|
Clubs I am in
  |
Statistics
Anime History Last Anime Updates
Mahou Shoujo Madoka★Magica Movie 3: Hangyaku no Monogatari
May 23, 2014 6:05 AM
Plan to Watch
· Scored
-
All Comments (8) Comments
P.S. Due to the club having so many members, we aren't able to send out newsletters to all of our members. If you would like to receive newsletters from the Slice of Life Club, post here.
Our newsletters include notifications on when our competition rounds start, club event information, information on our monthly banner contest (new feature starting in September), news about updates and changes to the club, etc.
P.S.S We are in need of active card makers!
We do a few monthly editions and we really need some more card makers to help out with those. If you are interested in applying, click here.
Hello. I am messaging you to inform you that you have been sorted onto the SOS Brigade team.
Please read the front of your team thread to learn how to earn points for your team and PP to cash in for prizes.
Thank you for participating!
Actually where the anime is an adaptation of a videogame then comparing the show to the game is one of the best things to do, but if an anime is very similar to a completely different game (i.e. they don't even look the same), then that's even better.
I can offer a few suggestions on how to improve your reviewing skills, but first and foremost and research and reaction. The majority of people write a review as soon as a show has finished, but this reactionary approach is often very biased and can be a bit too emotional. The best thing to do is to give yourself a day or two to note down some random thoughts about what you watched, read or played, and then research it.
Take a look at who directed it and what else they've had a hand in. Was it a major title, and did the director have the experience to make it work? Did the story make sense? Was the animation really as good as you remember?
There's a lot more are criticism is a surprisingly complex subject, but that should be enough for you for now. A key thing to remember is that it's okay to compare anime to other media, so if you've seen something done better in a game, movie or live-action TV show then feel free to reference it in your review. It gives readers an external context to what you're saying, and that can help them understand your points better.
As for Poppy Hill, it's a bit too much like Whisper of the Heart but it's still worth watching. I know that people disliked Goro's debut feature, but I quite liked Tales from Earthsea and he shows definite improvement in his new movie. I seriously doubt that his father was angry with him about making the movie, and I would question the intelligence of people claiming it to be so since Hayao Miyazaki wrote the script for the film.
I know that he did argue with Goro about Tales from Earthsea, but that was because Goro had focused on landscaping and had no animation experience when he was given the director's chair. Poppy Hill is a collaboration between father and son, so I have no idea where these claims have come from.
*first post* c: