| I was wondering if anyone has more of the Japanese version scans that are different from the original Korean version. Also, did they just increase the fan service or did they do anything else? |
 |
| jep the fanservice is increased in a level that just dont feel right so to say :/ but i dunno if there are actual complete scans of the japanese volumes i didnt checked that ^^ just check that:  it makes a huge difference in it for her to wake up in underwear and thinking after showering than waking up naked thinking while showering .... |
RaiStorMNov 15, 2009 3:22 PM
 "Smiles aren't made, they're shown."- Belldandy (A!MG) |
| Japanese version >>>>>>>>>>> Korean |
loplop said: Japanese version >>>>>>>>>>> Korean as expected from u loplop ^^ *sigh* |
"Smiles aren't made, they're shown."- Belldandy (A!MG) |
loplop said: Japanese version >>>>>>>>>>> Korean agreed :) |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
kaminakun said: loplop said: Japanese version >>>>>>>>>>> Korean agreed :) Okay well I kind of agree about the Japanese version, who doesn't want to see Nah Hae Young nude, but imagine what this will do the anime. If the manga has this much difference in fan service then the anime will probably be crap. |
| Where did you get the japanese version? oO |
audacious1 said: kaminakun said: loplop said: Japanese version >>>>>>>>>>> Korean agreed :) Okay well I kind of agree about the Japanese version, who doesn't want to see Nah Hae Young nude, but imagine what this will do the anime. If the manga has this much difference in fan service then the anime will probably be crap. I know where you are getting at ... however, just more fanservice does not equal completely altered story plot. In fact, I believe they'll keep the story relatively original if they are ever gonna animate it :) Otherwise, like I've mentioned before, I'll probably go everywhere in the net to make horrible nasty negative comments/reviews for the anime if they turn it into a pile of fan servicing shit. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| But, did they really do it? I thought they never did, they just fell asleep (maybe played a little) and she lost her shirt in the process. The way they changed how she woke up is a big difference and shouldn't have been changed. The shower scene is fine since its just her reflecting. |
| |
DragoZERO said: But, did they really do it? I thought they never did, they just fell asleep (maybe played a little) and she lost her shirt in the process. I advise you to read the manga over (at least that part) ... I think you got a bit too much imagination there :) ... both were semi-drunk to begin with when they enter the room... soon afterward they just fell asleep. Now sleeping with your shirts off or sleeping completely nude are both not that rare (I know people who sleep like that...not myself though) ... so I guess depending on your interpretation, I think both the Korean and Japanese scenario are acceptable (at least for me) |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| I did read it twice. How do I have too much imagination? I'm just trying to draw a conclusion from what little we know. But the question is, did they do it? Is that left up to interpretation or is it fact that they did or didn't. |
| |
| They didn't do it, I'm sure she would have noticed if she lost her virgnity. Although I have to say, I was confused when she thought she got pregnant, either she didn't attend sex education classes or she was really, really impulsive. Either way, no they never did it. Also, since I just realized, didn't Jin-ho himself said they didn't do anything and they fell asleep right afterwards? |
AmphetamineNov 16, 2009 12:14 PM
 |
| That's what I'm saying. The woman would know, especially if it was her first time. Okay, thanks. lol. |
| |
kaminakun said: DragoZERO said: But, did they really do it? I thought they never did, they just fell asleep (maybe played a little) and she lost her shirt in the process. I advise you to read the manga over (at least that part) ... I think you got a bit too much imagination there :) ... both were semi-drunk to begin with when they enter the room... soon afterward they just fell asleep. Now sleeping with your shirts off or sleeping completely nude are both not that rare (I know people who sleep like that...not myself though) ... so I guess depending on your interpretation, I think both the Korean and Japanese scenario are acceptable (at least for me) also dont see too much imagination since she is really sensitive thats why she always do things with quite a bit overeagerness :P if u remember stuff like with her clothes after Caroline arrived ^^ so i dont think that she would, even if its her normal sleeping habit, be totally nude while not sleeping alone even if she is drunk ^^ she is still a virgin in her age damn there must be a reason for her to survive those situations without awareness ^^ and second for woman thinking under the shower is like to regret something ^^ just ask one ^^ but she is just normaly thinking after the shower in the Korean version wich means after refreshing so in that version u dont get suggested thats she may wanted to do something like it is in the Japanese version .... ^^ |
"Smiles aren't made, they're shown."- Belldandy (A!MG) |
| Okay well I don't feel like adding quotes here b/c some ppl seem just a bit off. I own the english volumes so maybe they toned it down a bit. From what I've read: -They did not have sex -I think she woke up from her drunken slumber when Jin-Ho broke the camera lens -Since she was awake again they drank some more (I believe it was wine) -Hae Young thought she was pregnant b/c she missed her period Now the thing about the Japanese version I don't like is that she was nude when she woke up. That changes everything...why would she take her clothes off? That just doesn't fit her personality in the manga to get drunk, strip, and pass out, not Hae-Young at all. |
| thats the point auda ^^ |
"Smiles aren't made, they're shown."- Belldandy (A!MG) |
| Well it looks like Rai beat me to explaining the details, haha, so my explanation was pointless :P Anyone know where to get the Japanese version? I'm curious to see some of the other differences. Though that maybe a point to show her nude, but it's just big of a change for a person who has such high morals and principles. The original version is better in my opinion b/c there are suddle changes that lead her to be "open" throughout the manga |
| I think the raws are on MangaHelpers. And yeah...the original is better. |
| |
| No doubt about it, the original > new version ! Now all we need is a continuation (beyond chapter 72)... |
| Im really not sure what to think she is hot and seeing her naked makes my brain transforming into penis. But i just like Korean version more maybe its just because i really like this manhwa/manga and its hard to accept changes if you know what i mean . |
| The upped fan service is both good and bad. Good because the art is amazing but bad because it changes so much. Especially in chapter 9 when she wakes up. It totally changes the situation. |
| |
| I'm all for attractively drawn females being drawn without clothing, but not when the Korean version has been so tasteful--some erect nipples aside. Just look at the difference between these colour panels, and how tasteless the Japanese version is in comparison: Original:  Japanese:  They went from tastefully alluding to what may have (but didn't) occur via text and hands being connected to showing Hae-Young's tits, Hae-Young sticking her tongue out, and Hae-Young in the cowboy position. After having seen the original version, for me that takes away from the story; dirtying it in an attempt to make it more appealing to pervs. Going on the little I've read, the series will be released first in Japan in the future, and I'm assuming that means we're for in for cheap attempts at using sex to sell... |
| Yeah, it is really horrible. They did not have sex. |
| |
| I usually enjoy fan service. But I have to say this manwha is better as it originally is than it is in its japanese version. Japanese version is too direct and loses the spirit of this story, which allow for some imagination. Yet, new arts are great. |
| Do they still base the series in Korea? I'm wondering how they treat the food items and the slapping. |
| does anyone know when new releases are coming out for the japanese version? I'm still waiting to see what happens after chapter 72... and no way am I switching to english scans after getting to know the characters so well in the jp version. |
More topics from this board
» more manga? ( 1 2 )hznu - Oct 9, 2008 |
52 |
by thisguy2011
»»
Jan 17, 2012 7:54 AM |
|
Poll: » Who is your favorite UxU Character?audacious1 - Oct 5, 2008 |
30 |
by Nachtwandler_21
»»
May 11, 2011 12:09 AM |
|
Sticky: » Member Cards [STALLED] ( 1 2 3 4 )audacious1 - Apr 7, 2009 |
156 |
by Faktek
»»
Mar 29, 2011 8:29 AM |
|
Sticky: » About Vol. 10 / new chapters please read.RaiStorM - Apr 4, 2010 |
11 |
by rickyrock
»»
Jun 21, 2010 8:02 AM |
|
» Has anybody read Lee Soo Hyun's Onihime Vs?loplop - Jan 26, 2009 |
16 |
by Faktek
»»
Dec 5, 2009 2:50 PM |