I loved Strawberry Panic. As someone who prefers more action orientated anime (Huge Neon Genesis Evangelion fan here) I do enjoy a lovey one now and then.
Story: 7
It's about an all girls school which seems to be full of lesbians. Girl 1 meets Girl 2. Chaos ensues.
Art: 8
The characters and environment were oh so pretty. I especially liked Shizuma.
Sound: 8
The piano pieces were the best part of this soundtrack. Very in character.
Character: 8
Being a Yuri anime - I found it easier to root for certain pairings than if it was a regular heterosexual anime.
My favourite was probably Shizuma due to her backstory and damaged personality. Hikari and Nagisa were cute and I found Aname to be cool.
Enjoyment: 9
I very rarely got bored. There was always something new and funny happening. Whether it was searching for a lost umbrella or trying to get to the Dance Hall first!
Overall: 9
Strawberry Panic comes short of a masterpiece - but I still highly enjoyed it and recommend it to any fans of Yuri and Anime.