why did rudy get a lot dumber on how to use his magic in s2

Aug 19, 2024 12:04 PM

Offline

Apr 2022

title says it all, on s1 bro would cast one spell in each hand, use crazy mobility and just be a lot more creative, now he's a lot stronger, but he just stands still and casts a spell like any other mage would. If he used his magic like he did in s1

I love mushoku tensei and I think there's some reason behind it, I just don't know what it is

Aug 19, 2024 12:15 PM

ORV_Omar

Offline

Apr 2024

I think nerfing him was for the better
Would you rather have him solo everybody in 5 seconds or actually see him make progress as he fights higher monsters

Aug 19, 2024 12:18 PM

KSzet

Offline

May 2023

you cant compare the hydra the boss of a dungeon with common monsters from s1 but I agree that he is less creative with his magic

Aug 19, 2024 12:28 PM

Ragon_Qc

Offline

Nov 2021

273

in s1 against the giant snake he did just stand still.
Maybe when he has a party in front he focuses more on spells and less on movement, and when he's solo like vs North Saint Gallus he has to move more.

Aug 19, 2024 12:33 PM

Yantama

Offline

Feb 2022

234

OmarSawaby said:
I think nerfing him was for the better
Would you rather have him solo everybody in 5 seconds or actually see him make progress as he fights higher monsters

at least nerfe him with a reason

Aug 19, 2024 12:40 PM

ghier

Offline

Aug 2019

1512

Probably because he’s older and used to adventurer dynamics

Aug 19, 2024 12:48 PM

dmariam

Offline

Jan 2021

He doesn't use his cursed eye to it's full capability either

Aug 19, 2024 12:50 PM

SimplyBrazen

Offline

May 2024

1557

He hadn't actually fought properly in years before he fought with the hydra. How do you expect him to be at the same level he was while adventuring with Ruijerd and Eris?

Aug 19, 2024 12:51 PM

Oriorii

Offline

Jan 2023

124

Because he had problems to solve so he couldn't be himself anymore. He was depressed.

Aug 19, 2024 1:29 PM

#10

Piromysl

Offline

Jul 2015

13853

He quit being reckless.

Aug 19, 2024 1:34 PM

#11

IDKwhatonamemyse

Offline

Jan 2024

Could be his staff.
It could be more awkward to hold while running or moving which may limit his ability to move around more.

idk 🤷‍♂️

Aug 19, 2024 2:12 PM

#12

ktg

Offline

May 2016

2323

OmarSawaby said:
I think nerfing him was for the better
Would you rather have him solo everybody in 5 seconds or actually see him make progress as he fights higher monsters

I would rather watch a consistent story. The fights weren't in the focus either way.

Aug 19, 2024 2:15 PM

#13

SnailwithWings

Offline

Feb 2022

From the it’s been a while since I watched the anime but for the LNs at least it sort of explains that he starts to feel most comfortable with his earth magic and specifically his stone cannon. He tends to lean on it because he trusts it and it’s pretty reliable. Same with his Quagmire spell and hence nick name from early s2. I agree that I would love to see more of his creative aspects but that’s the thought process behind it from how I see it.

Aug 19, 2024 2:56 PM

#14

Zarutaku

Offline

Sep 2016

24351

Because according to many studies, prolonged depression usually leads to long-lasting impairments of cognitive abilities and Rudeus was severely depressed for a long time because of heartbreak and erectile dysfunction. This is why I hold Sylphie & Roxy in high regard for "curing" Rudeus when he was down, especially Sylphie because she realized how important Roxy's action was for his well-being and allowing her to join their relationship because she would have been extremely depressed if she had to leave Rudeus. Sylphie really is the embodiment of kindhearted in my eyes.

*kappa*

Aug 19, 2024 2:57 PM

#15

whynot081

Offline

Apr 2022

Yantama said:

OmarSawaby said:
I think nerfing him was for the better
Would you rather have him solo everybody in 5 seconds or actually see him make progress as he fights higher monsters

at least nerfe him with a reason

maybe the depression arc weakened him?

