Forum Settings
Forums

MAL Secret Santa 2020: Manga Edition - Sign Up!

New
This topic has been locked and is no longer available for discussion.
Pages (7) « First ... « 3 4 [5] 6 7 »
Nov 29, 2020 3:00 AM
Offline
Nov 2019
2
Min-Max length (volumes): No lımıts
Likes (genres, demographics, themes):Seinen
Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes):Romance/slice of life
Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies):No
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No):No
Number of Completed entries on your manga list:0
Does your list include everything you've read?:No
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Ali_S_A
Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: Elf gift (only receive)

Nov 29, 2020 5:22 AM

Offline
May 2014
7
❅ Min-Max length (volumes):No limit but must be completed
❅ Likes (genres, demographics, themes):horror,gore ,thriller, smut
❅ Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): *harem,love triangle,
❅ Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies):Nope
❅ Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): I have nothing on my plan to read since i read everything after i find it >...< so yep
❅ Number of Completed entries on your manga list:549
❅ Does your list include everything you've read?:Might miss something
❅ Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/_Freyah_
❅ Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?:Ye i want to create gift for other user
Nov 29, 2020 7:29 AM
Offline
Feb 2020
4
❅ Min-Max length (volumes): It doesn't matter. :)
❅ Likes (genres, demographics, themes): I like sports or action!
❅ Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): *Romance
❅ Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies):Nope
❅ Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No):Yes
❅ Number of Completed entries on your manga list:14
❅ Does your list include everything you've read?Not at all because a lot of it is not on myanimelist
❅ Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/nadijas
❅ Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)? Yes if they didn't read much because I didn't too and I couldn't recommend something to someone if they read it already.
Nov 29, 2020 7:52 AM

Offline
Nov 2015
7599
Min-Max length (volumes): Max 15 volumes (less than 150 chapters)
Likes (genres, demographics, themes): Anything works other than the ones listed in dislikes.(I'm not that picky with manga as much as I'm with anime)
Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): 4-Koma, Harem, Ecchi, Shoujo-romance
Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): It's fine if it's available in English in any site
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): Yes
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 202
Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes
Link to manga list: Link
Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: Elf Gift

Nov 29, 2020 8:28 AM

Offline
Nov 2020
10
❅ Min-Max length (volumes):No limit, but it can be good if it's completed.
❅ Likes (genres, demographics, themes):Horror, Mystery, Thriller, BL, Fantasy, Psychological, Dark, Supernatural.
❅ Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes):Harem
❅ Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies):No
❅ Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No):Yes
❅ Number of Completed entries on your manga list:5 (i continue with the other 3)
❅ Does your list include everything you've read?:No (Webtoon and other manga that is not added yet)
❅ Link to manga list:https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/nzoldyck
❅ Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: Elf Gift because i'm new at this.
nzoldyckNov 29, 2020 8:38 AM
Nov 29, 2020 8:34 AM
Offline
Nov 2019
3
❅ Min-Max length:
-i want it completed, (but its fine if its not)
❅ Likes:
-action, comedy, slice of live, bl, webtoon that isnt in mal alowed owo
❅ Dislikes:
-isekai
❅ Any availability restrictions?:
-if its online for free
-english
❅ Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list?
- I- well if u find something then sure XD
❅ Number of Completed entries on your manga list:
4 .-.
❅ Does your list include everything you've read?:
if bl doesnt count then yea
❅ Link to manga list:
- https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/uwuidknifn?status=2
❅ Will you create a gift for another user or do you only want to receive?:
-create a gift for another user
Nov 29, 2020 9:33 AM

