New
Mar 14, 2017 1:33 PM
#651
Grapefruit21 said: Because I am curious to see reactions to this and want to see other's lists since I derailed a whole day with mechanical talk it's t/s list time. Town Grapefruit JustKrista (Pending N2) Oyasumi_Rosie Lam-b Claire Togs Logic Rinto Kaitou (I have completely forgotten anything they've done when I had strong opinions about them D1... Next person to reread.) Sonata Grrr Shinichi (I hate our exchange about voting me/logic being scum, doesn't make sense with scum!Suzu) Suzu (Our mechanical discussion is well chronicled...) CPurity (Chronicled elsewhere but my addition is defensive and appealing to emotion. e.g. being rude while attacking others for being rude...) sad that u werent paying enough attention in the thread to see my soft claim, ik rosie noticed it. |
Mar 14, 2017 1:36 PM
#652
logic340 said: I would like to ask everyone on my train if you really think I am scum who do you think are my buddies? And when I flip town where will you go next? Honestly the first question strikes me at odd from you idk why, but as of reading ur posts im leaning more towards u still being slightly scummy. If you were to flip town i would end up rereading the thread to catch any wierd interactions. As for your scum buddies Rosie seems possible at this pint as for another or 3rd i have to think on that. |
Mar 14, 2017 1:38 PM
#653
logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: And what defining line has made me scum? Basically the case against me boils down to my activity isn't where it usually is. I talked mechanics with everyone else who was talking mechanics (less than most), and RL took me away for the better part of the last two real days. My post count is low as fuck and I've had a hard time getting into this game while I was dealing with 3 others. Grapefruit21 said: The fact that you said I was 90% scum and didn't vote me is pretty scummy though. Like that is higher than I've ever been sure anyone is scum without mechanical help. I'm very happy lynching with 75% confidence. @Shinichi-Kun why no vote? me voting you or what? cause i have my vote on logic. Other than ur anti town mind set their isnt anythign i have that can prove your scum once i find that defining line or factor ill vote you. @Sonata and @Claire talk to me about Suzune you both played with her as scum recently. She was extremely townie in those games as well and she feels almost too clean as town at this point. What does you previous experience as her partner tell you or am I overthinking this? Proving suzune is scum is almost impossible because she never slips, also i find your way of thinking this game different. Also find it weird that u pointed out u were towna gain while aslo refering to your past games. That and the fact you ept your rvs vote up without changing it. I mean even if ur busy its not like u forgot this game had existed. |
Mar 14, 2017 1:44 PM
#654
_Claire_ said: Suzune-chan said: _Claire_ said: logic340 said: _Claire_ said: I've gotten a similar feeling and then grrr also came with that we got Gwendolly line as well. Seems like a very comfortable team and I cannot say they are an unaligned pair based on their interactions so far. They both are pushing Grapefruit for similar reasons though as you have stated why would scum!Grapefruit do that? It's weird to me because Suzune doesn't seem any different than the scum games I have seen her in and the fact that no one is concerned about a pocket there surprises and concerns me. What does your meta say? You played a game as scum with her recently?Suzune-chan said: Sure. Although I would think at this point it would be clear. You are a constant this game at stifling speculation. You are also trigger happy and push for kills that are not smart. Yesterday when the miller was revealed you acted like they were expendable and that the town should sacrifice them. Later, you also thought that the vigilante should just kill someone for information. THis suggests that you are driven to push for townie deaths without stopping to weigh the town. You are pitching things that endanger the number of townies. That is a mafia mindset. You are trying to be reasonable to make your opinion sound good. But in the end, it the arguments are anti-town. Let's think for a minute. What would have happened if the vigilante killed the miller. What would that yield the town? A dead townie? We would be in a worse position then the day before and it would have been self inflicted. You have to see from his POV that a miller claims can be a scum claim . You seem to believe Grrr is miller, 100% sure? From this post. That wasnt the first time I was scum with her, but I admit she was just playing way too townish when she was scum. Like, flawlessly you know? And no you arent overthinking it. The fact that she pushes grapefruit's read is alarming to me because she should have noticed too-- scums would play very carefully... I doubt grape is scum in this game. Um, sorry? I have played as scum too, and i know how scums would most likely think. It is not absolute yes, but you need to agree that most scums would play very townish, no? scum isnt a mindset tho, the player makes the mindset. Just cause you were scum doesnt mean you know how scum should act lol |
Mar 14, 2017 1:46 PM
#655
logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: Is this a slip or do yo believe that the mafia think the same way you do? If that is the case then who thinks like you here that would make that move?Grapefruit21 said: And I'm trying to decide who is trolling me as scum and who just went to a horrible school of mafia theory. Because calling the assumption that a Vig should shoot on N1 anti town is ridiculous. Vig not shooting on N1 is the same argument as town no lynching on D1. Unless you are going for the hero play late in the game, but you can't claim and do that! And yeah my JustKrista vote was horrible and Sonata doesn't look great for sheeping it. But Krista being alive and not being roleblocked is pretty suspect too. But still a bad vote and why I've moved off of it. EIther we have another vig and they'll shoot Krista, or Krista is our vig and took a very over cautious line of play. mafia dont know the roles or the game either they hae as much information as us, it super risky to go for karote, when they can just try to put all their focus on someone no one was looking at atleast thats how i would play, as mafia i rather take risks after ive figured out the game. what slip i soft claimed my role along time ago lol,and seeing as how i dont use meta for a basis i have no clue who thinks like me in that situation |
Mar 14, 2017 1:49 PM
#656
logic340 said: Suzune-chan said: The vig always has the potential to destroy town that is kind of the nature of the game. A fake claimed vig that everyone believe would also have the power to destroy town wouldn't they? Why is talking about it any worse than you suggesting Claire or Gwendolly (who has now flipped town doc)? Was saying it was a dumb kill because you were going to go in on Gwen to day you way of covierng your night actions since you two had been into it at the end of D1?logic340 said: Suzune-chan said: This is where I get lost because it seems that I don't know what the best play is? I can see both sides of the Krista argument so I am not sure why Grapefruit's approach to that is considered so anti-town. In regards to the Miller it's just like any other claim we can choose to believe it or not. I chose to believe the claim but if people see behavior that they feel doesn't fit with said claim then shouldn't they be calling out said player for it and how is that anit-town? I guess what I am used to seeing as anti-town play isn't what I am getting from Grapefruit right now which is why I question what you are seeing?logic340 said: It is not that I do not understand grapefruit. I just think that their thinking is anti town and plays too fast and loose with the players. Thus endangers the town and seeks to dwindle the numbers for information rather then to craft the best play.Suzune-chan said: Is he not thinking or is he thinking in a way that you can manipulate? This is transparent Grapefruit at his finest right now not sure what you are seeing?Grapefruit21 said: Why would you choose to kill someone early rather then wait for a better more clear shot? I do not understand you, can you not count the number of pieces on the board and not see an odds advantage in waiting? You are all about quick trigger skills this game. Pause and plan. You are not thinking.Suzune-chan said: Grapefruit21 said: Technically the town as the same info it had yesterday. Not less.Well by waiting they give the town less info to work with now in exchange and lose a confirmed tow slot for nebulous control over the mafia? That doesn't seem like a good trade to me. I want to scum read Suzu and grr for defending that play but it seems more likely it's just that I went to a very different school of mafia game theory. But we have less because Krista decided not to shoot. That choice either denies town info or isn't a choice and is scum. You're correct, but not accurate. I feel like I explain this a while back. There's all kinds of game theory about how to play a miller. I feel like wasting the shot of our vigilante on the Miller is a waste of the shot. Since the Miller must be aligned with the town we have risk using our offense of Night action to destroy potentially more town. What a day would be better spent figuring it out. This is where I struggle, why would I use the towns offense of power roll to potentially destroy more town. Suzune-chan said: So I went back and checked because I have never said that and feel you are misrepresenting me on purpose. In post #495 I was responding to Krista who had said to CP "Are you trying to be pro-town?". I assume you bring this up to me because Gwendolly said the same thing of you during EoD1 but again since I have never used this phrase I have to wonder why you are asking me about it and why you are inferring that I have said it?logic340 said: Suzune-chan said: well let's hope that is the case this time around period I'm still salty...@logic340 I will never stack the odds against me. You are right that I once won a mafia game with no help from a replacement. Is that supposed to say something about replacements? Do you not think that Ruu and I held out and waited for Shi. Hoped beyond the stars he would show? Do you think I did not demand that whoever shuffled in knew the situation they came into? There are good replacements in this world. The best. In a mostly inactive slot, I see no reason not to replace. I would rather read a new face then random lynch an empty space. No reason to waste what might be a fortuneate opportunity for town. Suzune-chan said: not siure why you tagged me as I've never said this? Did you misread something?@logic340 Are you trying to be pro-town? this is becoming not everyone's favourite buzzword. Does it suddenly mean something new. It is like asking someone if they are scum this game. It has almost no meaning but looking busy, if you want to say. Kristina is scummy then do it. But say something that shows your thinking not casual commentary.one that confuses me is that you always point out your town record so why are u trying so hard to defend yourself by saying u never mentioned being protown when u clarify it every game by always boaosting about your town streak lol. |
Mar 14, 2017 1:54 PM
#657
