Attack on Titan
| >Why past shifters helped the alliance |
  Something that’s supposed to die and doesn’t… will eventually rot away , whether it’s a man or a nation |
| Where the hell is Eren? What is Ymir's goal? Who's the father of Historia's child? I think that's it. |
 |
| About Eren's point of view, it's not like he let the Alliance win (knowing AoT it might still be undecided who is victorious, lol; we don't know if Eren is really finished). He respected their free will and let them do what they want, but with emphasizing that if they want to stop him, then their paths might cross at some point. |
| - Historia's baby - Future memories, like you said |
| Whatever happened to Rico? We haven't seen her in nearly 60 chapters. |
Some of you never watched Bakugan Battle Brawlers on TeleToon in 2008 and it shows. |
| >Why ymir let go the pig >is the titan shifter can live longer >Why hallucigenia gift the power of titan to ymir |
| im not too good to speak english .. -- / -. --- - / - --- --- / --. --- --- -.. / - --- / ... .--. . .- -.- / . -. --. .-.. .. ... .... |
| My main questions that are unanswered are: - who is the father of Historia's child? - what is Ymir's point of view, or to be more precise what does she exactly want if it's not only having connection with anyone? - is Hallucinogenia some sort of an alien species? - will Ymir's curse be nullified by Eren, so titan shifters can live longer than only 13 years after awakening of their abilities? |
| What was the Monke's secret ass wiping technique? |
 |
FreeHobo said: What was the Monke's secret ass wiping technique? That's what Zeke was trying to tell Levi but he killed him, now we will never know. |
 cunnysseur |
| how did eren kruger get his attack titan without the notice of marley |
 |
Tasel said: Maybe Hobo saw it in the memories. Yams needs to enlighten us on this matter or this will be a huge plot hole.FreeHobo said: What was the Monke's secret ass wiping technique? That's what Zeke was trying to tell Levi but he killed him, now we will never know. |
|
| Why did the rumbling stop when Eren freed Ymir? |
 |
deg said: By freed I meant convinced her to stop listening to royal bloods. Maybe you're right about the why but I want it to be explained furtherGoZha said: Why did the rumbling stop when Eren freed Ymir? was it specifically said that he freed Ymir? if Ymir is truly free now then that means she can do whatever she wants then that includes helping the alliance so whats her true goal anyway analogy wise i look at Zeke (a royal blood) the modem that connects the computer (Eren) and the internet (Founding Titan and PATHS) so they destroyed the modem to kill that connection |
|
sammy69 said: how did eren kruger get his attack titan without the notice of marley it was always passed on to another eldian restorationist. but thats just my theory. |
 |
| I tried to answer all the questions I knew or tried to guess the answer to: For the same reason the alliance is against Eren. World > their own alaciko said: I feel like the way the future memories work is that the current holder of the power sends his predecessors the memories. In fact I believe Eren is the only one to have done it. What this means is that all instances of young Eren, Grisha and Kruger seeing future memories is because Eren from the future sent it to them. It's not an ability they can tap into.- Future memories, like you said Logical_ said: -She let the pig out because she was kind and wanted them to be FREE. She was punished for it unjustly.>Why ymir let go the pig >is the titan shifter can live longer >Why hallucigenia gift the power of titan to ymir -The shifters will live longer once the curse is removed in the next 2 chapters. -It's a parasite, it didn't choose Ymir. It would have attached itself to anyone. Adnash93 said: I believe hallucigenia originated on the SNK planet, it just evolved more than the real life version. And yes to your last question.- is Hallucinogenia some sort of an alien species? - will Ymir's curse be nullified by Eren, so titan shifters can live longer than only 13 years after awakening of their abilities? -They used the ice-burst crystal for that plane. As for Hizuru, I feel Mikasa might go there if she survives and Eren dies. To whatever is left of Hizuru that is. -Hallucigenia origin was explained in 137. It's evolution. -I feel like Connie's mom will revert back to human once the titan curse ends. sammy69 said: The Attack Titan was never in Marley's posession. It was passed down between the restorationists.how did eren kruger get his attack titan without the notice of marley |
 |
deg said: @Adnash93 do you think Eren will fight his friends on the next chapters then? AnR ending will happen? If AnR ending won't happen, then probably Eren won't fight his friends, at least it won't be a classic and direct fight, more like a fierce exchange of different views resulting in either Eren "resigning from his will to live" or his redemption. Both ideas sound really bad, if you ask me. I would love to see AnR ending becoming reality. It would be original, exceptional and really amazing ending. I still have hopes that it might become reality. There are two chapters left and I can imagine a plot-twist introduced in chapter 138, leaving all the details known from AnR ending theory for chapter 139. I_Am_Freeballing said: Adnash93 said: I believe hallucigenia originated on the SNK planet, it just evolved more than the real life version. And yes to your last question.- is Hallucinogenia some sort of an alien species? - will Ymir's curse be nullified by Eren, so titan shifters can live longer than only 13 years after awakening of their abilities? Yeah, that might also be a possiblity. That this powerful hallucinogenia was either an alien species or was just a creature that evolved on SnK planet. It is different world to ours after all. About Ymir's curse, it would be great if it was erased by Eren, whether he won (AnR ending) or not (Alliance ending). |