Offline
Jun 2015
240
Min-Max length (volumes): no minimum, 25 maximum
Likes (genres, demographics, themes): I'm gonna base this off my completed/on-hold (also anime list if the manga has been adapted)
- unique isekai plot (Real Account, Bakarina)
- feel good SoL (Komi-san, Azumanga Diaoh, Yotsuba)
- Shounen/Shojo Ai (Shimanami Tasogare, Yagate Kimi ni Naru, Given)
- pure fuckery (Sakamoto, Pop Team Epic)
- Idols, 4-koma, vampires
Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes):
- sexualization of minors (Nagatoro)
- Yaoi/Yuri/Hentai
- guro
Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): nope! I usually read my manga online, unless I own it. I'd rather have it translated in ENglish though (official or unofficial translation doesn't matter)
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): sure!
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 4
Does your list include everything you've read?: no, mostly everything in on-hold is manga I'm currently reading (unless it tagged as on hold, meaning it's been a while since I've read it and it'll be a while before I pick it up again)
Link to manga list: link
Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: elf gift please! Considering how little manga I've read, I don't feel confident exchanging gifs yet
nightfury10Nov 29, 2020 9:37 AM
Nov 29, 2020 10:52 AM
Offline
Aug 2013
12
Min-Max length (volumes): Nope, nope. Pretty much open to anything that's completed. I don't keep up with many currently publishing titles.
Likes (genres, demographics, themes): Pretty much anything goes.
Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): Nothing that seems like it would be illegal if read in the wrong place.
Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): Nope.
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): Yes, if I'm sleeping on a good title please bump that up for me.
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 27, I don't read nearly as much as I watch.
Does your list include everything you've read?: Should be fairly close.
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/nihongineer?status=2
Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: Yep, sign me up.
nihongineerNov 29, 2020 11:06 AM
Nov 29, 2020 12:01 PM
Offline
Sep 2018
2
❅ Min-Max length (volumes): no Minimum or Maximum

❅ Likes: Mystery, Psychological, Shounen; no particular demographic/themes

❅ Dislikes: Ecchi, Harem, Reverse Harem; anything involving Incest or Pedophilia

❅ Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): Doesn't matter

❅ Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list?: Yes

❅ Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 55

❅ Does your list include everything you've read?: I think so

❅ Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Sym3ra

❅ Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: I would like to create a gift for another user as well
Nov 29, 2020 3:09 PM

Offline
Jan 2017
1426
Min-Max length (volumes): No preference
Likes (genres, demographics, themes): romance, drama, slice of life, comedy, shoujo, josei, seinen
Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): vampire, hentai, yuri, yaoi, harem combined with ecchi
Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): No
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): Yes
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 20
Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Ylienna?status=2
Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: Gift Exchange
Nov 29, 2020 3:17 PM
Furious

Offline
Dec 2017
39
Min-Max length (volumes):
Any
Likes (genres, demographics, themes):
Comedy, drama, slice of life, avant garde, yuri, stuff from my favorite writers/artists, parents/adults as protagonists
Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes):
Horror, superheroes, too much action (some is ok)
Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies):
No, I will find it
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No):
No
Number of Completed entries on your manga list:
9
Does your list include everything you've read?:
Yes
Link to manga list:
https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/matrograde
Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?:
Both

.・゜゜・ anime list ・゜゜・.
.・゜゜・ manga list ・゜゜・.
.・゜゜・ gaming list ・゜゜・.



Nov 29, 2020 4:14 PM
Offline
Aug 2018
5
Min-Max length (volumes): No limit
❅ Likes (genres, demographics, themes): adventure,fantasy, yuri, comedy,romance and slice of life, seinen and josei, though i can also do shounen and shoujo, themes: i enjoy fantasy and nature a lot, if you find anything about the ocean i'm sure to love it.
❅ Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): yaoi, ntr, harem, isekai, 4-koma, anthologies, no top 50
❅ Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): No
❅ Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): No
❅ Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 65
❅ Does your list include everything you've read?: no, some manhwa and more unknow titles are not on mal
❅ Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/profile/Quinho697
❅ Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: Yes (Gift Exchange)
Nov 29, 2020 8:42 PM

Offline
Aug 2015
358
Min-Max length (volumes):
No maximum limit, but I'd like something that's not just a one shot.

Likes (genres, demographics, themes):
Mythology from any culture. Vampires. Magic. Bishonen.
Something that doesn't have animated adaptations. Manga, manhua, manhwa, and webtoon, are all good. I prefer more realistic art styles.
For the main recommendation: Romances between either two immortals or an immortal and a mortal, in a fantasy / historical setting. Either something cute + bittersweet or something mature + dark.
For any additional recommendations: Feel free to point me to anything you think I'd like based on both my manga and anime history!

Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes):
School settings. Petty drama. Damsels in distress / female leads with no agency. Old shojo style art.

Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies):
No, as long as there's English translations (official or fan made, doesn't matter)

Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No):
No. I'd like for the main recommendation to be something new, but feel free to rec a PTR as an additional one.

Number of Completed entries on your manga list:
7 (LOL)

Does your list include everything you've read?:
There's a few manhua and webtoons that aren't on MAL, but are on Mangadex. I'll include links to both lists - together they cover everything.

Link to manga list:
https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/whither
https://mangadex.org/list/688616

Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?:
Elf Gift.
whitherNov 29, 2020 10:47 PM
Nov 29, 2020 9:54 PM

Offline
Jun 2020
19
Min-Max length (volumes): Anything, but preferably completed.
Likes (genres, demographics, themes): Basically anything, you can check my anime list for stuff I like, I haven't read much manga before.
Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): Nothing really
Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): Nope
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): I have nothing on my PTR, but the manga CAN be something that I've seen the anime of or are planning to watch the anime of.
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 1
Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Atm2222
Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: Elf Gift
Nov 29, 2020 10:26 PM

Offline
Dec 2019
987
Min-Max length (volumes): Around 5 to 50 chapters would be alright and it should be completed.
Likes (genres, demographics, themes): Shoujo, Shounen-ai, Yaoi, Messed up stories with evil protagonists
Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): Realistically intense stories (e.g. Vagabond) and Shounen(I don't dislike it but I'd rather watch Shounen anime)
Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed or physical copies): No
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): Yes
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 51 as of now
Does your list include everything you've read?: No, manhwa, webtoons and novels that are not in the database are missing.
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/-iva
Will you you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: I haven't read much manga yet but I'd like to try Gift Exchange, if possible.
‎ ‎ ‎
Nov 30, 2020 9:50 AM

Offline
Feb 2016
419
Min-Max length (volumes): Any, tbh.
Likes (genres, demographics, themes): Romance and shoujo are my favorites, but I'm open to other things.
Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): Ecchi, yuri, yaoi, too much fan service, etc.
Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): Preferably something that has physical copies.
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): Preferably not, but open to it if you can't find something else.
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 17
Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes
Link to manga list: Here
Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: Gift exchange!




Hi
Nov 30, 2020 9:57 AM
Nobody

Offline
Jul 2013
12165
Min-Max length (volumes):
Likes (genres, demographics, themes): Horror pref (idm gore/nudity stuff), but anything not in dislikes
Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): Sports, Hentai unless it's good plot/sex is not the main standing point
Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): No
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): No
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 63
Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Shaka
Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: Create Gift
Nov 30, 2020 12:06 PM

Offline
Jan 2017
893
Min-Max length (volumes): min- 4 vols, must be completed
Likes (genres, demographics, themes): seinen, historical like Golden Kamuy, psychological, josei, mystery or something in medical like Jin or you can hit me with something really depressing but avoid works by Asano Inio, since I plan to buy his works
Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): ecchi, please avoid mary sue/gary stu characters if you can along with top 200, also I haven't taken a liking to works by Oshimi Shuuzou yet so it would be better to avoid stuff by him
Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): I just want the series to be completely scanlated
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): no
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 585
Does your list include everything you've read?: yes
Link to manga list: here
Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: gift exchange
Nov 30, 2020 1:02 PM

Offline
Sep 2019
212

❅ Min-Max length (volumes): Nothing too short, preferably 10+ vols long
❅ Likes (genres, demographics, themes): drama, mystery, seinen, action, romance, psycholoigcal
❅ Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): poorly done shoujo romance, poorly done harem,
❅ Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): No
❅ Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): Preferably no
❅ Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 29
❅ Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes
❅ Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/MSK3?status=7
❅ Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: I'll make a gift for someone as well.
Nov 30, 2020 1:48 PM
Offline
Aug 2017
1
Min-Max length (volumes): less than 50 volumes
Likes (genres, demographics, themes): Didn't read that many titles so as long as you think it would be enjoyable, I don't mind ;D
Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): sports/fashion/yaoi/cars.
Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): Nope
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): Yes
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 11 (+7 that I am up to date with)
Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Keninje
Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: Yes I would like to :)
Nov 30, 2020 2:44 PM
enjoy life