Rinto-kun said: As I see it right now, I'll have to allow myself to be practical on the case of the Vigilante and Miller. I'm kinda sure at least one of them two is telling the truth so let's just make the Vig kill the Miller. If the Vig refuses or doesn't shoot whatsoever(I'm giving them the freedom to shoot someone whom they think is suspicious), we're gonna lynch them. Also we don't have time to stall, so they MUST do it tonight. At least we have to confirm someone, moreover if the vig or miller is mafia then we can trace their relationships with other players and potentially identify other mafia. I'm disappointed in logic because I thought he'd poke me a lot more. Anyways, I'm here now and I'd like to chat with somebody about conspiracy theories and get back to the loop. WE'VE GOTTA GET OUR SHIT TOGETHER BECAUSE I HAVE BEEN LOSING THOSE PAST GAMES BECAUSE TOWN HAD TO ARGUE WITH TOWN AND I DON'T WANT TO LOSE BECAUSE OF THAT. this 1 post makes me wanna vote you Also no one should have to poke you lol Seriously i cant wrap my ahead around people being ok with killing a miller claim like i always day 1 claim miller when i get the role cause if u keep it a secret your scum. Penta claim it on the 2n or 3rd day once and he ended up being mafia unless it was someone else i cant remember but the scenario stiill remains the same. As scum he gained no benefit to claim miller n day 1 literally none. |
Mar 14, 2017 1:56 PM
#658
grrr said: By the way if you want, we can leave logic for tomorrow and lynch Kaitou intead. I am up for that. Both are useless townies heh. huh lol? |
Mar 14, 2017 1:57 PM
#659
grrr said: Sonata said: Yeah I dunno about this lynch tbh. Vote lynch: JustKrista (not sure if I did this already) It seems clear to me. I am not sure how to feel about this. I will leave you to @suzune. @grapefruit who would you kill tonight if you were mafia? @claire when krista shoot you tonight will you be salty? @Shinichikun: Generic question. generic question? |
Mar 14, 2017 1:57 PM
#660
Mar 14, 2017 1:58 PM
#661
Sonata said: grrr said: Sonata said: Yeah I dunno about this lynch tbh. Vote lynch: JustKrista (not sure if I did this already) It seems clear to me. I am not sure how to feel about this. I will leave you to @suzune. @grapefruit who would you kill tonight if you were mafia? @claire when krista shoot you tonight will you be salty? @Shinichikun: Generic question. ??? Isn't it stupid? He claimed vig, but he refused to shoot to prove his alignment. He was not roleblocked either, despite there being two roleblockers that had the chance to RB him (and if a mafia was one of them, they totally would have, so he'd have to make explanations the next day), and you guys just drink it all up? I don't get it. We lost cop and doc already, I thought that'd be enough pressure to not trust empty words? We are running out of chances, you guys know that right? huh by saving the shot he did well. Seorusly this post is weird. Its like u expected karote to know he wasnt gonna get roleblocked or something. |
Mar 14, 2017 1:59 PM
#662
Mar 14, 2017 2:08 PM
#663
Shinichi-Kun said: Rinto-kun said: As I see it right now, I'll have to allow myself to be practical on the case of the Vigilante and Miller. I'm kinda sure at least one of them two is telling the truth so let's just make the Vig kill the Miller. If the Vig refuses or doesn't shoot whatsoever(I'm giving them the freedom to shoot someone whom they think is suspicious), we're gonna lynch them. Also we don't have time to stall, so they MUST do it tonight. At least we have to confirm someone, moreover if the vig or miller is mafia then we can trace their relationships with other players and potentially identify other mafia. I'm disappointed in logic because I thought he'd poke me a lot more. Anyways, I'm here now and I'd like to chat with somebody about conspiracy theories and get back to the loop. WE'VE GOTTA GET OUR SHIT TOGETHER BECAUSE I HAVE BEEN LOSING THOSE PAST GAMES BECAUSE TOWN HAD TO ARGUE WITH TOWN AND I DON'T WANT TO LOSE BECAUSE OF THAT. this 1 post makes me wanna vote you Also no one should have to poke you lol Seriously i cant wrap my ahead around people being ok with killing a miller claim like i always day 1 claim miller when i get the role cause if u keep it a secret your scum. Penta claim it on the 2n or 3rd day once and he ended up being mafia unless it was someone else i cant remember but the scenario stiill remains the same. As scum he gained no benefit to claim miller n day 1 literally none. pointing it out because normally people are generally more invested with me, that's not the case here. Moreover most people who have called me out in previous games have been town and that's helping me discern mafia from the vast being of anti-town-villagers. And why shouldn't we kill a miller claim if we could at least confirm somebody. The miller wins in the end so what of it? People are getting taken with this situation so I'm proposing the most logical and working solution, I don't find anything bad in it, though I'd rather discuss something else. |
~ ~ Anime List ~ ~ Manga List ~ ~ |
Mar 14, 2017 2:10 PM
#664
Nothing interesting has happened so far tbh, I hate myself for not being in the timeframe of most players because I could have more time to investigate them... |
~ ~ Anime List ~ ~ Manga List ~ ~ |
Mar 14, 2017 2:12 PM
#665
Rinto-kun said: You would like to talk about something else me too. What first?Nothing interesting has happened so far tbh, I hate myself for not being in the timeframe of most players because I could have more time to investigate them... |
Where there is no imagination there is no horror. || Arthur Conan Doyle || Happy Halloween! |
Mar 14, 2017 2:23 PM
#666