| - What the fuck is the deal with Hallu-kun? Is that thing meant to be explained or just a cool symbolism? - Why in the flying fuck is Kruger even helping the alliance? Did yams and his cocksuckers forget that this is the same man that callously throw thousands of his own kin to death just so he could get that one chance to send one guy to paradis? Does the casualty number going up from thousand to million suddenly bother him or what? - What's with the pointless maury drama with Historia? If the father is just truly some random nameless farmer then why yams even framed the whole fucking shit like a sherlock murder mystery? To get mass traction from crazy shippers? |
 |
| My biggest question is the beast titan form why is zeke beast titan a monke? what makes the user turn into specific animal? |
Funseco said: It's probably their preference. We know Zeke played with a toy monkey and that was obviously before he inherited the Beast. Falco probably really likes birds. There's also a theory it's following the order of the Chinese zodiac.My biggest question is the beast titan form why is zeke beast titan a monke? what makes the user turn into specific animal? Rat Ox Tiger Rabbit Dragon Snake Horse Goat - Xaver Monkey - Zeke Rooster - Falco Dog Pig Pretty sure we also saw Ox, Rabbit and Snake titans in these last few chapters. If we are going in order tho, the baby to receive the Beast titan powers after Zeke should have a Dog one. |
|
I_Am_Freeballing said: There's also a theory it's following the order of the Chinese zodiac. Rat Ox Tiger Rabbit Dragon Snake Horse Goat - Xaver Monkey - Zeke Rooster - Falco Dog Pig Pretty sure we also saw Ox, Rabbit and Snake titans in these last few chapters. If we are going in order tho, the baby to receive the Beast titan powers after Zeke should have a Dog one. thats a good theory, but unfortunately the okapi ruins it |
Funseco said: Not really, you could probably fit a bunch of animals under the same category. Pretty sure there was a deer too. I think both deer and okapi could fit under Horse.I_Am_Freeballing said: There's also a theory it's following the order of the Chinese zodiac. Rat Ox Tiger Rabbit Dragon Snake Horse Goat - Xaver Monkey - Zeke Rooster - Falco Dog Pig Pretty sure we also saw Ox, Rabbit and Snake titans in these last few chapters. If we are going in order tho, the baby to receive the Beast titan powers after Zeke should have a Dog one. thats a good theory, but unfortunately the okapi ruins it |
|
| @hamza121419 looool you listed 15 questions but its more like 50! like one question have like 10 more questions in it. lol I took a look at some of your question and some of them are indirectly answered already, left for the readers interpretation, you have some good questions as well and then some questions are better left unexplained for mystery purpose and speculation and also you may need to re read the manga as it seems you have forgot some vital information as well. I'm sorry, not in the mood to touch on some of those question. I'm Lazy. :\ Answering every single question is not good and somethings are better left to interpretation, as the answers will most likely not be satisfying anyway. I will touch on one of your questions. 12) why did eren say he hated mikassa while it's obvious he didn't hate her? Is it because he is dying soon and want her to forget about him and live her life? This is one of them that doesn't need a direct answer and its better to leave it to interpretation or read between the lines, I think it would be insulting to the readers to spoon feeding info like this. I said I was going to touch on one point but let me touch on another one as this is a bit ridiculous. 10) is eren really free or just being controlled and forced? What is it in him that is free as armin asked? Is killing your enemies intill they are no more the real definition of eren's freedom? How dod you define your enemies? Are eldians that want to stop eren his enemies? How can you this is my enemy and this is not? You literally had six questions in this one. Eren said that he is going to kill everyone except the people of paradise island, which means that everyone outside of paradise island is his enemies whether they are innocent or not. The end. Just read between the lines you don't need Eren to sit down with you explaining who are his enemies or why, its self explanatory. If you want a manga that literally spoon feed the viewers by answering literally everything read hxh manga. You will get full explanation on why a character farted, why he farted at this particular time, was there a reason why he farted, or perhaps he farted by accident? In full details! There are some good questions in there, but some of them are ridiculous and are already answered just indirectly and not directly, you as the read will have to use some of your brain(This is not an insult btw) to put it together and figure it out. I honestly would have tried answering all the questions I could answer but I would be here all day basically writing an essay to you, look how much I have wrote even though I said I am too lazy. :/ A manga answering literally every single question is not a good decision imo. |