Offline
Jun 2014
107
❅ Min-Max length (volumes): No limit but **must** be completed
❅ Likes (genres, demographics, themes): Battle shonen, mystery, comedy, romance, mecha, space, time travel
❅ Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): nothing really
❅ Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): No
❅ Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): Sure
❅ Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 12
❅ Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes
❅ Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/natemillaveli
❅ Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: Haven't read as much as some other users so no
n_2000Nov 30, 2020 2:47 PM
Nov 30, 2020 4:48 PM

Offline
Jan 2014
479
Min-Max length (volumes): no limit~
Likes (genres, demographics, themes): anything, but im in the mood for something that will blow my mind
Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): slice of life,isekai,ecchi and im not really feeling shoujo these days
Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): nope
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): No
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 141
Does your list include everything you've read?: Mostly
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/scarletgirl
Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: Exchange
scarletgirlDec 12, 2020 8:59 PM
Game over. If that's the case, I just have to play again.
Nov 30, 2020 8:29 PM
Offline
Aug 2018
20
Min-Max length (volumes): No max or min, but must be completed
Likes (genres, demographics, themes): I love crime, mystery, mind-games, clean artstyle, slice of life. But I'm really new to the manga world, so if there is something you think is a must-read, I'm interested.
Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): Generic shounens, cringe, BL.
Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): Have good quality, english availability for free
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): Yes
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 2
Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/muzlee01
Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: Elf Gift, since I know nothing about manga
Nov 30, 2020 8:34 PM

Offline
Jun 2020
3747
❅ Min-Max length (volumes): No preference
❅ Likes (genres, demographics, themes): Seinen, shounen, psychological, military, political thriller, art clear enough to understand fight scenes
❅ Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): Bad writing, unclear art, tsunderes, themes/manga that glorify bad stuff
❅ Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): Must have official translation, prefer to read physical copies
❅ Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): Yes
❅ Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 2, almost 3
❅ Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes
❅ Link to manga list: myanimelist.net/mangalist/gozha
❅ Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: Haven't read much but will still try to exchange
HoodKublaiKhanNov 30, 2020 8:39 PM
Nov 30, 2020 11:09 PM
Offline
Aug 2020
6
❅ Min-Max length (volumes):
Any length, but must be completed

❅ Likes (genres, demographics, themes):
shoujo, action romance, rom-com, sad, any

❅ Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes):
none

❅ Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies):
any is fine

❅ Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No):
Any manga

❅ Number of Completed entries on your manga list:
Dont mind

❅ Does your list include everything you've read?:
No, must be something I havnt read

❅ Link to manga list:
https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Otaku_Daisy

❅ Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?:
Gift Exchange
Dec 1, 2020 1:14 AM

Offline
Jul 2013
1556
Min-Max length (volumes):
Something short, I'll trust on your decision to determine how short

Likes (genres, demographics, themes):
I am very open to almost any genre
Manga must be complete

Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes):
Shoujo-ai or shounen-ai or things like that
Generic MC without a personality or MC who is OP
Characters who are stupid and get constant screen time
Politics
If there is an anime adaptation and you find the anime better, don't recommend the manga
Please check my anime list (the ones I completed or not) to see if i've already watched the adaptation of the manga you wanna recommend https://myanimelist.net/animelist/LePiratePapi

Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies):
No

Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No):
No

Number of Completed entries on your manga list:
24

Does your list include everything you've read?:
Yes

Link to manga list:
https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/LePiratePapi

Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?:
I want to create gifts
I . A M . D E A D !  C O N T I N U E ?

INSERT COIN
Dec 1, 2020 1:49 AM

Offline
Mar 2018
189
❅ Min-Max length (volumes): Doesn't matter (preferable to be finished)
❅ Likes (genres, demographics, themes): Psychological, Game, Thriller, Sports, Seinen/Josei, but generally any genre is fine
❅ Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): Nothing
❅ Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): Available digitally for free
❅ Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): Yes
❅ Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 33
❅ Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes
❅ Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Misery_Gaming
❅ Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift): Gift Exchange
Dec 1, 2020 2:08 AM
Offline
May 2018
12
❅ Min-Max length (volumes): doesn't matter, but preferably nothing over 1000 chapters.
❅ Likes (genres, demographics, themes): ill read almost anything.
❅ Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): *yaoi, historical, Shojo
❅ Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): anything translated.
❅ Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): no
❅ Number of Completed entries on your manga list:210
❅ Does your list include everything you've read?: yes
❅ Link to manga list:https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/PinkTheDinosaur?status=2
❅ Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: yes
Dec 1, 2020 4:49 AM