Rinto-kun said: Shinichi-Kun said: Rinto-kun said: As I see it right now, I'll have to allow myself to be practical on the case of the Vigilante and Miller. I'm kinda sure at least one of them two is telling the truth so let's just make the Vig kill the Miller. If the Vig refuses or doesn't shoot whatsoever(I'm giving them the freedom to shoot someone whom they think is suspicious), we're gonna lynch them. Also we don't have time to stall, so they MUST do it tonight. At least we have to confirm someone, moreover if the vig or miller is mafia then we can trace their relationships with other players and potentially identify other mafia. I'm disappointed in logic because I thought he'd poke me a lot more. Anyways, I'm here now and I'd like to chat with somebody about conspiracy theories and get back to the loop. WE'VE GOTTA GET OUR SHIT TOGETHER BECAUSE I HAVE BEEN LOSING THOSE PAST GAMES BECAUSE TOWN HAD TO ARGUE WITH TOWN AND I DON'T WANT TO LOSE BECAUSE OF THAT. this 1 post makes me wanna vote you Also no one should have to poke you lol Seriously i cant wrap my ahead around people being ok with killing a miller claim like i always day 1 claim miller when i get the role cause if u keep it a secret your scum. Penta claim it on the 2n or 3rd day once and he ended up being mafia unless it was someone else i cant remember but the scenario stiill remains the same. As scum he gained no benefit to claim miller n day 1 literally none. pointing it out because normally people are generally more invested with me, that's not the case here. Moreover most people who have called me out in previous games have been town and that's helping me discern mafia from the vast being of anti-town-villagers. And why shouldn't we kill a miller claim if we could at least confirm somebody. The miller wins in the end so what of it? People are getting taken with this situation so I'm proposing the most logical and working solution, I don't find anything bad in it, though I'd rather discuss something else. cause its a waste of a ynch and a shot thtats why lol. I wanna shot mafia not shoot someone that has 50/50 chance of being mafia. Mind u the fact he claimed miller day 1 is something grrr would do as both a smart move and too troll. Grrr plays alot of tos and this exactly something i would see from a town of salem player. Thats why ik hes not lieing. |
Mar 14, 2017 2:28 PM
#667
Shinichi-Kun said: Rinto-kun said: Shinichi-Kun said: Rinto-kun said: As I see it right now, I'll have to allow myself to be practical on the case of the Vigilante and Miller. I'm kinda sure at least one of them two is telling the truth so let's just make the Vig kill the Miller. If the Vig refuses or doesn't shoot whatsoever(I'm giving them the freedom to shoot someone whom they think is suspicious), we're gonna lynch them. Also we don't have time to stall, so they MUST do it tonight. At least we have to confirm someone, moreover if the vig or miller is mafia then we can trace their relationships with other players and potentially identify other mafia. I'm disappointed in logic because I thought he'd poke me a lot more. Anyways, I'm here now and I'd like to chat with somebody about conspiracy theories and get back to the loop. WE'VE GOTTA GET OUR SHIT TOGETHER BECAUSE I HAVE BEEN LOSING THOSE PAST GAMES BECAUSE TOWN HAD TO ARGUE WITH TOWN AND I DON'T WANT TO LOSE BECAUSE OF THAT. this 1 post makes me wanna vote you Also no one should have to poke you lol Seriously i cant wrap my ahead around people being ok with killing a miller claim like i always day 1 claim miller when i get the role cause if u keep it a secret your scum. Penta claim it on the 2n or 3rd day once and he ended up being mafia unless it was someone else i cant remember but the scenario stiill remains the same. As scum he gained no benefit to claim miller n day 1 literally none. pointing it out because normally people are generally more invested with me, that's not the case here. Moreover most people who have called me out in previous games have been town and that's helping me discern mafia from the vast being of anti-town-villagers. And why shouldn't we kill a miller claim if we could at least confirm somebody. The miller wins in the end so what of it? People are getting taken with this situation so I'm proposing the most logical and working solution, I don't find anything bad in it, though I'd rather discuss something else. cause its a waste of a ynch and a shot thtats why lol. I wanna shot mafia not shoot someone that has 50/50 chance of being mafia. Mind u the fact he claimed miller day 1 is something grrr would do as both a smart move and too troll. Grrr plays alot of tos and this exactly something i would see from a town of salem player. Thats why ik hes not lieing. I'm aware of grrr's playstyle and I'm fine with it so whatever. I'm just saying the vig has to do something tonight. They can attack whoever they thing is mafia, they have around 25+% of hitting mafia so why not, the least we can get is a confirmed town and we already have a doc and and invest dead, what else is to lose? |
~ ~ Anime List ~ ~ Manga List ~ ~ |
Mar 14, 2017 2:28 PM
#668
Suzune-chan said: Rinto-kun said: You would like to talk about something else me too. What first?Nothing interesting has happened so far tbh, I hate myself for not being in the timeframe of most players because I could have more time to investigate them... Eeh? Suggest a theme, I'm bad at starting conversations. |
~ ~ Anime List ~ ~ Manga List ~ ~ |
Mar 14, 2017 2:34 PM
#669
Rinto-kun said: well, what's on your mind? Who are you leaning scum on? Do you think that Claire is attempting to deflect all of their comments on to people in order to spread around the guilt? Because that's kind of what I'm thinking.Suzune-chan said: Rinto-kun said: Nothing interesting has happened so far tbh, I hate myself for not being in the timeframe of most players because I could have more time to investigate them... Eeh? Suggest a theme, I'm bad at starting conversations. |