keragammingMar 1, 2021 6:03 AM
keragamming said: about eren's enemies i think you are taking the idea too simplisticly, because now the people he claims are not his enemies are fighting him and he is fighting them (or is it just ymir we still don't know) all eren's friend that he claims he is saving them could have died in chapters 135-137 if not for the incredible plot armor they had. So if eren is really the one who is controlling all the rumbling and that ymir is entirely with him then your simple idea of eren's enemies are those besides eldiens inside the wall is questionnable,as there is no meaning in fighting non enemies.@hamza121419 looool you listed 15 questions but its more like 50! like one question have like 10 more questions in it. lol I took a look at some of your question and some of them are indirectly answered already, left for the readers interpretation, you have some good questions as well and then some questions are better left unexplained for mystery purpose and speculation and also you may need to re read the manga as it seems you have forgot some vital information as well. I'm sorry, not in the mood to touch on some of those question. I'm Lazy. :\ Answering every single question is not good and somethings are better left to interpretation, as the answers will most likely not be satisfying anyway. I will touch on one of your questions. 12) why did eren say he hated mikassa while it's obvious he didn't hate her? Is it because he is dying soon and want her to forget about him and live her life? This is one of them that doesn't need a direct answer and its better to leave it to interpretation or read between the lines, I think it would be insulting to the readers to spoon feeding info like this. I said I was going to touch on one point but let me touch on another one as this is a bit ridiculous. 10) is eren really free or just being controlled and forced? What is it in him that is free as armin asked? Is killing your enemies intill they are no more the real definition of eren's freedom? How dod you define your enemies? Are eldians that want to stop eren his enemies? How can you this is my enemy and this is not? You literally had six questions in this one. Eren said that he is going to kill everyone except the people of paradise island, which means that everyone outside of paradise island is his enemies whether they are innocent or not. The end. Just read between the lines you don't need Eren to sit down with you explaining who are his enemies or why, its self explanatory. If you want a manga that literally spoon feed the viewers by answering literally everything read hxh manga. You will get full explanation on why a character farted, why he farted at this particular time, was there a reason why he farted, or perhaps he farted by accident? In full details! There are some good questions in there, but some of them are ridiculous and are already answered just indirectly and not directly you as the read will have to use some of your brain to put it together and figure it out. I known there can be some questions that won't be answered directly for the reader to interpret them and eren saying he hates mikassa is probably one of them, but there is no way you leave a tone of questions unanswered because of the excuse "left for interpretation", because there are things that needs to be answered especially those related to the power system, otherwise you'll never know why they were there, these things aren't for interpretation my dude because they constitute the core of the world and power system building, the laws of a new introduced univers (the paths) should be explored enough because a lot of events depend on this univers. The time travel paradoxes should be answered and the use of such element should be justified. And btw it's not kind to say to someone to use his brain and read between the lines because you assumed he didn't use his brain, which is pretentious from your side who neglected the 6 questions inside that one question about eren's freedom and enemies and cut it short to eren said he will kill every except those in paradise island. If you think it's as simple as what your are thinking then I don't know who isn't using his brain here, at least i'm problematizing the subject which is in its self a use of brain and analyzing capabilities. |
hamza121419 said: keragamming said: about eren's enemies i think you are taking the idea too simplisticly, because now the people he claims are not his enemies are fighting him and he is fighting them (or is it just ymir we still don't know) all eren's friend that he claims he is saving them could have died in chapters 135-137 if not for the incredible plot armor they had. So if eren is really the one who is controlling all the rumbling and that ymir is entirely with him then your simple idea of eren's enemies are those besides eldiens inside the wall is questionnable,as there is no meaning in fighting non enemies.@hamza121419 looool you listed 15 questions but its more like 50! like one question have like 10 more questions in it. lol I took a look at some of your question and some of them are indirectly answered already, left for the readers interpretation, you have some good questions as well and then some questions are better left unexplained for mystery purpose and speculation and also you may need to re read the manga as it seems you have forgot some vital information as well. I'm sorry, not in the mood to touch on some of those question. I'm Lazy. :\ Answering every single question is not good and somethings are better left to interpretation, as the answers will most likely not be satisfying anyway. I will touch on one of your questions. 