(Hi! Please read this review at anilist DOT co/review/20115 as it was intended. I've used many images and the formatting is suited for anilist's html. I've just copied and pasted it here but the review is mine.)
For starters, yes, I'm the odd one out here. I didn't like Paradise Kiss as much as I initially thought I would, but I didn't exactly hate it either. In Summation: it has its problems and in the end I decided to give it 6/10. Which, in my opinion, is pretty fair. There __WILL__ be spoilers in this review, so beware!
<hr>
Paradise kiss is about 18 year old Yukari Hayasaka,
...
who's a senior in high school and taking extra classes for the college entrance exam. She doesn't know what she wants to do with her life and is only doing so because of her uptight mother, who always expected her to be the best student in her class and, to be honest, _is a really bad mother_. But oh, how I wish that her mother was the only problem in this manga!
Yukari then cross paths with the Paradise Kiss crew, a group of teenagers from a fashion school who were in desperate need of a model. Yukari is a lean, tall and beautiful young lady, so naturally, she's a match. But here is where one of my major problems with the story begins:
#__~~~George.~~~__
img(https://i.imgur.com/W1tlSXR.png)
George is one of ParaKiss and probably is considered its leader. He is an excentric boy and quite frankly, not at all a good "hero" for this story. Before meeting George, Yukari was (supposedly) "in love" with Tokumori-kun:
img(https://i.imgur.com/1gBjSVs.png)
(Okay, yeah, CLEARLY the good choice is Tokumori-kun. But! I'm getting ahead of myself here. *a-hem*)
Only a few chapters in and suddenly, she's all about George! And okay, this is a shoujo (even though many consider it to be josei) and there's a love triangle tag ~~(that I didn't check beforehand but that's on me)~~, but I kind of expect love triangles to... make sense?
As in: I expected her to take a little longer to uh, "switch" sides. I expected her to show more love towards Tokumori, considering that she had a picture of him on her wallet. I wasn't expecting her first love to be so... shallow.
But okay, she immediately gets smitten by George, and I was hoping that George would be a good person, but...
__he's a terrible person.__
0 emotional availability or responsability, never calls her (waits for her to call him, ALWAYS), unavailable for serious conversations and only really available when he's kissing/having sex with her OR dolling her up with his outfits and makeup.
img(https://i.imgur.com/Fz6sRqm.png)
The amount of times he makes her cry in this story is abysmal. The amount of times he does something to rectify that (or even just say that he's sorry) is, literally, __ZERO__.
He's a terrible person and a terrible boyfriend and I'm nowhere near done with this review yet.
Meanwhile, Hiroyuki Tokumori is a hardworking student from the same class as Yukari. He's honest, he's reliable and he's... actually in love with one of Parakiss' members, his childhood friend Miwako:
img(https://i.imgur.com/h9tgkFT.png)
Who's actually been dating their childhood friend, Arashi:
img(https://i.imgur.com/B5x8rZF.png)
And hey, we got ourselves... a love sextuple?!?! I think that's the word. It's basically two love triangles, but they're interwoven together. (And utterly unnecessary, but ANYWAY).
Those three were childhood friends and have had issues since then. Miwako has admitted to loving both of them, but since Arashi gets insanely jealous, she decided __to stop talking to Hiroyuki altogether__. (Also, mind you, this stuff happened BEFORE THE EVENTS of Paradise Kiss, I think this is better explained in Gokinjo Monogatari).
As unhealthy as this is, he complied with her wishes and we only find out through Yukari, who arranged for a meeting of the two without them knowing. Upon finding out about his feelings for Miwako (who became a very dear friend to Yukari), I expected... drama. I expected a little bump on the road of their friendship but, THANKFULLY this time, I was happy to be wrong. Miwako stays strong with her choice of Arashi and even said that she'd be happy for Yukari if she ended up with Tokimori.
But.
Yukari immediately deflects that by telling her she actually thinks she's in love with George. *Sigh*.
And here's another problem I have with this manga: clearly, since the beginning, Ai Yazawa was planning for Yukari to end up with George. Tokumori was supposed to be a "mentor", just a good male friend. Which is a shame to me, considering he'd be a fantastic male lead, but then the story gets _worse_.
Out of NOWHERE, Tokumori says he's in love with Yukari (but by then, she was already in a toxic relationship with George). You'd think this would make me happy, but it didn't. Even though this story only has 48 chapters, I think there should have been enough room for things to happen in a natural progression. The way that things happened in Paradise Kiss were way too fast, with little to no time to develop its own characters, let alone a satisfactory relationship between them.
One chapter she likes Tokumori, the next she's madly in love with George. One chapter she's in love with George, the other she decides to tell him to fuck off, then she's back to being on her knees begging for him again. We see Tokumori being a nice friend and being worried for Yukari, but I don't think the little we've seen of him was enough for him to develop romantic feelings for her (especially since he was hung up on Miwako for so, so long). George is a dick to Yukari again, but the next minute he's being a slightly decent person. Really, I think the timing of Paradise Kiss was a huge mess and it got on the way of my enjoyment.
