Shomiji said: ]Is there a certain amount if chapters that has to be in the book...? I feel like I've seen the answer before, I just can't find it.. sorry prob not, since no matter the chapter count, the amount of pages in 1 vol is about the same, give or take 20 pages |
| It's good that Slop leveling won the CR awards with such a power gap, Gaijin Weebs don't deserve good anime. Not after what they did to frieren, kusuriya, and many others |
Shomiji said: Is there a certain amount if chapters that has to be in the book...? I feel like I've seen the answer before, I just can't find it.. sorry No, there's no limit. I think you should be fine, as long as it is a complete volume. :) omakase said: @Shomiji could you be a little more specific? By book do you mean light novel or manga tankoubon? EDIT: ah, there's that! |
i_yuuko-chanJan 8, 2018 8:01 PM
  |
omakase said: @Scarlett_ryuken what can I say, I'm a lenient dictator. @Shomiji could you be a little more specific? By book do you mean light novel or manga tankoubon? Scarlett_ryuken said: Shomiji said: ]Is there a certain amount if chapters that has to be in the book...? I feel like I've seen the answer before, I just can't find it.. sorry prob not, since no matter the chapter count, the amount of pages in 1 vol is about the same, give or take 20 pages i_yuuko-chan said: Shomiji said: Is there a certain amount if chapters that has to be in the book...? I feel like I've seen the answer before, I just can't find it.. sorry No, there's no limit. I think you should be fine, as long as it is a complete volume. :) omakase said: @Shomiji could you be a little more specific? By book do you mean light novel or manga tankoubon? EDIT: ah, there's that! Oh, okay thanks. I'm referring to does the manga have to have a more than a certain amount of chapters. |
Gwathgor said: Could someone give me a rec for 17, please? What do you think of these? :) Seiyou Kottou Yougashiten | v4.ch23 (shoujo, slice of life) Jumyou wo Kaitotte Moratta. Ichinen ni Tsuki, Ichimanen de. | v3.ch18 (shounen, drama) K no Souretsu | v2.ch22 (josei, mystery, psychological) Void | v1.ch06 (yaoi, sci-fi, drama) Kaori no Keishou | v2.ch13 (yaoi, drama) Your Plan-To-Read Doukyuusei | v1.ch06 (shounen-ai) |
|
| Does anyone have any recommendations for 17? I like weird/creepy stories, but I'm open for anything ^^ |
 |
| @Shomiji Some items have a length requirement, if the item doesn't not explicitly say read a manga with x number of chapters, then anything from a one-shot to Detective Conan levels of long-running counts as long as it fits the item you're trying to use it for. |
密室殺人はなぜ美しいのか。 |
omakase said: @Shomiji Some items have a length requirement, if the item doesn't not explicitly say read a manga with x number of chapters, then anything from a one-shot to Detective Conan levels of long-running counts as long as it fits the item you're trying to use it for. Okay, thank you!! |
EctoplasmicBlood said: Does anyone have any recommendations for 17? I like weird/creepy stories, but I'm open for anything ^^ Hello! :) I'm unsure as to what should be "creepy" enough for you... xD But let me try something. Would something like this sound creepy? K no Souretsu | v2.ch22 | (josei, mystery, psychological) Found some others: Mouryou no Yurikago | v6.ch41 | (seinen, horror, action) The survival situation and art leans more towards a horror, if you like. Blame! | v10.ch66 | (seinen, horror, sci-fi) The story per se is not necessarily creepy, but the environment and the art have a great chance of creeping ones out. :P 13 Club | v2.ch11 | (seinen, mystery) It's short and has a number of stories that are quite dark. Bokurano | v11.ch66 | (seinen, drama, mecha, psychological) This one is also very good. :) I see you like some yaoi, so... Itou-san | v1.ch07 | (yaoi) Aka no Theatre | v1.ch06 | (yaoi, psychological) Jigoku Meguri | v2.ch10 | (yaoi, supernatural, drama, romance) Hope you find something to your liking. |
|
| Any suggestions for 17? |
| Is Naver Webtoon an online magazine? |
Lohuydahutt said: Any suggestions for 17? https://myanimelist.net/manga/50027/About_Death https://myanimelist.net/manga/62887/All_You_Need_Is_Kill Coolio793 said: hi can some one help me find a award winning manga like maybe list 2 or something thanks for the help ur the best :) https://myanimelist.net/manga/44307/Kakukaku_Shikajika https://myanimelist.net/manga/664/Akira |
| It's good that Slop leveling won the CR awards with such a power gap, Gaijin Weebs don't deserve good anime. Not after what they did to frieren, kusuriya, and many others |
| Does doujinshi count? |
Shomiji said: Does doujinshi count? Doujinshi should count, yes. They're manga entries by their own right. |
HeNrYTG50 said: Shomiji said: Does doujinshi count? Doujinshi should count, yes. They're manga entries by their own right. OK, thanks you very much! |
