Non-spoiler version:
Story: 1; it was very predictable and didn't have any interesting themes. They barely did what we were promised that we were going to see.
Art: 8; This was actually very good. It was cute, had a nice style and the animation was good.
Music: 7; This was good too. The OP and the songs that the band performed were very good. But the background music and the ED wasn't very good (it didn't really have the same style as the rest of the music)
Characters: 2: The characters were even more predictable and one-sided.
Enjoyment: 3; the predictable and one-sided story and characters made it less enjoyable, but it was extremely cute.
Overall: 3
Spoiler review:
Story: It was very predictable and forgettable. They didn't do anything interesting, they barely played in the group. Did they expect me to believe that Yui learned to play guitar after like 2 times of playing? They just drink tea and eat cookies for the majority of the time. And the 13th episode was very weird. It felt like they wanted to change it into a drama at the end of the first season, and then changed their mind in the last 5 minutes of the episode.
Art: OK, this was actually very good. It was cute, the style was nice and the animation was smooth.
Music: I really liked the OP and the music that the Band performs. But the background music was very forgettable. And then we have the ED which was extremely out-of-place
Characters:
Let's see what characters we had.
Yui: extremely one-sided and had no character development. She begins as a child in a 15-year-olds body and ends up as a child in a 15-year-olds body. She didn't show any other characteristics other than being happy and childish.
Mio: She was the only one that wasn't as one-sided as the other ones, but she was definitely the most predictable one. She was always scared of something that Ritsu showed and then she would punch Ritsu which was apparently supposed to be funny. It was never funny. But I have to say that she is a shy and introverted character that doesn't go over-the-top, which is good.
Tsumugi: She didn't really have a character. She was happy and was rich. She was basically there to be rich. I don't really have anything else to say
Azusa: She was basically a combination of Tsumugi and Mio.
Ritsu: She was just annoying
Yamanaka: I liked her in the beginning. She was nice. And then they mention her also performing music back in the day and it was like it triggered something in her. After that, she becomes creepy, perverted, annoying and in general not nice. She had a line where she said that she could know the difference between Mio and Azusa by feeling their breast size. Think about that for a second. Their teacher just tried to sexually harass them. THEIR TEACHER TRIED TO GRAB THEIR BREAST!
Enjoyment: 3; The characters and the story made me furious. But it was extremely cute
Overall 3