Another (perhaps minor) complaint I have is with the 4th wall breaking. If it was fun and/or had any plot reason for that, I'd like it, but...
img(https://i.imgur.com/tmMPMD1.png)
Instead of laughing at the times they break the 4th wall (which are many), I was unamused. And I think it got in the way of the "flow" of the chapter. Here I am, trying to take this story seriously, and suddenly the characters are acknowledging they're only characters in a manga. And they just gloss over that fact, like it was no big deal.
Moving forward to other problematics, there's Ai Yazawa trying to bring LGBT characters to the story but without further fleshing out them. They're... George and Isabella.
img(https://i.imgur.com/sqRMAMO.png)
George is Bissexual, and at first that made me REALLY excited because 1) I hardly ever see bi characters in anime/manga, or at least it's handled poorly and 2) I happen to be bissexual myself.
Sadly, what we got was this:
img(https://i.imgur.com/1MM88Yf.png)
img(https://i.imgur.com/C4VJkgl.png)
img(https://i.imgur.com/5Lq3ftE.png)
img(https://i.imgur.com/TBMqOj4.png)
This isn't flirtation, this is harassment. Arashi is clearly uncomfortable, but all these situations are played for laughs. Instead of laughing, I was also uncomfortable. This is a caricature of what most straight people think being bissexual is like.
And then there's Isabella.
img(https://i.imgur.com/ESgPPL1.png)
She's a lovely trans woman who acts as the mother of the group. Too bad she _barely_ shows up.
img(https://i.imgur.com/wmKFYIh.png)
She's such an underused and underappreciated character. Whenever she shows up, it's always in the background and/or being nice, rarely did we get more insights on her thoughts and her character. There was ONE flashback chapter with her but that was it.
I can't help but think about the chapter amount. If only we got more chapters. If only Ai Yazawa knew how to properly manage those chapters. I know that Isabella is a supporting character, it's natural that she gets less screentime than the MCs, but out of all the supporting cast, she's the one with the very least amount of screentime. The only characters showing up less than her are the parents, who naturally weren't that important for the plot to start with.
There's also a hint of her maybe having feelings for George, but I couldn't say for sure due to her being severely underdeveloped.
~! img(https://i.imgur.com/oEOGFsy.png)
she does go with him to Paris, though. !~
Lastly, I'll be complaining about the ending of the manga, but it'll be in a long spoiler bubble so don't worry.
~! George doesn't become a better person (in my opinion), but he decides to go to Paris to pursue his dream of becoming a fashion stylist. He asks Yukari to come with him, but she decides to stay in Japan to focus on her own dream: becoming a model.
Not what I expected to happen, but not why I'm complaining either. This was a smart move. What I didn't like was this:
img(https://i.imgur.com/pCnUveO.png)
img(https://i.imgur.com/tgpO9X2.jpg)
there's a timeskip and then we're presented with Yukari being engaged to Tokumori. __OUT OF NOWHERE__.
We didn't see her getting over George nor him getting over Miwako. We didn't see either of them going on a date or confessing. We didn't see a kiss. We didn't see anything about their relationship and how they got together, we just got the aftermath of that.
Even me, who liked Tokumori since the beginning, who saw that he was the best choice, didn't like this ending. Yukari even blatantly asked him if he ever got over Miwako and he said he didn't!
To me, this feels like Yukari never got over George and Tokumori never got over Miwako. But they couldn't be with their loved ones, so they decided to get together. And that's bullshit.
Through the entire time I was reading, the story felt rushed. So I should accept this rushed ending, I suppose. But I can't get over the fact that Paradise Kiss had a lot of potential and it was all wasted.
!~
Overall, I can't give this a worse rating because I did have some moments of fun while reading. And I did read worse things before lol trust me. But yes, Paradise Kiss was a huge disappointment for me. Thank you if you read this review till the end :)
Feb 27, 2023
Paradise Kiss
(Manga)
add
(Hi! Please read this review at anilist DOT co/review/20115 as it was intended. I've used many images and the formatting is suited for anilist's html. I've just copied and pasted it here but the review is mine.)
For starters, yes, I'm the odd one out here. I didn't like Paradise Kiss as much as I initially thought I would, but I didn't exactly hate it either. In Summation: it has its problems and in the end I decided to give it 6/10. Which, in my opinion, is pretty fair. There __WILL__ be spoilers in this review, so beware! <hr> Paradise kiss is about 18 year old Yukari Hayasaka, ... 
Nov 4, 2020
Ningyo Series
(Manga)
add
Honestly, all of these short stories are interesting and could be very promising, but... they never amounted to anything.