Where there is no imagination there is no horror. || Arthur Conan Doyle || Happy Halloween! |
Mar 14, 2017 3:03 PM
#670
Mar 14, 2017 3:04 PM
#671
Shinichi-Kun said: Rinto apparently does not want to talk with me.rinto where art thou? |
Where there is no imagination there is no horror. || Arthur Conan Doyle || Happy Halloween! |
Mar 14, 2017 3:07 PM
#672
@Rinto-kun speak now or forever be scum |
Mar 14, 2017 5:03 PM
#673
logic340 said: Grapefruit21 said: I believe that was Purity but I would have to go look for it.One more whoever was suggesting we use other town roles like watcher to clear is scum, A for advocating wasting uses, and B for implying they should out themselves to clear the miller slot. Edit: All of this about the miller. I failed at typing I forgot to bring this up with the rest of the chaos but yes it was, and that is a large part of why they're on the bottom of my t/s list. As to other questions I missed @Shinichi-kun I noticed your soft claim, just not acting on it as of yet. ALso you didn't change your vote. Do you still have a high degree of confidence that I'm scum? Is there anything in logic's giant catch up that stood out making him more likely to be scum? @Rinto-Kun you inform the thread first of how you know you were roleblocked and then I'll go. And yes I'm making you go first because of LQ. Thoughts in general I hate going back to the miller well, but people who are scum reading me for my mechanics talk are saying things like the Miller can't live past D3. If that's the case why bother waiting at all? Edit: Why bother waiting if you don't feel good about other lynches for example D1. Second @Shinichi-Kun @Suzune-chan do you think my adovcated plays are bad (as in +EV for scum) or less ideal than yours? Because there is a big gap between the two and I know where my thoughts on yours fall on that spectrum. And it's in the less ideal, but still fine for miller and -EV for town on Vig. @grrr I'd kill Lam-b. Though I have no clue why town cares to ask this question. |
Grapefruit21Mar 14, 2017 5:10 PM
Mar 14, 2017 5:30 PM
#674
@Grapefruit21 Second @Shinichi-Kun @Suzune-chan do you think my adovcated plays are bad (as in +EV for scum) or less ideal than yours? Because there is a big gap between the two and I know where my thoughts on yours fall on that spectrum. And it's in the less ideal, but still fine for miller and -EV for town on Vig I'm confused about the question being asked. What is +EV vs -EV. |
Where there is no imagination there is no horror. || Arthur Conan Doyle || Happy Halloween! |
Mar 14, 2017 5:41 PM
#675
Suzune-chan said: @Grapefruit21 Second @Shinichi-Kun @Suzune-chan do you think my adovcated plays are bad (as in +EV for scum) or less ideal than yours? Because there is a big gap between the two and I know where my thoughts on yours fall on that spectrum. And it's in the less ideal, but still fine for miller and -EV for town on Vig I'm confused about the question being asked. What is +EV vs -EV.EV is expected value, basically a line of play that will usually be a good one in the long term is EV+ and one that will hurt in the long run is EV-. What I'm trying to ask is do you think my Miller and Vig lines of play are actively bad, or just not as good for town as yours? |
Mar 14, 2017 6:02 PM
#676
Grapefruit21 said: Listen Grapefruit we are derailing the topic. I do not want to do this again, you know where we both stand on this. I think you are trigger happy therefore I think you are looking at it as -EV. Instead, it is neutral. Letting the problem solve itself. I think town can and will work it out during the day without wasting our weapons. You are just being on the offense. While I am waiting and being defensive about the plays.Suzune-chan said: @Grapefruit21 Second @Shinichi-Kun @Suzune-chan do you think my adovcated plays are bad (as in +EV for scum) or less ideal than yours? Because there is a big gap between the two and I know where my thoughts on yours fall on that spectrum. And it's in the less ideal, but still fine for miller and -EV for town on Vig EV is expected value, basically a line of play that will usually be a good one in the long term is EV+ and one that will hurt in the long run is EV-. What I'm trying to ask is do you think my Miller and Vig lines of play are actively bad, or just not as good for town as yours? |
Where there is no imagination there is no horror. || Arthur Conan Doyle || Happy Halloween! |
Mar 14, 2017 6:20 PM
#677
Grapefruit21 said: logic340 said: Grapefruit21 said: One more whoever was suggesting we use other town roles like watcher to clear is scum, A for advocating wasting uses, and B for implying they should out themselves to clear the miller slot. Edit: All of this about the miller. I failed at typing I forgot to bring this up with the rest of the chaos but yes it was, and that is a large part of why they're on the bottom of my t/s list. As to other questions I missed @Shinichi-kun I noticed your soft claim, just not acting on it as of yet. ALso you didn't change your vote. Do you still have a high degree of confidence that I'm scum? Is there anything in logic's giant catch up that stood out making him more likely to be scum? @Rinto-Kun you inform the thread first of how you know you were roleblocked and then I'll go. And yes I'm making you go first because of LQ. Thoughts in general I hate going back to the miller well, but people who are scum reading me for my mechanics talk are saying things like the Miller can't live past D3. If that's the case why bother