Mayuka said: something trippy like what SHAFT is going to make. Are you sure you're familiar with this studio enough? |
09122013 said: From what I've seen so far, yes. I'm not saying trippy is bad but it definitely won't make 3gatsu better.Mayuka said: something trippy like what SHAFT is going to make. Are you sure you're familiar with this studio enough? |
| Well I didn't see that choice of studio coming, I have faith in Shinbou and Tatsuwa. |
| An suddenly this thing that I would have never watched is now going to my PTW. |
 |
| No, I mean Shaft has enough series without "trippy" effects on every corner, like Ef, Dance in the Vampire Bund, Soremachi or Denpa Onna. And they have a very big slice of life franchise so all these posts about unexpected studio look like people only heard about SZS and Madoka. |
| You are missing one point here. Even if Shinbo is listed as the director, most probably he'll just have general control and the actual director will be somebody else. |
 |
09122013 said: Those aren't relevant enough. Plus, Akiyuki Shinobu's recent series are nothing but trippy. No, I mean Shaft has enough series without "trippy" effects on every corner, like Ef, Dance in the Vampire Bund, Soremachi or Denpa Onna. And they have a very big slice of life franchise so all these posts about unexpected studio look like people only heard about SZS and Madoka. That's like saying: Writer A's old stories are really melodramatic so therefore, his new stories have a potential to be like that. Why did Nisekoi have so many trippy effects when the source material didn't ask for it? |
09122013 said: No, I mean Shaft has enough series without "trippy" effects on every corner, like Ef, Dance in the Vampire Bund, Soremachi or Denpa Onna. And they have a very big slice of life franchise so all these posts about unexpected studio look like people only heard about SZS and Madoka. > EF > Not trippy. Also frankly I fully expect this to be adapted in style of SZS. That's the only way I can see premise like in the description to even work. And that's perfectly fine with me. Mayuka said: Why did Nisekoi have so many trippy effects when the source material didn't ask for it? Adaptation does not have to be a copypasta of source material. |
AhenshihaelJan 5, 2016 6:04 AM
|
| Yes! Shaft all the way! |
 Credits: @Fanatique1337 |
Mayuka said: I think it actually gels pretty well with the style of the manga, there really isn't that much of it relative to say SZS or Monogatari. It doesn't even utilize jump cuts and dutch angles nearly as much as any of his other works.Why did Nisekoi have so many trippy effects when the source material didn't ask for it? |
Fai said: Thank you, Captain Obvious-san.Adaptation does not have to be a copypasta of source material. Fai said: If so, instant drop.Also frankly I fully expect this to be adapted in style of SZS. Feaor said: Sure, but 3gatsu is as serene and moody as Mushishi. Why would people allow them to add extra sparkles to that kind of stuff?Mayuka said: I think it actually gels pretty well with the style of the manga, there really isn't that much of it relative to say SZS or Monogatari. It doesn't even utilize jump cuts and dutch angles nearly as much as any of his other works.Why did Nisekoi have so many trippy effects when the source material didn't ask for it? |
| If it's Shaft I've gotta watch it |
| sup |
Mayuka said: I don't think they will add sparkles if its not appropriate, its not like they haven't produced serious series before, heck their two best selling series are Madoka and Monogatari. The former is absolutely a serious show and the latter has plenty of serious and heavy moments.Sure, but 3gatsu is as serene and moody as Mushishi. Why would people allow them to add extra sparkles to that kind of stuff? |
| Been wanting to read the manga for a while now so this is great news :3 |
Mayuka said: Those aren't relevant enough. Plus, Akiyuki Shinobu's recent series are nothing but trippy. That's like saying: Writer A's old stories They're Shaft so pretty relevant. And no, they're new, not old in any aspect. New Shaft with Shinbo as a main man and his style and everything. Fai said: > EF > Not trippy. Oh, come on, it's not. Just two or three Shimbo shticks in two seasons. |
| i think i just ripped my dick off out of excitement |
WAT Now thats a surprising choice. but im ok with this, if they can do something else than what they are used to do because this doesnt look like something shaft usually do. |
DatRandomDudeJan 5, 2016 7:34 AM
STOP SLEEPING ON ODD TAXI |
| Wait? What? Shaft? No way :( |
 |
| an interesting concept given to an overrated studio.. will give it a shot but shaft will probably find a way to make me drop it. |
 |
| I wish there is a Kickstarter for changing studio. Shaft is a great studio but that doesn't mean they are capable of doing everything, nobody is perfect, no one. If you want to see a show like "3-gatsu no Lion" in its most glorious form possible, Shaft would be the last choice you go to. |
 "A Legend is but a tale of a beautiful lie." |
| This hard polarization of opinions on an announcement and studio yet again. The anime fanbase stands forever clearly divided into extremes though I can't help but notice it's all the regular shitposters that seem most happy about the studio announcement for whatever this is essentially proving a couple of things to me. |
| salt salt salt salt salt |
"Hi!" |
Dovakiihn said: Even funnier when the only people happy about this are people who haven't read the Manga yet.It's funny how many pepole are complaining about the studio and they haven't even seen much by them. |
Mayuka said: Dovakiihn said: Even funnier when the only people happy about this are people who haven't read the Manga yet.It's funny how many pepole are complaining about the studio and they haven't even seen much by them. You dont need to read the source material to enjoy or judge an adaptation. |
AhenshihaelJan 5, 2016 7:53 AM
|
Fai said: lol. you need to know a character well enough to judge their voice actor, as with knowing a manga/book/source well enough to judge what studios it should have as well as staff.Mayuka said: Even funnier when the only people happy about this are people who haven't read the Manga yet. You dont need to read the source material to enjoy or judge an adaptation. |
Mayuka said: Dovakiihn said: Even funnier when the only people happy about this are people who haven't read the Manga yet.It's funny how many pepole are complaining about the studio and they haven't even seen much by them. And shitposters and Shaft fanboys but that's hardly surprising. I haven't read the manga but boy does it not look like something Shaft should be touching just by reading the description and looking at some artwork. On the other hand this is one last chance to prove they can somehow do something besides the usual tired direction, ultra fanservice and cost cutting gimmicks. Mayuka said: Fai said: lol. you need to know a character well enough to judge their voice actor, as with knowing a manga/book/source well enough to judge what studios it should have as well as staff.You dont need to read the source material to enjoy or judge an adaptation. I think it's pretty safe to assume they'll just load it up with their favorite people like Hiroshi Kamiya and Chiwa Saito so thake that as you will. Whether they'd fit I don't know, but that's pretty much what you're getting unless this really is a new approach "proving grounds" kind of thing. You can already tell this is going to result in a really harsh mix of source fans and Shaft studio die-hard fans when it comes air time. |
PeacingOutJan 5, 2016 8:00 AM
Kaoishin_sama said: Eh, Kamiyan is...Alright. He was one of the main leads in Honey and Clover as well. I'm rooting for Miyu Irino or Hanae Natsuki to take the main lead. There's no main female in this series, so I don't really care as long as Chiwa fits.. She'd fit the older sister, if anything.I think it's pretty safe to assume they'll just load it up with their favorite people like Hiroshi Kamiya and Chiwa Saito so thake that as you will. Whether they'd fit I don't know, but that's pretty much what you're getting unless this really is a new approach "proving grounds" kind of thing. Other seiyuu I want in: Kamiyan as Rei's fat best friend because he looks like Yato/Morita. Ai Kayano as middle sister I'm more worried because this series feels like Mushishi (using this example because you've watched it) and it's so serene. If SHAFT did anything extra, it would just ruin the mood. :/ Dovakiihn said: I don't think they're a bad studio. It's their style that does not suit this.Shaft is a bit crappy recently Think "Tsumiki no Ie" but with SHAFT. |
09122013 said: Looks like it's "Shaft strange people" again? Thanks God, it's not about girls again like their recent animes. 3/4 of the main characters are girls so..... there's a possibility. |
"Hi!" |
ExtraCheeky said: No, they're recurring characters. There is only one main character and that is the glasses boy.09122013 said: Looks like it's "Shaft strange people" again? Thanks God, it's not about girls again like their recent animes. 3/4 of the main characters are girls so..... there's a possibility. |
| SHAFT is an odd choice. I don't think they've ever done a straight adaptation without any of their usual flair. So that's worrying. I was hoping for Morio Asaka or the original H&C director, but I'm not that down on it. Shinbo hasn't directed this type of show before so it's only fair to give him a chance. I just hope he changes his style and respects the material. |
| Wow it's been a while since Shaft picked up an actual decent source material, will definitely watch. It'll be interesting to see if Shinbo will be actually directing or whether he'll stand back as chief director like he always does these days. Shaft have become quite stale recently in the visual department and I think this is an excellent opportunity to inject some long needed creativity back into their TV series. |
KoybzJan 5, 2016 8:27 AM
Mayuka said: Well whoever is producing the show obviously thinks that it does since they choose the staff, although I suppose Shinbou could have gone to the publisher to arrange the production which would mean that he has something in mind.I don't think they're a bad studio. It's their style that does not suit this. Either way its too early to make any comments about quality but I'm more intrigued now because its a bit of a curveball choice, it'll be interesting to see how it goes. The upshot is that SHAFT works tend to sell reasonably well if they're at least decent and they're more likely to produce sequels and complete adaptations than many studios. If it works out well, it could be the best shot the manga has of getting a complete adaptation. |
| Not this freaking studio again... Xenocrisi said: rederoin said: >All this hate on shaft >People not noticing its not directed by Shaft's usual director. hue And I didn't even get the hate. They animate anime differently, in a interesting way. *shit way. and if you can read japanese (or try translete it with google or something like that), most of Japanese comment on Otakomu don't like SHAFT to animate this series. |
IZUMI64Jan 5, 2016 8:46 AM
| Just stick to the manga ppl and forget that the series ever got a anime adaptation. The head tilts just don't work in every series, which Shaft probably doesn't understand as they throw them in everything. The studio that did Barakamon should have done this too. |
 |
IZUMI64 said: Not this freaking studio again... Xenocrisi said: And I didn't even get the hate. They animate anime differently, in a interesting way. *shit way. and if you can read japanese (or try translete it with google or something like that), most of Japanese comment on Otakomu don't like SHAFT to animate this series. Neets not being happy with it is actually a good sign, upping the chances of it becoming more than even more of the same kitschy mainstream stuff. Xenocrisi said: rederoin said: >All this hate on shaft >People not noticing its not directed by Shaft's usual director. hue And I didn't even get the hate. They animate anime differently, in a interesting way. People hate unique and different things. Nothing new. |
AhenshihaelJan 5, 2016 9:02 AM
|
IZUMI64 said: Not this freaking studio again... Xenocrisi said: And I didn't even get the hate. They animate anime differently, in a interesting way. *shit way. and if you can read japanese (or try translete it with google or something like that), most of Japanese comment on Otakomu don't like SHAFT to animate this series. SHAFT doesn't seem to have many fans outside of die-hard otaku types and trolly people nowadays and I can kind of understand why, it just seems like it took longer than it probably should have getting to that point by a few years, but I can say the same for a lot trends in this scene. A few years ago this news would have probably been received far more positively than just the few people that you'd expect to be excited over this. I'm sure people know exactly who I'm referring to by now. |
PeacingOutJan 5, 2016 9:05 AM
| Oh god :( Now this will go from a respected anime to a gimmick anime :( |
 |
Shinigami1992 said: IZUMI64 said: Not this freaking studio again... *shit way. and if you can read japanese (or try translete it with google or something like that), most of Japanese comment on Otakomu don't like SHAFT to animate this series. Isn't that good that otakus aren't pleased and happy for that? or what do you want to prove with this "source" it means the majority of people who look forward for this series to be animated do not approve SHAFT (that's a great thing). I'm not saying SHAFT bad studio, but if they're still forcing that sparkle and weird shit animation to all series (no matter what the genre). They just ruining their image even more. Their style work for some but definitely NOT for all. For now I can only hope they will go with more 'normal' style (even though the chance is pretty low). And... F*cking this. Ramkec said: Just stick to the manga ppl and forget that the series ever got a anime adaptation. The head tilts just don't work in every series, which Shaft probably doesn't understand as they throw them in everything. The studio that did Barakamon should have done this too. |
IZUMI64Jan 5, 2016 9:16 AM
still forcing that sparkle and weird shit animation so you not understand the animation direction and because of that is shit? epic |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| The sales of Madoka Magica and Bakemonogatari sales otherwise if you wanna go down that route. |
"Hi!" |
Biasa said: okay, shaft fanboystill forcing that sparkle and weird shit animation so you not understand the animation direction and because of that is shit? epic okay. not every anime needs fucking head tilts and deep toothbrush scenes to be good... |
| Will watch because shaft. Don't know much about the source material, might check it out also :d |
 |
| Not interested in "Shaft" anime, the only one that was decent is Nisekoi. Shaft is just overrated. Shaft > how to make a cuppa tea process, step by step while other studio would have just edited |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
DJAnime said: Considering you have an Aria forum set, definitely. That's pretty much the same style of stories.Will watch because shaft. Don't know much about the source material, might check it out also :d |
Biasa said: still forcing that sparkle and weird shit animation so you not understand the animation direction and because of that is shit? epic if SHAFT really using their 'usual' art for this series. Just imagine watching Titanic sinking scene with benny hill theme, actually I'm doing it right now and it's fucking ruined (or if you're a special maybe you can enjoy it). |
IZUMI64Jan 5, 2016 9:51 AM
| Having read the manga, this isn't the sort of series that suits Shaft's style. |
More topics from this board
» GoHands Produces Original TV Anime 'Momentary Lily' for Winter 2025DatRandomDude - 12 hours ago |
12 |
by _ATG_
»»
3 hours ago |
|
» Manga 'Senpai ga Uzai Kouhai no Hanashi' Ends with 13th VolumeHyperion_PS - 9 hours ago |
7 |
by Yubisoft
»»
4 hours ago |
|
» 'Mahoutsukai no Yakusoku' Announces Production Staff, CastDatRandomDude - Apr 24 |
5 |
by Kushna
»»
12 hours ago |
|
» 'Code Geass: Dakkan no Rozé' Announces Additional CastDatRandomDude - Apr 10 |
17 |
by animegamer245
»»
Yesterday, 4:09 PM |
|
» Manga 'Ninja to Koroshiya no Futarigurashi' Gets AnimeVindstot - Apr 23 |
31 |
by animegamer245
»»
Yesterday, 1:34 PM |