Shingeki no Kyojin Episode 25 Discussion

Offline

Apr 2009

2596

Darklight0303 said:

Amarrez said:

Daw11 said:
Season 2 needs to start with a remake of this episode.

Season 2 doesn't need to start at all. What we need is SnK: Titanhood.

So just cause of one episode they should remake the whole first season. >_> That's being unreasonable and you know it.

They're going to need to retcon about half of this episode to do a second season.

Also, wasn't the whole point of Levi's character in these chapters the fact that even though he wants to, he can't avenge his comrades due to his injury? Lol, no, let's just have him be the Deus Ex Manlet and save the day. Fujoshit pandering if I've ever seen it.

Sep 28, 2013 11:00 AM

#54

mixordia

Offline

Jan 2009

150

Anyone who thinks at least, know that they would change something. I expected more from the last episode, but everyone expected more, think well, this anime was great, I honestly don't know what I expected... but I expected some thing... I think this is the problem, this anime was so good, we expected something even better... but whatever... I want a second season.

10/10 I will not change anything only because this episode. The entire anime compared to other animes I have seen lately, was much better.

Now I continue reading the manga. I'm waiting for chapter 50... I can't wait for read this :)

english isn't my native language... ;)

Sep 28, 2013 11:00 AM

#55

Darklight0303

Offline

Apr 2008

11325

Amarrez said:
Snip

Then why make Titanhood when only one episode needs to be fixed? >_>

Sep 28, 2013 11:01 AM

#56

surywatsuki

Offline

Jan 2013

24

7/10, subpar adaption
Too many (bad) fillers, horrible pacing, disappointing production values. I know WIT had several problems, especially time issues, but this doesn’t make things better.

Sep 28, 2013 11:07 AM

#57

Offline

Jul 2013

1554

Erhm.... well.... at least Eren didn't breath fire or throw fireballs? So I guess it's ok.

I shall be a bitch and watch this episode latah, when the subs are out.

Until then, peace fellas.

#CheapLife

Sep 28, 2013 11:07 AM

#58

Offline

Apr 2009

2596

Darklight0303 said:

Amarrez said:
Snip

Then why make Titanhood when only one episode needs to be fixed? >_>

Any excuse to get Araki's ass off the staff.

Sep 28, 2013 11:08 AM

#59

LeElPsy89

Offline

Aug 2013

14

Sourire said:

LeElPsy89 said:
Avarage anime, final episode gets 5/10, complete anime gets 6/10. thanks for nothing WIT. :>

And you rated game neptune a 8/10 lololol

Tastes differ, right? ;-)

Sep 28, 2013 11:09 AM

#60

Offline

Sep 2012

378

-Levi was supposed to be injured
-Eren's supposed to be able to control his titan form, but they made his reaction last week that way to foreshadow the fire titan thing.
-The wall titan is supposed to appear right away.

That's the main problematic things here. Accidentally voted 5/5, but 3/5 for this episode, if you look at it on it's own, it was a cool and brutal fight and they did not miss any of the key points, but still some Magi ending crap here.

btw. All anime-onlies, go read the manga. The adaption was pretty much 90% faithful overall, but there's some aspects to some characters the anime's missing, I'd probably give the series as a whole about a 8/10, though. When it shined, it really did.

Just gonna wait for subs now.

PipokoSep 28, 2013 11:20 AM

Sep 28, 2013 11:10 AM

#61

LivingANightmare

Offline

Jul 2013

838

Rating 5/5 by default. Can't wait to watch later on.

Sep 28, 2013 11:11 AM

#62

dany_elle1908

Offline

Aug 2008

788

Surysasuri said:
7/10, subpar adaption
Too many (bad) fillers, horrible pacing, disappointing production values. I know WIT had several problems, especially time issues, but this doesn’t make things better.

if u think was all that bad
watch naruto
maybe u'll change your mind
being myself a manga reader i enjoyed the episode even with the few changes

The spider is watching

Sep 28, 2013 11:12 AM

#63

Yuushin7

Offline

Dec 2009

110

My God! Some things people bitch and complain about and reasonings it's just....Sad....So sad *agonizing facepalm*

It's not that Eren can't control his Titan form. He can't control himslef. I'm sure you people noticed by now, and those who read manga that Eren might not be quite right in the head. When he's consumed with rage, there's no stopping him. That guy has some legit psycho problems xD
He can control his titan form in a sense that he'a able to stay conscious while transformed. Unlike the first time he transformed on his own ( to fix breach in the wall) where he was basically asleep.