waiting at all? Edit: Why bother waiting if you don't feel good about other lynches for example D1. Second @Shinichi-Kun @Suzune-chan do you think my adovcated plays are bad (as in +EV for scum) or less ideal than yours? Because there is a big gap between the two and I know where my thoughts on yours fall on that spectrum. And it's in the less ideal, but still fine for miller and -EV for town on Vig. @grrr I'd kill Lam-b. Though I have no clue why town cares to ask this question. not that i see him more as scum its just i see him less as town because nothing has said has made me want to remove my vote just yet. As for your ev shit i kinda get it because i play pokemon lol, but at the same time my views on hoe certain stuff should be looked at is just different than yours and many others. Maybe cause of the enviornment we played in or something along those lines. The problem i have with ur methods is prob the morality of them, you a town/scum that isok sacrificing people for results and information and you see the future results. While I rather take risks at the same time while not hurting town at the cost of those risks. Im all for killing the miller but not as early as you normally would be used to. Same goes for the vigilante im all for him making a kill i just rather it not be done on n1 because the potential risk i has on town if he msses or kills another town on top of the one that dies every night phase. |
Mar 14, 2017 6:21 PM
#678
Mar 14, 2017 6:21 PM
#679
@Suzunie-chan Cool, that's all I needed was a full you think it's a bad play not a sub optimal one. Not going any further with the debate just needed to know where you stood. @Shinichi-kun what about you? Edit: I see you had already responded. Thanks Shini. These responses have me convinced my vote is in the right spot. I'm now putting SHini in my lower confidence town block. |
Mar 14, 2017 6:22 PM
#680
On a serious note we should drop this arguement because its pointless. We can see you as possible <<<Edited those 2 bolded word in > scum for your -ev mainly cause it can hurt town which is something scum would do, problem is we don't know if ur using the -ev mindset to help town or destroy town. |
Shinichi-KunMar 14, 2017 6:26 PM
Mar 14, 2017 6:51 PM
#681
Grapefruit21 said: @Suzunie-chan Cool, that's all I needed was a full you think it's a bad play not a sub optimal one. Not going any further with the debate just needed to know where you stood. @Shinichi-kun what about you? Edit: I see you had already responded. Thanks Shini. These responses have me convinced my vote is in the right spot. I'm now putting SHini in my lower confidence town block. so u think im scummy or u just dont believe im as townie as the rest |
Mar 14, 2017 6:59 PM
#682
Okay, we need to look towards the lynch tomorrow. Where does everyone stand? |
Where there is no imagination there is no horror. || Arthur Conan Doyle || Happy Halloween! |
Mar 14, 2017 7:04 PM
#683
@Shinichi-kun I think you're town, just not as confident as I am in the reads I had colored blue on my wall. You're in the green now. @Suzune-Chan If I can't get you lynched CorruptedPurity is a good place to look. |
Mar 14, 2017 7:06 PM
#684
Grapefruit21 said: Still would personally like Claire best.@Shinichi-kun I think you're town, just not as confident as I am in the reads I had colored blue on my wall. You're in the green now. @Suzune-Chan If I can't get you lynched CorruptedPurity is a good place to look. Vote: Claire Trust me. You cannot get my lynched. I have an ace in my sleeve. |
Where there is no imagination there is no horror. || Arthur Conan Doyle || Happy Halloween! |
Mar 14, 2017 7:21 PM
#685
Mar 14, 2017 7:22 PM
#686
Mar 14, 2017 7:24 PM
#687
Suzune-chan said: Grapefruit21 said: Still would personally like Claire best.@Shinichi-kun I think you're town, just not as confident as I am in the reads I had colored blue on my wall. You're in the green now. @Suzune-Chan If I can't get you lynched CorruptedPurity is a good place to look. Vote: Claire Trust me. You cannot get my lynched. I have an ace in my sleeve. Another softed claim isn't going to stop me given how many of those are floating around. Can you talk me through your Claire case? Do you not see CPurity as scum at all or just prefer Claire? |
Mar 14, 2017 7:26 PM
#688
Grapefruit21 said: Suzune-chan said: Grapefruit21 said: @Shinichi-kun I think you're town, just not as confident as I am in the reads I had colored blue on my wall. You're in the green now. @Suzune-Chan If I can't get you lynched CorruptedPurity is a good place to look. Vote: Claire Trust me. You cannot get my lynched. I have an ace in my sleeve. Another softed claim isn't going to stop me given how many of those are floating around. Can you talk me through your Claire case? Do you not see CPurity as scum at all or just prefer Claire? I've been super softing my claim all day. I just prefer Claire. Claire is my choice because she reflects comments that are suspicious against her onto others who might be guilty in order to make others guilty. I have suspected her since pretty early day one. |
Where there is no imagination there is no horror. || Arthur Conan Doyle || Happy Halloween! |
Mar 14, 2017 7:31 PM
#689
Suzune-chan said: Grapefruit21 said: Suzune-chan said: Grapefruit21 said: Still would personally like Claire best.@Shinichi-kun I think you're town, just not as confident as I am in the reads I had colored blue on my wall. You're in the green now. @Suzune-Chan If I can't get you lynched CorruptedPurity is a good place to look. Vote: Claire Trust me. You cannot get my lynched. I have an ace in my sleeve. Another softed claim isn't going to stop me given how many of those are floating around. Can you talk me through your Claire case? Do you not see CPurity as scum at all or just prefer Claire? I've been super softing my claim all day. I just prefer Claire. Claire is my choice because she reflects comments that are suspicious against her onto others who might be guilty in order to make others guilty. I have suspected her since pretty early day one. I'm torn on Claire. They know the best way to pocket me is to agree with me on theory. So I'm worried about that, but I haven't seen any of the red flags I saw when I reread LQ after the fact. I'll reread and get back to you. |
Mar 14, 2017 7:33 PM
#690
Grapefruit21 said: Claire tends to focus attention away from her. Notice when you reread how her posts are insert based and rely on everything around it instead of being new or telling.Suzune-chan said: Grapefruit21 said: Suzune-chan said: Grapefruit21 said: Still would personally like Claire best.@Shinichi-kun I think you're town, just not as confident as I am in the reads I had colored blue on my wall. You're in the green now. @Suzune-Chan If I can't get you lynched CorruptedPurity is a good place to look. Vote: Claire Trust me. You cannot get my lynched. I have an ace in my sleeve. Another softed claim isn't going to stop me given how many of those are floating around. Can you talk me through your Claire case? Do you not see CPurity as scum at all or just prefer Claire? I've been super softing my claim all day. I just prefer Claire. Claire is my choice because she reflects comments that are suspicious against her onto others who might be guilty in order to make others guilty. I have suspected her since pretty early day one. I'm torn on Claire. They know the best way to pocket me is to agree with me on theory. So I'm worried about that, but I haven't seen any of the red flags I saw when I reread LQ after the fact. I'll reread and get back to you. |
Where there is no imagination there is no horror. || Arthur Conan Doyle || Happy Halloween! |
Mar 14, 2017 8:41 PM
#691
grrr said: Sonata said: Yeah I dunno about this lynch tbh. Vote lynch: JustKrista (not sure if I did this already) It seems clear to me. I am not sure how to feel about this. I will leave you to @suzune. @grapefruit who would you kill tonight if you were mafia? @claire when krista shoot you tonight will you be salty? @Shinichikun: Generic question. Lol, If I get shot/lynched, I am going to laugh because I will flip towns and prove all these amusing "Claire is scum" wrong :> But please don't, my win-rate as town is really low lol. |
Mar 14, 2017 8:42 PM
#692
Sonata said: grrr said: Sonata said: Yeah I dunno about this lynch tbh. Vote lynch: JustKrista (not sure if I did this already) It seems clear to me. I am not sure how to feel about this. I will leave you to @suzune. @grapefruit who would you kill tonight if you were mafia? @claire when krista shoot you tonight will you be salty? @Shinichikun: Generic question. ??? Isn't it stupid? He claimed vig, but he refused to shoot to prove his alignment. He was not roleblocked either, despite there being two roleblockers that had the chance to RB him (and if a mafia was one of them, they totally would have, so he'd have to make explanations the next day), and you guys just drink it all up? I don't get it. We lost cop and doc already, I thought that'd be enough pressure to not trust empty words? We are running out of chances, you guys know that right? I wouldn't play recklessly by using my vigilante shot in Night 1, tbh. It has a high chance of hitting town. |
Mar 14, 2017 8:43 PM
#693
Shinichi-Kun said: _Claire_ said: Suzune-chan said: _Claire_ said: personally, I think you're abusing the idea that scum try to play townie. As you're using that for the entire crux of your argument.logic340 said: _Claire_ said: I've gotten a similar feeling and then grrr also came with that we got Gwendolly line as well. Seems like a very comfortable team and I cannot say they are an unaligned pair based on their interactions so far. They both are pushing Grapefruit for similar reasons though as you have stated why would scum!Grapefruit do that? It's weird to me because Suzune doesn't seem any different than the scum games I have seen her in and the fact that no one is concerned about a pocket there surprises and concerns me. What does your meta say? You played a game as scum with her recently?Suzune-chan said: Sure. Although I would think at this point it would be clear. You are a constant this game at stifling speculation. You are also trigger happy and push for kills that are not smart. Yesterday when the miller was revealed you acted like they were expendable and that the town should sacrifice them. Later, you also thought that the vigilante should just kill someone for information. THis suggests that you are driven to push for townie deaths without stopping to weigh the town. You are pitching things that endanger the number of townies. That is a mafia mindset. You are trying to be reasonable to make your opinion sound good. But in the end, it the arguments are anti-town. Let's think for a minute. What would have happened if the vigilante killed the miller. What would that yield the town? A dead townie? We would be in a worse position then the day before and it would have been self inflicted. You have to see from his POV that a miller claims can be a scum claim . You seem to believe Grrr is miller, 100% sure? From this post. That wasnt the first time I was scum with her, but I admit she was just playing way too townish when she was scum. Like, flawlessly you know? And no you arent overthinking it. The fact that she pushes grapefruit's read is alarming to me because she should have noticed too-- scums would play very carefully... I doubt grape is scum in this game. Um, sorry? I have played as scum too, and i know how scums would most likely think. It is not absolute yes, but you need to agree that most scums would play very townish, no? scum isnt a mindset tho, the player makes the mindset. Just cause you were scum doesnt mean you know how scum should act lol Does not mean its 100% incorrect. If you say this you need to admit that Suzune's saying "scums should have anti-town mindset" is wrong too because not all scums act the same. |
Mar 14, 2017 8:50 PM
#694
Suzune-chan said: Grapefruit21 said: Suzune-chan said: Grapefruit21 said: Still would personally like Claire best.@Shinichi-kun I think you're town, just not as confident as I am in the reads I had colored blue on my wall. You're in the green now. @Suzune-Chan If I can't get you lynched CorruptedPurity is a good place to look. Vote: Claire Trust me. You cannot get my lynched. I have an ace in my sleeve. Another softed claim isn't going to stop me given how many of those are floating around. Can you talk me through your Claire case? Do you not see CPurity as scum at all or just prefer Claire? I've been super softing my claim all day. I just prefer Claire. Claire is my choice because she reflects comments that are suspicious against her onto others who might be guilty in order to make others guilty. I have suspected her since pretty early day one. Aww Here comes the manipulation. What happen if I flip town then? What happen if I flip scum? :) |
Mar 14, 2017 9:14 PM
#695
Claire ISO #101 Literally your second post after game starts. You never explained your vote on Kit who had 2 votes on him. Literally hopped on a train with no explanation. #223 I asked you to get off the train 2 hours before phase ends. You left this messsage asking me who you should vote for even though you don't have a clear reason to vote for Kit You never came back after that. You had the option to get out of the Kit train 2 hours before phase was supposed to end. Instead you ask who else you should lynch and went off without another word #378 Either unaware that everyone most probably has a power role or trying to use power role as a defensive fallback. Anyone with a power role wouldn't want to draw attention to it. You're dangling your role as bait hoping others won't lynch you in case you flip power role. Not a town thing. #380 Attempt to deflect attention off you. Also, I did show you that what you said about me saying that people in Kit train was supposed to be less scummy than people who vote one person who only has that single vote was untrue. Literally fabricating stuff to misdirect attention. #381More misdirection towards Shinichi and others who suspect Grrr. In denial that people on the train should feel guilty as they are the prime suspects. #397 Thinks thats it is unreasonable that people who were on Kit's lynch trains are suspects. Said she wasn't online at the time when she was online and made a post 2 hours before planned phase change. #425 Starting to sound like a broken recorder here but you WERE online 2 HOURS before planned phase change. You had enough time to respond a post from me, that means you had enough time to change your vote before going MIA. Also, trying to redirect attention towards lamb and logic at the last part. #574,#576,#602 All of these are basically you beating around the bush and trying to defend grape because "scum would play more town and he's playing too anti-town" From Suzune to show what I mean #694 Trying again to misdirect the main topic of how she's acting scum by having questions that will scare town like "What happen if I flip town then?" Misdirection once again. |
Mar 14, 2017 9:16 PM
#696
Sorry that I'm late on my ISO, shit happened irl yesterday and I really had to clear it up. I'll try to be more active today. I'll also make a seperate post regarding my thoughts on the Suzu/Grape fiesta. And also Vote:Claire You really have no pro-town play so far. Also, ISOs on MAL is harder than I thought... Sorry if mine isn't as good as I planned it to be, it really is hard to ISO a person thru 14 pages on MAL. |
Mar 14, 2017 9:23 PM
#698
Also someone should look into interactions between Grape and Claire, both seem extremely scummy but the way they defend each other makes me think that they can't both be scum |
Mar 14, 2017 9:23 PM
#699
CorruptedPurity said: Sorry that I'm late on my ISO, shit happened irl yesterday and I really had to clear it up. I'll try to be more active today. I'll also make a seperate post regarding my thoughts on the Suzu/Grape fiesta. And also Vote:Claire You really have no pro-town play so far. Also, ISOs on MAL is harder than I thought... Sorry if mine isn't as good as I planned it to be, it really is hard to ISO a person thru 14 pages on MAL. It sucks right? Thanks for doing it I was just about to start my Claire one, saves me a lot effort |
Mar 14, 2017 9:27 PM
#700
Never say Suzune is scum. I am more convinced about CP, tbh. |
More topics from this board
» [GAME] (* ̄・ ̄)ノ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated Staff Member Posts! v4 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Togs - Jul 2, 2017 |
2866 |
by fausifahrial
»»
Nov 7, 2023 9:07 AM |
|
» [GAME] Last Letter Game ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )grave_robber - Sep 9, 2014 |
8750 |
by fausifahrial
»»
Nov 7, 2023 9:06 AM |
|
» Count To 7777 V3 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Lambtron - May 15, 2018 |
1159 |
by fausifahrial
»»
Nov 7, 2023 9:06 AM |
|
» [GAME] Say something about the person above you ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Haine - Jul 19, 2014 |
3810 |
by Zymf
»»
Jun 19, 2023 2:43 PM |
|
» [GAME] Truth or dare (ToD) 2.0 [Round 5] ( 1 2 )Lambtron - Mar 12, 2019 |
92 |
by Zymf
»»
Jun 18, 2023 12:09 PM |