- Supporter
- Last OnlineApr 12, 4:43 PM
- GenderMale
- BirthdayJan 20, 1995
- LocationErinn
- JoinedApr 4, 2017
RSS Feeds
|
![]()
Mar 25, 2018
Fans of monster girls, you've got to try this!
Not only is this a new take on the idea of monster girls, it's one of the better slice of life love comedies out there. If you like Ojojojo, Ninja Shinobu, etc., you will love this.
Story: 9
Perfect slice-of-life elements. The only pity is that it's too short. Sweet, to the point, and funny, this will lift your spirits after wading through a swamp of trashy dramas. It wraps up pairings nicely, without making anything feel forced, and it's one of the first romance where a confession doesn't occur, and isn't necessary at all.
Art: 9
Fits this mange well.
...
Simplistic background and scenery, but characters are well drawn to fit their nature and personality. For a monster girl that's both dinosaur and human, you can feel the rawness in the art style that reflects the "Cretaceousness" of their primal side, like in how teeth are depicted with much more crudeness. Yet, you can also feel the typical cutesy Japanese manga girl from elements like hairstyle and eyes. There's also some good attention to detail as well, and certain elements maintain their needed continuity across panels.
Characters: 10
Unique, fun, memorable, and likable. Although their personalities might be slightly cliche, the addition of the dinosaur element evens things out and keeps things fresh. Character growth is apparent as the series progresses, and characters that is initially unlikable makes a reasonable comeback. One of the better aspect though is probably the translator's skillful and...liberal use of language in dialogues, which adds to the realism.
Enjoyment: 9
I thoroughly enjoyed this manga, although I definitely think more could be done. It has so much potential, breaking one of the new frontiers of the monster girl genre. While character backgrounds were explored, it certainly could have done much more towards that end. And, ffs, it'd just be nice to see more of the characters interacting with one another.
Overall: 10
Read it. I highly recommend it.
Reviewer’s Rating: 10
What did you think of this review?
Nice
 0
Love it
 0
Funny
 0
Confusing
 0
Well-written
 0
Creative
 0Show all
![]()
Mar 25, 2018
Light-hearted, amusing, and absolutely cliche, this fanservice, run-of-the-mill ecchi manga is a good pick up when you're bored.
Story: 7
For a short manga, it progresses properly and ends. That's something you can't say about a lot of other manga. The romance ending isn't super conclusive, but it works. The romance itself isn't anything new, but it works. The action sequences are average, but it works. The humor is standard fare, with boobies abound, but it works. All of these things work in this manga because it doesn't try to sell itself as more than it is, and if you approach the story with that mindset, it's
...
enjoyable.
Art: 7
Cannot be more average for an ecchi romcom. The girls are decent, generic, sharp, and well-shaded, and defined. The effects are standard, same with background and scenery. The contrast between light and dark in this manga is pleasing to the eyes: Don't have to increase your screen brightness, but don't feel like you're staring at the sun all the time.
Character: 6
With the exception of the MC, everyone else is stereotypical. There's the big-breasted "kaichou" type, the tsundere loli, and the mischievous henchman. All in all, the main cast very much resembles High School DxD's, but with A LOT less development. The MC himself is your standard OP protagonist with an absurd hidden trait. However, it's nice that he can make quick decisions without relying on some bullshit personality change or "rage mode." He speaks his mind properly and isn't an indiscriminate pervert, and it works well for a fast-paced series like this one.
Enjoyment: 7
To say it's my favorite is going too far, but I don't hate it either. Would I reread? Probably not. Am I glad I read it? Sure, it was fun. Was it satisfying? Definitely. No feelings of "why didn't this happen" or "it could be longer." Was I frustrated at any point? Not really. The drama was minuscule but sufficient, and the story didn't drag on. It was fine, and that's that.
Overall: 7 - Give it a shot!
Reviewer’s Rating: 7
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
![]()
Mar 24, 2018
A so-so manga that's fine to read when you're absolutely bored.
Story - 7/10
Overall story progression can be very confusing, especially with the currently available translation. Had to re-read pages at times just to understand what's going on.
There is a decent amount of attention given to world creation, including explanation of the games and abilities. That said, the relationship between the abilities characters have and the actual games seem underwhelming and mismatched. The world concept is pretty original, but quite confusing.
Pacing of the story is way too quick. All of the character interactions feel incredibly rushed, and events that occur in the course of
...
the story needs way more explanation and backstory than given.