i_yuuko-chan said: EctoplasmicBlood said: Does anyone have any recommendations for 17? I like weird/creepy stories, but I'm open for anything ^^ Hello! :) I'm unsure as to what should be "creepy" enough for you... xD But let me try something. Would something like this sound creepy? K no Souretsu | v2.ch22 | (josei, mystery, psychological) Found some others: Mouryou no Yurikago | v6.ch41 | (seinen, horror, action) The survival situation and art leans more towards a horror, if you like. Blame! | v10.ch66 | (seinen, horror, sci-fi) The story per se is not necessarily creepy, but the environment and the art have a great chance of creeping ones out. :P 13 Club | v2.ch11 | (seinen, mystery) It's short and has a number of stories that are quite dark. Bokurano | v11.ch66 | (seinen, drama, mecha, psychological) This one is also very good. :) I see you like some yaoi, so... Itou-san | v1.ch07 | (yaoi) Aka no Theatre | v1.ch06 | (yaoi, psychological) Jigoku Meguri | v2.ch10 | (yaoi, supernatural, drama, romance) Hope you find something to your liking. Thank you so much ^^ I think I might read all of them at some point o.o |
|
Samii said: I've started reading Kokou no Hito and would like to know if it fits challenge no. 74, Read a manga based on real event or person It says in Wikipedia that it is "partially based on real-life mountain climber Buntarō Katō". So I wonder if it is okay for it to be only loosely based? I guess nobody saw my post so I'm quoting it... Also to clarify, the character name in the manga is Mori Buntarou and not the same as the real person Katou Buntarou. So I'm not really sure if that is acceptable. Would really like some help with this! |
Armandoriel said: Souhei said: Hello! Can someone give me some reccomendations for these categories? (17) Read a manga recommended to you by another participant in the discussion thread: (78) Read a manga recommended to you by a challenge staff member If it is possible I would prefer that they are complete. Don't mind genre or number of chapters. Thank you very much in advance! https://myanimelist.net/manga/12922/_C__Sword_and_Cornett https://myanimelist.net/manga/584/Mirai_Nikki https://myanimelist.net/manga/5119/Hoozuki_no_Shima https://myanimelist.net/manga/10865/Touhou_Shinigami__Meteor_Methuselah_Gaiden Hope one of those will be useful for your challenge ;) Here are some recommendatios, hope some get your interest. https://myanimelist.net/manga/62887/All_You_Need_Is_Kill https://myanimelist.net/manga/221/Basilisk__Kouga_Ninpouchou https://myanimelist.net/manga/936/Homunculus https://myanimelist.net/manga/481/Planetes Thank you! I'll try them ;) |
 |
omakase said: @Shuichi2 well, just reading one volumen counts, I should probably make a note of that in the list lol Oh, thanks haha. I might give Youjo Senki a try then, I didn't like the anime but the plot sounded interesting. |
Well, for the purpose of this challenge, it will count as one, yes. @Samii I could have sworn I replied to you! Sorry for the wait, yes that would count for the item of based on a real person. |
密室殺人はなぜ美しいのか。 |
omakase said: Well, for the purpose of this challenge, it will count as one, yes. @Samii I could have sworn I replied to you! Sorry for the wait, yes that would count for the item of based on a real person. https://myanimelist.net/manga/94005/Kekkon_shitemo_Koishiteru fam, dis counts for tat item? |
| It's good that Slop leveling won the CR awards with such a power gap, Gaijin Weebs don't deserve good anime. Not after what they did to frieren, kusuriya, and many others |
omakase said: @Samii I could have sworn I replied to you! Sorry for the wait, yes that would count for the item of based on a real person. No it's okay ^^ Thank you very much! |
| Someone recommend me something (70) Read a manga with more users listed in PTR than Completed: (73) Read a manga with a non-human main character: I'm in your care. |
 |
| Could i get a recommendations for : (78) Read a manga recommended to you by a challenge staff member (54) Read a manga by an author and artist duo (41) Read a manga that takes place outside of Japan, but in the real world |
| Because we're stupid that we love to have fun |
Pandemonium: Majutsushi no Mura |
| Because we're stupid that we love to have fun |
i_yuuko-chan said: Gwathgor said: Could someone give me a rec for 17, please? What do you think of these? :) Seiyou Kottou Yougashiten | v4.ch23 (shoujo, slice of life) Jumyou wo Kaitotte Moratta. Ichinen ni Tsuki, Ichimanen de. | v3.ch18 (shounen, drama) K no Souretsu | v2.ch22 (josei, mystery, psychological) Void | v1.ch06 (yaoi, sci-fi, drama) Kaori no Keishou | v2.ch13 (yaoi, drama) Your Plan-To-Read Doukyuusei | v1.ch06 (shounen-ai) Thanks a lot! I'll use some of them for the other requirements, too ^^ |
 |