12) why did eren say he hated mikassa while it's obvious he didn't hate her? Is it because he is dying soon and want her to forget about him and live her life? This is one of them that doesn't need a direct answer and its better to leave it to interpretation or read between the lines, I think it would be insulting to the readers to spoon feeding info like this. I said I was going to touch on one point but let me touch on another one as this is a bit ridiculous. 10) is eren really free or just being controlled and forced? What is it in him that is free as armin asked? Is killing your enemies intill they are no more the real definition of eren's freedom? How dod you define your enemies? Are eldians that want to stop eren his enemies? How can you this is my enemy and this is not? You literally had six questions in this one. Eren said that he is going to kill everyone except the people of paradise island, which means that everyone outside of paradise island is his enemies whether they are innocent or not. The end. Just read between the lines you don't need Eren to sit down with you explaining who are his enemies or why, its self explanatory. If you want a manga that literally spoon feed the viewers by answering literally everything read hxh manga. You will get full explanation on why a character farted, why he farted at this particular time, was there a reason why he farted, or perhaps he farted by accident? In full details! There are some good questions in there, but some of them are ridiculous and are already answered just indirectly and not directly you as the read will have to use some of your brain to put it together and figure it out. I known there can be some questions that won't be answered directly for the reader to interpret them and eren saying he hates mikassa is probably one of them, but there is no way you leave a tone of questions unanswered because of the excuse "left for interpretation", because there are things that needs to be answered especially those related to the power system, otherwise you'll never know why they were there, these things aren't for interpretation my dude because they constitute the core of the world and power system building, the laws of a new introduced univers (the paths) should be explored enough because a lot of events depend on this univers. The time travel paradoxes should be answered and the use of such element should be justified. And btw it's not kind to say to someone to use his brain and read between the lines because you assumed he didn't use his brain, which is pretentious from your side who neglected the 6 questions inside that one question about eren's freedom and enemies and cut it short to eren said he will kill every except those in paradise island. If you think it's as simple as what your are thinking then I don't know who isn't using his brain here, at least i'm problematizing the subject which is in its self a use of brain and analyzing capabilities. I'm not saying it is as simple as that, it was just an example, as I said I am lazy as fuck right right now not in the mood for long discussion or in depth reply. I wasn't going to even bother reply, now I wish I didn't, if I'm going to give a half ass reply its better not to reply at all, if I was in the mood I would answer the questions I could and give my interpretation of some of the questions as well. Yes, I know what you are saying, like for example if Mikasa, Armin and company are fighting against him are they his enemies then? Well Eren did say they can try and stop him, so that's up to the readers interpretation and we may get a full answer on that, but at the same time its not necessary. My main problem with some of your questions is that you literally want the author to answer every single question without leaving any interpretation. Hence why I simple gave you the bare bone reply, as I said before you the reader can read between the lines and figure out plenty of those things. I also mention that some of your questions imo are legit and I too hope to get answers for them, but I feel like %80 of the questions you dish out where either ridiculous or already answered indirectly. use some of your brain I apologize for saying that but what I was saying is that some of those questions are answered indirectly and its just you need to put it together, the author is expecting his readers to be able to do it, but its a double edge sword, because if you spoon feed the readers and gave them all the answer on silver platter, some readers will see it as an insult of their intelligence, but on the other hand if you don't give them the answer on a silver platter and they either forgot certain details or misunderstand something then they will see it as a flaw in the series. |
| who is eren kruger...i mean who is he actually? |
| I have some questions. I will be grateful if someone answers these questions. 1. Who or what was the titan that rescued/helped Zeke dying from the thunder spear by putting him inside it's stomach or whatever it was. 2. How Armin was able to go to the paths? What exactly is these paths? 3. From where and how did all those titans and titan shifters from the past came to the present to help our characters? |
keragamming said: @hamza121419 If you want a manga that literally spoon feed the viewers by answering literally everything read hxh manga. as you know togashi not gonna back ever so he want from isayama to turn aot into another hxh |