Offline
Aug 2015
281
Min-Max length (volumes): Preferably nothing over a couple hundred chapters.
Likes (genres, demographics, themes): Lighthearted romances are my favourites. A lesser known work in that category would be great. Alternatively, older works are very much welcome, be it classic or more underground references. Overall, good shoujo (aka something more than the million of clichés the genre is swamped by) or seinen have solid chances with me. Finally, good yuri, preferably on the longer side, is also something I can enjoy.
Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): No shonen. Nothing too psychological. Nothing exceedingly bizarre. Ecchi in general is not what I'm looking for either.
Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): Anything that can be found online.
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): No, unless you really can't find anything else, and in that case I'd like an explanation of why I should prioritize it.
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 67
Does your list include everything you've read?: A combination of my MAL and Anilist lists should contain most of it, barring a few entries that aren't on either database.
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Mamamama99 and https://anilist.co/user/Mamamama99/mangalist
Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: Gift Exchange

Avatar and signature picture made by aryandil.
Dec 1, 2020 5:47 AM
Offline
Aug 2018
2
❅ Min-Max length (volumes): None but preferably not short
❅ Likes (genres, demographics, themes): No strong preference.
❅ Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): Nothing from the top 50, Mecha, Yuri, Yaoi, Psychological Horror, Dementia, Military
❅ Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): No
❅ Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): No
❅ Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 34
❅ Does your list include everything you've read?: My list does not include webtoons :P
❅ Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Afloat
❅ Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: Yes (Gift Exchange) although my manga knowledge isn't great
Dec 1, 2020 6:15 AM

Offline
Aug 2019
12
❅ Min-Max length (volumes): No limit but series must be completed, I am super new to the manga game so please consider that when recommending.
❅ Likes (genres, demographics, themes): I enjoy a lot of world-building and great legend stories; Tower of God, for example, then genre I enjoy are Comedy, Romance, Action, (p.s IDK why but I have come to enjoy these ecchi mangas that have a surprisingly good plot(Nozoki ana for example) )
❅ Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): Anything is fine as long it's complete and has an interesting plot try staying way from harem tho..
❅ Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): No
❅ Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): No
❅ Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 14
❅ Does your list include everything you've read?: yep
❅ Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/profile/RauMac29
❅ Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: Any is fine by me (if you think an elf is more suitable go with that)
RauMac29Dec 12, 2020 3:11 AM
Dec 1, 2020 9:02 AM
Offline
Apr 2018
4
❅ Min-Max length (volumes): I'd like something with long chapters and many volumes.
❅ Likes (genres, demographics, themes): Romance, Drama, Slice of Life.
❅ Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): Yaoi.
❅ Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): No.
❅ Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): No.
❅ Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 13
❅ Does your list include everything you've read?: No
❅ Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Bibanu
❅ Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: I'll also create a gift for someone.
Dec 1, 2020 12:00 PM
Offline
Apr 2018
3
❅Min-Max length (volumes): 10-150 chapters and it has to be completed

❅Likes (genres, demographics, themes): Anything, surprise me

❅Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): They can be sexual but not explicitly pornographic

❅Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): No restrictions

❅Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): No

❅Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 173

❅Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes

❅Link to manga list:
https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/PolyphemusTC?

❅Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: Gift Exchange
Dec 1, 2020 3:01 PM