Sep 28, 2013 11:14 AM

#64

Offline

Apr 2009

2596

Yuushin7 said:
My God! Some things people bitch and complain about and reasonings it's just....Sad....So sad *agonizing facepalm*

It's not that Eren can't control his Titan form. He can't control himslef. I'm sure you people noticed by now, and those who read manga that Eren might not be quite right in the head. When he's consumed with rage, there's no stopping him.

But in the manga he did control himself during this fight, it was a major turning point for his character. That was the whole god damn point.

However, clearly Eren's character boils down to "HURR MAD AS HELL".

Sep 28, 2013 11:16 AM

#65

Offline

Jul 2013

1554

Amarrez said:

Yuushin7 said:
My God! Some things people bitch and complain about and reasonings it's just....Sad....So sad *agonizing facepalm*

It's not that Eren can't control his Titan form. He can't control himslef. I'm sure you people noticed by now, and those who read manga that Eren might not be quite right in the head. When he's consumed with rage, there's no stopping him.

But in the manga he did control himself during this fight, it was a major turning point for his character. That was the whole god damn point.

However, clearly Eren's character boils down to "HURR MAD AS HELL".

Let's hope that S2 or Attack: Titanhood will not bust that scene when

Sep 28, 2013 11:17 AM

#66

Falcomster

Offline

Aug 2011

2514

Needs mawr Bert

Sep 28, 2013 11:17 AM

#67

Offline

Jul 2013

1554

NihonFalcom said:
Needs mawr Bert

Season 2 mate....

Or as some people call it...

Attack: Titanhood

Sep 28, 2013 11:20 AM

#68

Narutotaku

Offline

Jul 2013

120

if they did what people say WIT did, then it's sad. Just go with the manga ffs why cant all anime adaptations just follow he fucking manga damnit.

Sep 28, 2013 11:20 AM

#69

stAtic91

Offline

May 2009

3818

Should've at least had Erwin or someone else cut Eren out of the titan instead of Levi since he's supposed to be hurt.

Sep 28, 2013 11:22 AM

#70

Shuryou55

Offline

Sep 2013

14

Yuushin7 said:
My God! Some things people bitch and complain about and reasonings it's just....Sad....So sad *agonizing facepalm*

It's not that Eren can't control his Titan form. He can't control himslef. I'm sure you people noticed by now, and those who read manga that Eren might not be quite right in the head. When he's consumed with rage, there's no stopping him. That guy has some legit psycho problems xD
He can control his titan form in a sense that he'a able to stay conscious while transformed. Unlike the first time he transformed on his own ( to fix breach in the wall) where he was basically asleep.

Not quite right, its been shown that the Titan "takes over" Eren. In the manga, when he fought with Annie and said he would "devour" her, there are two panels that show Eren in the Titan. After he said he'd "devour her," you can see that the Titan consumed more of his face. A similar sort of thing happened in Trost. When the Titan takes over the Titan-Shifter, it turns into a monster.

Eren was supposed to control his Titan in this episode, and his rage in the last. But the anime hasn't been very generous when it comes to developing Eren's character as opposed to the manga. I guess this way it's more epic? Hopefully season 2 will develop him better.

Sep 28, 2013 11:24 AM

#71

Alzea

Offline

Dec 2007

436

Okay, so could someone sum up for me what did they change, since it looks like a whole fandom is raging? I'm not able to watch this ep right now but I'm curious ;o

Sep 28, 2013 11:28 AM

#72

Offline

Apr 2009

2596

Alzea said:
Okay, so could someone sum up for me what did they change, since it looks like a whole fandom is raging? I'm not able to watch this ep right now but I'm curious ;o

I'll try to sum up all the changes from memory, both good and bad. Mostly bad.

