed to me like the plot kinda stalled out, recovered, but not at the same altitude (plane geek talk here) around Unfortunately everything else I never watched, please forgive me and my due lack of watching anime. V_V I'm sure they were all good regardless though. :) |
| I haven't seen any of your 10s except for Elfen Lied, so there's no much to say. Elfen LIed was good, but I personally think an 8 might've been better. |
     |
| PenguinChika Gintama- Yeah, it deserves a 10. Really awesome except for some eps like the 'hard boiled egg' one. |
| pmpy Higurashi no Naku Koro ni- It was awesome, but the art and animation could've been so much better. Higurashi no Naku Koro ni Kai- I thought it was a letdown. Not scary. School Days- Liked it in the psychological sense, but hated all the damn characters. |
More topics from this board
» Give Anything To The User Above You v.10 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Kunii - Sep 13, 2022 |
5149 |
by dfsafsaf
»»
12 seconds ago |
|
» Say Something You Have In Common With The Person Above v5 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Kunii - Jun 25, 2021 |
8802 |
by dfsafsaf
»»
1 minute ago |
|
» Rate 1-10 how much aura the user above has ( 1 2 3 4 )Masuko - Jan 20 |
150 |
by iHateAnimeBro
»»
1 minute ago |
|
» How often do you see the user above in the forums? ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )lucasmrNd - Aug 20, 2021 |
8501 |
by LabMemberX
»»
2 minutes ago |
|
» Have you talked to the user above? v2 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )DeadlyRaven - Nov 14, 2019 |
8076 |
by LabMemberX
»»
3 minutes ago |