VioLink said: Young Ja'far <3 Has Masrur appeared in the manga yet? Not yet, unless I'm blind XD |
 |
SorrowEnd said: VioLink said: Young Ja'far <3 Has Masrur appeared in the manga yet? Not yet, unless I'm blind XD Damn, yeah I think he meets him when is older. |
[center] |
| Oh Candor, same old Candor. Disliked the anime? Read the manga. Disliked the manga and the way it's developing? Continue reading on for the sake of bashing it under the facade of "hoping it will get better later on". On topic, great news, but only one OVA episode, huh.. I was hoping that this spin off could also get it's own anime adaption. |
| Honobono Log - best slice of life short -------------------------------------------- most kawaii loli overlord ---------------------------- Donquixote Doflamingo AMV - Control |
| Yessss, little Ja'far! I'm so excited. The second season has been doing relatively better than the first, I hope it stays that way. I was kind of hoping that it'd get it's own TV anime adaptation but I don't think there's enough material for that. |
| Well yeah, it was only a matter of time. Looking forward to this. |
 |
Candor said: I always laugh at people like yourself, they butchered a small part of season 1, season 2 is perfectly adapted so far.I wonder what plans they have for butchering it and ruining the hell out of it like they did with the anime series. |
 |
| I wonder if Magi is more butchered than SAO sometimes... Well gotta read manga to find out. |
| HECK YEAH SINBAD |
 |
| Sinbadass gets his own animation? Excellent. I read the manga too and is excited to see this! |
 |
| Well that's nice and all but... it's way too early. The manga only has like 17 chapters right now. If it's going to be an OVA then they might mean an adaption of the manga prototype (?). I think they should have waited some time and then adapt the whole story. And Ono Daisuke as 14-year-old Sinbad... might sound a little weird :) |
mikadocsJan 13, 2014 3:09 AM
| I'm not going to have high expectations for this if the entire manga thus far is being condensed into thirty minutes but it will be nice to see young Sinbad animated. |
| "Now if you'll excuse me I must get back to my Madoka anime. Pink lesbian saved time lesbian and now they're about to fight Walmart" |
Candor said: And faithful to the manga in the 2nd season? I wonder who said that, but I'd hardly say making Aladdin a little cute damsel in distress in the pirates' arc when he's a freaking Magi being faithful to the manga. (that's where I dropped it, since I didn't want the war to be ruined as badly as Balbadd was ruined) You know, I had a lot of hope for this anime up until that particular arc. It really felt like it had a lot going for it, but Balbadd wasn't nearly as good as I hoped it would be. I had friends hyping the hell out of that arc, but I couldn't consider it anything more than mediocre. The episodes proceeding that arc were horrible too. I really held Alibaba in high regard too, so seeing butcheries of his character like this leaves a bad taste in my mouth. Glad I decided to pass up on the sequel. I don't want my experience with the manga to be tarnished any further than it already has when I do get around to starting it. |
mikado34 said: Well that's nice and all but... it's way too early. The manga only has like 17 chapters right now. If it's going to be an OVA then they might mean an adaption of the manga prototype (?). I think they should have waited some time and then adapt the whole story. And Ono Daisuke as 14-year-old Sinbad... might sound a little weird :) Read more at http://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=727467&show=20#AxvMWzMXHUeJsAEV.99 Yes just like the title of the article says its an OVA |
 |
Sourire said: You and I might have watched a different show since first season was not only heavily butchered, but also changed some things.Candor said: I always laugh at people like yourself, they butchered a small part of season 1, season 2 is perfectly adapted so far.I wonder what plans they have for butchering it and ruining the hell out of it like they did with the anime series. I don't know maybe 100+ chapters(maybe even more) in 25 eps isn't really a lot. |
 |
kenshin_sama said: It's really a shame that people are basing their judgement of season 2 on what they had seen in season 1. Season 2 has been incredible so far.Candor said: And faithful to the manga in the 2nd season? I wonder who said that, but I'd hardly say making Aladdin a little cute damsel in distress in the pirates' arc when he's a freaking Magi being faithful to the manga. (that's where I dropped it, since I didn't want the war to be ruined as badly as Balbadd was ruined) You know, I had a lot of hope for this anime up until that particular arc. It really felt like it had a lot going for it, but Balbadd wasn't nearly as good as I hoped it would be. I had friends hyping the hell out of that arc, but I couldn't consider it anything more than mediocre. The episodes proceeding that arc were horrible too. I really held Alibaba in high regard too, so seeing butcheries of his character like this leaves a bad taste in my mouth. Glad I decided to pass up on the sequel. I don't want my experience with the manga to be tarnished any further than it already has when I do get around to starting it. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Minagatachi said: ^kenshin_sama said: It's really a shame that people are basing their judgement of season 2 on what they had seen in season 1. Season 2 has been incredible so far.Candor said: And faithful to the manga in the 2nd season? I wonder who said that, but I'd hardly say making Aladdin a little cute damsel in distress in the pirates' arc when he's a freaking Magi being faithful to the manga. (that's where I dropped it, since I didn't want the war to be ruined as badly as Balbadd was ruined) You know, I had a lot of hope for this anime up until that particular arc. It really felt like it had a lot going for it, but Balbadd wasn't nearly as good as I hoped it would be. I had friends hyping the hell out of that arc, but I couldn't consider it anything more than mediocre. The episodes proceeding that arc were horrible too. I really held Alibaba in high regard too, so seeing butcheries of his character like this leaves a bad taste in my mouth. Glad I decided to pass up on the sequel. I don't want my experience with the manga to be tarnished any further than it already has when I do get around to starting it. |
|
| I have a question, is the second season of Magi actually connects somehow to the ending of season 1, which was anime original, or it just passes it up? Season one had so many faults because A-1 didn't handle it properly, and the ending was terrible for me. I'm well aware season 2 is considered much better, but still, I'm scared they'll ruin the season again with a terrible AO ending. I really wonder if season 2 will have an anime original ending aswell... That's why I didn't pick it up. Those who watch the anime, is the second season going on a direction that is at least faithful to the manga so far, and if so, does it show signs of staying that way? |
 |
| @ deadIEnd its a valid question that you have asked , if you care to see the labyrinth of magic (season 1) threads you will find those long discussions .and yeah it strays from main canon big time . i wont bring them here coz its sinbad thread and its been discussed already many times. @ others for those who find it relevant so most of the people say those were small changes , mixing canon with filler had zero impact . all the characters play out perfectly . ok . so basically you are happy with season 2 . i cant be . coz its the continuation of a faulty product . after butchering 120 chapters in 25 episodes you should never have the courage to rampage with season 2 just because a damn good arc is finished recently . and lets milk money next from it . season 2 is doing good because its a good arc . i still expect them to make a filler from it . if you plan to stay true to the canon in s2 then why planned to rush s1 ? coz they didn't have any plan to begin with ...they were totally uncertain about this adaptation . but they didn't hesitate to pick it for s2 even after straying far away from the main plot point ... ( why ?? coz magnosthtd is a great arc and its nearly finished ...lets milk it) it will go on like this unless i stop . but hey !! 17 chapters out and lets make a sinbad ova now .. with what ? the prototype off course .. which is pretty much the vol 1 of sinbad . so when the anime comes out ?? add more filler !! only one example ... i still dont know how they can consider the ending of ep 24 part of canon where al thamen stood up to congratulate alibaba as their SAVIOR dark king !!!! well ... i practically laugh out loud each time now when i think of how they will connect it with s2 ending ... and probably they wont or add some filler again to make it relevant with s1 ending if they got balls . so yeah ... am not happy how much good they make the s2 coz the potential to make it big is already destroyed not to mention there is a word called perfectionism and staying honest to the source material. and i can show you how big of an potential the magi anime had !! its in top 4 bestselling manga now..almost big 3 level ..and for me its in my big three (op,HxH,magi) . so do you consider this brilliant adaptation at the same level to the top 3 anime ?even top 13 ?? 23 ??? should i go on ?? so extremely sorry if i cant be happy with season 2 like the rest of you . i dont plan to ruin your enjoyment either . everyone has rights to enjoy themselves .it pains me to see that you dont find these small mistakes , change of tone , change of story , change of characters relevant and big NO NO for s2 and take s2 and forget s1 . fine... magi will go down like blue exorcist , black butler etc etc etc A1 products . enjoy the ride while it lasts . anime almost caught up to the manga . everyone will forget this adaptation once its over and with a bad impression of balbadd arc , damaged zagan arc etc etc . am sorry if i cant be happy with season 2 even if they make it a masterpiece . |
headless_nickJan 13, 2014 3:50 AM
| Woah really? My birthday? What coincidence x3 |
Will you make a contract with me? ／人◕ ‿‿ ◕人＼ |
| Sorry but no. With only three volumes, that will be awful. Sadly, it's a good manga and a good serie ... but no. |
 |
| nice we will see some of sinbad 's past. |
ShiroiRyu said: O V ASorry but no. With only three volumes, that will be awful. Sadly, it's a good manga and a good serie ... but no. |
|
| Looking forward to this! :) |
| Anime Key Visual: http://natalie.mu/media/comic/1401/extra/news_large_magi_sin.jpg |
I ♥ Two Syaorans from Tsubasa RESERVoir CHRoNiCLE and TRC!!! |
| News Update Staff and cast members have been announced on the official anime site. Staff Director: Yoshikazu Miyao Script: Suguru Kishimono Character Design: Souichirou Sako Music: Tomohiro Ookubo Studio: Lay-duce Production: AOS PROJECT Cast Sinbad: Daisuke Ono Drakon: Tomokazu Sugita Yunan: Akira Ishida Serendine: Ai Kayano Badr: Katsuyuki Konishi Esra: Yoko Hikasa |
NaruleachMar 23, 2014 6:59 PM
I ♥ Two Syaorans from Tsubasa RESERVoir CHRoNiCLE and TRC!!! |
More topics from this board
» Manga 'Ikoku Nikki' Receives TV AnimeDatRandomDude - Yesterday |
18 |
by Kazou-nozumu688
»»
5 hours ago |
|
» 'Kono Sekai wa Fukanzen Sugiru' Reveals Additional Cast, Theme SongsNioxys - 7 hours ago |
0 |
by Nioxys
»»
7 hours ago |
|
» 'Kikansha no Mahou wa Tokubetsu desu' 2nd Season AnnouncedVindstot - Dec 23, 2023 |
19 |
by JugNut001
»»
7 hours ago |
|
» 'Dragon Ball' Creator Akira Toriyama Dies at 68 ( 1 2 3 4 )Vindstot - Mar 7 |
165 |
by LusenProd
»»
Yesterday, 7:57 PM |
|
» 'Mononoke: Karakasa' Reveals Supporting Cast, Theme Song, TrailerDatRandomDude - May 1 |
7 |
by Rhae
»»
Yesterday, 1:45 PM |