Aug 19, 2024 4:51 PM

#16

STK_Aeon

Offline

Jul 2024

bot3141 said:
title says it all, on s1 bro would cast one spell in each hand, use crazy mobility and just be a lot more creative, now he's a lot stronger, but he just stands still and casts a spell like any other mage would. If he used his magic like he did in s1

I love mushoku tensei and I think there's some reason behind it, I just don't know what it is

1-It's his first time in a labyrinth, he was nervous.
2-He had a false sense of security with Paul and his party being there.
3-The hydra is by far the strongest monster he's encountered who isn't called Orsted or Badigadi, besides maybe the red wyrm he took down.
4-He hasn't done any adventuring in years and hasn't done any adventuring where he was actually at risk since Orsted.

Aug 19, 2024 6:25 PM

#17

pavkata

Offline

Apr 2018

damn bros, i don't want to ruin the fun, but actually it's probably just the budget being nowhere near as much as the one for the first season. Compared to s1, s2 is like a jpeg slideshow to a Imax movie theater experience. Rudeus aint doing shit, bcs there is just not enough cash for the sakuga.

Aug 19, 2024 8:16 PM

#18

sonu711

Offline

May 2021

1233

I love mushoku tensei and I think there's some reason behind it, I just don't know what it is

easy answer, Rudeus was in a dungeon and couldn't break the formation, elinalise, paul and thaland had to protect both roxy and Rudy. plus the manatite hydra absorbed most of the magic using its scales, so spells like quagmire or stone canon would be nullified before it reached it. think it as a rock, paper, scissors game and Rudeus on was scissors and the hydra was a rock, just a bad match up

https://youtu.be/dQw4w9WgXcQ
[WATCH THIS^^^]

Aug 19, 2024 9:19 PM

#19

crackedHail156

Offline

Feb 2024

Probably because they lack the budget really the second season dedicated 12 episodes of the show to erectile dysfunction really they could’ve done anything else like progress the plot (not to mention, I can’t stand the pedo crap or the main character) I think I’m done with the show for good. I’ll stick to 12 kingdoms ,konosuba ,overlord, reincarnated as a slime and re-zero basically my reaction to the jobless reincarnation https://youtu.be/pU2VY4vCDug?si=DPrbA4MZjp1J1WEx you all need to rethink why you like the show

crackedHail156Aug 20, 2024 7:20 AM

Aug 19, 2024 9:41 PM

#20

WestxMVP

Offline

Feb 2021

I love mushoku tensei and I think there's some reason behind it, I just don't know what it is

First reason is that he was in a Party that he was not used to work with, so to avoid being in the way or straight up injuring his new teamates, he stuck to the plan they has thought of beforehand and only used surprise spell when in emergency. Second, the hydra was a lot tougher than shown in the anime, this boss is worse in the light novel where they go more in depth with how strong it is. Third, Rudeus spent these last few years not developing new spells or training, he only thought of his and Eris survival and then spreading his name to search for his mother, so he did that by adventuring. On his journey and his quests, he realized that the most effective way to do all of that was to use quagmire, mist ans stone cannon. He became really good and mastered those spells, but doing so, didnt really used or trained other spells. So, when in face of his first labyrinth and some unknown monster, he defaulted to those spells or simple fire spells in the latter half.

With all of that, what the author was actually trying to do was two things. First, he wanted him to experience Paul’s death, opening his eyes on the mistakes he made in how he treated his family in the past and how he was making the same mistakes. By that, he also realized how important Paul was to him and how, despite his flaws, Paul always did his best, was a great dad and he really was Paul’s son. Second, Rudeus became complacent in his training thinking that he didn’t really need to be stronger. Now with a wife and a kid on the way, that was an alarm for him that he needed to be stronger if he wanted to protect his family against anything. So, to sum up, with was a great moment to push the story forward, showing Rudeus he needed to become stronger physically and mentally.

Aug 20, 2024 9:04 AM

#21

Puntosmx

Offline

Jun 2022

165

I love mushoku tensei and I think there's some reason behind it, I just don't know what it is

It is mostly due to two reasons:

First, an op character is hard to write.
Having Rudy being so powerful and smart in how to use his magic makes every challenge suddenly too easy.
So, the writers nerf the characters to keep him manageable.

