Kimi no Iru Machi Chapter 256 Discussion

Spider-titan55 said:
i pty haruto as well inclduing how everyone treated him. but haruto did hurt everyone before dating asuka. he threw his entire life away and his friends didn't really agree to his decisions.

jose21 said:
If Asuka gets hurt again, it will be only her fault. She should know better by know that Haruto doesn't love her as much as Yuzuki. Plus, I do hope she has some self respect and doesn't start dating the same guy who left her for other girl. Also, it should be pretty clear to her that the reason Haruto broke up with Yuzuki this time isn't because he doesn't love her anymore, and as soon as they can be together again there is a high probability they will be.
Anyway, I doubt Asuka will appear again, is more likely that the one that will show up on the following chapters will be Rin. Besides, how the hell will she know that they brake up (Unless she is stalking haruto).

Spider-titan55 said:


how do you suppose the aftermath of the breakup will then?

Sugram22 said:


Should he listen to friends & be miserable his hole life? maybe he would have married some1 else & Yuzu to after Kaza death, hell maybe she would have even married Kaza to make hes final day's happy & later remarried to some1 else, then Haru & Yuzu meet again bi coincidence, they both may have kids, but when they see each other old feelings surfaces & they start to cheat, Haru hes wife & Yuzu hes husband (that what people would do if old flame surfaces, they ton't know how to handle the situation, they what to be together, but then they ask how, they wont find answer & that confusion makes them cheat, it happens in real life to sometimes, but that way is just rare, i meant that part that past lover's meet again & old flame surfaces), would that out come have been better in ur opinion? cause if u love like they love each other, this feeling never goes away, only if 1 of them dies then other1 can move on somehow, maybe, if u have seen romance anime's before u should know that, only thing that would have made it better, if both of them talk things trough before deciding, then maybe Haru would have told Yuzu ton't do it, neither u or Kaza will be happy if u do it out of pity & so on & on, that's their problem, they decide themselves with out talking to other side

Spider-titan55 said:


how do you suppose the aftermath of the breakup will then?

Spider-titan55 said:


you do have a point. but, it was still painful to see that happen to haruto the first time and painful the second time. i can't imagine the scolding he's gonna get the third time. plus, haruto did make those actions to begin with that rifled up his friends and parents. i mean if you think the shit he recieved in the before and after the tokyo arc was painful, then i have no idea how bad he'll recieve in the real world arc.

Sugram22 said:


we just half to W8 & see :D
we can come out with theory's our hole life & not get the right1 :D, so pointless to speculate & come out with theory's :)

Hole life part is figure of speech :)

Spider-titan55 said:


speaking of half, you think shinichi from half and half will be yuzuki's boyfriend?

jose21 said:


I don't understand what you mean. I already mention on this same discussion on previous pages what I think could happen. But in summary:
Either Yuzuki was trying to say she was pregnant or quit her job.
Rin would yell at Haruto for hurting Yuzuki, and she already warned him on the chapter Yuzuki fainted.
How Rin will find out they brake up, easy she lives with Yuzuki, even if Yuzuki doesn't tell her, she should be able to notice something and call haruto to find out what is going on.

Also, I haven't mention it before, but what if Seo decides to go for something cheesy and makes Haruto leave in the middle of the meeting he was preparing for, just to go back to Yuzuki and say sorry. Yuzuki x Haruto has been always the main couple, and IMO is a bit too late for Seo to change the ending couple, plus I don't think it is his style.

Pure Speculation, I am not saying that will happen
Just like Sugram said, is better to wait and see what happens.

jose21 said:


LOL, You are kidding, right?

Sugram22 said:


true, lets just hope Rin beats some sense in to him if words are not enough, but knowing Rini :D, her tongue is sharp at times LOL, if she say's something to him i bet it will be like slap at the face with full force :D

Spider-titan55 said:

no, i'm not kidding. yuuki has only less than 3 days to live and a few casts from suzuka cameoed in KNIM. so i suppose shinichi will make a full appearance and telling haruto about love and loss and someday that fate will come to home or something like that. if he goes back to yuzuki, he'll feel even more dead inside(no pun intended)

jose21 said:


If it is just to give advice to Haruto, them it might be alright, but as Yuzuki's new boyfriend not really. That will ruin both mangas (especially Half & Half). Plus, it will be a huge spoiler. I mean, sure, from the one shot, most people is expecting the girl to die, but the serialisation is still going on and he may still give a different ending. Also, Suzuka was already finished when they cameoed in KNIM.

Spider-titan55 said:


i know suzuka ended along time ago but knwing seo and the successfulness that half and half is getting, i expected shincihi making a cameo. hell, i just hope that we'll be getting more of half and half already

jose21 said:


I mean, your idea of him "telling haruto about love and loss... " sounds pretty cool, and I would actually like to see something like that, but like I said before it will be a huge spoiler telling the half & half readers that the girl died on the serialization too. Unless, it happens just before she dies, on one of the days they have left.

Spider-titan55 said:

hell, maybe asuka will be shinichi's girlfriend.

Spider-titan55 said:

also, it wouldn't be great for shincihi to give advice to haruto before he and yuuki joined together since shinichi is experiencing how it feels like to lose someone you love deeply and movie on or be a man and go back with her.

jose21 said:


yeah, Asuka x Sinichi why not, I'll buy that. Personally, I would prefer Rin X Sinichi.



Why not Yuuki and Shinichi talk to Haruto together just before their time run out, telling him how they feel knowing they will be separated pretty soon.

I don't read girls of the wild, so I have no idea what to tell you.

Spider-titan55 said:


LOL. hell if seo fucks over rin then fuck him. and speaking of rin and fuck, what ever happened to that lesbian. more importantly, where's that job hunting girl? what the hell are they gonna do with them. you think seo is planning to develop asuka into a bi-curious woman since she's one of the main characters or something?

Sugram22 said:


when a say'd lets just hope Rin beats some sense in to him if words are not enough, i mean that she makes Haru & Yuzu make Up

about the others, good question, maybe they are W8 for their turn (at least 1 of them), that they will be in same position Asuka was, date him & then get dumped bi him for Yuzu, history repeats, But with different girl, lets hope Seo wont Troll us that way :D

Spider-titan55 said:


no, i'm not kidding. yuuki has only less than 3 days to live and a few casts from suzuka cameoed in KNIM. so i suppose shinichi will make a full appearance and telling haruto about love and loss and someday that fate will come to home or something like that. if he goes back to yuzuki, he'll feel even more dead inside(no pun intended)

Sugram22 said:


when a say'd lets just hope Rin beats some sense in to him if words are not enough, i mean that she makes Haru & Yuzu make Up

about the others, good question, maybe they are W8 for their turn (at least 1 of them), that they will be in same position Asuka was, date him & then get dumped bi him for Yuzu, history repeats, But with different girl, lets hope Seo wont Troll us that way :D

Spider-titan55 said:


Also, if Seo uses that red headed lesbian, you think he might be gutsy enough to make asuka bi curious?

Benphyre said:


Don't think it will get that confusing lol >.<

Spider-titan55 said:
You think yuzuki will die by the same illness as her mother

Sugram22 said:


no i meant, same position Asuka was, was Asuka dumped cause of that? cause some1 was ill?, no!!!, Asuka was dumped cause Haru met Yuzu again after some years past & realized he still loves her + Rin messed with them & pushed them to each others arms, so same happens to 1 of them, Yuzu & Haru broke up 1 of them starts dating him & later some years past & he meets Yuzu again & same thing happens again, but with different girl not Asuka

but its possible that she dose have that same illness & dies in future, that no meant that i ton't mean it happens with them, that if Haru starts something with 1 of them Yuzu gets sick at that point & he dumps hes GF to be with Yuzu, i meant that i ton't think this scenario will be like that :), but who knows, if Seo wants to Troll us more then maybe he dose, but what i mentioned above, even that would be enough to Troll us, i that happens to 1 of them with Haru what happened to Asuka

Spider-titan55 said:


i meant that if yuzuki is ill like her mother asuka might have a shot but in realistically i know she won't be much of a bitch to go back to haruto but i think haruto might make a move on her out of pity. but if yuzuki does die, who does haruto end up with anyway?

Sugram22 said:


Asuka Rin Akari or that girl who Haru saved, when she was about to give her body to get a job, or 1 of the others, they seem to like him to :D, Akira gets divorced Cause she also like Haru, this are the possibility's, i would give my vote to Asuka Rin & Akira cause they are closest to Haru, bi vote i mean that i believe that 1 of them is gonna do it if Yuzu dose die (what i doubt), & others have less chance with him then this 3, i forgot Nanami, maybe she will be the 4th of them

Spider-titan55 said:


I agree with you on Akari. I mean this is the same woman who kissed him in chapters 79 and 80 and almost gave her body to him in chapter 219. He'll, maybe she'll take her kids with her too and lie to haruto that narumi is a cheating scumbag.

It's been three years since her met that job hunting girl and I felt that she never existed chapters later. If Seo makes her yuzuki's replacement then I'll give him credit because their interactions with each other are spot on.

I hope he ends up with asuka because I really love their scenes together how their personalities click. Reminds me of how I feel about Peter Parker and Mary Jane Watson. Hell, in chapter 250 haruto turned his eyes around when he was about to answer to her if she would still choose her over yuzuki really, I'll be honest that despite yuzuki and haruto having their great moments together, their relationship never clicked for me. Do you feel the same?

Rin? Maybe a pity sex or a pity French kiss but not entirely a going out kind of deal.

I believe you about nanami considering how her personality is. Boy, she's gonna break that kid's heart.

Speaking of which, is since characters from Suzuka made a few cameo, I was thinking that shinichi and yuuki from half and half should make a guest appearance before one of their last days together to develop haruto to either go back to yuzuki or go back to the person we just listed(mostly asuka) if yuzuki is going to die or almost die.

Also ever read girls of the wilds and nozoki Ana?

Sugram22 said:


at that time when it came out why Yuzu dumped Haru i was against her, new seeing how deep their love is i support their relationship & want them to make up

Well Rin as we see her is a Mask, i have not seen real her, but i noticed the Mask on her, she pretends, if she dose not, she would trow herself on Haru & also be totally different person, a more likable char then she is, well i like her, her supporter side currently, she pushed them back together before Haru dumped Asuka

this are possibility's if Yuzu dies, Yuzu's death is possible, But i doubt that she will, most readers would crucify Seo alive if he dose that :D

Sugram22 said:
@Spider-titan55

they may not seem right cause anime over exaggerates with some stuff (its anime logic :D)

True, i think that as well, that u get flamed for this LOL

Spider-titan55 said:

yeah, i know alot of yuzuki fans will get angry at me for this but i don't care. i honestly just want haruto and yuzuki to break up and i finally got my wish even though it was done horribly i can imagine yuzuki haters want it to be done with but we all know that haruto will end up with maybe asuka or possibly akari if she's bitchy enough to dummp narumi(i don't think i ever liked him though) to be with haruto. hell, if that glasses girl is gonna be haruto's new girlfriend then go for it. i may be upset that haruto won't share the same length with asuka when he was with eba but i just hope i'll enjoy it if he does end up with asuka for 2 or 3 more years when seo decides to put yuzuki in america like any other anime characters ever would and haruo will dump asula yet again to go to amaerica. wash, rince, and repeat. hell, why not leave asuka at the alter? why not let her end up with that red headed lesbo we haven't seen since issue 209 or 210 or some shit since that's her reason for being here, just to make asuka bi-curious.

god, i feel like a dick for writing this but i hope haruto ends up with asuka for 2 and a half years and yuzuki just leaves us alone. i'm getting real tired of her. btw, how long has haruto been with yuzuki for?

jose21 said:


FIrst, I just want to clarify, I am not really a Yuzuki fan, but WTF she has always been the main chick, almost 70 percent of the manga is about them and honestly, them not ending together would make most of those chapters a complete waste of time.
In a perfect world Yuzuki would have died around chapter 220, right before Akari ask haruto to sleep with her, that way Haruto would have been able to fight for Akari and we would have had an Akari ending (Right now I couldn't care less for Akari).
Asuka going back to haruto, well, I had always been indeferent towards her, and if she does she'll serioulsy will become annoying, specially if she is the one going after him once again. IMO she is almost at the same level of Kazama. I got it, she truly likes Haruto, but he never has, and the only reason they end up together is cause, not as bad as how kazama did it, she sort of blackmail him into dating her by telling him to either be her boyfriend or not be friends anymore. (BTW, they have already been together for about two years, right before Haruto left her, so I doubt them spending other two years would make any difference.)

jose21 said:
@Spider-titan55

I forgot to say that Yuzuki going to America, that will be so stupid. If she can go to america, don't you think she can't easily just quit her job and go with Haruto. The reason she can't leave Tokyo is cause she is teaching in her alma mater, unless her school has a branch in the US. Also, wouldn't it be easier to get a job as a teacher in the same place as Haruto rather than in America.

Spider-titan55 said:

god, i feel like a dick for writing this but i hope haruto ends up with asuka for 2 and a half years and yuzuki just leaves us alone. i'm getting real tired of her. btw, how long has haruto been with yuzuki for?

Spider-titan55 said:

yeah, sure haruto should end up with akari after yuzuki dies. but, if she slept with him before akari's wedding it would kinda make her a bitch and if she dumped narumi because of haruto and left her kids back at hiroshima then FUUUUUUCK HER! and not in a have sex with her way.

Spider-titan55 said:
asuka blackmailed haruto? when did that happen? what chapter did she say that?

Benphyre said:


No, I don't think you're wrong. Everyone has their own version of a perfect ending in their mind. After all that desire is what keeps you reading the manga.

Although I personally don't see a possibility of another Haruto x Asuka love saga. It will just boil down to another one sided love. Chapter 250 tells us why.

Spider-titan55 said:

i meant i'm a dick for writing things like asuka the lesbo and other stuff before calling myself a dick. but hey, if that lesbo existed for a reason then i think it's going to be asuka considering the number of dramas i've seen and how people are in relationship.

Spider-titan55 said:

well there's no telling if asuka goes back with haruto or haruto goes with that job hunting girl

Benphyre said:


Um... if I really have to choose I would say job hunting girl. At the very least it gives Seo more stuff to write about rather than going to repetitive route for Asuka.

Benphyre said:


Um... if I really have to choose I would say job hunting girl. At the very least it gives Seo more stuff to write about rather than going to repetitive route for Asuka.

Spider-titan55 said:


If haruto broke up with that glasses girl and yuzuki died of the same illness as her mother, what do you suppose might happen to haruto?

Benphyre said:


I highly doubt Yuzuki will be plague by illness. Same thing.. it will be another repetitive plot. If she really does then there is really no point continue reading the manga, since we can all guess how to story will end.

Haruto x job hunt girl... well... i guess it will be okay to see them together but it will probably be like a few good chapters then back to stagnant plot again. (The usual couple daily life like what Haru x Yuzu been doing). At the current point of the story line, I feel there is really no point for either of them to get into a new relationship. The manga really should have an ending soon.

Hell, we might never know.. there might even be a time skip/flash backs/side story before we get back to the main plot.

Ultimately, the plot will still go back to Haruto x Yuzuki. They are the MC of the series after all.

Spider-titan55 said:

I still enjoy the whole asuka and haruto relationship based on their interactions and their dialect. I wonder how it would be like if their relationship continued if haruto is strong enough to be with asuka.

Spider-titan55 said:

Now where was I? Oh right, this manga is fucking stupid. Why could they just call it "The boy from Hiroshima", or "the boy from the village" or something(anything good title replacements because I can't think of any title that capitalizes haruto) since haruto and yuzuki had done do much damage to each other and broke up over and over again while having many girls fall head over heels for him. Why not have it like anagami ss where the main character end up with different girls?

jose21 said:


Too be honest, I don't want more Asuka since she kind of reminds me of Suzuka, and I didn't really like Suzuka that much.
On the other hand, instead of some Amagami SS plot, I would rather see a spin off of Haruto and Akari's childhood.

Spider-titan55 said:


You mean replace yuzuki with Akari and make them start off as friends and continue to expand thrir friendship in an organic matter and develop Askari's feelings toward haruto into a more realistic way instead of out of nowhere and years later they expand their lives together to relate more to the readers? Sure I'd go for it. It's also ironic since Akari's fantasy chapter is revealed as them being happily married and from the looks of it, we're gonna enjoy this more than the past fantasy chapters.

Benphyre said:


A town where you live.

Well, that is where the plot of the series begins. The place where Haru met Yuzu, where the cliques grew up at and where memories were made.

Even though ever since they moved to Tokyo the plot kinda drifted away from Hiroshima. Sometimes I wonder if Kimi no Iru Machi wasn't the title of the series, Seo probably wouldn't even make them visit Hiroshima yearly lmao.

Not a biggie though, Seo can always end the series with the final plot at Hiroshima which would make sense too. End it where it all started. :3