Jin-Roh should be must-watch movie if you're really into Anime and like elements from the science-fiction gerne or militairy series. I would for instance recommend this to people who liked Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex.
But it's definitely not your anime for anybody, that seems clear.
Story: Dramatic and intoxicating, the silence and then the "loud action" was intriguing. Everybody should know the story of Little Red Riding Hood, "Rotkäppchen" in German. A diferent interpretation of Rotkäppchen is used here. The aspects of the psychology of the wolf are worthwhile to witness, the story is also told in a way, that I didn't even
want to pause the movie for one minute. But others may not think like this, because it is very slow-paced on some parts. I on the other hand find this very befitting of the athmosphere.9/10
Art: Realistic and good, it is almost unusual to see an anime movie with art and actions being displayed this realistic. It's almost outstanding, 9/10
Sound: Especially the ending theme really got to me. It broke me down to pieces....
The silence...was something which showed more emotion than almost any other dialogue scenes I ever saw. The score is very good. 8/10
Character: 10/10. 'nuff said. But most of you will probably disagree with this rating. Still....wah!
Enjoyment: Wonderful. Just something you have to see once. I couldn't look away for a second. 9/10
Overall: The realism and story made this movie one I will always remember. 10/10