Report Verboten's Profile

[ 10 ] - Brilliant. I would recommend this to everyone. Practically perfect and exceptionally memorable. This went above and beyond my expectations.
[ 9 ] - A fantastic work that was vastly enjoyable and engaging. Its few flaws are likely nothing more than minor blemishes.
[ 8 ] - Overall, a really amazing piece of media. Perhaps a couple of things could have been improved, but the lasting impression is admirable.
[ 7 ] - This was pretty great and certainly worthwhile. It may not be overwhelmingly exceptional, but its merits are commendable enough to make it distinctive.
[ 6 ] - A good, but ultimately flawed work. Although decently entertaining, its weaknesses held it back from rising above the rest.
[ 5 ] - Completely average. There's nothing about this particular piece that makes it stand out; although some elements may have been enjoyable.
[ 4 ] - Although this work may have contained a smattering of positive qualities, the overall execution was decisively lacking.
[ 3 ] - An unsatisfactory work. Perhaps it has some modicum of value if the genre interests you, but it's likely not worthwhile.
[ 2 ] - Awful. This piece of media was painful to get through and there were almost no redeeming qualities to be found.
[ 1 ] - Offensively bad. I entirely regret picking this up to begin with. Avoid this work at all costs.

Disclaimer: All of my ratings are subjective. Furthermore, each work is rated according to it's context; I would not rate a yonkoma using the same criteria as a long-running shounen. One-shots, specials, music videos, and movie remakes are typically not assigned a rating.