Second, during his battle with the Hydra, Mangonote needed to inject some drama, and the easiest way was by having Paul dead.
Unable to find another way to justify that death, Mangonote had Rudy become useless for a second and have everyone conveniently too far away to help.
All so that more drama and pity sex could be put into the story.

Mangonote is a good writer.
But scenarios like those show his weak points.

Aug 20, 2024 9:06 AM

#22

Puntosmx

Offline

Jun 2022

165

OmarSawaby said:
I think nerfing him was for the better
Would you rather have him solo everybody in 5 seconds or actually see him make progress as he fights higher monsters

Ghislaine could solo her way through everything in under 5 seconds.

I would prefer the story to go up and put Rudy on par with Ghislaine than having everyone powered down.

Aug 20, 2024 9:08 AM

#23

Puntosmx

Offline

Jun 2022

165

SimplyBrazen said:
He hadn't actually fought properly in years before he fought with the hydra. How do you expect him to be at the same level he was while adventuring with Ruijerd and Eris?

Rudy did not just jump to the hydra battle.
They adventured a few days before facing it.
The way up and down is the warmup he needed.

Now, Rudy can fly.
It was a big deal back in novel 7.
Why everyone has forgotten about it?

Aug 20, 2024 9:21 AM

#24

tanjiromybaby

Offline

Jun 2024

1836

Because he's fighting a boss and not a normal enemy, I guess. Plus, he's in a team in a dungeon and can't just spam nukes, there would be collateral damage.

Aug 20, 2024 9:29 AM

#25

SimplyBrazen

Offline

May 2024

1557

Puntosmx said:

SimplyBrazen said:
He hadn't actually fought properly in years before he fought with the hydra. How do you expect him to be at the same level he was while adventuring with Ruijerd and Eris?

The hydra wasn't just your average monster of the week, no amount of preparation with fodder enemies could've prepared him for that battle.

Aug 20, 2024 11:18 AM

#26

ORV_Omar

Offline

Apr 2024

Yantama said:

OmarSawaby said:
I think nerfing him was for the better
Would you rather have him solo everybody in 5 seconds or actually see him make progress as he fights higher monsters

at least nerfe him with a reason

erectile dysfunction is a valid reason
He can't get his pp up

Aug 20, 2024 3:12 PM

#27

Puntosmx

Offline

Jun 2022

165

SimplyBrazen said:

Puntosmx said:

The hydra wasn't just your average monster of the week, no amount of preparation with fodder enemies could've prepared him for that battle.

If Paul's death had been at the start of the battle, or maybe at the middle, it would make sense.

Having 10 heads makes it harder to cut the first and then freeze it. They did that 9 times, and it was the last head the one where they failed? Nonsense.

Consider all the things that had to go wrong for that to happen:
- Rudy spaced out, which as an experienced fighter would not do.
- Rudy had to turn off the eye, which we know he had active from previous scenes.
- Rudy had to be close enough to the hydra, although the strategy was for him to fall back after each head was cut.
- Rudy had to be away from Elinalise and the drawf, who were tasked with protecting the rest.
- Paul had to be close enough to jump and push Rudy away.
- Paul had to be far enough for him to reach Rudy right as the hydra hit and not have time to move away.
- Paul had to bodyslam Rudy and remain in the hit zone for the Hydra, instead of.... maybe.... pulling him to the ground and avoid the hit altogether.
- Elinalise had to be distracted enough to not notice that Rudy was in a vulnerable location, which does not maje sense since a few heads before the hydra had already targetted him.
- Ditto for the dwarf.
- Yet, they both did protect Rudy when the Hydra still had like 4 heads, failing the second time with less targets to look out for is nonsensical.
- Roxy had to be busy doing..... nothing?.... she was back, could see Rudy out of formation, and did not even shout to him, much less cast something to provide cover for him.

As Class S adventurers, it is illogical to accept that Paul, Elinalise, Roxy AND the dwarf all failed so espectacularly at such a basic concept as "protect your wizard".

Yet, it all conveniently aligned so that Paul could die and Rudy could mope for it.