| Once again I'm doing a full BL/shounen ai list but I need help with these. (21) Read a web manga or 4-koma manga when it says web manga does it have to be in the MAL database? I'm reading one on a website called Lehzin. Does that count? (51) Read a gekiga manga (78) Read a manga recommended to you by a challenge staff member |
 |
| @i_yuuko-chan @omakase Thank you. I'll read all of them (although Nodame will have to wait). |
Scarlett_ryuken said: https://myanimelist.net/manga/94005/Kekkon_shitemo_Koishiteru fam, dis counts for tat item? Listed as semi-autobiographical so yeah, sure. @Shineee_ more PTR than Completed: Kakukaku Shikajika @podetus (78) Read a manga recommended to you by a challenge staff member - Planetes (54) Read a manga by an author and artist duo - All You Need Is Kill (41) Read a manga that takes place outside of Japan, but in the real world - Emma @Mariemaia Girl Friends or Aoi Hana @EION You can use something outside the MAL database, yes. If it's on baka-updates, link that in your form, if it's not, link to the pace where you read it. I'm not sure if there's BL gekiga though?? @lady_freyja do you know any? As for a rec from a staff member No Color is one of my favorites :D @lubryka yeah, I know it's kinda long haha |
密室殺人はなぜ美しいのか。 |
podetus said: Could i get a recommendations for : (41) Read a manga that takes place outside of Japan, but in the real world Benkei in New York. (I was gonna say Green Blood, but it looks like you've already read that one. |
   |
| @omakase Thanks @BrainpanSonata Thanks |
| Because we're stupid that we love to have fun |
oberstein said: EION said: Once again I'm doing a full BL/shounen ai list but I need help with these. (51) Read a gekiga manga There's a change you can use MW by Osamu Tezuka for this item, it depicts a homosexual relationship (though it's not tagged as BL in MAL) and I'd say it counts a gekiga as it was published in the second half of the 70's when Gekiga was still going strong. I read that last year for the challenge... |
| |
Scarlett_ryuken said: chibieska said: I need help for: (49) Read a manga with a protagonist who shares your hair color. My dyed hair count? Or only my natural hair color? (82) Read a manga recommended to one of your favorite manga. This about recommendation by users in manga page or what? yes the recommendations by user on the manga page thank you for help |
belugabaleia said: I'm sorry if the question is stupid, but am I allowed to increase difficulty mid challenge (or perhaps post completion, if I complete Newbie faster than I thought)? If so, should I just edit the post? Mid challenge, yes; Post completion, no. :P (Technically post-completion, yes, before you turn-in your form) "Confirm all items/details are correct before posting. Once you turn-in your challenge, you can't continue working on it, but you may edit the post to correct information." |
| Thank god for being allowed to swap an item out, I'm dumping the light novel for gekiga. @omakase sorry to add onto your pile more, but could I have a rec too please? Ideally 3-7 volumes? |
  |
| @letsgomeisei for any item in particular? If not, then Planetes |
密室殺人はなぜ美しいのか。 |
| @omakase ah, it was just the "recommended by a challenge staff member" one, so thank you very much! |
|
| Hello. For the challenge (76) Read a manga that takes place in Japan, if it's a fictional city IN Japan does that count? Or does it need to be a real japanese city? |
Nagizuma said: Hello. For the challenge (76) Read a manga that takes place in Japan, if it's a fictional city IN Japan does that count? Or does it need to be a real japanese city? I'd say if it's fictional but still in Japan it should count. @omakase for good measure |
KazzeonJan 9, 2018 2:45 PM
HeNrYTG50 said: Nagizuma said: Hello. For the challenge (76) Read a manga that takes place in Japan, if it's a fictional city IN Japan does that count? Or does it need to be a real japanese city? I'd say if it's fictional but still in Japan it should count. @omakase for good measure Eh, yeah. It has to be a real one, sorry. |
密室殺人はなぜ美しいのか。 |
| Hi! As one of the items in my challenge list, I got this: (78) Read a manga recommended to you by a challenge staff member I was wondering how I should go about contacting a staff member for this or if one passes by here, if I could get a recommendation, please! |
  |
More topics from this board
» Have you ever droped a manga that you had been following for a long time and with great interest?RobertBobert - Sep 7 |
20 |
by ryan77999
»»
6 hours ago |
|
» The Second Manga General Election on Niconico MangaGinIonSui - Aug 11 |
3 |
by GinIonSui
»»
6 hours ago |
|
» Any manga related?giandambro3 - 12 hours ago |
1 |
by geberim
»»
9 hours ago |
|
» Someone have thriller seinen for me?Gilgagulag - Sep 20 |
3 |
by geberim
»»
10 hours ago |
|
» Why is so much new manga isekai and yaoi/yuri?fallout45 - Yesterday |
3 |
by Uukki
»»
10 hours ago |