deg said: -Don- said: I have some questions. I will be grateful if someone answers these questions. 1. Who or what was the titan that rescued/helped Zeke dying from the thunder spear by putting him inside it's stomach or whatever it was. 2. How Armin was able to go to the paths? What exactly is these paths? 3. From where and how did all those titans and titan shifters from the past came to the present to help our characters? 1. it was Ymir the founding titan 2. Armin was swallowed by the Pig Titan of Ymir the Founding Titan and she took him to the paths dimension 3. Paths dimension is the heaven of all Eldians so those old Eldian titan shifters was awaken by Ymir the Founding Titan to help Armin we do not know what is the goal of Ymir so if that is answered then your questions will have more concrete answers Tnx a lot for the answers deg :) But, why did Ymir save Zeke? And from where did that titan come? Did it come out of nowhere? A wild guess from me. Ymir saved Zeke because she wanted the rumbling. But if it's true, an another question arises- why did she try to help the people who tried to stop the rumbling? |
| wtf is hallucigenia and how did it even lead to fucking titan powers LMFAO |
-Don- said: deg said: 1. it was Ymir the founding titan 2. Armin was swallowed by the Pig Titan of Ymir the Founding Titan and she took him to the paths dimension 3. Paths dimension is the heaven of all Eldians so those old Eldian titan shifters was awaken by Ymir the Founding Titan to help Armin we do not know what is the goal of Ymir so if that is answered then your questions will have more concrete answers Tnx a lot for the answers deg :) But, why did Ymir save Zeke? And from where did that titan come? Did it come out of nowhere? A wild guess from me. Ymir saved Zeke because she wanted the rumbling. But if it's true, an another question arises- why did she try to help the people who tried to stop the rumbling? From my understanding, the titan who sheltered Zeke was just one of the eldians who drank his spine fluid in the wine and happened to survive Levi's slaugther, and then Ymir used that titan to protect Zeke. I might be wrong, though. As to why she did it: at that point, Ymir still had the idea of having to obey to royalty and keep building titans and passing her powers through generations ingrained in her mind. It think it's also implied that it's due to her powers that titan shifter have inhuman regeneration, since she is rebuilding their bodies to keep them alive. Ymir didn't help the people who tried stopping the rumbling, she just followed the same resolution of Eren regarding "freedom to fight back", I assume. I'm not really sure, though. Ymir has had contradictory and confusing actions so far. |
| tfw there's even more questions and only 45 pages left give up on your dream and die |
burakk637 said: I lost my hope honestly. Nothing is going to be explained now well if we can know the goal of Ymir i will be satisfied by that at least but looks like she is a fan of love or romance that she is heavily deprived of Isayama said in his last interview that this manga will not give a moral message of right or wrong so my guess is he will go for his biggest influence that is Muv Luv and its ending   |
| In this chapter, Eren's revealed to be indecisive and unsure. He didn't want to end the world, and now he's dead--seemingly. Who knows what Isayama'll pull. This chapter contradicts everything that Eren was built up to. The only explanation is that this is just Mikasa's fantasy in the next chapter. Otherwise, Eren's whole character is fucked. |
deg said: deg said: for me - the goal of Ymir (Armin asked this same question on chapter 137) - the remaining point of view of Eren like why he let the alliance win? - the details of how the future sight of the Attack Titan works especially its limitation like how far in the future can it see or is there some other limitations like maybe Erens rage or love blinds him to see further into the future? how about you? you can answer others questions as well if you know them well only the goal of Ymir which is her to be free from the pain of love (stockholm syndrome) is answered along with Eren wannabe like Lelouch for his friends to be heroes we did not get details of the Attack Titan powers but it seems he can erase memories for a duration of time too Was it that or was this the founder's power? Eren seems to imply in this chapter that he caused his mother's own death instead of Berthold's. He then used the founder to control Dina to go after his house, and so began his dark path in the military, which would eventually lead him to now. Strange thing is, this mind controlling and sending signals to the past from the future began when he kissed Historia's hand, right? I'm so confused. |
More topics from this board
» Most underrated AOT part/arc in your opinion?DarkFirefly72 - Oct 7 |
11 |
by Rexaly
»»
Oct 9, 11:00 PM |
|
» 'Even a Child Can Do It': Shonen Jump Editor Calls Out Attack on Titan as Just 'Making a Lot of Noise'deg - Jul 18 |
6 |
by therealnagora
»»
Sep 13, 10:00 AM |
|
» Worst death of the series?Dragevard - May 29, 2021 |
3 |
by Kawaii_Otaku04
»»
Aug 3, 8:38 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Chapter 19 Discussionricardocsc - Oct 2, 2012 |
17 |
by Jeffrey8172
»»
Jul 11, 7:15 AM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Chapter 130 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )keragamming - Jul 6, 2020 |
213 |
by Adam_________
»»
Jun 3, 1:39 PM |