PuntosmxAug 20, 2024 7:46 PM

Aug 20, 2024 4:33 PM

#28

bot3141

Offline

Apr 2022

Piromysl said:
He quit being reckless.

I think this is it, I was thinking of the kidnappers encounter with eris when he was a kid, he used magic to move around a lot, but rudy would've died if it wasn't for ghislaine so you're right

bot3141Aug 20, 2024 4:37 PM

Aug 20, 2024 9:47 PM

#29

ilusatus

Offline

Nov 2017

253

I can think many reason.
1) The higher the spell, the more focus he need, the least he can move around.
2) Hes around advance adventurers, he need to follow them not the other way around.
3) Mentally not prepared for enemy on this magnitude, he cant think straight cause 1 mistake means death.
4) He surrounded by genius/strong people all the time so he might see them do things as the "better" or "correct" way.

Aug 21, 2024 1:22 AM

#30

xay_sama

Offline

Sep 2023

105

OmarSawaby said:
I think nerfing him was for the better
Would you rather have him solo everybody in 5 seconds or actually see him make progress as he fights higher monsters

your comment made zero sense

Aug 21, 2024 4:10 PM

#31

ORV_Omar

Offline

Apr 2024

Reply to xay_sama

OmarSawaby said:
I think nerfing him was for the better
Would you rather have him solo everybody in 5 seconds or actually see him make progress as he fights higher monsters

your comment made zero sense

@xay_sama What I mean is I don't want Rudy to be as powerful as Saitama so him being less powerful than he was before is a good thing basically

Aug 22, 2024 1:36 AM

#32

xay_sama

Offline

Sep 2023

105

OmarSawaby said:
@xay_sama What I mean is I don't want Rudy to be as powerful as Saitama so him being less powerful than he was before is a good thing basically

the strength of the mc is relatively irrelevant as long as the powerscaling for the mc in the mc's universe is relative to the narrative

Aug 24, 2024 11:45 AM

#33

ORV_Omar

Offline

Apr 2024

Reply to xay_sama

OmarSawaby said:
@xay_sama What I mean is I don't want Rudy to be as powerful as Saitama so him being less powerful than he was before is a good thing basically

the strength of the mc is relatively irrelevant as long as the powerscaling for the mc in the mc's universe is relative to the narrative

@xay_sama fair enough

Aug 26, 2024 8:53 AM

#34

Manurk

Offline

Aug 2018

I love mushoku tensei and I think there's some reason behind it, I just don't know what it is

i don't understand your point. did you not Watch the first part of s2? He literally climbs a dragon and goes crazy with the movements when saving Sara. Also, Is he less creative? nah. he already esperimented in S1, he discovered which spells are the most effective ones and he uses those. And when he is in a party like in the labyrinth, he cant go full speed in movement since he has to stay in the formation, that's why he's still

Aug 26, 2024 10:35 PM

#35

middle_pickup

Offline

Aug 2022

164

Rudy didn't get dumber is s2. The whole show did. Don't try to make sense of this mess. It's a waste of time.

Aug 28, 2024 8:49 AM

#36

Petrtep

Offline

Aug 2021

he mostly played support in this season, that's what mages are for. He also didn't have much need for increased mobility, since he didn't fight any swordsman, or stuff like that. But believe me, next season will bring much more "creative" fights

Aug 30, 2024 6:15 AM

#37

Sionuss

Offline

Feb 2021

Oriorii said:
Because he had problems to solve so he couldn't be himself anymore. He was depressed.

This is exactly what we don't want to see in an anime as good as this one

Sep 28, 2024 7:09 PM

#38

KayShawn258

Offline

Nov 2018

228

I love mushoku tensei and I think there's some reason behind it, I just don't know what it is

i think i was the same. when i was in elementary school i was way more creative and productive.

but as i grow up, i learn less, i use the same things i know. get better at them. instead of learning new things.

i think they are trying to portray the above

Oct 17, 2024 2:10 PM

#39

Yantama

Offline

Feb 2022

234

OmarSawaby said:

Yantama said:

at least nerfe him with a reason

erectile dysfunction is a valid reason
He can't get his pp up

in my case I will be a better person if this happened to me.
because all dumb ideas comes from the pp. especially when your brain is in it.
like rudy.