Art - 5/10
The art itself isn't exactly terrible, but there's something to be said about the distinctiveness of each character as well as the consistency between them. While the characters are drawn with different features that separate them, a good portion of their design are similar to one another, to the point where you sometimes can't tell which character is which (although this might have more to do with how the characters are introduced).
Coloration/shading is the biggest issue. Some characters are unshaded, while others are. Some are well-defined while others look sketchy. Between characters that make an impact to the story, some are detailed, while others should have remained background characters. Background and scenery are bland. The overall jarring differences in shading scheme makes it feel as if you're reading the manga with a light in your face.
Character - 5/10
Unmemorable. Character development feels forced and is almost non-existent. Character traits and personalities are also rather inconsistent. The introduction of some characters are very sub-par, leading to confusion between similar-looking characters. While the concept of the abilities is thought-out, individual abilities are not. Naming of these abilities feels random and hard to follow. At first, it was super confusing trying to understand who can do what, which is made even harder by the characters trying to keep them a secret from each other as part of the plot device.
Enjoyment - 5/10
Half the time, it's an uphill battle trying to figure out what's going on in the scene, and how it relates to the overall plot. That said, the manga's premise does have potential, and some parts were relatively enjoyable, but don't look for too much!
Overall - 6/10
Reviewer’s Rating: 6
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
![]()
Mar 24, 2018
A lot of reviews seem to praise this manga. Although I find it an ok read, I definitely wasn't pleased with the story.
*SPOILERS AHEAD. READ AT YOUR OWN RISK*
Before I go into details, keep in mind that this isn't an issue with who was coupled together, but the way there were coupled. I will ty to keep spoilers light, but no promises.
...
Story - 6/10
Pretty standard romcom that got a little better near the end. However, my biggest issue with this story is how forced it feels. It's incredibly obvious that the author intends to "ship" a particular pair, and goes to great lengths to bend the story to fit it. Normally, this would be acceptable. However, with the short length of this manga, the necessary elements weren't developed. The reader did not get a real chance to empathize with the MC or heroines.
Within the story itself, there was practically very little development, and the ending felt more as a result of a deus-ex-machina thanks to convenient flashbacks that somehow resolve the problems rather than out of character growth of plot development. The MC just happens to already be in love, even though he acted the same way towards other contenders in the love triangle in the past, and trauma that haunted him for years just vanishes at the end due to a tiny realization. Towards the end, the series started a strong arc that ended up leading nowhere, and nothing came out of it.
Art - 8/10
Standard fare, nothing special. Characters are distinct and defined. Background fits. Character design was a tiny bit quirky for my taste but not bad.
Character - 6/10
Characters were stereotypical: Childhood friend type, big-breast type, sadistic kuudere type. The one character (Ruri) that actually had the most development in the series gets screwed over.
The main heroine had practically no development at all, and weaseled her way to the ending by practically being drunk and crying, even though she had a strong start. It felt cheap, and the romance didn't feel deserved.
The MC seems like he was under a hypnotic love spell that pointed towards only one girl for reasons not revealed until near the end (which ended up being a total cop-out for a reason too), and puts himself down way too much for no reason.
Not to mention the random introduction of another titular character that felt like the author had no other way out, and really out of place (although she did freshen up the series due to how ridiculous she is).
Enjoyment - 6/10
It was enjoyable enough. The drama wasn't particularly heavy, and the humor was pretty average for a romcom. It, however, definitely left a feeling of frustration behind with how it ended, and I'm confident to say I won't be re-reading this any time soon.
Overall - 6/10
Reviewer’s Rating: 6
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Mar 24, 2018
Other reviews will probably give you a good idea of how the manga is so I'll take a slightly different approach.
If you want to see an example of GOOD supporting characters and good friends, read HajiOtsu.
The story itself isn't anything to boast about, but it feels nice to read a manga where the MC has a great pair of friends who aren't just helping him forward but also looking out for him and for each other.
That, coupled with the sweet story and great art will definitely result in a nice read anywhere, anytime. Can't say I will re-read, but can't say I don't want
...
more.
Story: 8
Art: 9
Character: 9
Enjoyment: 9
Overall: 9
Reviewer’s Rating: 9
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
![]()
Mar 24, 2018
Wow. This is definitely a hidden gem. I wouldn't consider it one of my all-time favorites, but it was certainly super enjoyable.
