Back to hman1313's Profile hman1313's Profile

Jul 26, 2020
Mixed Feelings
A quick note before the review, this show spoils some of the major events in A Certain Scientific Railgun, while Railgun spoils very little of what happens in A Certain Magical Index, if you plan on watching both, watch Railgun first.

Story: 6/10
Nice concept, good setting, poor execution. The show is supposedly set in a relatively high fantsasy AND Sci-Fi setting, yet we see next to none of it. The Esper and Science part of the show ends up being this background mystery, whereas the Magic part is explained and in broad daylight, robbing it of any real mystique.

Art: 8/10
I've seen better, but the shows ...
Jul 25, 2020
Side note, this show is a spinoff to A Certain Magical Index, but I watched it before that show, as its own work, and will review it as such.

Story: 6/10.
The overall story is good and builds upon itself quite nicely in the end. The "in the end" part is important, because the majority of the episodes feel like self contained side stories that have nothing to do with one another. This is not the case, no episode is unnecessary, all is used in the final grand scheme so to speak. However, it makes the pacing feel awkward and detracts from the enjoyment.

Art 8/10.
Not much to ...
Oct 8, 2019
Mixed Feelings
Overall 5/10 (spoiler free review btw)

Story 4/10
Now the story wasn't terrible, and there where a few times where I legitimately wanted to jump to the next episode, but it was only 4 or 5 times, and my expectations where rarely met, though there were a few nice twists.

Art 8/10
A bit poor the first few episodes, but the simplistic style grows on you.

Sound 8/10
Solid voice acting and sound track, but it was missing that bit of extra oomph.
...
Sep 23, 2019
Story - 6/10
Unsurprising score since the story isn't really the main focus of the show, but there was a kinda clear read thread in this season so there is that.

Art - 9/10
Well drawn flowy animations, never anything groundbreaking or any sakuga shots but how would anything in this kind of show warrant that kind of extreme animation? Just a few times when zoomed out faces were wierd.

Sound - 8/10
Wierd thing to praise, but Takagi has the least offensive over the top giggle of any anime character I've heard, which is good since she giggles quite a lot. Other voice actors do a great job as ...
Jul 22, 2019
Season 2 of my favorite show, I will most definitely be biased but I'll try to give all of the good and the bad.

Story - 10/10
About the same gripes with the story in this season as I had with season 1, that is to say that they leave out some foreshadowing details and interactions that alter the tone of certain moments from "eureka" moments to "aha, that's kinda funny" moments. However unlike season 1 there is no true flaw in any part of the story from my view, even though they left out quite a lot from the manga, 10/10 would (and have) watch(ed) again.

Art ...
Jul 22, 2019
Season 1 of my favorite show, I will most definitely be biased but I'll try to give all of the good and the bad.

Story - 9/10
Excellent story, though they skipped some details from the manga, and as this is a review of the anime, it does detract a bit, because there were some few moments that felt more like "ah that's how it goes!" (as in it being more of a punch line in a joke) rather then "oh, that's how it goes!" (i.e. a serious revelation of how things will turn out) when they cut out some of the foreshadowing, though all of the ...
Jul 5, 2019
Most things have been said already so I'll make this review a bit tl;dr

Story: Pacing was worse than season 1, but the story itself wasn't any worse per say, 7/10

Art: Horrendous the first few episodes, got better but even at the end stuff like reflections on Genos' body looked really wierd, 6/10

Sound: Voice acting wasn't always that great, sountrack was worse than season 1 and felt overused quite a lot, especially in one fight where they just restarted the same OST 3 times in a row... 5/10

Character: I don't have a lot too say, 7/10

Enjoyment: Maybe this score had been worse if hand't just binged ...
Jun 28, 2019
DISCLAIMER: I've been following a "cut content" series on YouTube, so I might mention differences from the source from time to time, or jumble the show and source together.

Story: 8/10, nice deconstruction of the isekai trope, the main character is really the underdog without being completely powerless, though the show apparently skips a lot of the grinding, crafting, etc to give a sense of accomplishment rather than a sense of "oh they are more powerful now, cool." They also skipped some actually important parts of the narrative and changed stuff in a way that don't always completely make sense, in particular that Naofumi and the ...
Jun 28, 2019
Dororo (Anime) add
Story: Kinda slow beginning, very good throughout the rest of the show until the ending, which sucked... badly enough to bring the whole show down a notch or two... 7/10

Artstyle and animation: Great, barring the final episode which featured some.. questionable moments.. but not enough to bring the whole show down, 9/10

Sound: Good OST, voice acting was exelent most of the time, some few moments of "that wasn't very convinving" though, 9/10 in total.

Character: The story had character on its own, but the characters themselves where mostly bland, 7/10

Enjoyment: Had a jolly old time mostly all the time, except when I didn't, in which most ...
Mar 18, 2019
Re:Creators (Anime) add
Great show that while not ground breaking manages to be original and fun.

Story: 9/10
The story of Re:Creators is really good. However it is a bit absurd which could make it a bit difficult to take completely seriously, although that's not actually a bad thing, good shows should be light from time to time, and it's probably intended.
Can't say a lot of bad stuff about it, it just didn't quite reach 10/10 for me so it gains a 9/10.

Art: 10/10
Well animated, distinct and interesting character designs, gets a 10/10 pass.

Sound: 10/10
...


It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login