| maybe sora no otoshimono final, they try to squeeze 1-2 season possibility into 1 movie. tsukimichi, i know this based on LN but i prefer manga version (story more detailed) if anime really following LN version. |
 - -  |
Vibranium95 said: sadly true man. should've just remained a one-shot, would've wasted way less pages that way.ANTITHE5IS said: If we're terrible honest here, Bleach doesn't even deserve a manga.Hell's Paradise was a butchered productional wreck and M(ID)APPA tarnished its reputation when it should've gotten similar treatment to Jujutsu Kaisen. I consider it the only good modern fighting shounen manga. If we're being brutally honest here, One Piece doesn't even deserve an anime. |
 |
| chainsaw man manga - best manga ever created in modern times chainsaw man anime - straight up garbage made for normies |
    |
Za_Panda said: I just said that I disliked the CGI but still rated the Anime high but you One Piece Fans are so doltish you find excuses just to attack random people on the InternetOne piece Faxtual_Ghoul said: I am just biased against CGI but I still rated it fairly >bias- inclination or prejudice for/against one person, group or topic, especially in a way considered to be unfair >fair- impartial and just, without favouritism, discrimination or prejudice >self-proclaimed high level thinker  |
| If you want to reply to my posts, come up with valid arguments instead of ad hominem HIGHER LEVEL THINKERS ONLY |
suneys said: Yeah, the OP and first two episodes feel like they were worked on by a completely different team than the rest; the nosedive in production was jarring. The manga also has this delicately free-flowing visual presentation that's very beautiful and neutralizes the expositions. Meanwhile, the anime's direction lacks any artistry. Quality felt more like that of a long-running shounen occupied with churning out the weekly episode on time as opposed to a flagship seasonal battle shounen. Too bad this was an afterthought from the studio despite inherently carrying far more potential for greatness than CSM.ANTITHE5IS said: Hell's Paradise was a butchered productional wreck and M(ID)APPA tarnished its reputation when it should've gotten similar treatment to Jujutsu Kaisen. I consider it the only good modern fighting shounen manga. It starts off great but after sometime one can see inconsistency in the animation, the plot starts dragging with too much explanation as a result of which it ends on an unsatisfying note. I consider Jigokuraku to be on the same level as my favorite new generation shonen that is JJK but sadly the anime doesn't live up to it. Not a big fan of the JJK manga because I don't like its presentation and the stuff past Shibuya Incident, but the anime is one of my favourites from the genre. The direction for S2 in particular has been amazing so far and it'll be adapting one of the best arcs in shounen to match. |
 |
Thanatos1 said: CSM was a perfect adaptation. Moreover they added extra contact to enhance the source material.Girls' Last Tour and Chainsaw Man are the only ones that come to mind. |
| Nah, the Claymore anime is still the best adaptation it could have realistically had honestly. For me, OPM S2 of course. And nanatsu no taizai, rip :(. |
 |
kushakashi said: D.Gray-man's anime wasn't bad tho.kings game, claymore, berserk, kingdom, one piece, tokyo ghoul , d.gray man, the promised neverland (goldy pond onwards ofc), vampire hunter D, record of ragnorok. these are just some of the great manga that have garbage anime adaptations. i can name more if you want. |
 |
| How topical, Helck is airing right now. Though, I still have to give this one to Hoshi no Samidare. |
baki im no where near caught up to the manga but i've seen comparisons of the current season to the manga and its disappointing i mean i understand that the anime will never look as good as the manga but i would've liked a little more detail.  |
bubba460zAug 27, 2023 4:00 AM
 |
kushakashi said: I don't mind the rearranged events, pacing and fillers, they gave certain characters more characterization and made them more memorable, and characters going off-model at certain parts is something that always happen in anime. Also DGM is not even close to ending, the manga is still being published, so I see no issue about the ending other than it ends on a cliffhanger (which was needed as the manga was going through a hiatus at the time).Illyricus said: D.Gray-man's anime wasn't bad tho. some events are changed a little bit, there are noticeable fillers throughout, pacing is kinda wobbly at times, occasionally characters go in and out of model and it also ends like 50 chapters before the actual ending. all in all, it's on the better side of the bunch but it's still noticeably worse than the manga. you can check this out if you want to talk about it a bit more: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=37613 I can respect you preferring the manga, but saying the anime is garbage is beyond harsh. |