Oct 18, 2024 3:19 AM

#40

DarkAnima

Offline

Oct 2009

Reply to Puntosmx

SimplyBrazen said:
He hadn't actually fought properly in years before he fought with the hydra. How do you expect him to be at the same level he was while adventuring with Ruijerd and Eris?

@Puntosmx Wait Rudy can fly? I know he can propel himself insanely high up but I don't remember any flying and I've finished the LN already

Oct 21, 2024 11:22 PM

#41

Puntosmx

Offline

Jun 2022

165

DarkAnima said:
@Puntosmx Wait Rudy can fly? I know he can propel himself insanely high up but I don't remember any flying and I've finished the LN already

And what is flying if not propelling oneself into the sky with control of your destination?

It is a rudimentary form of flight.
Not a gracious flight at all.
But flight nonetheless.

Oct 24, 2024 6:32 AM

#42

DarkAnima

Offline

Oct 2009

Reply to Puntosmx

DarkAnima said:
@Puntosmx Wait Rudy can fly? I know he can propel himself insanely high up but I don't remember any flying and I've finished the LN already

And what is flying if not propelling oneself into the sky with control of your destination?

It is a rudimentary form of flight.
Not a gracious flight at all.
But flight nonetheless.

@Puntosmx Flying would be if he could stay up there, it's more like an insane jump

Oct 26, 2024 12:27 PM

#43

Puntosmx

Offline

Jun 2022

165

DarkAnima said:
@Puntosmx Flying would be if he could stay up there, it's more like an insane jump

Jumping does not allow you horizontal movement nor control of your destination once you are in the air.
It is flight.
You not understanding the description does not change that fact.

Nov 27, 2024 4:30 PM

#44

Alekindred

Offline

May 2022

what I understood from this anime is that magic doesn't work like how it typically works in other animes. What I mean is that magic is always portrayed as this overpowered dynamic kit that has an answer for any and all situations.

I'm a very big fan of this magic system. For example, the scene where he got rushed by the assassin and didn't just use a magical shield in a split second is as close as you can get to magical realism.

Magic is very technical and requires concentration. It was displayed beautifully in the show. Melee has a huge advantage against Magic users up close, but alot of animes fail to understand this and give them plot armor.

Another example is when the Hydra went to bite him. Typically, he'd use a magical barrier and that would be that, instead he gets startled by the attack breaking his concentration and he doesn't have the time to cast a magical barrier, because in this anime you actually have to cast spells, rather than spells popping up put of nowhere.

Thus the result being the death of his father. Honestly, this 10/10 this anime was very thought out and the plot is the best I've seen in many years.

See All Discussions

Poll: » Mushoku Tensei II: Isekai Ittara Honki Dasu Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ) Giorgosman13 - Sep 3, 2023	245	by le0ofthelake »» Yesterday, 6:34 PM
Poll: » Mushoku Tensei II: Isekai Ittara Honki Dasu Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 ) Giorgosman13 - Aug 27, 2023	199	by le0ofthelake »» Jan 7, 4:33 PM
Poll: » Mushoku Tensei II: Isekai Ittara Honki Dasu Episode 7 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page ) Stark700 - Aug 20, 2023	297	by le0ofthelake »» Jan 7, 3:37 PM
Poll: » Mushoku Tensei II: Isekai Ittara Honki Dasu Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page ) Stark700 - Aug 13, 2023	272	by le0ofthelake »» Jan 6, 6:25 PM
Poll: » Mushoku Tensei II: Isekai Ittara Honki Dasu Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page ) MegamiRem - Sep 24, 2023	487	by kuilherme »» Jan 4, 8:23 PM

why did rudy get a lot dumber on how to use his magic in s2

More topics from this board

Poll: » Mushoku Tensei II: Isekai Ittara Honki Dasu Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )

Poll: » Mushoku Tensei II: Isekai Ittara Honki Dasu Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )

Poll: » Mushoku Tensei II: Isekai Ittara Honki Dasu Episode 7 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Poll: » Mushoku Tensei II: Isekai Ittara Honki Dasu Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Poll: » Mushoku Tensei II: Isekai Ittara Honki Dasu Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters