| Next time please report the 10K topic and a moderator will remake it. Feel free to discuss anything relating to Battle Shounen Anime or Manga in this thread. Discussion will occasionally waver towards other aspects of the Shounen demographic, this is not to be frowned upon. Just no Shoujo regardless of how superior it may be. This thread will be officially recognized as the "General Battle Shounen" thread from now on. Any new topics about the subject will be linked/redirected here. Please refrain from trolling, insulting other users and/or spamming. Make sure to use spoiler tags when necessary Please refrain from posting "x > y", "x vs. y", and the like of raw discussion in this thread. They are denoted as spam, as stated above. I really can't stress this one enough, but please refrain from any discussion about a single episode of Anime or chapter of Manga. A note about what is going on in the series (new plot twists, characters, fights) is fine but if it only applies to the most recent chapter (especially if it is spoiler heavy), just discuss it the respective Manga board. Try to keep the fighting to a minimum, you can't prove something's worth by belittling another. This is the v2 version of this thread. ----------------- Mod Edit: Any further comments saying to ignore a user for whatever reason will warrant warnings and or bans. If you think they're trolling report it. Repeatedly telling X user to be ignored will be considered harassment. |
TyrelNov 26, 2014 12:22 AM
[i][b]I'am the Mayor of under development residential called MAL Backstreet Residential. [/i][/b]Now what are you waiting for?! Come join us at MAL Backstreet Residential!! |
| There's another battle shonen thread already made but this one got the title correct. |
 |
| Naruto is still over Strawhats have been in Dressrosa for almost 2 years (?) Nobody has any emotional investment in Bleach or Fairy Tail at this point KHR is kill HxH is still on hiatus Welcome to V.2, Shonenbros |
| This one got the title correct and the mod's blessing. I'll be posting in this one unless a mod closes it. |
     Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
Kaimon said: I do.Nobody has any emotional investment in Bleach at this point |
 |
| Ah Bleach, remembering those good ol times when Kubo is still trying to make it good. Kaimon said: Naruto is still over and this, "still" over? implying there will be a sequel to Naruto? all I heard was a little spinoff about Bolt next year. |
BangToyibNov 23, 2014 12:25 PM
[i][b]I'am the Mayor of under development residential called MAL Backstreet Residential. [/i][/b]Now what are you waiting for?! Come join us at MAL Backstreet Residential!! |
| congrats on new thread, also first page! LucasRTS said: DrGeroCreation said: I do. Also me too. I still hope it'll get another anime adaption though. |
 |
| V2? I think Bleach can redeem itself if it started over from episode 1 |
 |
| So how do you folks feel about Boku no Hero Academia so far? |
FragOutFire said: Why am I a Berserk fan? All I ever experience is pain. We are in the eclipse and Miura has sacrificed us |
JumpinJackCrash said: It was closed. This is the one we use from now on.So this is the "official" battle shonen v2 thread, eh? Wonder what'll happen to the other one made by Mikasa. |
Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
| We needed this. That old thread would take one minute to load. |
| can a mod edit in what a battle shounen is? I'm tired of explaining to morons that F/SN and Avatar aren't battle shounens |
JumpinJackCrash said: So this is the "official" battle shonen v2 thread, eh? Wonder what'll happen to the other one made by Mikasa. We're working on having "big 3" removed from the title due to redundancy, an include other genres. |
| End Zionazism |
JD2411 said: can a mod edit in what a battle shounen is? I'm tired of explaining to morons that F/SN and Avatar aren't battle shounens This is new to me, Never heard someone mention about F/SN and Avatar is a battle shounen. |
|
LucasRTS said: it happened a few times in the last thread and it derailed the threadtr1ckst3r said: This is new to me, Never heard someone mention about F/SN and Avatar is a battle shounen. |
| Just because they are mods doesn't mean their definition is accurate you know. Also Avatar seems like a battle shonen so far. |
| End Zionazism |
JD2411 said: LucasRTS said: it happened a few times in the last thread and it derailed the threadBut it sucks, we are too restricted in these forums. |
 |
