10 - Because reasons
9 - Nothing to complain about.
8 - Really good.
7 - Stands out.
6 - Entertaining.
5 - Nothing special.
4 - Pointless.
3 - Horriburu.
2 - Plz stahp.
1 - Anime! No! Where are you going?!
Tags used for... well they're being used...
Animewatching pal from Finland.
After rigorous argumentation (or not) the ratings magically happen based on various arbitrary variables I might be able to name afterwards for those interested.
I re-rate shows to see if my opinion of them has changed overtime (usually for worse). Therefore shows with best ratings are usually those which had greatest impact on me and left most memories.
Scores are often relative to other anime of same genres and anything that makes an anime stand out in the genre is usually an upside, if executed properly.
Adaptations I try to compare to the original whenever I have actually read the said manga/VN. There are several ways adaptations can fail to live up to the originals, but at best they might even enhance them.