Oreimo had everything above but it also had more to say. If you ignore the shitty ending it was a very enjoyable show with decent characters and development in which they put all the trashy elements for us to enjoy - and it kinda worked out (till last OVA ofc). Eromanga is only that trash and nothing else.
Characters are blant with no development just for a sake of being there, story is missing, whole "12 year olds writing novels" thing feels retarded, MC is freaking Ki-ri-to (yup, as they couldn't make MC more generic and dense, they even hired Kirito VA) and yes, our imouto had a major upgrade with result of the most cute and unrealistic girl ever - shut-in loli imouto that draws eroge and loves onii-chan [did I mentioned that THEY ARE NOT BLOOD RELATED, for some reason show likes to remind you this] - yeah, they are still pussies for not going full incest but atleast we have all the trash as compensation.
That's it. And don't get me started on other girls. Especially Mrs. Filthy Frank "Ore wa ochinchin ga daisuki nandayo". You know who is gonna win this so what is the point of having any classic harem "competition". Hint - SHE IS NOT BLOOD RELATED TO KIRITO-JESUSU. In the end even (unlike in Oreimo) the main romance isn't very developed.
There is no development or explanation why they end up liking each other so much. It's like author knows that you have been through that in Oreimo so they just skipped to the part where they just want to f-ck each other. WHICH IS ALL RIGHT BECAUSE THEY ARE NOT BLOOD RELATED. Please help, this is autistic...