Mikasa said: I know but we need some kind of rule to stop morons discussing anythingJust because they are mods doesn't mean their definition is accurate you know. people will use the fact that a series had some obscure spin-off manga published in a shounen magazine as an excuse to discuss that show here |
| That won't stop them. Majority rules. If some moron thinks a show is just a shonen based off the magazine without using logic, then there is no stopping him. And since many people believe that already (because intelligence doesn't go well with quantity of people who possess it), even more people will continue to. |
| End Zionazism |
| Well, No need to make things even more complicated than it is. Basically, Shounen IS not a genre, it is a demographic (target audience). Anything that published in Shounen Magazine is a Shounen Manga. Any adaptation of a Shounen Manga is called Shounen Anime. Content is irrelevant to determine whether a series is a Shounen or Seinen, the publisher/adaptation is what count. I know there's a lot of debate about "content is irrelevant to determine Shounen and Seinen" BUT let's just stick with this to make things easier and refrain from pointless debate about "a series is not a shounen because it is darker". |
[i][b]I'am the Mayor of under development residential called MAL Backstreet Residential. [/i][/b]Now what are you waiting for?! Come join us at MAL Backstreet Residential!! |
| Dafuq happened to the Old One Mikasa said: If some moron thinks a show is just a shonen based off the magazine without using logic, then there is no stopping him. To be more Precise,It's based off of the Target audience......Which can is reflected by the magazine it's published in JD2411 said: I'm tired of explaining to morons that F/SN and Avatar aren't battle shounens Dafuq??? |
 |
Hand_of_the_King said: Threads get a new version once they reach post 10,000.Dafuq happened to the Old One |
Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
| What seems to be too complicated for you is common sense. Your claim in itself makes no sense and you did nothing to back it up. Seinen is a demographic? A- Berserk B- K-on Completely different content Your argument: well people of the same demographic might have different tastes, some may like mature content, some like childish content. - But that renders the idea of demographic absolutely pointless. If it's supposed to refer people to a shows of certain content, then it should have consistent aspects to identify with. If some 18+ year old likes less than 18 year old content, he should watch shonen, not label the stuff he watches "seinen that is more like shonen but we'll call it seinen because some 18+ year old watches it". Fact: Mature content differs greatly in the same demographic, so much so, that a seinen may seem more childish than the average shonen, and a certain shonen may have more adult content parallel to that of the average seinen. Conclusion, as demographics these words do little to distinguish anime and are useless. In fact, you all agree with this view subconsiously whether you admit it or not. You all ask for "shonen similar to one piece" because of "action/certain event/type of character", and not "I need anoter under18 shonen anime" |
| End Zionazism |
| ^ yeah pretty much this If you would look at the demographic than even One Piece could be called a Seinen since supposedly around 88% of the fanabase of One Piece in Japan is 18+ |
 |
| Geez, Pseudo-Intelectual people these days... I try to make thing easier and he gone to make things even more complicated. |
[i][b]I'am the Mayor of under development residential called MAL Backstreet Residential. [/i][/b]Now what are you waiting for?! Come join us at MAL Backstreet Residential!! |
BangToyib said: Geez, Pseudo-Intelectual people these days... I try to make thing easier and he gone to make things even more complicated. Things get real on the "Big 3" threads. |
| A great protagonist once said, "It's only overpowered if you can't return the favor!" |
| No dude, you're trying to make it dumber. TheNextChamp said: ^ yeah pretty much this If you would look at the demographic than even One Piece could be called a Seinen since supposedly around 88% of the fanabase of One Piece in Japan is 18+ Anyone can claim a seinen is shonen provided they watched it pre-18 or think it doesn't seem mature enough for them. Ans vice-versa. We're gonna go two versions of this thread and people like these will never provide any logical reasoning against this, only stubborness. |
| End Zionazism |
| K-ON > Berserk in maturity. |