Story - 10/10
Story concept is incredibly original, and was definitely pulled off well. I came into the manga expecting it to be a drama-filled, pity-the-MC sort, but it definitely betrayed my expectations, for good. Pacing of the story was nice. Humor was well-placed. Drama is relatively light, although it definitely picks up a LITTLE towards the end, understandably.
Despite what people say about the author ending it a bit quick, I thought the ending was perfect. Sure, it could have used a little more romance
...
(aka leading up to a confession), but it really would be out of character for THIS particular manga for the MC to end up with one of the girls. The fact that it ended as a manga mostly focused on friendship yet with romance elements was superb for its premise.
I would also classify this as a harem manga, and one of the better-executed ones. More about that in "Characters".
The only downside of the manga is its obvious anti-American sentiments, although that in itself is satire so it's fine.
Art - 9/10
One of the better depictions of a yandere character that I've seen. Most other yandere art gives off an almost horror feel, which isn't always the right tone. The way the Stalker is drawn in yandere moments really conveys the possessiveness of the yandere personality, but also doesn't make the reader feel repulsed. In a way, it fits with the Stalker's cute alter-ego.
Other than that, the action sequences are pretty standard fare, with some pockets of over-the-topness for humor, which works well. Background and scenery isn't noteworthy, but there aren't any glaring issues either. Not worthy of a 10/10, but better than an 8.
Character - 10/10
Highly memorable and bond-able characters. Character design is obviously well-thought out, and the inclusion of their backstory between chapters is nice, especially at the beginning as it served as a good reminder. Character traits are definitely unique, although there are some cliches in personalities/alter-egos.
One of the things that stood out was that even though the MC is supposedly in the worst situations ever, he's one of the more likable characters. Not dense (to a certain point), not stupid, actually skilled in his own way, cares, and takes initiative. His growth is also very apparent as the manga progresses.
The other interesting aspect is the subtle inclusion of the harem element. The manga manages to weave it in without it becoming obnoxious, and also keeps it controlled. Each member of the harem is decisive in their own way, and aren't always happy-go-lucky about their attraction to the MC. They also do things that makes you respect them as the reader, and they follow through. No unnecessary melodrama. Because of this, it feels like what a true harem manga should be like: Jerking the reading back and forth between which girl to support, without wanting to support everyone, but without knowing for sure which one right away.
Enjoyment - 9/10
I would definitely want to see more filler regarding their romance, but how it is is perfect. It made me laugh, it pulled some heartstrings, it made me ship, and best of all, it didn't piss me off after I finished reading.
Overall - 10/10 flat.
Nevermind, it'll be going in the all-time fav's.
Reviewer’s Rating: 10
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
![]()
Mar 23, 2018
One of my all-time favorite manga. However, do keep in mind that I've had a history of reading plenty of ecchi and hentai, and as such am much more tolerant of those scenes and topics.
Story - 10/10
Incredibly sweet, funny, cute, yet captivating story. Even though it follows a more slice-of-life approach with less of a central driving plot point, there are linked-chapters, and most chapters flow smoothly without leaving big question marks. Well thought out and ties up most loose ends. Not many cliches or annoying fan-service, and ones that are there makes sense (I don' count the "ecchi scenes" as fan-service as they fit
...
into the plot progression well. Thorough explanation for jargons throughout. Might come off as a little preachy regarding eroge, but it makes its point well and becomes totally forgivable.
Good pacing, although I wouldn't mind it being 30 chapters longer for the enjoyment. Plot actually progresses reasonably within the chapter.
Amount of drama/problem is just perfect to stir the story, but not leave the reader frustrated and/or depressed. The nature of the issues/drama is also light, and gets resolved quickly but also reasonably and with obvious care to detail and story continuation (no big deus-ex-machina type turnarounds).
Also, highly recommend you specifically read "Shishunki Crazies" before this, you'll see why.
Art - 9/10
Perfect art style for this kind of story, although it's not anything glamorous and might even come off as a bit out-of-date. Personally enjoyed the fact that it's in black and white. For some reason, that conveys the characters' sentiments well. Characters are defined and distinct. Kanna's so cute. Very similar to "Jitsu Wa..." art style in the sense that characters' facial expressions remain "world-consistent," so that the reader can tell a glare is a glare no matter who it's on. I find that nice, although some might prefer more variety. Art style is also consistent between characters.
Background and scenery are nothing special, hence the 9/10. However, the author's experience in drawing hentai manga definitely influences shading choices and style in many scenes, for the better. Some attention to detail.
Character - 10/10
Kanna's so cute! Definitely memorable and likable characters. Supporting characters introduce conflict, but also act as proper support for the MC's when all is said and done. Could do with a little more expansion on their own arcs, but still good as is. Characters are distinct and do not fit in stereotypes, mainly because they grow out of them and become something more by the end.
Main male character is highly relatable, realistic, and demonstrates growth. Main female character might come off as a little static throughout, but it works well, and there is decent development.
Enjoyment - 10/10
Super super enjoyed this manga. It's long enough to sit down and read over a couple days, but also short enough to binge. Thanks to its more slice-of-life style, you can pause reading whenever and it won't feel frustrating (don't have that urge to know the ending); even the manga's characters take this laissez-faire attitude as well. The plot doesn't make you feel tense all the time. Plot armor is just right to keep you at ease that nothing will go TERRIBLY wrong. If you're looking for a nice and cute yet hilarious and mature (both in topic and presentation) manga, this is for you.
Overall - 10/10. Would be an 11 if possible.
Kanna is SO cute.
Reviewer’s Rating: 10
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
![]()
Mar 23, 2018
A decent read to pick up in-between longer and heavier manga.
Story - 7/10
Story is captivating enough to keep you reading till the end, although it is relatively short. Drama is very light, humor is so-so. Ending is sufficiently conclusive but seems incredibly rushed and not well-reasoned or well-thought out compared to all the build-up.
Art - 8/10
Standard fare harem art. Low focus on background and scenery. Good focus on female characters. Main female characters are cleanly drawn, defined, and distinct. MC cannot be more average.
Characters - 6/10
Unremarkable. Standard fare childhood-friend, ojou-sama, and classmate-types. Characters do develop over the course of the story, but in very expected
...
ways. One different thing about this manga is that for once, the MC isn't totally dense and useless. In fact, the relationship dynamic in the harem is reversed (girls are the ones hurting MC with their indecisive nature and insensitivity).
Enjoyment - 7/10
Readable in one sitting. Would not re-read. Decent enjoyment and engagement. Nothing to fan about. Nothing too frustrating, except maybe the feeling of pity for MC for having such a shitty selection for a harem.
Overall - 7/10
Reviewer’s Rating: 7
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
![]()
Mar 23, 2018
A good, quick manga to read in-between longer ones for romcom fans.
Story - 8/10
Somewhat cliche throughout, but the story manages to surprise you with reasonable plot twists for a manga of this caliber. Thick plot-armor throughout: Drama and problems get resolved unusually quickly. Ending was a bit meh. Expected a more realistic ending with the way the story was progressing, but it makes sense considering the plot armor.
Art - 7/10
Not bad, but nothing super beautiful. Characters' faces are a little on the odd side. Somewhat inconsistent art style at times. No breathtaking scenery or anything. Average attention to detail.
Character - 6/10
Unmemorable. Every single girl feels
...
the same. Heroine cast is filled with stereotypes. MC is standard fare "knight saves damsel" kind of character and is somewhat stupid but not dense to feelings. No feelings of bonding between reader and characters.
Enjoyment - 8/10
Oddly enough, the story and quick-pacing seems effective at keeping reader engaged. Quite enjoyable if you go in with low expectations. A good read after reading a "heavier" manga. Can't see myself re-reading though.
Overall (not averaging) - 7.6/10 or rounded 8/10
Reviewer’s Rating: 8
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
![]()
Mar 17, 2018
Story - 7/10
Art - 7/10
Character - 6/10
Enjoyment - 2/10
Overall (using a very complicated formula) - 6.4/10 rounded down to 6.
Story: Some cliches here and there, but the overarching plot concept leaves room for originality at certain points. Not your standard everyone-loves-MC kind of harem. Side stories feel forced, and makes little impact to MC's or plot.
Art: So-so for a harem-romcom. Nothing decidedly beautiful, but not hard on the eyes. Standard run-of-the-mill designs.
Character: Unremarkable. Could be because it's short compared to one with 70+ chapters, but there's not an overwhelming sense of attachment. Decidedly cliche personalities. MC isn't a total wimp, but not super awesome.
...
Some character growth, but nothing groundbreaking.
Enjoyment: Not for me. Incredibly frustrating to read due to a LOT of expectable plot-teasing. Makes you want to skip to the end. Ending feels forced and downright unnecessary, but pretty realistic.
Okay to read through once but would not re-read.
Reviewer’s Rating: 6
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
|
