| I've heard many times that the first season was altered quite a bit compared to the source material, most notably with Suzune Horikita being given a lot more screen time. My question is why this is such a terribe thing? Were the events of the LN truly so much greater to warrant this hate? I personally would actually prefer if they kept Horikita as the lead heroine, but maybe that's because we share kind of similar characteristics in terms of temperament. |
 |
DinoTimmy said: Because the anime treats her as a main character in a way, while in the LN she is mostly a side character. Allot of scenes got changed where a difrent girl was present and not horikita. Personally I hope they keep it that way lol. Horikita is one of my favourite characters and I'd like to see her character develop and for her to see the value of companionship. |
|
| it's because the scene that switches to her belongs to the two most popular girl characters in COTE Kei and Ichinose, so a lot of hate is coming from both fandoms. |
 |
| I love Horikita. As a Light Novel reader, I'm an exception as everyone in the fandom either hates her or feels indifferent. I love how progressed through the series and the way she's written just doesn't appeal in a conventional sense, which is why I have gravitated towards her the most. Hate is going to be there for her given the other two popular girls within the fandom. I don't care either way if they gonna stick with Horikita for this season or back to Kei as the Light Novels intended. Sooner or later, Horikita's development will come in anime form as it was in the Light Novels. |
MonkeSupremacy said: I've heard many times that the first season was altered quite a bit compared to the source material, most notably with Suzune Horikita being given a lot more screen time. My question is why this is such a terribe thing? Were the events of the LN truly so much greater to warrant this hate? I personally would actually prefer if they kept Horikita as the lead heroine, but maybe that's because we share kind of similar characteristics in terms of temperament. people dont exactly hate her the thing is the development that other character supposed to get is given to horikta, this in itself is not bad but in light novels author had already given us tremendous growth of horikta as a character later (in season 3 u will see) so the point was if horikta already bound to get such a development then why steal the moments of other characters if u like horikta then u gonna love season 3 but season 1 and season 2 should like what they are, horikta fans have to wait for their moment and right now let other shine since its a battle royale so there's a lot of characters to see and understand them |
 |
MonkeSupremacy said: I've heard many times that the first season was altered quite a bit compared to the source material, most notably with Suzune Horikita being given a lot more screen time. My question is why this is such a terribe thing? Were the events of the LN truly so much greater to warrant this hate? I personally would actually prefer if they kept Horikita as the lead heroine, but maybe that's because we share kind of similar characteristics in terms of temperament. Part of the problem with the changes is that at the time the first season aired, there were only like 6 volumes of the LN released. If you consider when they would've started planning and creating the series, it would've been long before the 6th volume came out, probably even well before the 5th volume. So they didn't actually know which characters were going to be important later in the story. This is why it is somewhat dangerous to make changes when you don't know the potential consequences of said changes. As an example, Karuizawa was a very minor character in the beginning of the series. If they knew how important she was going to become, they might not have replaced her parts with Horikita's parts. (I'm not saying she is more important than Horikita) It's entirely possible they just assumed that Horikita was going to be the main heroine, and thus decided to make those changes. But at the end of the day, she isn't, so the extra focus from the first season is at best, misleading. It's understandable that some fans might be upset. Making changes isn't in and of itself an inherently terrible thing. But there are implications when you don't understand what you are changing. For me personally I don't hate her, and I don't hate season 1. I just think she is kind of boring. Especially compared to all the other girls in the series. |
| Because LN readers cry that their favourite girl wasn't in a scene where they were supposed to be and were replaced with Horikita there. For me, I dislike her because I dislike her (I know, pretty repetitive reason), not helpful that she reminds me a lot of Yukino Yukinoshita. |
| I dont know why But from what I remember from s1, i didn't mind her at all |
rezeroS1plot said: she gets better later on but for most of it she's just really immature and prideful. as her brother says mistaking isolation for independence That quote really stuck with me too; very well written from the author. Angel_crush1 said: rezeroS1plot said: she gets better later on but for most of it she's just really immature and prideful. as her brother says mistaking isolation for independence That's honest what make her an amazing character imo a character who has a room for growth and the author definitely did amazing job on her character Suzune >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Kei |
|
| MonkeSupremacy don't get offended. But when the MC of the anime himself calls another character useless. That character archives a level of infamy far greater than any we the viewers can bestow upon them. Considering we tried extra hard, especially for characters like Sakura Haruno. And yet Ayanokouji put us to shame, with just that one sentence he slapped Horikita over the face with. |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Youkoso Jitsuryoku Shijou Shugi no Kyoushitsu e (TV) 2nd Season Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jul 4, 2022 |
296 |
by NadiaEros
»»
Oct 22, 5:54 PM |
|
Poll: » Youkoso Jitsuryoku Shijou Shugi no Kyoushitsu e (TV) 2nd Season Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Softhenic03 - Jul 18, 2022 |
227 |
by Weeb_Isekai
»»
Oct 14, 11:59 AM |
|
Poll: » Youkoso Jitsuryoku Shijou Shugi no Kyoushitsu e 2nd Season Episode 13 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Sep 26, 2022 |
467 |
by merly_
»»
Sep 14, 5:01 AM |
|
» Why is the MC in the Anime different from the LNKingOfMAL - Sep 10 |
22 |
by KingOfMAL
»»
Sep 13, 1:15 AM |
|
» what did Ayanokoji saw on Karuizawa chest on cruise Ship_Gurjeet_ - Jul 26 |
7 |
by BugsBuggy
»»
Jul 27, 9:09 AM |