Offline
Feb 2018
35
Min-Max length (volumes):
It should at least have 3 volumes, but the more the better (could also mean there are already 3 volumes and ongoing, but not stuck)
Only these ultra long running series which are quite hard to find should be excluded, so less than 24 volumes would be good
Likes (genres, demographics, themes):
I mostly read romance, shoujo, yuri, fantasy
Japanese cultural elements are also always welcome
The scores on my list show kind of what I like, so a look there might be helpful
And... if you know something, suttle fluffiness in romance, I'm searching always for that :3
Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes):
I kind of ran in some yaoi, which traumatised myself a little bit, so please don't 🙂
Also, if ecchi or sexual content can be avoided, that would be great!
Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies):
I like reading "the old style" so if possible, the manga should be available at the german publishers Altraverse, Tokyopop (Germany), Egmont Manga, Carlsen Manga, KAZÉ Manga (this also means, it should be available as new print, I don't really buy second hand)
But if not possible for that manga, as far as I can find an english version it should be fine (but as said I prefer reading printed, so it would need to suit me really good)
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No):
As the Plan to Read list isn't really long, I would like to ask you to find something new for me ^^
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 23 (but the most stuff is ongoing or unfortunately on Hold)
Does your list include everything you've read?:
Yes, I track every manga volume and every chapter I read
Link to manga list:
Manga-List / malgraph
Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?:
Yes, if I'm allowed I will happily agree in doing the gift exchange!
lumarelDec 1, 2020 3:05 PM
Dec 1, 2020 5:58 PM
Offline
Oct 2015
6
Min-Max length (volumes): no limit but please nothing canceled
❅ Likes (genres, demographics, themes): romance, josei, seinen, comedy, yaoi, tragedy
❅ Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): * magical girls, meccha, vampires
❅ Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies):no
❅ Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No):sure
❅ Number of Completed entries on your manga list:95
❅ Does your list include everything you've read?: i think so? it may be missing some yaois
❅ Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/basedpeyt?
❅ Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: ill create one too
Dec 1, 2020 6:56 PM
Offline
Aug 2020
2
❅ Min-Max length (volumes): any length is fine
❅ Likes (genres, demographics, themes): Seinen, Shounen, Adventure, mystery, romance, sci-fi, dementia, drama, psychological, and fantasy. I'm open to trying out horror manga too. It's not a necessity, but I enjoy good art as well.
❅ Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): ecchi and harem
❅ Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): nope
❅ Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): yes but preferably no.
❅ Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 2, but I'm caught up with 5 ongoing ones, so I've read 7 in total.
❅ Does your list include everything you've read?: yes
❅ Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/XGachaHeatLuvurX
❅ Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: I think elf because I haven't read a lot.
♡Thank you♡
Dec 1, 2020 10:31 PM
Offline
Dec 2015
1
❅ Min-Max length (volumes): Anything as long as it's not something that started very recently.
❅ Likes (genres, demographics, themes):Anything is fine. (don't make me regret saying this pls.)
❅ Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes):Just don't recommend something everyone already knows of (like something from the top 50/100 manga). I am open to every genre but from my mangalist you can see the types I'm most fond of.
❅ Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): Anything that I can read online in English.
❅ Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): If it is something you REALLY REALLY REALLY recommend and you have nothing better, sure.
❅ Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 112
❅ Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes. There are only a few that are not on MAL yet are missing.
❅ Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Agarica
❅ Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: Gift Exchange
AgaricaDec 2, 2020 4:53 PM
Dec 2, 2020 1:55 AM
Offline
Sep 2018
6
❅ Min-Max length (volumes): Min-100 and Max-300
❅ Likes (genres, demographics, themes): I would preffer a good romance
❅ Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): no dislikes
❅ Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): no
❅ Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): Dont need,but if it is please tell me why do I need to start it
❅ Number of Completed entries on your manga list:13
❅ Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes
❅ Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/profile/GoncaloPC4
❅ Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: IDK xd
Dec 2, 2020 3:47 AM
ฅ^•ﻌ•^ฅ

Offline
Jun 2020
204
Min-Max length (volumes): no One Piece.length
Likes (genres, demographics, themes): dementia, psychological, horror, mature , plot-twists
Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): top 200, predictable
Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): No
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): No
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 3
Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/sspookyboogie
Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: I would only like to receive. Thankyou. :)
Dec 2, 2020 6:31 AM

