Story: 9
This route is a nice one in terms of Shirou development, in this his abilities appears more. The start is the same as the previous route, but in this Shirou relation with Tohsaka is more worked. So if you are a Rin's fan you should like this route.
Art: 10
Ufotable design is so beautiful, the characters art and the battles scenes were very good!
Sound: 10
Personally I like the composer and opening singers works (Kalafina :( ). So the OST's were wonderful to hear and their insertions combined with the scenes.
Character: 9
Shirou's "fight side" is more strong and his relation with Tohsaka too, I can't complain.. this is their route. The characters evolution were nice.
As a conclusion:
This route is good, with more "strong battles" than 2006 Stay Night anime. I liked everything, but I prefer Saber route...
As a Fate fan this anime is very enjoyable, and as any other anime, the first episodes are boring, but it's normal, because they are an introduction, and I recommend you to watch all Fate Stay Night routes.
In the end is nice that the producer didn't "filled" this show with NP's, because if this happens they would have no more impact.