- Mikasa doesn't discover the titans in the wall. It happens later when no one is around to see it. Hanji, Armin and Pastor Nick do not learn of it.
- Eren turns into a fire titan.
- Levi uses 3DMG despite his injury to cut Eren out of his titan when he attempts to eat Annie (another change).
- Before she turns into a crystal, Annie cries.
- Instead of being thrown up to Annie by an in control Eren, Mikasa just uses 3DMG to zip up to Annie instead.

There were more, but I've forgotten. The wall reveal and fire shit is the main prickly point, and rightfully so.

Sep 28, 2013 11:30 AM

#73

stAtic91

Offline

May 2009

3818

Amarrez said:
- Before she turns into a crystal, Annie cries.

This was in both anime and manga.

Sep 28, 2013 11:31 AM

#74

Offline

Jul 2013

1554

Alzea said:
Okay, so could someone sum up for me what did they change, since it looks like a whole fandom is raging? I'm not able to watch this ep right now but I'm curious ;o

Well, they added a few extra scenes that isn't quite like the manga:

Honestly, from a manga reader's standpoint, this episode and episode 24 had some subtle changes, but is still enjoyable in the end. I get why some people are worked up about it though.

From a viewer's standpoint, man, you've gotta drop your bullshit. You have to admit that the episode was epic.

I kinda see why they change a little bit on the anime. The manga has a more horror and calm vibe to it while the anime version has a more epic and action vibe. Both versions are very consistent, but each has its own pros.

Sep 28, 2013 11:31 AM

#75

Offline

Sep 2012

378

Amarrez said:

Alzea said:
Okay, so could someone sum up for me what did they change, since it looks like a whole fandom is raging? I'm not able to watch this ep right now but I'm curious ;o

I'll try to sum up all the changes from memory, both good and bad. Mostly bad.

- Mikasa doesn't discover the titans in the wall. It happens later when no one is around to see it. Hanji, Armin and Pastor Nick do not learn of it.
- Eren turns into a fire titan.
- Levi uses 3DMG despite his injury to cut Eren out of his titan when he attempts to eat Annie (another change).
- Before she turns into a crystal, Annie cries.
- Instead of being thrown up to Annie by an in control Eren, Mikasa just uses 3DMG to zip up to Annie instead.

There were more, but I've forgotten. The wall reveal and fire shit is the main prickly point, and rightfully so.

I think they should've gone pure anime-only ending or just pure manga material instead of trying to balance it between "series finale" and "there's more to come".

Sep 28, 2013 11:31 AM

#76

RagingMan

Offline

Jun 2013

332

Amarrez said:

Alzea said:
Okay, so could someone sum up for me what did they change, since it looks like a whole fandom is raging? I'm not able to watch this ep right now but I'm curious ;o

I'll try to sum up all the changes from memory, both good and bad. Mostly bad.

- Mikasa doesn't discover the titans in the wall. It happens later when no one is around to see it. Hanji, Armin and Pastor Nick do not learn of it.
- Eren turns into a fire titan.
- Levi uses 3DMG despite his injury to cut Eren out of his titan when he attempts to eat Annie (another change).
- Before she turns into a crystal, Annie cries.
- Instead of being thrown up to Annie by an in control Eren, Mikasa just uses 3DMG to zip up to Annie instead.

There were more, but I've forgotten. The wall reveal and fire shit is the main prickly point, and rightfully so.

Annie DID cry before the crystal thing in the manga.

Also, some characters were switched, Jean was attacking the crystal Annie was in rather than some random Scouting Legion guy and being stopped by Levi rather than Hanji.

Sep 28, 2013 11:31 AM

#77

Narutotaku

Offline

Jul 2013

120

Eren rage mode ain't pretty....instead of improving his character with original scenes, they're destroing it. WTF WIT STUDIOS JUST STICK TO THE MANGA. First episode I wont rate 5/5. And I know, majority of those haters of the finale are manga readers. TOTALLY UNDERSTANDABLE. Ugh!! :(

Sep 28, 2013 11:32 AM

#78

Offline

Apr 2009

2596

stAtic91 said:

Amarrez said:
- Before she turns into a crystal, Annie cries.