Offline
Apr 2011
68
Min-Max length (volumes): max. 5 to 10 Volumes
Likes (genres, demographics, themes): Romance, but I am open for everything you think is good =)
Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): Yuri, Ecchi
Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): None
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): If possible not, but when it’s too hard to find something than ok
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 658
Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes
Link to manga list: List
Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: Yes, will create a gift
ani_magDec 3, 2020 10:16 AM
Dec 2, 2020 8:12 AM
Offline
May 2015
20
Min-Max length (volumes): At least something substantial, not like 10-20 chapters.
Likes (genres, demographics, themes): Anything not listed below. Has to have above 7.5 score.
Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): Harem, Ecchi, Gag, 4-koma (for the most part), Extreme Drama (ie. Scum's Wish), Isekai, Mecha, Horror, Gore. Avoid some Shojuo with very shojuo like troupes (ex. of good shojuo manga imo: Machida, Wake Up Sleeping Beauty, Akatsuki no Yona).
Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): : None.
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): No. Also please don't recommend a manga which has an anime that I've already watched (ie. FMAB, I've seen the anime but haven't read the manga).
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 166, I include manga I am currently reading though. Otherwise 61.
Does your list include everything you've read?: Nope, I don't add a lot of trash Isekai or trash romance if I read it. Also, not a lot of mahuwa/webtoons I like a lot (Beginning of the End, Black Haze, etc.) because its not on MAL.
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Avajou
Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: Of course, give and take in equal proportions. (Gift Exchange)
AvajouDec 10, 2020 8:44 AM
Dec 2, 2020 8:15 AM

Offline
Apr 2016
20
❅ Min-Max length (volumes): No limit but the series should be completed

❅ Likes (genres, demographics, themes): Romance, slice of life and comedy are some genres I enjoy. Psychological plots with focus on character development are always enjoyable to reading, Kasane for instance. Honestly, I haven't read enough manga to find a specific niche so surprise me!

❅ Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): no such thing as long as it has a good story to tell.

❅ Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): no

❅ Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): nope

❅ Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 26

❅ Does your list include everything you've read?: yes

❅ Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/GlitchedFuruya?status=2

❅ Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to
receive (Elf Gift)?: gift exchange
Dec 2, 2020 9:48 AM
Offline
Feb 2016
6
Min-Max length (volumes):
No restrictions here.
Likes (genres, demographics, themes):
Drama, action, romance!
Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes):
Moe
Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies):
No.
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No):
no.
Number of Completed entries on your manga list:
9
Does your list include everything you've read?:
Yeah, basically. Most ongoing mangas I've read up to the newest volume.
Link to manga list:
https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Antwere
Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?:
I want to only receive!
Dec 2, 2020 11:11 AM

Offline
Apr 2015
190
Min-Max length (volumes): Any; Preferably Completed series
Likes (genres, demographics, themes): Romance, Drama, Shounen Ai, Slice of Life, Josei
Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): Horror, Gender Bender, Harem. Shoujo Ai
Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): Mangadex
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): Sure
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 323
Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/gekkouka
Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: Gift Exchange

Although we part as I leave for Inaba,
where pines grow on the moutain peaks
If I am to hear that you pine for me
I shall come back to you again
Hyakunin Isshu (小倉百人一首):
Poem #16 "Tachiwakare"
©
Dec 2, 2020 11:27 AM

Offline
Apr 2013
34
Min-Max length (volumes): 1-20 volumes
Likes (genres, demographics, themes): I don't like the seasonal hype factory, I follow things with a lag. So, make it older than, let's say, ~4 years. Also, in case of manga, I like to experiment with more obscure stuff (example).
Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): things for kids, mecha, sports, and no explicit hentai for now (ecchi is fine)
Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): none
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): yes, bonus points if not :)
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 33
Does your list include everything you've read?: yes
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/L0rd
Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: Gift Exchange - I'll create. However, I understand I don't read a lot of manga, so I'm happy with just a gift. :)
Dec 2, 2020 11:56 AM
Offline
Aug 2020
6
Min-Max length (volumes): 1 - 20-ish

Likes (genres, demographics, themes):

- Genres: Slice of Life, Psychological, Mystery, Drama, Romance, Comedy, Historical and Sci-Fi.

- Demographics: All welcome.

- Themes: Mental Health, Enjoying the Moment, Importance of Community, War is Hell, Importance of Trusting Yourself, and Learning to Open Yourself Up. In general if a theme is delivered well, even if I disagree with its use/message, I tend to enjoy it.

- Additional Context: I equally enjoy both weird content and more standard content, so make it as weird or normal as you'd like. In terms of art-styles I enjoy both clean and rough/sketch looking art. In regards to the Romance Genre, it can be from any perspective male/female main, straight/yaoi/yuri, don't be afraid to throw any of it my way. I misuse tags on my list to give my general thoughts/notes-to-self on a series, so feel free to use those to get an idea where my interests lie.


Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes):

- Genres: Shounen Battle Series, Action (unless it goes way over the top, or has something else backing it.).

- Additional Context: While I do like a fair number of Isekai/Romance/Harem/etc., self-insert fantasy content usually doesn't work for me. Any would have to hold up despite their self-insert elements, rather than because of them. Edgy content, for edginess sake, also doesn't jive for me. I'll need some meat for that edge to cut through.


Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): No.


Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): Preferably no, but if you feel you must go for it. The passion behind recommendations always makes them better.


Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 5 (the 6th is still ongoing, just re-reading it).


Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes.


Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/B-dar


Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: Gift Exchange.
B-darDec 3, 2020 12:28 PM
Dec 2, 2020 12:16 PM
Offline
Oct 2015
5
❅ Min-Max length (volumes): any
❅ Likes (genres, demographics, themes):
-Character focused manga
-LGBT themes/relationships
-Seinen
-Mystery
-Yokai, urban fantasy, magic
-Found family
-More than one main character
-Good slice of life
-Comedy

❅ Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes):
-Ecchi/harems
-Painfully hetero stuff
-Fetishized gay relationships
-Shounen if its only abt battling/getting stronger

❅ Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies):no
❅ Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): no
❅ Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 21
❅ Does your list include everything you've read?: no
❅ Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/maayafey
❅ Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: gift exchange
Dec 2, 2020 2:30 PM

Offline
Feb 2019
32
Min-Max length (volumes): nothing toooo long, but anything is good
Likes (genres, demographics, themes): cgdct, psychological, mystery, romance, sol, action, drama, fantasy, anything
Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): bl
Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): no
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): yes ;)
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 1
Does your list include everything you've read?: yes
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/Chop_in
Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: Elf Gift (unless you match me with someone, good luck with that)




Set by Secret Santa Stardew <3
Dec 2, 2020 2:37 PM
Offline
May 2016
10
Min-Max length (volumes): Any length, but need to be finished.
Likes (genres, demographics, themes): Anything except the ones in Dislikes.
Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): Ecchi, Harem, H-Manga, Yaoi, Yuri, School-Manga(90% of the plot is in school)
Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): no restrictions
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): No
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 21
Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes
Link to manga list: Here
Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: Yes (Gift exchange)
Dec 2, 2020 6:08 PM

Offline
Aug 2017
214
Min-Max length (volumes): No maximum, but I would prefer something longer than 5ish volumes.
Likes (genres, demographics, themes): Romantic Comedy
Dislikes (genres, demographics, themes): I really just want to read a good RomCom to distract me from the existential loneliness inside.
Any availability restrictions? (e.g. must have printed/physical copies): Nope
Can the recommendation be on your Plan to Read list? (Yes or No): No. I'd also prefer a manga where I haven't already seen the anime adaptation, hopefully, that's not too difficult, soz.
Number of Completed entries on your manga list: 30
Does your list include everything you've read?: Yes...
Link to manga list: https://myanimelist.net/mangalist/DistructiveNick?status=2
Will you create a gift for another user (Gift Exchange) or do you only want to receive (Elf Gift)?: Gift Exchange
DistructiveNickDec 2, 2020 6:12 PM
If I had a nickel for every anime that began airing on October 9th 2022 that started with a B and ended in "ock", I would have two nickels.
That's not a lot, but it's funny that it happened twice.

This topic has been locked and is no longer available for discussion.
Pages (7) « First ... « 3 4 [5] 6 7 »

More topics from this board

» | OPEN | Best Profile Design (October 2025) NOMINATIONS

Phraze - Oct 4

7 by Ms_Muffin »»
Today, 3:04 AM

» | OPEN | Best Profile Design (September 2025) NOMINATIONS

Phraze - Sep 7

10 by Ms_Muffin »»
Oct 1, 10:02 AM

» Best Profile Design (August 2025) WINNER

Phraze - Sep 7

4 by KarenShirotori »»
Sep 12, 1:48 AM

» | CLOSED | Best Profile Design (August 2025) VOTING

Phraze - Aug 22

13 by wujack »»
Sep 4, 8:53 PM

» | CLOSED | Best Profile Design (August 2025) NOMINATIONS

Phraze - Aug 4

9 by Phraze »»
Aug 22, 11:06 PM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login