|
Faxtual_Ghoul said: HnK has an amazing adaptation that greatly surpassed manga for the part it adaptedAll my favorite Mangas and Light Novels never got a perfect adaptation Tokyo Ghoul, Blade of the Immortal, Houseki no Kuni, Shinsekai Yori |
 |
MarkVijet said: No, it did not surpass the MangaFaxtual_Ghoul said: HnK has an amazing adaptation that greatly surpassed manga for the part it adaptedAll my favorite Mangas and Light Novels never got a perfect adaptation Tokyo Ghoul, Blade of the Immortal, Houseki no Kuni, Shinsekai Yori SHAFT should have adapted all those Manga I mentioned because other studios simply cannot create the appropriate ambience for Seinen |
| If you want to reply to my posts, come up with valid arguments instead of ad hominem HIGHER LEVEL THINKERS ONLY |
Faxtual_Ghoul said: Gallop, Deen, Madhouse, Shin-ei, and TMS have all made great adaptations of seinen manga.SHAFT should have adapted all those Manga I mentioned because other studios simply cannot create the appropriate ambience for Seinen |
| その目だれの目？ |
| Record Of Ragnarok had very good art and yet such a bad adaptation. |
Vibranium95 said: One Piece, Tokyo Revengers. They don't deserve the treatment they get for them. One Piece is an all time masterpiece, bruh. |
| Anyone who says Chainsaw Man are entitled to their false normie opinions. |
| It's not out yet in fact it's out next year. It's called Mato Seihei no Slave. I started reading the manga last night and remembered there is an anime of it coming out. I watched the trailer and did it look back compared to the manga. |
"Nobody could laugh at someone who's trying their hardest" -Machio- |
| obv Hell's Paradise & CSM I doubt anyone who gets triggered by that opinion have read those thoroughly I'm mostly disappointed with Aku no Hana, the animation is ass and the butchered art-style is so unattractive, why would they bother with a tryhard philosophical route if they wouldn't bother adapting the part that makes Aku no Hana good ?? |
| The Hoshi no Samidare anime adaptation was awful lmao. It deserved better. |
| 07-Ghost, I think. I think it would have been more interesting if someone else was in charge of writing the script. |
        |
eli_shmeli said: Thanatos1 said: Girls' Last Tour and Chainsaw Man are the only ones that come to mind. girls last tour??? huh??? man that's crazy, i don't know what u mean I mean that the anime doesn't look as good as the manga in my opinion. |
 |
| The Promised Neverland, I don't even need to explain the reason lol, the score I give to the second season is my rate for everything but the plot. Toilet Bound Hanako-kun, at first sight it's actually fine but when I take a look at the anime adaptation again it feels like they made cheap new brand of the manga. The inconsistent quality of the cutesy-manga-like animation style... overall is just, meh. Well, I think that's just my personal problem since everyone like the anime but me. |
 |
Faxtual_Ghoul said: YO!! my son. I am officer jim hopper, wanna file a report against them ho ho!!Za_Panda said: I just said that I disliked the CGI but still rated the Anime high but you One Piece Fans are so doltish you find excuses just to attack random people on the InternetOne piece >bias- inclination or prejudice for/against one person, group or topic, especially in a way considered to be unfair >fair- impartial and just, without favouritism, discrimination or prejudice >self-proclaimed high level thinker Lmao, stop crying like a bitch. |
| Tokyo Ghoul adaptations are the ones that bug me the most. They had such rich material on their hands and the result is... very mid battle 'seinen' with shit-ass animation. |
| uh oh! |
More topics from this board
» Is it bad to raw-dog seasonals?thewiru - 2 hours ago |
14 |
by Lucifrost
»»
2 minutes ago |
|
» Which anime have you almost ruined for yourself?Rally- - Oct 10 |
17 |
by phokingbeast
»»
4 minutes ago |
|
» Anime musicnishant0 - Today |
25 |
by jacobPOL
»»
5 minutes ago |
|
» Why do you rewatch anime? ( 1 2 )AnimeDownUnder - Oct 1 |
53 |
by phokingbeast
»»
6 minutes ago |
|
» Are we going through a Yuri Renaissance? ( 1 2 )Dragevard - Yesterday |
56 |
by vasipi4946
»»
9 minutes ago |