This was in both anime and manga.

You're right, but the entire sequence was very different.

link removed (chapter 33, page 41)

Mod Edit: Please do not link to images on manga reading sites but upload them somewhere else.

LunaSep 28, 2013 12:06 PM

Sep 28, 2013 11:33 AM

#79

Offline

Sep 2012

378

Amarrez said:

stAtic91 said:

Amarrez said:
- Before she turns into a crystal, Annie cries.

This was in both anime and manga.

You're right, but the entire sequence was very different.

link removed (chapter 33, page 41)

here you can see her crying. Not as straight-up, but you can see her tears.

Mod Edit: Modified quote.

LunaSep 28, 2013 12:06 PM

Sep 28, 2013 11:34 AM

#80

Chiyosuke

Offline

Jan 2011

203

Now that's a friggin' fail. So sad to give the anime 7/10, but can't help it, they've ruined some of the best moments in the manga.

I can see beauty where others see ugliness. That either makes me an artist or a person of very poor taste (с)

Sep 28, 2013 11:35 AM

#81

erika4dsl

Offline

Sep 2013

68

Amarrez said:

Alzea said:
Okay, so could someone sum up for me what did they change, since it looks like a whole fandom is raging? I'm not able to watch this ep right now but I'm curious ;o

I'll try to sum up all the changes from memory, both good and bad. Mostly bad.

- Mikasa doesn't discover the titans in the wall. It happens later when no one is around to see it. Hanji, Armin and Pastor Nick do not learn of it.
- Eren turns into a fire titan.
- Levi uses 3DMG despite his injury to cut Eren out of his titan when he attempts to eat Annie (another change).
- Before she turns into a crystal, Annie cries.
- Instead of being thrown up to Annie by an in control Eren, Mikasa just uses 3DMG to zip up to Annie instead.

There were more, but I've forgotten. The wall reveal and fire shit is the main prickly point, and rightfully so.

Sounds anti climatic, especially regarding the wall reveal.
And awwwww I was kind of looking forward to seeing Mikasa being thrown -.-
fire titan? huh? is that some kind of titan power he'll have in the future or was it just used because it looks cool (but makes no sense since I don't remember that happening in the manga)

Sep 28, 2013 11:37 AM

#82

AmberFebruary

Offline

Jul 2010

618

its nice to watch a lot of people go "rage mode" like Eren after worshiping this anime a lot. OH THE INEVITABILITY OF EXPECTATION.

Simplistic beauty can't be appreciated by someone who looks for something grand in everything he watch.

Sep 28, 2013 11:39 AM

#83

Offline

Sep 2012

378

erika4dsl said:

Amarrez said:

Alzea said:
Okay, so could someone sum up for me what did they change, since it looks like a whole fandom is raging? I'm not able to watch this ep right now but I'm curious ;o

I'll try to sum up all the changes from memory, both good and bad. Mostly bad.

- Mikasa doesn't discover the titans in the wall. It happens later when no one is around to see it. Hanji, Armin and Pastor Nick do not learn of it.
- Eren turns into a fire titan.
- Levi uses 3DMG despite his injury to cut Eren out of his titan when he attempts to eat Annie (another change).
- Before she turns into a crystal, Annie cries.
- Instead of being thrown up to Annie by an in control Eren, Mikasa just uses 3DMG to zip up to Annie instead.

There were more, but I've forgotten. The wall reveal and fire shit is the main prickly point, and rightfully so.

Sounds anti climatic, especially regarding the wall reveal.
And awwwww I was kind of looking forward to seeing Mikasa being thrown -.-
fire titan? huh? is that some kind of titan power he'll have in the future or was it just used because it looks cool (but makes no sense since I don't remember that happening in the manga)

It was just essentially a stylistic choice because he doesn't really do anything that he hasn't done, even if it seems like that on the surface. Unless the characters state something about it, which can't tell for now because no subs yet.

Sep 28, 2013 11:39 AM

#84

ErenxMikasa

Offline

Aug 2013

925

Oh alright, Eren not throwing Mikasa is a real bummer.

Sep 28, 2013 11:42 AM

#85

Unchou

Offline

Jul 2012

637

The fire scene was just not right imo. And the wall reveal felt more like a puzzle coming together in the manga. I really wish this series had around 20 episodes and kept a standard pacing.

So, What do you think is on the other side?

Sep 28, 2013 11:43 AM

#86

Madara31

Offline

Oct 2010

592

I didn't really like some of the changes they made in this episode, but an amazing series nonetheless. I'm really gonna miss it, and season 2 can't come any sooner.

Sep 28, 2013 11:58 AM

#87

Alzea

Offline

Dec 2007

436

Huh, by not watching it, just reading what you say the worst thing seems to be

- Mikasa doesn't discover the titans in the wall. It happens later when no one is around to see it. Hanji, Armin and Pastor Nick do not learn of it.

a bit of anti-climatic and they might have problems in s2 but oh well. Thanks for the answers, I'll probably watch it in two days or so and see for myself. Fire-mode Eren sounds funny (but this show or at least this fight shouldn't be funny).
Also fangirl mode on: does this mean my baby Hanji gets less screen time? ;__;

Sep 28, 2013 12:00 PM

#88

Offline

Jul 2013

1554

ErenxMikasa said:
Oh alright, Eren not throwing Mikasa is a real bummer.

They need to make SnK: Titanhood/Attack: Titanhood and add that fucking scene.

Fuck, I don't care if we have to wait until SnK the manga is almost finish (which is like in 3 years, volume 20 and all) to get SnK: Titanhood. I was defending episode 25. But not throwing Mikasa? Fuck.

EDIT: Wait wait guys....

This type of set-up....

I've figured out the conspiracy behind this.

They're trying to pull a Brotherhood conspiracy. This is not speculation, it actually makes sense, all the events leading up.

First, make as much money and popularity on SnK as possible, ensuring that people would crave for it more.
Second, deviate from the manga, in this case minorly.
Third, 2nd step cockblocks people.
Fourth, people would still crave for it.
Fifth, mangaka announces end point for his manga (volume 20 in this case, which would span across for about 3 more years)
Sixth, wait until the year before the manga finishes and announce a remake.
Seventh, remake would have epic and consistent animation, following closely with the manga, more than the first attempt. It would have as many episodes as it demands to catch up to the manga.
Eighth, everyone realizes that they pulled a Brotherhood.
Ninth, goes on par/outranks Brotherhood in MAL, if everything's done right.

Busted, WIT studios.

XinceptionSep 28, 2013 12:05 PM

Sep 28, 2013 12:07 PM

#89

Offline

Sep 2012

378

Xinception said:

ErenxMikasa said:
Oh alright, Eren not throwing Mikasa is a real bummer.

They need to make SnK: Titanhood/Attack: Titanhood and add that fucking scene.

Fuck, I don't care if we have to wait until SnK the manga is almost finish (which is like in 3 years, volume 20 and all) to get SnK: Titanhood. I was defending episode 25. But not throwing Mikasa? Fuck.

EDIT: Wait wait guys....

This type of set-up....

I've figured out the conspiracy behind this.

They're trying to pull a Brotherhood conspiracy. This is not speculation, it actually makes sense, all the events leading up.

First, make as much money and popularity on SnK as possible, ensuring that people would crave for it more.
Second, deviate from the manga, in this case minorly.
Third, 2nd step cockblocks people.
Fourth, people would still crave for it.
Fifth, mangaka announces end point for his manga (volume 20 in this case, which would span across for about 3 more years)
Sixth, wait until the year before the manga finishes and announce a remake.
Seventh, remake would have epic and consistent animation, following closely with the manga, more than the first attempt. It would have as many episodes as it demands to catch up to the manga.
Eighth, everyone realizes that they pulled a Brotherhood.
Ninth, goes on par/outranks Brotherhood in MAL, if everything's done right.

Busted, WIT studios.

Oh shit! Is this what's in the basement?

Sep 28, 2013 12:08 PM

#90

Offline

Jul 2013

1554

Pipoko said:

Xinception said:

ErenxMikasa said:
Oh alright, Eren not throwing Mikasa is a real bummer.

They need to make SnK: Titanhood/Attack: Titanhood and add that fucking scene.

Fuck, I don't care if we have to wait until SnK the manga is almost finish (which is like in 3 years, volume 20 and all) to get SnK: Titanhood. I was defending episode 25. But not throwing Mikasa? Fuck.

EDIT: Wait wait guys....

This type of set-up....

I've figured out the conspiracy behind this.

They're trying to pull a Brotherhood conspiracy. This is not speculation, it actually makes sense, all the events leading up.

First, make as much money and popularity on SnK as possible, ensuring that people would crave for it more.
Second, deviate from the manga, in this case minorly.
Third, 2nd step cockblocks people.
Fourth, people would still crave for it.
Fifth, mangaka announces end point for his manga (volume 20 in this case, which would span across for about 3 more years)
Sixth, wait until the year before the manga finishes and announce a remake.
Seventh, remake would have epic and consistent animation, following closely with the manga, more than the first attempt. It would have as many episodes as it demands to catch up to the manga.
Eighth, everyone realizes that they pulled a Brotherhood.
Ninth, goes on par/outranks Brotherhood in MAL, if everything's done right.

Busted, WIT studios.

Oh shit! Is this what's in the basement?

I ninja'ed Mr. Grisha Yaeger to get this.

Sep 28, 2013 12:09 PM

#91

Beaver897

Offline

Aug 2012

367

Oh, man. Ev'rybody mad. QQ

Edit:
But guys, won't this mean that they'll just involve all the necessary characters in the wall scene for next season and continue from there?

Beaver897Sep 28, 2013 12:13 PM

Sep 28, 2013 12:10 PM

#92

removed-user

Offline

Jul 2018

564084

Episode-7.5/10
Series-9.5/10

Not the kind of finale episode I was waiting for.Lots of error in the episode just ruins the mood.First of all they made a fool of the titan inside the wall scene.It was going to be one the major revelation of the series and they just ruined it! Next is the scene where Levi pulls out Eren from this titan form. Wasn't he supposed to be injured?

I don't see a possibility of Season 2 in 1-1.5 years due to unavailability of enough source material. It would be interesting to see how they tackle the Titan in the wall in the next season.
Nevertheless Shingeki no Kyojin has been an exciting series and hope we get S2 in the near future!

Sep 28, 2013 12:14 PM

#93

liv3urway

Offline

Aug 2012

57

Wow such a mediocre adaptation of chapter 33. Eren suddenly getting a deus ex machinia power boost and levi suddenly being healed. Wtf was the director thinking when he was working on the finale :/.

liv3urwaySep 28, 2013 12:40 PM

Sep 28, 2013 12:14 PM

#94

bakuramariks

Offline

Nov 2009

755

It's after the ending credits.

I screamed when Annie and Eren fought. It was far, far, far more brutal than in the manga.

Sep 28, 2013 12:15 PM

#95

qsswd

Offline

Sep 2013

1

guys, is there any news about season 2 ?

Sep 28, 2013 12:16 PM

#96

Koybz

Offline

Oct 2012

1079

qsswd said:
guys, is there any news about season 2 ?

Nope and I doubt we'll be getting news any time soon.

KoybzSep 28, 2013 12:25 PM

Sep 28, 2013 12:17 PM

#97

Offline

Jul 2013

1554

qsswd said:
guys, is there any news about season 2 ?

We just finished season 1 mate?

That said, you won't be seeing season 2 for a long time, since there isn't enough source material ATM.

When season 2 comes, they'll start with a redo of the Wall Scene, that I bet.

Or....

We wait 3 more years for Shingeki No Kyojin: Titanhood, as many manga readers hope. :P

Sep 28, 2013 12:19 PM

#98

Offline

Apr 2009

2596

You know the worst part? They were throttling the pacing and adding lots of fillers to pad the series so they could end on this episode.

And they absolutely blew it.

Sep 28, 2013 12:25 PM

#99

Beaver897

Offline

Aug 2012

367

I'll be waiting for Isayama's blog to update.

Sep 28, 2013 12:25 PM

#100