Critics & Connoisseurs' List of Highly Recommended Manga
Manga
Critics & Connoisseurs was a club that was founded in 2008 and ended club activities on the 31st of 2022.
The goal of the club was to come up with a list of highly recommended quality shows and manga that are exemplary either within its genre or universally. A manga needed a 70% approval rate in our voting to get on the relation list. The following manga are all part of said list.
Do note that our club's main focus always was anime, our club's readership was relatively low which results in a lot of manga not being able to reach enough votes to get on the relation list despite having a 70% or higher approval rate.
You can see the club page here:
https://myanimelist.net/clubs.php?cid=2913
Anime Relation List Part 1: https://myanimelist.net/stacks/324
Anime Relation List Part 2: https://myanimelist.net/stacks/328
The goal of the club was to come up with a list of highly recommended quality shows and manga that are exemplary either within its genre or universally. A manga needed a 70% approval rate in our voting to get on the relation list. The following manga are all part of said list.
Do note that our club's main focus always was anime, our club's readership was relatively low which results in a lot of manga not being able to reach enough votes to get on the relation list despite having a 70% or higher approval rate.
You can see the club page here:
https://myanimelist.net/clubs.php?cid=2913
Anime Relation List Part 1: https://myanimelist.net/stacks/324
Anime Relation List Part 2: https://myanimelist.net/stacks/328
Manga, 22 vol, 1999
Me:-
Author:-
Approval Date: 17th May 2008
Approval Rate: 86.96%
Approval Rate: 86.96%
Manhwa, 3 vol, 2010
Me:-
Author:-
Approval Date: 28th November 2015
Approval Rate: 76.67%
Approval Rate: 76.67%
Ashita no Joe
Ashita no Joe: Fighting for Tomorrow
Manga, 20 vol, 1968
Me:-
Author:-
Approval Date: 19th March 2016
Approval Rate: 94.16%
Approval Rate: 94.16%
Bokurano
Bokurano: Ours
Manga, 11 vol, 2003
Me:-
Author:-
Approval Date: 18th March 2011
Approval Rate: 87.50%
Approval Rate: 87.50%
Manga, 23 vol, 2000
Me:-
Author:4
Approval Date: 14th November 2015
Approval Rate: 94.12%
Approval Rate: 94.12%
Manga, 18 vol, 1997
Me:-
Author:-
Approval Date: 5th September 2015
Approval Rate: 94.12%
Approval Rate: 94.12%
Manga, 27 vol, 2001
Me:-
Author:7
Approval Date: 30th November 2012
Approval Rate: 92.00%
Approval Rate: 92.00%
GTO
GTO: Great Teacher Onizuka
Manga, 25 vol, 1996
Me:-
Author:-
Approval Date: 15th March 2008
Approval Rate: 78.36%
Approval Rate: 78.36%
Haruka na Machi e
A Distant Neighborhood
Manga, 2 vol, 1998
Me:-
Author:-
Approval Date: 30th September 2011
Approval Rate: 85.71%
Approval Rate: 85.71%
Houseki no Kuni
Land of the Lustrous
Manga, 13 vol, 2012
Me:-
Author:10
Approval Date: 1st August 2022
Approval Rate: 93.75%
Approval Rate: 93.75%
JoJo no Kimyou na Bouken Part 4: Diamond wa Kudakenai
JoJo's Bizarre Adventure Part 4: Diamond Is Unbreakable
Manga, 18 vol, 1992
Me:-
Author:6
Approval Date: 16th April 2016
Approval Rate: 92.00%
Approval Rate: 92.00%
JoJo no Kimyou na Bouken Part 7: Steel Ball Run
JoJo's Bizarre Adventure Part 7: Steel Ball Run
Manga, 24 vol, 2004
Me:-
Author:-
Approval Date: 19th June 2016
Approval Rate: 100.00%
Approval Rate: 100.00%
Kakukaku Shikajika
Blank Canvas: My So-Called Artist's Journey
Manga, 5 vol, 2011
Me:-
Author:6
Approval Date: 28th October 2018
Approval Rate: 84.21%
Approval Rate: 84.21%
Kaze no Tani no Nausicaä
Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind
Manga, 7 vol, 1982
Me:-
Author:-
Approval Date: 21st January 2011
Approval Rate: 100.00%
Approval Rate: 100.00%
Kiseijuu
Parasyte
Manga, 10 vol, 1989
Me:-
Author:-
Approval Date: 18th October 2014
Approval Rate: 94.12%
Approval Rate: 94.12%
Marie no Kanaderu Ongaku
The Music of Marie
Manga, 2 vol, 1999
Me:-
Author:-
Approval Date: 28th October 2011
Approval Rate: 79.17%
Approval Rate: 79.17%
Shinseiki Evangelion
Neon Genesis Evangelion
Manga, 14 vol, 1994
Me:-
Author:-
Approval Date: 7th July 2019
Approval Rate: 93.75%
Approval Rate: 93.75%
Manga, 1 vol, 2003
Me:-
Author:6
Approval Date: 12th February 2017
Approval Rate: 86.96%
Approval Rate: 86.96%
Omoide Emanon
Emanon: Memories of Emanon
Manga, 1 vol, 2006
Me:-
Author:-
Approval Date: 27th June 2011
Approval Rate: 75.00%
Approval Rate: 75.00%
Otoyomegatari
A Bride's Story
Manga, ? vol, 2008
Me:-
Author:-
Approval Date: 21st October 2018
Approval Rate: 100.00%
Approval Rate: 100.00%
Oyasumi Punpun
Goodnight Punpun
Manga, 13 vol, 2007
Me:-
Author:9
Approval Date: 14th March 2014
Approval Rate: 93.10%
Approval Rate: 93.10%
Pluto
Pluto: Urasawa x Tezuka
Manga, 8 vol, 2003
Me:-
Author:-
Approval Date: 14th August 2009
Approval Rate: 75.00%
Approval Rate: 75.00%
Manga, ? vol, 2005
Me:-
Author:-
Approval Date: 18th September 2014
Approval Rate: 85.71%
Approval Rate: 85.71%
Manga, 14 vol, 1994
Me:-
Author:-
Approval Date: 19th April 2008
Approval Rate: 88.24%
Approval Rate: 88.24%
Yotsuba to!
Yotsuba&!
Manga, ? vol, 2003
Me:-
Author:8
Approval Date: 17th October 2015
Approval Rate: 88.24%
Approval Rate: 88.24%