Attack on Titan
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| Wtf this episode is full of action scenes but mappa fucked up with the stupid Cgi. Also I watched it in 1080 and they just make some of the scenes not very clear to watch. MAN I will do anything for wit to just animate this episode and the one after gosh |
| Mikasa's face is very weird. Change my mind |
| This is an episode that I as a manga reader enjoyed more than the previous ones excluding ep 1. I think the emotions are conveyed exactly as in the manga and for that I gave this episode a 5/5. Sure, the fights were bad but the author's intent and what the story wanted to showcase was presented tastefully. |
 |
Farga said: Mikasa's face is very weird. Change my mind It's the same as in the manga so I won't blame Mappa for that. But I agree that the face is not good. But it's atleast better than the PV I guess? |
|
Jehad321 said: Wtf this episode is full of action scenes but mappa fucked up with the stupid Cgi. Also I watched it in 1080 and they just make some of the scenes not very clear to watch. MAN I will do anything for wit to just animate this episode and the one after gosh If Wit would've made it with the same schedule as Mappa it would've been absolute dogshit. |
 |
PrasantGrG said: Great episode tbf. CGI was at its best and worst this ep. This 2D side of things looked very good. Really worried if this is gonna be the season's best animation from what leakers are saying It seems like this season doesn't have a super animator which is very disappointing to say the least. |
|
Lumiax said: Jehad321 said: Wtf this episode is full of action scenes but mappa fucked up with the stupid Cgi. Also I watched it in 1080 and they just make some of the scenes not very clear to watch. MAN I will do anything for wit to just animate this episode and the one after gosh If Wit would've made it with the same schedule as Mappa it would've been absolute dogshit. If Wit would've made it with the same schedule as Mappa it would've been absolute masterpiece. See, I can argue too. |
|
| My God Atrocious CGI! Literally Berserk 2016 tier But good pacing and good directing! Very good first half. Action was shit Preview for the next episode looks even worse Mappa must really hate Beast Titan. Disgusting |
| This thread is currently being cleaned. Please refrain from posting more baiting/abusive/or off topic posts. If you want to have a long discussion with another user, do it with PMs. Don't overload this episode thread with a back and forth, off topic, discussion. |
 |
Alpha_Druid said: Lumiax said: If Wit would've made it with the same schedule as Mappa it would've been absolute dogshit. If Wit would've made it with the same schedule as Mappa it would've been absolute masterpiece. See, I can argue too. Have you seen s3p2? Do you remember the cgi colossal titan? Wit would've definitely used cgi for s4 too and Mappas cgi is like 2d animation compared to Wits cgi. |
|
Alpha_Druid said: Farga said: Mikasa's face is very weird. Change my mind It's the same as in the manga so I won't blame Mappa for that. But I agree that the face is not good. But it's atleast better than the PV I guess? yes i know it, but mikasa's face on the poster is better than in this eps |
| I actually liked how this episode looked and I prefer these fast paced action scenes with CGI than the boring 2D titan fights from Season 3 Part 2. I still agree this show could have looked stellar if it wasn't for the horrible schedule. Still mad props to Mappa for making this season work |
Lumiax said: Alpha_Druid said: If Wit would've made it with the same schedule as Mappa it would've been absolute masterpiece. See, I can argue too. Have you seen s3p2? Do you remember the cgi colossal titan? Wit would've definitely used cgi for s4 too and Mappas cgi is like 2d animation compared to Wits cgi. I don't think so. What makes you believe that Wit would've used CGI for all the titans? I could understand with Mappa because the director also directed another CGI show i.e Dorohedoro. The CGI in this episode isn't even better than S3P2 CGI. Only the ep1 CGI is better. Isn't this charged guilty until proven innocent kinda thing from you? |
|
Lumiax said: Jehad321 said: Wtf this episode is full of action scenes but mappa fucked up with the stupid Cgi. Also I watched it in 1080 and they just make some of the scenes not very clear to watch. MAN I will do anything for wit to just animate this episode and the one after gosh If Wit would've made it with the same schedule as Mappa it would've been absolute dogshit. You saw what was done in s3p2. Mappa should have said no. Mappa funked up |
Jehad321 said: Wtf this episode is full of action scenes but mappa fucked up with the stupid Cgi. Also I watched it in 1080 and they just make some of the scenes not very clear to watch. MAN I will do anything for wit to just animate this episode and the one after gosh Wit is no more, GET OVER IT |
  |
| Criticizing the season is fine. CGI is bad, fine. OST is bad, fine. What's not fine is going beyond that and trying to paint it as trash or something that it definitely isn't. Spending the amount of time here only to go around every thread trashing Mappa does nothing but make you appear childish. Saying you've dropped it yet still discussing it here, why? You'll be back next week and you know it. Being disappointed is understandable, but don't act as if your partner has cheated on you here. The fact remains, even with all the flaws (which I agree are valid), this season will still be GOATED. There is no debating this. All the flaws one might come up with will NOT touch the status SNK has acquired. Only fucking up the story will. Which it won't. And before someone comes in saying there are other aspects to the anime but the story, I know, but story is the most important one. Take GOT S8 for example, the best looking season with the best acting, reduced to trash because of writing. So yes, criticisms are valid. People trying to make this a failure by going around acting as if someone killed their family member isn't and never will be. Right to an opinion does not include not being judged for it. The way you express your opinion is very important. ''I dislike the CGI in this episode because reasons.'' - valid criticism ''CGI is bad omg no Mappa why?! Why are people accepting mediocre adaptations?! I'm dropping this.'' - invalid everything |
 |
Alpha_Druid said: Lumiax said: Have you seen s3p2? Do you remember the cgi colossal titan? Wit would've definitely used cgi for s4 too and Mappas cgi is like 2d animation compared to Wits cgi. I don't think so. What makes you believe that Wit would've used CGI for all the titans? I could understand with Mappa because the director also directed another CGI show i.e Dorohedoro. The CGI in this episode isn't even better than S3P2 CGI. Only the ep1 CGI is better. Isn't this charged guilty until proven innocent kinda thing from you? WIT used CG on normal Titans, horses and even people sometimes. Even in Season 2 they used CG also on normal Titans on the last episode |
| |
| Loved the episode, kinda hated that they destroyed Eren's emotions at the talk with Mikasa when in manga it was obvious he wasnt enjoying what he is doing but other than that it was a really good episode |
Alpha_Druid said: Isn't this charged guilty until proven innocent kinda thing from you? It is indeed, yes. It isn't even anything against you or Wit. I'm just tired of the Wit fanboys who think this would've been 10 times better if Wit would've made it. Maybe it would've been better but it could've also been even worse and when I look back at s3p2 it would've definitely been worse cuz they just don't have the time and recoursses anymore to work on it, they even lost money by working on AOT. That's why they gave it to another studio. So you would've to force them to work on AOT and then it would definitely look like garbage. |
|
MWAsura said: Jehad321 said: Wtf this episode is full of action scenes but mappa fucked up with the stupid Cgi. Also I watched it in 1080 and they just make some of the scenes not very clear to watch. MAN I will do anything for wit to just animate this episode and the one after gosh Wit is no more, GET OVER IT I can't man. I got to a point that I wished that mappa worked on AOT from the beginning. That way we will never think of wit |
| always a pleasure to see Mikasa and Liva in battle ^^ |
| The only major complaints I have is when the Attack Titan threw himself onto the crowd, that looked kinda wonky. And also the fact that the Scouts were CG. Other than that are only minor complaints and my perfectionism acting |
| |
| I mean, yeah the cgi is not that good but are we going to repeat the same thing every single week? Great episode regardless just for the content, and there is a new great sound track. |
| awesome episode, aside the animation difference im enjoying it a lot |
| Me:Checking the comments CGI , MUSIC BAD MAPPA AND KODANSHA RUINED ANIMATION Me:Why do i bother, let me go back to Twitter Twitter:Literal snake pit me:Ok i cry |
| May our sweet and Merciful Madoka be with you |
| @I_Am_Freeballing, your post presented the voice of reason, but I doubt it will convince blind haters from doing what they have kept doing in the last weeks (every next week after they "dropped this anime for good", if I may add). |
| Episode is 73% of 5/5 at this moment. Let's see where it lands after the anime only vote in a few hours. |
cAbaddonJan 17, 2021 12:54 PM
| Even if they used mediocre cg for humans and titans, I can't help but love this episode. 5/5 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Feb 7, 2021 |
432 |
by Atlas77
»»
7 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Jan 31, 2021 |
823 |
by Atlas77
»»
Nov 23, 7:26 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Episode 7 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Jan 24, 2021 |
989 |
by Atlas77
»»
Nov 23, 1:32 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Jan 10, 2021 |
989 |
by Atlas77
»»
Nov 21, 7:45 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Dec 27, 2020 |
463 |
by Atlas77
»»
Nov 21, 7:02 PM |