This arc was the point in the series that it become a favourite in my youth, being much older now my enthusiasm for it has certainly waned but inversely I do think I appreciate it more because this is still clearly a great starting arc to the series, being the first one with any real stakes at hand.
The arc is a bit simplistic, the story is essential two fight scenes with a some brief plot & training sandwiched in between them but Kishimoto did a great job of using the first fight and the middle bit to help set-up for a strong finish. There's a lot of nice callbacks in the ending, and while the scale of the story is small, it's nice to see Kishimoto utilize the size to make a tightly-knit action story. Even the bridge stuff, while ultimately a bit hokey, was used pretty well to tie Naruto's purpose into it pretty well. Stuff like Sasuke actually surviving Haku's attack is something that could easily be dismissed as poor writing if handled poorly but the first encounter with Zabuza showed Haku using that same attack to put Zabuza into a death-like trance while the middle portion provided us enough insight into Haku's character that not only does Sasuke surviving not feel cheap, but the realization that Haku spared him is one of the more poignant pieces of the arc.
What really stands out here is Zabuza and Haku. I'm quite aware that Kishimoto is a big Togashi fan, and I'm glad one thing from Togashi's work that he seems to deliver on here is treating his villains more like people than straight out villains. Of course Gato is unabashedly villainous but he mostly serves to give the villages a conflict to rise against at the end, as well as allow Zabuza a fitting closure to his story. Zabuza and Haku are both great characters. Haku's more obvious, he's immediate gentle nature and parallels to both Sasuka and Naruto made him pretty likable and a character of intrigue, plus his Mirror powers are awesome. Whereas Zabuza was likely a stronger character but one that took more work to reveal that. Kishimoto did a great job of balancing Zabuza, his "Not another word" tear moment at Haku's death held power in it, both towards how the moment built up in the moment, but because of Zabuza's own characterization prior to that (in that it conflicted with the personality generally shown but there were enough shown to make it feel obvious).
On the note of Zabuza, it's never stated why he attempted a coup but it seems pretty obvious to me that he disagreed with the general treatment of shinobi as tools (and the likely the exclusion of people like Haku). Which is another point I really liked about this arc, it was wise for Kishimoto to address this ideology in the first true arc of the series, and making Haku and Zabuza cornerstones of that was smart in helping developing Naruto's own stance.
If there's one major sore spot in this arc, it's Sakura. I'm not of the mindset that you have to contribute to the action to be a useful character but damn is it upsetting that Sakura basically gets no time to shine here, and is relegated to just worrying about Sasuke at the end. I'm glad that she was capable of controlling her chakra during the tree segment pretty much immediately but that accomplishment was severely undercut by having Kakashi immediately mention that Naruto & Sasuke dwarfs here with their chakra pool. We got to see Kakashi being awesome all-throughout and his abilities, Sasuke got to use the Sharingan (something cleverly hinted at through Kakashi's earlier usage of it), and Naruto go Nine-tails for the first time (which was awesome too). All Sakura gets is an immediate remainder that Sasuke and Naruto will eclipse her with a bit of training. Still, that aside, this is really solid first arc in the series. |