BahamutPriest said: This ain't a seinen thread, if you want to talk about seinen shows, make your own thread.K-ON > Berserk in maturity. |
 |
7starkiller99 said: You wut..Milk_is_Special said: This ain't a seinen thread, if you want to talk about seinen shows, make your own thread. Lol! |
|
BahamutPriest said: K-ON > Berserk in maturity. Yes, of course. |
|
clare77 said: Mikasa said: Anyone can claim a seinen is shonen provided they watched it pre-18 or think it doesn't seem mature enough for them. And vice-versa. So Basically,what you've been doing Everyone agrees about claiming? |
| A great protagonist once said, "It's only overpowered if you can't return the favor!" |
| He did exactly say this BangToyib said: BUT let's just stick with this to make things easier and refrain from pointless debate about "a series is not a shounen because it is darker". And it's already happen, the long awaited pointless debate! |
|
tr1ckst3r said: He did exactly say this BangToyib said: BUT let's just stick with this to make things easier and refrain from pointless debate about "a series is not a shounen because it is darker". And it's already happen, the long awaited pointless debate! Because Darker than Black has its own genre :D |
| A great protagonist once said, "It's only overpowered if you can't return the favor!" |
clare77 said: Mikasa said: Anyone can claim a seinen is shonen provided they watched it pre-18 or think it doesn't seem mature enough for them. And vice-versa. So Basically,what you've been doing How can I do that when m argument is "shonen is not a demographic/it's dumb to consider it so)? I simply said calling x show shonen (as a genre) is dumb due to it being illogical, and the demographic thing being dumb altogether. |
| End Zionazism |
robis798 said: BahamutPriest said: K-ON > Berserk in maturity. Yes, of course. Puck and that kid swordsman are more childish than anything in K-On. |
clare77 said: Mikasa said: How can I do that when m argument is "shonen is not a demographic/it's dumb to consider it so)? I simply said calling x show shonen (as a genre) is dumb due to it being illogical, and the demographic thing being dumb altogether. Yeah,But it started out as you pretty much waking up one day and claiming HxH is'nt a shonen Or if I remember correctly it was something along the lines of "I do'nt watch shonen and my favourite anime are'nt shonen" (I do'nt remember,but it was something like that) Yes that's what I referred to in my second line. HxH is indeed not a shonen, as characteristics of the shonen genre do not apply to it, and hxh includes genres beyond those which are within the shonen spectrum. We've been over this. As predetermined demographics, shonen and seinen hold no value to begin with. |
| End Zionazism |
clare77 said: Mikasa said: Yes that's what I referred to in my second line. HxH is indeed not a shonen, as characteristics of the shonen genre do not apply to it, and hxh includes genres beyond those which are within the shonen spectrum. We've been over this. As predetermined demographics, shonen and seinen hold no value to begin with. Sure.....If you say so Last thing I need is another one of those dumb arguments that basically comes down to "It is,cuz I said so" You have provided no counterargument, and everyone who disagrees with this view seems to go "because I said so" and that's the last thing you need? It's the first thing you say. Please, use "it". |
| End Zionazism |
? Thread officially derailed people. Let's go back to the big three xD |
| A great protagonist once said, "It's only overpowered if you can't return the favor!" |
| Let's talk about...Yugioh: Duel Monsters! What do you think about this anime? Favorite Arcs, Characters, Duels? Me: 1) Millenium World 2) Battle City 3) Waking the Dragons 4) Kaiba Corp GP 5) Duelist Kingdom 6) Dungeon Dice Monsters 7) Noah's Virtual World 8) Legendary Heroes |
More topics from this board
» My thoughts on the aftermath of Kyoto Animation's arson attackTechnoMellow724 - Today |
9 |
by Twintail_Daemon
»»
1 minute ago |
|
» Are we going through a Yuri Renaissance? ( 1 2 )Dragevard - Yesterday |
57 |
by Yuu_Kanzaki
»»
9 minutes ago |
|
» Is it bad to raw-dog seasonals?thewiru - 3 hours ago |
20 |
by Yuu_Kanzaki
»»
12 minutes ago |
|
» Anime characters that used to be older than you, now you're older than themComeInReiAsuka - Yesterday |
19 |
by powermaiden02
»»
18 minutes ago |
|
» Waifu War V5 (Anniversary-Edition!) (Round 1) ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Minkalex - Sep 28 |
380 |
by RaiYou
»»
23 minutes ago |