It's kind of that formula "monster of the week" (which in this version it's like "villain of the week"), but without a bigger villain or bigger... plot? The MCs don't have a common goal, in fact, they don't have a goal at all. Mana and Yuta teamed up because, well, she had nowhere to go and apparently neither did he? But like... they have nothing in common. And this could've been better explored, but oh well... no time for character development when we have to create a brand ... 
Aug 31, 2019
Peach Girl
(Manga)
add
This is less of a review for others and more of a: >my< thoughts on Peach Girl.
So it DOES include spoilers!!!!! (but if you’re familiar with the TokyoPop version, you know about the titles. And if you know about the titles, I’m sure you can at least guess where I’m going at). ~INTRODUCTION~ Listen, Peach Girl means a lot to me. It was the first shoujo I ever read, the first manga I ever collected and the first manga that I bought completely “blind”: all of the other mangas I bought I had already watched the anime adaptation first and knew at least a little bit about ... 
Aug 30, 2019
Peach Girl
(Anime)
add
I first found out about Peach girl through its manga, when it was licensed in my country in the very beginning of the 2000s. Years later, I found out there was an anime adaptation, but I postponed watching it because I wanted to reread the manga and experience it alongside the anime.
That was a MISTAKE. Comparing both of them at the same(ish) time only made the anime’s flaws WORSE. The original manga has its problems (which I’ll discuss when I write my manga review), but the anime’s far surpasses those! Almost nothing about the anime is worth: – not the animation; Which is ugly, broken, lazy, not at all ... 
Jul 24, 2019
Boku no Hero Academia Smash!
(Manga)
add
Wow. This is so silly and dumb sometimes, but it's also one of its greatest assets!!! I absolutely love Neda's comedy and to be honest, it baffles me how little popular this is and how many low ratings it got. REALLY????? THIS IS COMEDY GOLD RIGHT HERE!!!
*a-hem* of course, to like and even want to read this spin-off, you have to first be acquainted with the characters of bnha. But even so, I think the comedy is funny enough even to the more "casual" fans. All of the characters' personalities are slightly exaggerated (for comedic purposes), but even so, they're all very much "them". I didn't ... 
Jul 9, 2019
[Very little spoilers about only one of the chapters, but it's not a big deal]
!!!!!!!!!!This is a review of the FIRST VOLUME ONLY. I don't know if this gets better later or not!!!!!!!!! This was basically fanfiction written by a man who's never written fanfic before and for which i had to PAY TO READ Some characters were kinda.... ooc??? not entirely, but their characteristics were either watered down or way too exaggerated. You could tell hori didn't write this. Not to mention that you have the opportunity to write whatever you want with the characters and yet you dedicate A LOT OF PAGES to mineta and kaminari ... 
Jun 25, 2019
[THIS REVIEW CONTAINS SPOILERS!!!]
To be honest, the only redeeming quality about this is the art. For me, a slice of life is only successful if you CARE enough about the characters to want to know what happens in their life. And the characters from Solanin? ugh. I couldn't connect to ANY of them!!! Meiko and Taneda's relationship didn't seem real to me. They didn't seem like they liked each other, it just felt like they were together out of necessity, like "I have no one else here in Tokyo so I'll just have to stick with you". That's... not romance. That's not what a relationship is supposed ... 
Jan 15, 2019
Sora wo Kakeru Yodaka
(Manga)
add
so let me get this straight about this manga
- the fat chick is SO UGLY to the point that she's bullied by her classmates - her only family is her mother, who doesn't treat her well either - she has NO FRIENDS - in the very first chapter she TRIES TO KILL HERSELF and yet *somehow* she's THE VILLAIN of the story???????? and the beautiful, thin main character, who has a boyfriend and lots of friends, is the UNDERDOG???????????? did I get it all right or am I hallucinating??? I know I only read 3 chapters but that's pretty much the idea I got from it. I already disliked it ... 
Dec 22, 2018
What if I told you that
- I'm a guy - But as a kid I used to crossdress - Also my family has this weird "condition" that makes the guys slowly turn into girls if they're kissed before they're adults and the only way to counteract this sorcery is if the person that they kissed keep kissing them and making them hot and bothered, which in turn increases the level of testosterone but not enough to fully turn them back into guys - ?????? uuuuhhhhh... I lost my train of thought This is the basic (LOL "BASIC") premise of this manga. Since I read this in the middle ... 
Dec 8, 2018
From episodes 1~3 it's a really interesting story and it makes you fall in love with the characters (mostly Bunny Senpai). You know the drill: girl is invisible, boy is the only one able to see her, they start to bond and he somehow wants to (and is able to??) stop the ~curse~ and she's visible again!!
Yes, all of that happens in the lapse of 3 episodes. This anime has 13 episodes. WHAT THE HELL HAPPENS IN THE REMAINING 10 EPISODES?!?!?! I was already kinda skeptical before going to episode 4. I mean, it all moved SO fast... the romance (it was basically: episode 1 they ... |
